Newer blog post
more in Blog
Older blog post
Newer blog post by Open Question
more by Open Question (oldest)
Older blog post by Open Question
Open Question's Picture
Open Question About: Do you have a question for the Weddingbee community? Please email us at ask@weddingbee.com with your question!
About Open Question

Open Question: Diamond Alternatives

January 19th, 2007 @ 12:25 pm by Open Question

Hi,

I love your site, so when I began having this dilemma, I realized you would be the perfect place to go. I’m looking for some help on alternatives to diamonds for engagement rings. My boyfriend and I have basically decided we are getting married, and he still would like to surprise me by popping the question. I’ve been trying to help him with ideas for an engagement ring, and though originally I thought I would want a diamond (what girl doesn’t?), I have since become concerned about cost. He’s in law school and I’m finishing up undergrad, and the idea of dropping a couple thousand dollars or more on a ring bugs the part of me that wants to save for a beautiful wedding and honeymoon, as well as our future home.

So I’ve been looking for some alternatives, and I’ve stumbled across white sapphires and pearls. I’ve been having some trouble finding reputable websites and research, so I was hoping those of you at weddingbee could help me. Do any of you have any experience with nontraditional (nondiamond at least) engagement rings? How did you go about researching and purchasing said rings? I’m based in Illinois (Chicago and/or Champaign), so if anyone has any specific recommendations for my area as to where to go, that would be helpful as well. Thanks for any and all help!

Caitlin

Tags: advice |
advertisement below
Newer blog post
more in Blog
Older blog post
Newer blog post by Open Question
more by Open Question (oldest)
Older blog post by Open Question

28 Responses to “Open Question: Diamond Alternatives”

1 2 

1.
Guest Icon
Guest
njgirl

my FI and I decided against diamonds for different reasons and ended up with moissanite– it has a similar hardness as a diamond, but comes from meteorites (the crystals are too small, though, and they grow them up in a lab).
check out http://www.fromthesky.com
they’re great, and i’ve gotten lots of compliments on my ring (even from people who really believe in the whole diamond thing)

 
2.
Guest Icon
Guest
K

I’m not much of a help…I’m still out there searching for the perfect ruby engagement ring.

 
3.
Guest Icon
Guest
Alexandrialeigh

My ring is my birthstone, an aquamarine (and a pretty large one), surrounded by diamonds. The smaller diamonds are much more cost-effective, and I love having a larger center stone — I would never have spent the money it would’ve taken to get a diamond in the same size.

You don’t have to go with a white gem if you’re looking for an engagement ring — it’s your ring, you can choose whatever you want. Diamonds are just traditional.

 
4.
Guest Icon
Guest
Nancy

Just an FYI that pearls are very delicate and cant stand up to lotions, perfumes, being knocked, etc. There are some very pretty pearl rings out there but they arent the sort of thing that can be worn every day because they are so easily damaged. Youre probably better off going with something inorganic like a mineral (ruby, emerald, sapphire, etc)

 
5.
Guest Icon
Guest
valeqt

My boyfriend and I are doing something similar, except I want a blue sapphire. Here’s a link about buying colored gems that was helpful.
http://www.winkjones.com/colored/buycolored.php

Pricescope.com also has lots of different threads about other gems for engagement rings.

And here are two sites that have white sapphires.
http://www.simplysapphire.com
awesomegems.com

 
6.
Guest Icon
Guest
thistleorchid

Look into shops that sell estate jewelry, there’s lots of gorgeous rings made with different stones that are antiques - they were bigger about the different stoned diamonds then than we are now, so my guess is there would be a lot of gorgeous options. Good luck and have fun!

 
7.
Guest Icon
Guest
Miss Lime

i second pricescope.com. they have a colored gems forum with tons of past posts you can search as well as some helpful experts on there. they also have tons of photos posted for ideas and so you can see examples of colored or other gemstone rings.

 
8.
Guest Icon
Guest
Alisa

Another alternative if you wanted to go the “white sapphire ring” is to go with man-made diamonds. I know a few of my friends who are engaged who have gotten these from their fiance’s and they are gorgoeous! RussianBrilliants.net is one very reputable site that uses man made diamonds in their jewelry. They also have colored stones as well, and their price is way way lower then what it would have cost if it was a mined diamond.

This company is also affiliated with Hadar Diamond Corp. which is a very reputable jeweler…but thought of an alternative for people just like us who can’t afford a really big diamond ring, but would still like something nice.

My friends who do have rings from there, are always getting compliments…and they can actually say that is a real diamond..because it is! It’s just man-made.. not mined. It’s stronger than moissanite, better quality then CZ and has the identical qualities of a real diamond..but is harder when tested. So it’s less prone to cracking or breaking, cuz that happens sometimes.

Hope this info. helps in some way!

 
9.
Guest Icon
Guest
Caitlin

Thank you all for your help! For some reason I wasn’t finding these sites when I searched :)

 
10.
Guest Icon
Guest
jj

i wouldcheck out man-made diamonds. and second what alisa says… it’s not a fake diamond. It is a diamond… and it is affordable!

 
11.
Guest Icon
Guest
Jamie

My friend has a sapphire and diamond engagement ring that her fiance got from
http://www.bluenile.com
It’s a beautiful ring, and because the center stone is a sapphire, it wasn’t as expensive. I’ve always heard good things about this site.

 
12.
Guest Icon
Guest
Mrs Ant

Please do your research before trusting all of the comments on this site.

The stones from Russianbrilliants are high quality cubic zirconias, NOT real diamonds (cultured or mined).

Also, there are cultured (man-made) diamonds currently available, but they still cost thousands of dollars per carat and are mostly fancy colored diamonds (pink, yellow, blue).

 
13.
Guest Icon
Guest
Iris

Fascinating.

One suggestion…. If buying a diamond-looking non-diamond stone, and you prefer people to presume it’s a diamond (for any number of legitimate reasons, including not having to explain all the time), it should be a… shall we say… “realistic” size (or maybe just a tad bigger) correlating to what you could afford in a diamond? (That 5-carat size is going to be a dead giveaway.) Maybe invest in the setting instead of up-sizing the stone(s).

 
14.
Guest Icon
Guest
twelvetigers

I would suggest having a non-diamond center stone in a gemstone, like sapphie, ruby, emerald, toapz, peridot etc. etc. and having some smaller diamonds around it. You can geneally find lower prices that way. My ring is actually from Zales and cost

 
15.
Guest Icon
Guest
twelvetigers

Wow, where’d my post go? I guess I should avoid HTML symbols. Anyway, it cost less than $1000, but my FI an I are both still in college and have small incomes as well. But, I like my ring just as much as I would like a $4k rock, just because it’s mine and he picked it out for me. So, you could also get smaller diamonds… and maybe plan for a 10 year anniversary ring that is stunning?

 
16.
Guest Icon
Guest
Ms. Albatross

Couple of points -
I’m pretty sure that man-made diamonds are not commercially viable in reasonable sizes yet as jewelry. There has been hype, but no product.

How about a beautiful eternity band that you can use as your wedding ring too, and then get a big rock for a later anniversary.

Or, get a really nice ring (those can easily be 1K+) with a synthetic center stone now, and plan to replace it with diamond at a future date. You can get just a cubic zirconium or they have some out now that are more durable than normal CZ (and more $ than CZ - but much less than diamond).

Or go for a sapphire or other colored gemstone instead of diamond.

 
17.
Guest Icon
Guest
Ms. Albatross

Just as others have mentioned, colored gemstones are not as durable as diamonds. Rubies and sapphires are still pretty hard, but emeralds are much softer and not suitable for a lifetime of daily wear. Nor are pearls, at least not on a ring.

 
18.
Guest Icon
Guest
Henderson

I’m just going to play the mother’s role here and remind you that this is the ring that you will have forever. It should be what you want to wear on your finger for the the rest of your lige. Other stones are indeed beautiful and there are many reasons to choose a less traditional ring, but if you WANT a diamong engagement ring, I would recommend researching financing options before alternatives. You can also always add to the ring later when finances are less of a concern. I realize your fiance may still be in law school, but one day, you two will have the financial security you’re working so hard now to attain, and you might still wish that you had received the ring you had imagined when daydreaming about the proposal. Perhaps your fiance has school debt, but there are resources…major chains and independant shops have financing options….even for long periods of time. In two or three years, he could pay it off entirely with a portion of his signing bonus.

But, if you WANT a different type of ring, then you should get it. I’m just saying - a couple years of financing the engagement ring is not a huge burden. Men, smart men I go to business school with, do it all the time.

 
19.
Guest Icon
Guest
jasmine

One thing you should consider:

I believe Tiffany’s has a policy where you can buy a ring, now, and then turn it in for an upgrade in years to come. They will take the ring back and put the money you paid initially towards the price of the new ring. That way, as you and your honey bring home the big bucks later in life, you can get a ring with a larger diamond later.

You can read more about it here:

http://abcnews.go.com/GMA/Business/story?id=2731353&page=1&CMP=OTC-RSSFeeds0312

 
20.
Guest Icon
Guest
Alison

if you want a diamond, I’d get one. You don’t want to feel like you got something because of money. You can get 3 stone ring or have a smaller center stone to save money.

I have a purple sapphire e-ring in a pave setting and I wouldn’t trade it for anything. But I think you have to want a color e-ring.

I also agree pricescope.com has awesome forums where you can get really informed answers to your questions - a lot of jewelers frequent the boards there.

Hope this helps!

 
1 2 

Leave a Reply


You can also just...

Newer blog post
more in Blog
Older blog post
Newer blog post by Open Question
more by Open Question (oldest)
Older blog post by Open Question

Visit our sister sites eHarmony
Online Dating
eHarmony Advice
Dating Advice
Project Wedding
Wedding Songs
JustMommies
Pregnancy Calendar

Copyright 2004-2012, Weddingbee.com
 

Find your vendors on Weddingbee

Real reviews from brides in your area!

Favors by Weddingbee

  • Favors by season

Shop Now ยป

Open Question
Open Question

Open Question About: Do you have a question for the Weddingbee community? Please email us at ask@weddingbee.com with your question!

Boards
Classifieds

Blog Calendar
February 2012
SunMonTueWedThuFriSat
2930311234
567891011
12131415161718
19202122232425
26272829

Weddingbee Bios
Wiki
More