Register or log in —

Newer blog post
more in Blog
Older blog post
Newer blog post by Mrs. Emerald
more by Mrs. Emerald (oldest)
Older blog post by Mrs. Emerald
Mrs. Emerald's Picture
Mrs. Emerald, Chicago Age and Occupation: 26, Wedding Planner Fiance's Age and Occupation: 26, Paralegal Engagement Date: October 8, 2006 Wedding Date: September 2007 Blogging Since: November 29, 2006 Venue: Hyatt Lodge, Oak Brook IL About Me: I have been dreaming about my wedding forever, and flipping through bridal magazines since high school, so I am in my element! I am calling our theme "Vintage Inspired French/Asian Fusion." Mr. Emerald is very involved in the planning process, but of course he generally defers to me cuz I have a strong opinion of how I want everything to be :-).
About Mrs. Emerald

Ode to Cookware

February 5th, 2007 @ 1:18 pm by Mrs. Emerald

It is almost time for Mr. E and I to partake in one of the most beloved and age-old (well, maybe not) wedding traditions… registering! Hallelujah! Since I love to cook, I am *so* excited at the chance to finally upgrade all my icky IKEA cookware. Now don’t get me wrong, I wouldn’t have gotten through the past 7 or 8 years without IKEA, but I’ve had to toss many of their pots cuz the plastic handles started melting and gave off this gaseous stench. *blech.*

We have decided to register at Crate and Barrel, Macy’s and Amazon.com. This coming weekend Mr. E and I are going to Crate and Barrel’s Sunday Morning Engagament event, and so I’ve diligently started doing my research. However, this is what stumps me:

Calphalon versus All Clad?

For example, here we have Calphalon Contemporary Non-Stick Cookware with Bonus Everyday Pan and Bonus Casserole 10 piece set for $399.95.

pots1.jpg

Versus All Clad Stainless Cookware with Bonus Grill Pan and Cookbook 9 piece set for $569.95. 8O Eeks!

pots2.jpg

That’s a hefty chunka change. Being slightly lazy, I find the non-stick option to be very attractive, but I’ve heard that the coating can sometimes leave a funky taste when preparing sauces? The All Clad set looks sooo pretty, shiny and new, but how hard is it to keep them looking that way? And it seems that All Clad is higher end than Calphalon? Yes/No? Is it worth the extra cost?

So I am asking you, my lovely helpful readers, what opinions do you have regarding Calphalon versus All Clad?

Tags: |   Link for this post | Share this post: Ode to Cookware      
Newer blog post
more in Blog
Older blog post
Newer blog post by Mrs. Emerald
more by Mrs. Emerald (oldest)
Older blog post by Mrs. Emerald
advertisement below

41 Responses to “Ode to Cookware”

1.
Guest Icon
Guest
k

We registered for all-clad non stick at macys

it’s worth it to get the better pots (all-clad is the best brand overall) and we found that they were only about $10-20 more, per pot, than calphalon. buying all clad will mean you won’t have to buy another set for 20+ years if you take care of them correctly

i don’t know about sauces tasting funny, but i figured i would use them even less if i had to spend a long time cleaning the pots.

 
2.
Guest Icon
Guest
Lauren

We went with the all-clad (similar to the picture). I too love to cook, and most cooks or foodies would recommend going with the all-clad. We registered for the pots and pans at Macy’s, because you can put the individual pieces on the registry, and that enables guests to just purchase one for you, rather than having a group go in on the entire set for you. I did also register for a non-stick skillet that I figured would be for quick, easy cleaning.

 
3.
Guest Icon
Guest
Kglan

I own a smaller set of all-clad and will never go back! I love them. I would recommend to register for a few non-stick skillets (for eggs or omletts) as the stainless all-clad isn’t too easy to do eggs. :-)
I heard that all-clad has some non-stick now as well that I will look into registering for.

 
4.
Guest Icon
Guest
Katie

I cook a ton and when i decided to go low fat i purchased new calpahlon fry pans and sautee pans as when you are preparing delicate items in a lower fat manner they stick to all-clad and end up looking like hell! i prefer all clad pots i think they heat through better. and if you take care of them they will last for years.

 
5.
Guest Icon
Guest
sally

How far in advance do you register before the wedding? HOw do you let people know where you are registered without appearing rude? You don’t put it on the Invite, I don’t have a wedding website (NEVER), and it is not going on the STDates either. Just wondering.

 
6.
Guest Icon
Guest
Sarah

instead of registering for a set, i registered for a hodge podge of all clad, calphalon, analon, and le creuset pots and pans. that way i have the best of all worlds.

 
7.
Guest Icon
Guest
Mrs. Butterfly

i got the all clad non stick version - much more expensive than regular stainless steel. however, i find it to be completely worth it because i rarely use any oil/butter/fat now. much healthier!

 
8.
Guest Icon
Guest
turtle

we registered for all clad at williamsonoma. we fell in love with it. we consider ourselves foodies and love love love to cook. we wanted what the great chefs use. we did get a non-stick omlette pan. Another great buy is the creuset pot. I heard it lasts forever, and you can hand it down to your grandchildren!

 
9.
Guest Icon
Guest
artsyvixen

We went for calphalon and i LOVE LOVE LOVE!!! Cooks very evenly and heats up quickly. I have no complaints!

 
10.
Guest Icon
Guest
katielynn25

I actually just got the All Clad 10 piece set from Macy’s yesterday from my parents. They cook with All Clad so I have used them before. All in all they are WONDERFUL. They heat up really quick and are a dream to clean. My parents are about 3 years old and they still look new. I will only use non-stick to cook things like eggs. I actually purchase my non-sticks from a restaurant supply store.

 
11.
Guest Icon
Guest
PhillyM

We received a Calphalon stainless set for our wedding. We cook alot and I’ve cooked with All Clad before. The Calphalon stainless works just as well. It’s wonderful! It is a little more work to keep stainless cookware in its original condition. But, with regular TLC and by using Barkeeper’s Friend to clean the cookware, it’s really not a big issue.

The other thing to consider–by registering at Bed, Bath and Beyond you give your guests the chance to use those 15% or 20% off coupons they always send out. That makes registering for a large cookware set (or other big ticket items) a little easier on your guest’s wallets.

 
12.
Guest Icon
Guest
Pencils

You can hand Le Creuset down to your grandchildren–my mom has a very nice frying pan that belonged to my great-grandmother, and I keep trying to get it from her because she hardly uses it! (It’s heavy.)

We only registered for one large roaster/lasagna pan. I’ve got nice pots and pans already that have served me well for ten years. I’d rather people buy us the flatware, the knives, the Kitchenaid mixer, or the lovely, lovely Jasper Conran for Wedgewood china we registered for. I actually don’t think we’re going to get that much from the registry, we’re having a small wedding and my fiance says that his family gives cash. Which we’ll use to buy the flatware, etc., that we don’t get! :D

 
13.
Guest Icon
Guest
pam

like phillym, we got the stainless steel set from calphalon. i love it, and it performs beautifully.

 
14.
Guest Icon
Guest
Roslyn

I was just talking to a sales associate about this exact thing the other day! He recommended all-clad–anything that is five-ply because they will loast a lifetime. Granted they are more expensive (the two sets we were looking at were $799 and $899 Canadian dollars), but I think it is totally worth it–especially if you like to cook like we do. I actually have been reading about health risks associated with non-stick cooking surfaces as well. I would definitely opt out of a whole non-stick set but maybe buy one or two non-stich frying/sautee pans because making eggs on all clad is impossible!!!

 
15.
Guest Icon
Guest
hm

all-clad! all-clad! all-clad!

i have never heard of sauces tasting funny due to nonstick, but you can’t make a great sauce with a non-stick pan anyway (does not develop good fond).
non-stick does not mean no oil! you just use less oil, make sure the pan is properly heated and eggs do release.
the all-clad in the picture is stainless steel with aluminum core; all the nice heating properties of alumnium with the easy cleanup and durability of steel.
it’s not hard to keep shiny. if something does get stuck, make a little paste of baking soda, bon ami or barkeepers friend and scrub!

calphalon is all aluminum, hard anodized. it’s actually stronger than stainless steel. but i don’t like because its dark surface sometimes makes it hard to see how the crust is developing.

quick PSA: aluminum = alzheimer’s is a myth. check snopes, which has a great article from scientific american.

 
16.
Guest Icon
Guest
hm

also — calphalon and all-clad do not use teflon in their non-stick.

 
17.
Guest Icon
Guest
D

My FH and I did a lot of cookware shopping for our registry because we LOVE to cook. We registered for the Calphalon tri-ply stainless steel (not the non-stick set). We were advised by a very knowledgeable sales rep/manager at BBB that while All-Clad is generally considered top-of-the-line, the Calphalon stainless steel lines last as long as the All-Clad, are of equivalent quality, and unless you are planning to do professional cooking, the added expense isn’t worth it.

Also, you should consider the weight of each pan. I am a relatively small woman and I found that the Calphalon stainless steel pans had more ergonomic handles and were slightly lighter (which is important when you are trying to lift a pan full of food by yourself with one hand).

If you are concerned about food sticking or healthy cooking, purchase one good-quality non-stick pan for eggs and whatnot, and/or buy a Misto (sold at various stores such as BBB and W-S) for use on your stainless steel pans.

FYI, we also compared prices between Macy’s and BBB, and we found that for any given item that both stores carry, the prices are about 10-20% cheaper at Bed Bath and Beyond than it is at Macy’s. And as PhillyM has pointed out, your guests can save even more by using those coupons that BBB sends out regularly. You’d be surprised at just what range of items BBB offers - almost as broad a range as Macy’s, and with better prices to boot. They also have a completion discount.

 
18.
Guest Icon
Guest
Lewie

About those BBB coupons: They specifically exclude All-Clad! But you can use them for the Calphalon. So for us, it was a no-brainer. Calphalon it is!

 
19.
Guest Icon
Guest
sara

I have the Calphalon ones. I LOVE them! they are so great to cook with, so easy to clean, I couldn’t be happier with them.

 
20.
Guest Icon
Guest
tracy

i love calphalon :)

 
21.
Guest Icon
Guest
Miss Bluebear

I own All-Clad right now (the stainless steel with copper lining) and maybe it’s just me, but after the first use, the “shinyness” was no longer there. It was replaced by irremovable watermarks and a bunch of what looks like yellow and blue marks on the bottom of the pots. It takes forever for me to boil a pot of water since it specifically says not to have the heat on high otherwise it’ll damage the pot so it takes just that much longer on medium fire. Finally being the lightweight that I am, I find the pots on the heavy side and they are not easy to lift. I think next time I’ll go with the Calphalon ones that require less maintenance.

 
22.
Guest Icon
Guest
 
23.
Guest Icon
Guest
wormy

If you want non-stick I would say go with a cheaper version and consider just buying a nonstick skillet for eggs and other delicate items separately, then a set of stainless steel pots & pans. I’ve found that my calphalon non-stick pans last about as long as much cheaper ones. You can be careful with the coating but eventually it starts showing wear and shortly after that it becomes junk. Regular SS cookware (whether its calphalon or all-clad) is pretty much indestructable and can last a lifetime. You should check them out in person and see which you like the feel of.

 
24.
Guest Icon
Guest
Miss Lemon

I wanted to know this answer too!!! So… CONSUMER REPORTS to the rescue!

And… Costco & Sam’s Clubs sets ended up at the top of the list :)

For what its worth, this from the Dec ‘05 issue of Consumer Reports. Cookware was rated on cooking evenness, non-stick durability (if applicable), safety, comfort, sturdiness, and ease of cleaning.

Nonstick (20 rated):
1) Kirkland Signature (Costco)
2) Anolon Titanium
3) Anolon Advanced
4) Emerilware
5) Scanpan Classic 20203
Notables: 11) Calphalon One, 13) Calphalon Essentials, 17) Simply Calphalon

Uncoated (16 tested)
1) KitchenAid Gourmet Essentials Brushed Stainless
2) Calphalon Contemporary
3) Emerilware Stainless
4) Magnalite Classic
5) Member’s Mark (Sam’s Club) Tri-Ply-Clad Item 955462
Notables: 8) All-Clad Master Chef 2 700393, 10) All-Clad Copper Core 6000-7SS, 38) Viking Professional Starter Set

 
25.
Guest Icon
Guest
M

Miss Bluebear–Some Bon Ami or Bar Keepers Friend and those spots and stains will be gone! It’s like a little miracle. I swear.

 
26.
Guest Icon
Guest
Jennifer

I have Calphalon non stick. I know that there are varying degrees of Calphalon, and I got one towards the top, and I’m so glad I did. I agree about the handles being ergonomical and the pans being easy to use. And I don’t have any funny tastes in my sauces. And, yes, you can make sauces in non-stick! I love my pans!!!!

 
27.
Guest Icon
Guest
ms mouse

hm- that’s really good to know. I know that Teflon has been found to be dangerous and breaks down quickly at over 600 degrees (3 minutes on high with nothing in it)… do you know what All-Clad and Calphalon use and if it has similar problems?

 
28.
Guest Icon
Guest
HC

Personally I love our Viking cookware. I really don’t like the handles on the All-Clad. If lifting a heavier pot (which they all are full of liquid) they are not at all comfortable. Have you tried holding both styles to see if you have a preference?

 
29.
Guest Icon
Guest
Laura

non-stick scares me. although they are supposed to phase out the carcinogens by 2015!

 
30.
Guest Icon
Guest
Iris

For me, Le Creuset — Guaranteed forever! Nonsticks are sort-of disposable (and upgradeable — the technology keeps getting better), and I want wedding gifts I will have always.

That said, get what you need realistically to cook in the style YOU like. No point getting anything but what you can use.

 
31.
Guest Icon
Guest
wsukarebear

SALLY-I don’t know if anyone answered your question, but at that point really all you can do is word of mouth. If you have any showers that are thrown for you, then it is generally more acceptable to include the info on that invite (or again, word of mouth). Hope that helps you out!

 
32.
Guest Icon
Guest
hm

MS MOUSE: all-clad and calphalon both use their own proprietary non-stick. all-clad’s is called “excalibur” (OOOoo!) and calpahlon did not give theirs a fancy name. neither contain teflon, which is a specific kind of nonstick made by dupont.

also, if you’re cooking at 600 degrees, the food is burning.

i’ll have to check cook’s illustrated for their recommendations; for cookware and food things, i trust them over consumer reports.

 
33.
Guest Icon
Guest
sally

Thanks!

 
34.
Guest Icon
Guest
Danielle

i’ve been married and using calphalon for 2 months now. it’s AMAZING!!!! easy to clean, even heat distribution, cool handles. AWESOME! i would DEFINITLEY recommend it!

 
35.
Guest Icon
Guest
ms mouse

hm- I meant it to illustrate how easily it is to get to 600 degrees without noticing. You put a pan on the stove, turn the heat up and start looking for the butter/egg/whatever, and you’ve already exceeded the safety range. For a long time they thought the breakdown of Teflon at high temps or through scratching wasn’t a problem because it was thought to be inert. It’s not, and one of the big questions is how long Dupont knew that. In further reading it’s been suggested that the polytetrafluorocarbon, one of the ingredients of concern, is used in other non-Teflon coatings. I don’t want to be anti-nonstick, I just want to know that what I’m using is safe. It’s so frustrating because there aren’t many straightforward (don’t need a science degree) and reliable sources of info out there.

 
36.
Guest Icon
Guest
SoireeLaura

We have the same Calphalon ones you have in the photo, and we love them! We don’t do any gourmet cooking and aren’t picky about the minute differences between how quickly they heat up or how even the heat distribution is. For the things we do make, they’re great! Super easy to clean although you can’t pop them in the dishwasher. The price difference was worth it to me and I have no regrets so far. Hope that helps — good luck!

 
37.
Guest Icon
Guest
Annie

get the nonstick.. i got all stainless steel and it’s just annoying by now. i keep reaching for my cheapy ikea nonstick frying pan and my ancient nonstick saucepan.

also take a good look into a good knife set - wusthof isn’t good for women (too heavy) but i like my henkels.

 
38.
Guest Icon
Guest
Kris

Get a mix- I love to cook, and I would want to make a nice sauce in the all clad, but I wouldn’t want to sear a piece of fish on anything that wasn’t nonstick. Pick the set you would want to use most and get a couple extra pieces in the other.

 
39.
Guest Icon
Guest
Michele

I owned a few Calphalon, and upgraded to All Clad when I got married.

I also traded in my 10″ All Clad Tephlon skillet for the regular skillet (love that lifetime guarantee). I have no problems cooking eggs without tephlon, just need to watch the heat and oil.

 
40.
Guest Icon
Guest
Stainless Steel Flatware

Interesting, I have not heard about this

 
41.
Guest Icon
Guest
SouthWind88

Media headlines emphasize drug and alcohol abuse among youth, teen pregnan- cy, the rise in youth gangs, or school dropout rates and often leave it at that. ,

 


You can also just...

Newer blog post
more in Blog
Older blog post
Newer blog post by Mrs. Emerald
more by Mrs. Emerald (oldest)
Older blog post by Mrs. Emerald
Visit our sister sites Project Wedding
Wedding Songs
eHarmony Advice
Dating Advice
JustMommies
Pregnancy Calendar
Fertile Thoughts
Infertility Support
Copyright 2004-2009, eHarmony, Inc., Advertise
 


Sponsors
Mrs. Emerald
Mrs. Emerald Mrs. Emerald, Chicago Age and Occupation: 26, Wedding Planner Fiance's Age and Occupation: 26, Paralegal Engagement Date: October 8, 2006 Wedding Date: September 2007 Blogging Since: November 29, 2006 Venue: Hyatt Lodge, Oak Brook IL About Me: I have been dreaming about my wedding forever, and flipping through bridal magazines since high school, so I am in my element! I am calling our theme "Vintage Inspired French/Asian Fusion." Mr. Emerald is very involved in the planning process, but of course he generally defers to me cuz I have a strong opinion of how I want everything to be :-).
Weddingbee PRO
 
Boards
 
Classifieds
 

Blog Calendar
November 2009
SunMonTueWedThuFriSat
1234567
891011121314
15161718192021
22232425262728
2930

Weddingbee Bios
Wiki
More