Register or log in —

Newer blog post
more in Blog
Older blog post
Newer blog post by Reader Buzz
more by Reader Buzz (oldest)
Older blog post by Reader Buzz
Reader Buzz's Picture
Reader Buzz About: Let us know what you think by leaving a comment...
About Reader Buzz

Reader Buzz: Religion and Weddings

February 28th, 2007 @ 5:10 pm by Reader Buzz

Miss Blueberry had a great post yesterday about how her atheist background has caused a conflict with her ringbearer participating in her wedding. Obviously coming from a different religious background than your SO can potentially create issues. But having no religious affiliation can cause conflict as well; whether it’s selecting a venue or officiant, dealing with in-laws, etc., these issues often present themself when planning a wedding and a life together.

Has your (or your FI’s) lack of religion posed any problems in your relationship or your relationships with your in-laws? How has it affected your wedding planning, and how have you handled or resolved such issues?

Tags: , |   Link for this post | Share this post: Reader Buzz: Religion and Weddings      
Newer blog post
more in Blog
Older blog post
Newer blog post by Reader Buzz
more by Reader Buzz (oldest)
Older blog post by Reader Buzz
advertisement below

13 Responses to “Reader Buzz: Religion and Weddings”

1.
Guest Icon
Guest
wsukarebear

Although my FI is Catholic as is his large family, when I asked him what he wanted to do, he said to get married outdoors (which I luckily agreed with!).

I don’t know how his family, or even my Catholic dad, feels about this…but now I really wonder since that post!

What I do like is that we’re being married by a “retired” Presbyterian minister…so although we want a lightly religious ceremony, there was no pressure to talk about our relationship through counseling (which I hear can be stressful admitting to church officials!) or to have a deeply religious ceremony–hence our tying in the Celtic quaich ceremony. I think being married by a friend ordained online is lovely, but it wasn’t for us and I am glad a member of the clergy is marrying us!

 
2.
Guest Icon
Guest
Tessa

Absolutely. My family is Mormon and of course they want us married by a Mormon officiant (Bishop) in a Mormon church, blah blah. I just say what I want and my mom says what she wants and we come up with a compromise. I didn’t want to get married in a Mormon church, so we found a venue that both of us really liked where we could also have the reception.
I don’t know, it just worked out by us talking it through.

 
3.
Guest Icon
Guest
SarainSeattle

I am Catholic and hubby is Lutheran so we are not an extreme case, but it did require a compromise. We too decided on outside rather than in either of our churches. Most people in the family seem to be ok with it, my grandmother is probably the only one having a hard time, but she still agreed to play the piano at the ceremony so she isn’t too upset. We are having a Christian minister marry us so it will still be a religious ceremony.

 
4.
Guest Icon
Guest
FarmGal

Our families are very religious, just not the same ones (Catholic & Episcopalian). FI and I have similar, but still differing spiritual beliefs, yet we were 100% on the same page about how we saw our ceremony. Our families were *very* upset/offended/concerned that we are not having any religion whatsoever in our ceremony. We explained that, while we appreciate their perspectives, we have always held these beliefs and don’t intend to change them for this particular occasion. We’ve heard nothing more about it since. :)

We’re having a private ceremony: just our closest family members (even still, there will be 41 in attendance!), and that has created equitable a fuss as well.

We figured out recently that it’s impossible to please both families, so we might as well make it a joyous day for ourselves and hope the rest will fall into place!

 
5.
Guest Icon
Guest
elizabeth

My fiance and I are both atheists. My father is a methodist preacher and fiances family is devoutly catholic. We are getting married in a non-demoniational chapel with my father serving as the officiant. FI family doesn’t care about our non-religious ceremony but my mom has some choice words to say about it! She keeps throwing barbs out about how our wedding will be only 5 mns long and it will have no meaning. Although she complains, she realizes that it is our wedding and we can do as we like.

 
6.
Guest Icon
Guest
bunnybride0108

We have been lucky that our families do not really influence what we do. Neither of us live by them. I am Buddhist. He is Christian and Buddhist. We are crafting our own ceremony. We actually spent the past weekend at a marriage preparation retreat organized by and for Catholics. They were just nice enough to let us participate and they did not try to disuade us from not being Catholic. It was good to talk about spirituality in our lives as it pertains to the wedding and our values.

I practice more structured spirituality than my fiancee and he now plans to attend services held at our home institution. In turn he will teach me a few prayers because I am completely ignorant about the bible and prayers. We are fine with the arrangements for the ceremony but thought more about how to rear our family as we start having kids. We are in agreement as to how we will do this. It is just good to talk about this kind of stuff beforehand. Before our retreat we went through exercises in the Conscious Brides Wedding Planner, so we had no surprises.

Good luck to everyone with this issue because it can be tricky when you are not the same faith, or are not following the faith exactly as how your family wishes.

 
7.
Guest Icon
Guest
twelvetigers

We’re both equally indifferent about religion, and that works well for us. I’m glad I don’t have to wrry about anyone being mad that we’re not getting married in a church or by a pastor/priest. My sister had to REmarry (have another wedding) to appease the mother in law. They eloped the first time, but I think she didn’t appreciate having to toss together an event like that.

 
8.
Guest Icon
Guest
beta

We are atheists and my parents are Evangelical Christians. They knew long before we were engaged that we wouldn’t have a church ceremony–and they agree the church should be reserved for the believers not the pretenders. But, I didn’t want to ignore my upbringing or disrespect their beliefs by having no religion in our ceremony. So, after we are married, my grandmother is coming up to give a blessing–sort of a closing prayer. It made my mom really happy that I was going to do this.

 
9.
Guest Icon
Guest
Bebe

We are agnostics, and everyone else runs the gamut from total atheist (my dad) to extremely devout Episcopalian (his dad) to every variation and just about every Christian denomination in between.

We’re having a UU ceremony. FI wanted there to be a minister out of respect for his father; I didn’t want to be a hypocrite. We did a ton of research, and I feel very comfortable with UUism, and I like our minister very much.

Luckily, no one has said a single negative word about it, so I am glad we do not have that drama to deal with…

 
10.
Guest Icon
Guest
thistleorchid

I was raised in many religions. My mother was raised Unitarian (although my grandmother was a Transendentalist, but when that died out, many became Unitarians and my grandfather was an aethist). My father was raised in a Catholic country (Columbia/Panama/Costa Rica) by a Baha’i and a Jew who pretended to be Catholic in public in the 1950’s. So there are pictures of my Dad the Baha’i/Jew in front of Christmas trees.

Needless to say, when I was born in a Catholic country, my grandparent’s maid found out that there were no plans to baptise me, so she kidnapped me for the afternoon and stood up as my godmother in church to have me baptized in the Catholic church. She soon after confessed and apologized to my parents who thought it was pretty damn funny and figured hey - she’s pretty covered by the Christian/Judea God. I was raised knowing all of these religions and developing my own sense of spirituality/religion

So when I became engaged to my FI who was raised Catholic, his mother had hopes that we’d have a Catholic ceremony b/c I could after all with being baptized. But we put our foot down pretty strongly that we’d be having a very multi/non-denominational (it’s still a little fuzzy, haven’t figured it all out) outside so long as it doesn’t rain.

My FI’s response to his mother I thought was brilliant. His comment was “Mom, God’s a pretty smart guy, he’ll figure it out.”

 
11.
Guest Icon
Guest
Di

Neither of us are very religious (he is atheist, I am just not much into religion) but his family is catholic. His whole family is not very happy that it’s not going to be in a catholic church, but rather the courthouse… but we don’t care.

 
12.
Guest Icon
Guest
future mrs j.o.b

i’m catholic qnd sweetie is baptist. well we decided to get married in another location that is outside the church. Since then my family has been criticising how ungodly i’m starting my marriage. it hurts my feelings but that’s what we wanted.

 
13.
Guest Icon
Guest
Emms

We are meeting with my FI’s mom this weekend, and for some reason I have a feeling that it is about her family and religion at our wedding.(She grew up very religious and much of her family is) We are having an outdoor wedding and neither of us are religious. Will be interesting to see what mom is going to say!

 


You can also just...

Newer blog post
more in Blog
Older blog post
Newer blog post by Reader Buzz
more by Reader Buzz (oldest)
Older blog post by Reader Buzz
Visit our sister sites Project Wedding
Wedding Songs
eHarmony Advice
Dating Advice
JustMommies
Pregnancy Calendar
Fertile Thoughts
Infertility Support
Copyright 2004-2009, eHarmony, Inc., Advertise
 


Sponsors
Reader Buzz
Reader Buzz Reader Buzz About: Let us know what you think by leaving a comment...
Weddingbee PRO
 
Boards
 
Classifieds
 

Blog Calendar
November 2009
SunMonTueWedThuFriSat
1234567
891011121314
15161718192021
22232425262728
2930

Weddingbee Bios
Wiki
More