Hot Searches:

Tags on this Entry

Tags: ,
 

 

 
 
 
Mrs. Flamingo Mrs. Flamingo, Montreal, Canada Age and Occupation: 25, Graphic Designer Fiance's Age and Occupation: 30, Nursing Student Engagement Date: December 2004 Wedding Date: June 21, 2008 Venue: Imperia Hotel (modern chic hotel) About Me: I am a passionate designer who loves anything pretty. I heart all paper products (eco-friendly of course). My passion revolves around anything considered glamour; vintage and modern. In my free time, I love reading Martha mags, designing jewelry and making a pit-stop at Starbucks for a chai latte. I'm also a chocoholic at heart and my family drools over my homemade truffles.
 
Mrs. Flamingo's Picture
Mrs. Flamingo, Montreal, Canada Age and Occupation: 25, Graphic Designer Fiance's Age and Occupation: 30, Nursing Student Engagement Date: December 2004 Wedding Date: June 21, 2008 Venue: Imperia Hotel (modern chic hotel) About Me: I am a passionate designer who loves anything pretty. I heart all paper products (eco-friendly of course). My passion revolves around anything considered glamour; vintage and modern. In my free time, I love reading Martha mags, designing jewelry and making a pit-stop at Starbucks for a chai latte. I'm also a chocoholic at heart and my family drools over my homemade truffles.
About Mrs. Flamingo

Do Me A Favor… Be Honest

January 21st, 2008 @ 2:33 pm by Mrs. Flamingo

I came across a brilliant post written by Manolo for the brides about giving favors and the good and not so good choices. It was extremely well written and straight to the point. But there was just one part of the post that hit a soft spot:

Just do me one favor, if you’ll pardon the pun: if you decide not to give out favors, for the love of all that’s holy do not put out some sort of notice that you decided rather than spending the money on your guests, you’ve given it to charity for them instead. For one thing, people should be allowed to choose their own charities. I don’t care who you give it to, you’re going to at least annoy and possibly offend someone. More than that, though, those notices tell your guests that it wasn’t spending the money you minded, but spending the money on them which is an incredibly rude thing to say. Go ahead and give to the charity of your choice. Just don’t try to tell me that’s my party favor, because it isn’t.

After reading this… I started to question myself. Let me give you a little history. As favors for our guests, I was planning on giving a donation to the Quebec Breast Cancer Association. This is really important to me because 5 years ago my grandmother passed away of breast cancer. Also, my mom was diagnosed with the cancer several years back and she can now call herself a survivor. I thought a donation to a known charity with some significance would be nice, instead of offering the not so useful favor.

I still wanted to highlight the whole breast cancer thing because it is important to me, but at the same time we did not want our guests leave empty handed so Mr. Flamingo and I thought it would be nice to offer a little something. We thought that maybe some truffles could be a neat idea, but then again, we need to buy the chocolate and the packaging, so the price would go up rather quickly. Then there was the option of a bottle of imported sparkling water which could be a good choice. Someone also suggested pink m & m’s but they only come out in October which is breast cancer awareness month, and the ones left in the store will be stale by my wedding. Of course there will be pink and red ones for valentine… but that defeats the purpose since there is no donation given.

I personally wouldn’t mind going to a wedding and having a donation to a charity as a favor. I find it to be a really neat idea, both ‘green’ and for a good cause. But is that just me? Am I totally out of the loop?

What do you think readers and bees? How would you feel to receive a donation as a favor. Please be honest. I don’t want my guests to be offended! Thanks a million.

{Images courtesy of : Marthastewartcrafts.com}

89 Responses to “Do Me A Favor… Be Honest”

1.
amysue says:

you know - i throw away most inedible favors i get. i went to a wedding where they put up cards notifying us that they’d donated to a charity in our name, and i thought that was awesome. then again, it was a charity that i supported, so i can see how somebody could be offended if the money was given to a group the person had a problem with. i can’t see that being the case with breast cancer research.

anyway, i didn’t feel cheated or offended at all.

2.
wsukarebear says:

It’s kind of a semantics argument…do I care if someone notifies me that they’ve made a donation in lieu of a favor? Heck no–it’s a great cause and probably something the bride and groom care about. It almost sounds like that poster wouldn’t mind as long as you didn’t “say” it was a favor. But I can’t believe anyone cares that much!

One of the bees posted a while back about a board where guests choose where they would like money donated–it was really cute! Then you make the donation after the wedding in proportional allotments–at least I think that was the idea. ;-)

Continue with your plans. I highly doubt you’ll offend a guest by making a charitable donation to breast cancer research…and if so, does it REALLY bother you? I don’t think it should. :-)

3.
Bee Icon
Miss Dahlia says:

I’ve thought about it, and participated in other discussions about this. I’ve also given to charity as a gift before (but I’ve asked the recipient which charity they would prefer I make a donation to.)

I could see myself being bothered with the whole giving to charity “favor” idea. First, because donating to charity is something that is deeply personal and private for me- I don’t give because I want others to know about it. Second, because it is possible that the chosen charity would be one that others might be offended by. (NARAL and Planned Parenthood come to mind.)

Mr. D, on the other hand, really wants charity giving to be a large part of our wedding- and we’ve registered with Heifer International. However, I felt conflicted about having both traditional registries and one for a charity, so we have not advertised our HI charity.

We will be giving out traditional favors. But we will be donating a sizable amount of the cash gifts which we receive.

Why not just make the donation to charity and scrap favors all together?

4.
rebecca says:

honestly, i’ve heard so many different views on favors, i have no idea what to do! like amysue said, people throw away inedible favors, but edible favors can be considered not so sentimental — and now people are getting offended by a favor!

i was going to go the charity route after okaying it with my mom and my FMIL (donating to the shelter where my FI and I adopted our dog from), but now i’m having second thoughts!

5.
tberry says:

I have to say that I agree with Manolo. If you are going to do the charity favor a token favor (choclates, candy etc.) in addition to the charity is necessary. It is easy to offend somone. I alsa don’t suggest that you say the donation is given in the guest’s name. I would be offended if my name was put on a doantion for a charity I was against. (not because of the cause per se but many charities are so poorly run that the majority of the donations end up funding the admisnitration and not the good works or research that it was meant to). I would make the donation in the name of the person or persons that inspired the charity. For instance your mom’s name or you could put it as a generic name, such as the “Family & Friends of the Flamingos”

6.
vee says:

i don’t really understand people who are “offended” by a donation in lieu of a party favor. it’s such a wonderful idea to give to charity and really, no one needs another useless wedding favor. the guests don’t get to “choose” the charity but who’s going to think that donating to breast cancer awareness or an organization for kids with cancer, etc. is offensive?

in short, i think it’s a great idea and will probably do it myself too!

7.
Tracy Torre-Walsh says:

I don’t think charitable donations are at all offensive or annoying.
By choosing a charity that’s meaningful to you, it offers your guests an opportunity to know of a good cause that you care about.

For example, for my wedding in June, on the back of my menu cards (alternating sides on every other place setting), I made donations to my late grandfather’s foundation and my late cousin’s foundation–and I explained what the charities did and why we picked them (I’m a law student and my husband is a software developer).

Many guests commented how nice it was to learn a little bit more about my family and that it was a generous way to remember two important people.

“In Lieu of Traditional Wedding Favors,
A Donation Has Been Made To:

The Justice Porfirio V. Sison Foundation
Giving Scholarships to Law Students
Who Promote Social Justice

The Miguel C. Sison Foundation
Giving Computers to Underprivileged Children
Who Deserve Education

In Honor of Tracy’s Grandfather and Cousin,
We Celebrate Law and Technology–A Perfect Pair”

8.
suzanno says:

You can actually get pink m&ms all year round (or any other color, or mixes of colors, and with custom stuff written on them) from http://www.mymms.com. So if you want, you could get the two pink color mix, with your names or the date… You are limited to two lines of text at eight letters per line. I have ordered these for various fund raiser dinners, and they are generally a big hit.

9.
deanna says:

I really like the pink m&m’s idea. I believe you can get pink all year long at http://www.mymms.com/customprint/. Check it out!

10.
Tea says:

i can see how some people may get offended depending on their religious or political leanings but considering that your charity of choice isn’t rooted in a potentially controversal charity, i say go ahead with your idea. you can also order pink m&m’s from m&ms.com i believe if that’s something you’d like to do in addition to your planned contribution.

i wouldn’t feel cheated either way. i don’t usually keep the favors anyway so there’s no love lost there.

11.
deanna says:

ha ha I just posted the same thing, suzanno!

12.
liv says:

I wouldn’t feel offended at all. In fact, that’s what we’re doing (haven’t picked which charity yet, though). I personally think most favors are pretty stupid and wasteful. I think edible favors are nice, but since we’re having a “green” wedding I am generally against candy (really bad for you and full of chemicals and takes lots of resources to produce) and individually wrapped chocolates (so much paper plastic to package) and things like that.

The last wedding I went to, the couple put a notice on each table saying that a donation was given in our name to a depression research charity. I thought it was awesome. The only thing I would consider odd would be something incredibly political like a particular election campaign or something very pro/anti the war.

I’d go for it. But maybe it depends on your crowd. I can’t imagine any of our wedding guests finding it annoying/rude, but that’s probably why they are our friends.

13.
Bee Icon
Miss Penguin says:

My opinion is that its YOUR wedding day and if this particular charity is important to YOU than its totally acceptable to give to it in lieu of favors. All of the favors that I’ve received (and to be honest, the ones I plan to give) are merely trivial. Granted, yes, I’m handcrafting mine with love, but do people care that much about receiving some chocolate/coasters/winestopper/bauble? No. Most people spend less than $5 per favor on their guests…but added all together, that can be a huge chunk of change that can really help make a difference for a charitable cause. I think if a particular charity is truly meaningful to you, then you should give, with no regrets, in lieu of favors.

And honestly, the person who wrote that comment is rude and selfish to say something that basically boils down to “I’d rather you spend money on me then send it to a good cause.” Yikes. I dont care what the cause is, because chances are you as the bride and groom have picked it because its important to you. I’d like to think that yes, your wedding is to entertain your guests, but in the end, is really about YOU, your commitments, and your beliefs.

Go for it Miss F!

14.
KermitClin says:

I think if you approach it delicately and give a short explaination of your reason for choosing the charity that you did. As a guest I’d much rather see the charity has a meaning to the couple instead of just something randomly chosen to give to.
I can see Manolo’s point about not sharing the donation so not to offend guests, however it can also be beneficial to share the cause as well. I heard about some local (Columbus, OH) brides who shared their donations made in guests’ honor and it spurred more giving from guests through random donations and also engaged couples who did donations at their weddings. So in the end, the charity received much more money than it would have if the couple had stayed silent about their donation.

15.
Maple says:

I wouldn’t at all feel offended if a donation was made to a Breast Cancer Association - that’s a wonderful idea. Call it a favor/don’t call it a favor - it’s a little over the top if this is something people are complaining about, IMO.

If someone donated to a more controversial association, in my name, I might feel odd/offended.

16.
kris says:

who cares about favors! no matter what I usually give/throw away most favors I receive at wedding, u know what you will NEVER EVER be able to please anyone so give ti charity if u want, I think it’s a great idea

17.
Bee Icon
Miss Flamingo says:

Thanks everyone with your honest comments. When I told my mom about the idea… she got all teary eyed. She tought it was a great idea to give a donation… but then again she had never heard of charity donations as favor so she might not know the complexity.

My issue with mms is that I wanted to purchase one which is directly linked to breast cancer. Buying the typical pink would be useless since part of the proceeds are not given to research.

Also, I think that Breast Cancer is something that affects everyone man, woman or child. You are bound to know someone who has or has had breast cancer… therefore I personally don’t think my family would be offened… yet I do not know. I was gonna make a speech about the reasoning behind the idea….

but what… should i just give a donation to the cause, and on a card with a ribbon write a little message… or should I opt to buy something else so people dont leave empty handed?

18.
LB says:

honestly, i think the fact that anyone is making you second guess an idea for a thoughtful gift (which is NOT a requirement) is a bit insane. since when have weddings gotten so out of control that many people think they are required to give their guests a gift (besides an expensive dinner and beautiful evening), but are now concerned that they are offending someone by this gift?
your charity is the breast cancer foundation and it is in memory of someone you cared about, which i think its absolutely wonderful and admirable! go with your gut and dont overthink this.
if you would like to do something extra with chocolates, that is sweet too, but know that your guests are there because they love and care about you, not because they want to judge you, or require anything extra!
good luck!
i love your ideas!

19.
psu01 says:

If you can swing it and want to make both camps happy, I’d say make a donation & buy the candy in bulk and make little favors for your guests (just a handful of candy wrapped up in tulle with a ribbon). I did a quick search on pink candy and found this site: http://www.candywarehouse.com/pinkcandy.html

20.
AOEBuckeye says:

I think it is a wonderful choice for you if you explain the significance beyond your choice to your guests. Maybe on small cards with your mom overcoming breast cancer and in memory of your grandma? And if you feel bothered by manolo’s comment, I’ve seen before small cards explaining the donation attached to those wrist bands (you know like the lance armstrong yellow ones, but they have them for breast cancer, dummy me the name escapes me now). They’re a dollar a piece, and they used to sell them online for a bulk price.

21.
Christine says:

I’m in the same situation - I want to do the donations to the American Cancer Society or some cancer research organization since my grandfather had cancer. I’m going to do a card for each seat with a awareness ribbon pin attached in periwinkle ribbon (which is the stomach cancer color). Almost everyone there will know why even though I won’t be putting his name on the card and like you said, for those who might not know about my grandfather exactly, everyone has been touched by cancer in some way. I think it’s a great idea & would mean a lot to those most important to you! And that’s all that matters.

22.
Liz says:

Here is a site through m & ms http://www.mymms.com/sgk/

They donate 10% of the purchase to breast cancer research.

23.
Nopinkertons says:

I dunno, I have to agree with the Manolo post. I have no problem with you donating to any charity you choose on the occasion of your wedding–it’s meaningful to you, and I think that’s terrific. We all have causes we care about. I also don’t care if I don’t receive a favor at a wedding: a lovely meal, a great party, and the chance to see someone I care about so happy is plenty. But linking the two is weird to me; it usually makes me think, “Well, it’s not a favor to [i]me[/i].” To me, there’s no connection between the two things, and forcing the connection just seems bizarre and can lead to offense, particularly as it can come across as being linked only so that you can advertise your generosity, presumably in contrast to your guests’ lack of it.

If it’s important to you to remember your grandmother in this way, you could instead, for example, put out a small sign next to your guestbook with her picture and the note that, since she could not be with you on your special day, you’ve remembered her with a donation to the Quebec Breast Cancer Association. This way you get your message across without suggesting that your guests are so backwards that you had to donate on their behalf.

24.
Liz says:

I totally agree with LB on this one.

Don’t question your ideas because of this article. I think people feeling this way about favors have been to a few too many weddings. It’s a gift no matter whether you take it with you or not.

25.
Bee Icon
Miss Flamingo says:

Sister Flamingo offered we make chocolate ribbons to offer with the card. That way they can eat it and with the card would clearly know its a donation for a good cause.

Of course I dont want to spend a fortune on the favors (donation or not) but with all your comments, I think its made me more certain of my choice.

I was afraid… but im reassured. And like you all said.. if someone is affended (which i doubt) well too bad for them!!! Thanks so much guys. And if you have more ideas… keep them coming! :)

26.
Bee Icon
Miss Flamingo says:

Thanks for the link Liz, but I wanted to donate to a Canadian foundation and that site is american. It all comes down to the same thing, and if I find not other way I will…. but I might opt for something else instead.

27.
pancy says:

I agree with the other people who say that the Manolo for Brides post sounds a bit crazy. My FI and I are also making a donation to the American Cancer Society in lieu of traditional favors and I feel like it fits perfect with us because we volunteer with them every year in honor of my father who passed away 5 years ago from cancer. All of our friends and family know that my father passed away from cancer and that we were very close and I honestly can’t see anyone being offended by knowing we donated to ACS because even though donations are personal, my close family and friends already know that we give them donations. We will just be upping the ante for this particular one in relation to the wedding. Honestly, as a guest, I feel special enough to be invited and be given a nice meal. I don’t expect anything all that special as a gift to me for coming to take part in my friend’s special day. I am more offended by her post than any favor I have or have not received at a wedding.

28.
Liz says:

I like the idea of the chocolate ribbon. That would be uber cute and totally fit within your donation.

29.
beanchar says:

I don’t know who “Manolo” is, but I sure wouldn’t want him for a wedding guest– or a friend! What a selfish brat.

First of all, the wedding “favor” is a quite recent phenomenon (probably dreamed up by the Wedding Industrial Complex) and not AT ALL required by established etiquette.

That said, many couples enjoy the idea of giving a little something extra to their guests (on top of the food, drink, music, good time, etc.) and that’s just fine, but again, NOT REQUIRED.

Like many couples, you have chosen a favor that has symbolizes something important to you. I applaud your desire only to spend money on a physical favor that would also benefit your chosen cause. If you can’t find one, I’m sure the donation will be just fine with your guests– the fact that it is “in their honor” instead of in their pocket will be irrelevant.

BTW, I was the one who suggested the pink M&M’s, but I see now you can only get them year-round here in the States– with the proceeds going to the Susan G Komen Foundation. http://www.mymms.com/sgk/promise_blend_detail.asp

That said, if you do want them, I’d be happy to be your US “shipping address” and then send them on to you in “Canadialand”. You have my email addy. :)

OK, this post is turning into a novel, but I just want to say one last “BRAVA!” for making charitable giving a part of your big day. You rock.

30.
beanchar says:

Ooops! I was writing my post before I saw your about wanting to donate to the Canadian Foundation. Makes sense!

31.
Helene says:

Personally, I don’t see a problem with charity donations for favors if that’s what you want to do, especially for something like medical research - who could get offended by that?

There are other alternatives though for anyone who might be questioning these types of favors. I found out that the website weddingchannel.com offers charity donations through their registry setup. If guests buy their registry gifts through that site, they will donate a percentage of the amount spent to the charity of your choice. My husband has a disease called cystic fibrosis, so we made a weddingchannel.com account, picked the Cystic Fibrosis Foundation as the charity, and put a link to the registry site on our wedding website. Granted, the percentage donated is small, and guests might not use that website to make their registry purchases. However, we did have several guests who noticed this and made extra contributions in addition to their gifts, which I thought was really nice. We weren’t fishing for donations, but just thought it would be nice to do a little something in an unobtrusive way.

I’m sure there are lots of other alternatives out there too - but whichever way you go, I just can’t find anything wrong with charitable donations to a good cause that’s important to you! As for what to give as a physical favor - maybe try something like the shop at komen.org or another breast cancer fundraising organization, where you can buy something small for your guests, and part of your purchase goes to fund research.

32.
Courtney says:

I wouldn’t be offended, but I don’t view a favor as a charity gift. It’s more like the bride and groom spent a part of their budget on a charity of their choice instead of on a small keepsake that many guests may not want anyway.

If you want your guests to enjoy something and not do a charity gift, it’s hard to go wrong with something edible…

33.
MCB says:

I don’t think you should worry about your guests leaving empty-handed, Miss F — I’ve been a guest at several weddings and I couldn’t tell you if they had favors or what they were (except for the wedding where it took me fifteen minutes to figure out what the favor actually was! It was a paper circle embedded with flower seeds, meant to be planted in a pot — and mine was missing the instructions, so I had no idea why the bride and groom were handing out bumpy paper circles). If you can’t find a favor that donates money to a Canadian breast cancer charity, just give the money to the charity outright. No one will feel jipped that they didn’t receive a chocolate truffle or heart-shaped soap. Whether you want to tell the guests that’s what you’ve done is up to you, but I think if you’re honoring a family member they will love to hear about it.

34.
Liene says:

It’s not offensive. I agree that it really boils down to a semantics issue. Many brides choose to say “a donation has been made in your honor” so that it is personalized for the guests. I wouldn’t say in lieu of favors or call it a favor or anything like that. Even edible favors get tossed or left behind. I often wind up giving them to the college-aged catering staff at the end of the night to take home to their roommates so that I don’t have to throw them away.

35.
Kristin says:

I think this is a great idea. I was at a wedding last year. The groom’s mother has passed away from ALS some years before. The couple had donation favors to the ALS Foundation. They printed a simple card explaining the reason for their choice and attached a ribbon (white with black stripes) to it. I thought it was very thoughtful.
I feel like most guests discard favors after the wedding. But with a donation you know that your dollars are going to waste.

36.
Laura says:

I think anyone expecting a favor at a wedding is offensive!! Tradition or not, the guests are invited to take part in your day, to celebrate you, because they are supposedly your loved ones! If you want to make it more personal you can simply state (as others suggested) that the donation was given in honor of “…”, maybe add a meaningful quote or photo. Its up to you to include any more info about why you chose that organization.

I also have no problem if a bride/groom choose something politically charged so long as they make that donation either in their own names or anonymously. Because really, when it comes down to it, this day is about celebrating two people, and if that organization is who you are then your guests should respect that. And if they dont’–why are they at your wedding!!

37.
LM says:

I would much rather someone give to any charity than give me a glass, chocolate I don’t eat, or anything else I will most definitely throw away. I have been to weddings where the bride and groom have given a donation to charity, and I have always felt very happy about their choice, regardless of the charity they chose. I will be doing this at my wedding as favors and have registered at charities in lieu of traditional gifts. I don’t think it’s necessary to do this, but I certainly don’t think it’s wrong.

And I think it’s very selfish for someone to think that a charity donation isn’t really a gift for them. And doing so certainly does NOT mean you’d rather not spend the money on them!!!!

38.
Marianne says:

When one of my close friends married this summer, she and her hubby donated to a breast cancer charity in honour of his late mother, and our favours were those pink rubber bracelets. I think they bought them off The Breast Cancer Site, and we were all thrilled.

39.
Kristen says:

Please make a donation! I liked what the last girl said about giving the pink rubber bracelets. If someone is offended by the idea of money being donated instead of a take home gift, they need to examine their own feelings and beliefs on charity!

40.
Bee Icon
Mrs. Corn says:

Ok…so I am late to this, but I did want to add that I find it interesting that in defending the position of giving to charity in lieu of favors, many people are downright mean to those of us who choose to just give favors. Who knows, maybe in a few years it will be de rigeuer to carry a sign for your favorite charity instead of a bouquet…if you decide to go the bouquet route, will you be chastised for being wasteful?

Honestly, if you want to give a favor, that is great. If you want to do a charitable donation, that is great. If you want to combine the two, that is great. You are throwing a party where you are feeding people, entertaining them, and allowing them to witness one of the most personal moments of your lives. No one can complain about that.

41.
deluscious says:

Reading your motivations behind the donation and Manolo’s reasons for finding a donation-as-favor offensive, it seems more appropriate for you to highlight your chosen charity as an alternative gift for your guests to give to you, on your registry page (doesn’t have to be in lieu of a registry, but just one of the choices).

Consider this statement:
“My gift to you is a donation to a charity that -I- care about.”

Then, consider this statement:
“My gift to you is a donation to a charity that -you- care about.”

A favor is a gift to your guest. You should give a gift that will me meaningful to them.

Your guest’s gift to you will be something useful or meaningful to you. If you tell them that breast cancer is meaningful to you, guests will be happy to donate to your charity, and your charity will get more money than the amount you would have donated as a single donor.

Whatever you choose, consider this: What if your guest’s gift to you was a donation to Planned Parenthood because they care about a woman’s right to choose, or a donation to their own religious organization? Would you appreciate their “gift”? Or would you wish they had let you choose the charity?

42.
erika426 says:

The whole time I was thinking of Mrs. Eggplants simple favors to tell people where the candy bar was….maybe something like that and they would think it was great it was donated and happy they got some chocolate :)

43.
HCB says:

I have to agree with Miss Dahlia and Nopinkertons… I don’t have any opinion on who you choose to give your money to, but to characterize it as a wedding favor just seems slightly wrong to me. I think it’s wonderful that you want to make a donation to a cause that is close to your heart, but why do you need to characterize it as a wedding favor? Just skip favors altogether if you have to choose between the two, or give something else if you feel the need to give a favor.

Also, people keep saying “how could this possibly be offensive?” But, how do you really know what offends others? This organization may give money to researchers who are using embryonic stem cells (I’m just using this as an example, I really have no idea what this organization does) and there are a significant number of people who may be offended by this.

I wouldn’t want a donation in my name going to an organization I don’t support. I do care about what organizations my name is associated with.

Finally, I don’t see how the quote is actually requiring favors or complaining about not getting a favor. I don’t see where that came up at all… in fact, I read it as: it’s ok to skip favors… but, its not ok to give to charity in your guests names without their blessing.

44.
Rebekah says:

Donate! I think it is so sweet, especially given your family’s history. And honestly? The favors are usually left on the table at the end of the night, thrown away, or put into a drawer and forgotten. The hubby and I are big on charities. We would be honored.

45.
Liz says:

I COMPLETELY disagree with Manolo. For our wedding, we gave to the American Cancer Society. We didn’t make a donation in our guests names, but rather in memoriam of my husband’s father who passed away from cancer. We felt like it was a great way to include him.

It’s your wedding - do what you want.

46.
gji7 says:

It sounds like you could make everyone happy if you just worded the sign to say “in lieu of favors the bride and groom have donated to XXX in memory of the brides grandmother” since the problem appears to be that the people against it don’t think it counts as a favor and the people for it couldn’t care less how you word it.

47.
CharlestonBride says:

I don’t think I’d be offended if I went to a wedding and didn’t receive a favor, but I agree that charities are very personal and private. A donation can be done without being an exchange.
What’s the point of a favor, anyway? To me, it’s a way to say “thank you” to each guest. Your guests have invested a lot of time and money into coming to your wedding (in my case, 80% of them will be traveling) and giving them a small favor is saying “thanks for taking time out of your busy life to celebrate this important moment in our lives.” To that end I plan on hand-making the favors (but I am a crazy DIYer who grossly overestimates her free time).

48.
Bee Icon
Miss Daffodil says:

not offended at ALL! i went to a wedding where they donated to the heifer project, where you buy livestock for families in developing countries…it provides for them income, food, etc. through all the different ways they can raise the animal. we thought it was incredibly thoughtful and it introduced us to a new charity that we thought was amazing.

49.
Allison says:

I’d like to say, as a previous wedding guest, I have never once really viewed the favor as a thank you for attending the wedding. The thank you is the many-times open bar, the great food, the fabulous dj, aka the all-around-fun party these two people are throwing to celebrate their union. The favor is just a bonus, and you may not like it but the bride cannot please everyone all the time.

It is not like a wedding is a charity event that you pay to attend. Yes, you might pay for a hotel room, airfare and a gift, but you don’t pay for the dj, the dinner, the drinks. If you were expecting the favor to make up for what you spent to attend the weddin you are crazy. You obviously forked over the money because you wanted to be a part of their big day, not because you were expecting some favor. The favor–if there is one–is just a nice traditional gesture. For Manolo for Brides to say that you didn’t want to spend money on your guests is absurd! You’ve spent a small fortune ensuring they have an excellent time!

With any change in tradition, you might offend at least one person at your wedding - I say do what ever the heck you want! Give a favor, don’t give a favor, give a donation in your grandmother’s name, give a donation without saying anything, etc.!

50.
SoCalBride says:

This is petty. I don’t see anything wrong at all with a donation in lieu of a favor! The last three favors I have received have been personalized playing cards, a heart shaped tea steeper and one LOVE coaster. Now seriously, what on earth am I supposed to do with this stuff? I feel honored enough to have been invited to the joyous occasion. A favor is nice, but not necessary. A donation is even better! To whatever cause!

51.
beckums~ says:

Manolo has a major ad for a favor company flashing at you as you scroll by so I would take any of their advice with a teeny grain of salt.
I think favors in general are very WIC and that your intentions are beautiful.
My mother is in the last stages of ovarian cancer and we will most definitely be donating money in her honor as part of our wedding budget. We don’t associate with anyone that would be offended by this so I don’t have to worry about it at our wedding.

52.
karebearlbc says:

Wow popular post!

I have actually decided not to do favors for a # of reasons and ppl seem to be offended by THAT! Ugh, you can’t win!

As many other girls said, It’s your wedding, not anyone else’s!

And ppl wonder why brides become so biatchy by the end of planning…..lol!

53.
Julieulie says:

I read the same thing on Manolo, and was really offended upon reading it. I’m sorry, but because you came to my wedding, I am in no way, shape, or form OBLIGATED to provide you with a favor. We are paying over $200 per person for the reception alone (I’m not factoring in all my wedding costs divided by the number of guests — this is just the cost I am paying the hotel for each guest in attendance), plus paying more for a live band for dancing. Yes, people will bring gifts, though they are also not obligated to do so, and the majority of couples will not show up with $400+ gifts, so we are winding up with a net loss. That is fine — that is how weddings work. But don’t give me crap because I am not PROVIDING you with some dinky little favor you will go home and throw away anyways! (Note: rant not directed at anyone, just in general!)
We will be giving to the American Cancer Society and Children’s Cancer Foundation in lieu of favors. That’s exactly how we’re wording it — not that a donation has been made in your name, not “your favor is a donation”, just “In lieu of favors, we are making a donation to…”.
And if people think I’m saying that I don’t mind spending the money, just on them… well, maybe they’re right. After $200+ per person, I think we can give a little back to those who are less fortunate and who need more help. If anyone takes offense to my charities of choice, I don’t want them in my life anyway, since I am a pediatric oncology researcher, and if you think funding pediatric cancer research is a waste, then to put it bluntly, I don’t like you.
I have been to several weddings where donations were made in lieu of favors, and it always makes me happy to know that people are considering others. There is nothing wrong with those who do chose to donate favors, particularly ones which are thoughtful and well-chosen, but the majority of favors are just given for the sake of being given, and picking a charity is more meaningful than something you picked out of the back of a catalogue because it was cheap enough to buy in bulk.

54.
Melissa says:

Bed Bath and Beyond seems to have the breast cancer m&ms year round…but maybe they are old? I think if you can find them, they would still be good for your June wedding!

55.
kelly says:

I was floored that someone would be offended by my giving to a chairty.
First of all, I’m giving my money to a charity called Humane Rights Campaign because though I’m having a wedding, I can’t legally get married. And a lot of my guests are gay as well. I can’t see why giving them stupid playing cards would be worth more to them than contributing towards the goal of gay marriage.

56.
piperbenjamin says:

I wouldn’t be offended if a couple spent a portion of their wedding budget on a charity donation instead of a mini gift for me. And i would especially not be offended if they donated to a cause *i like*. I would never advocate against donating money in general, either. However I DO think that certain wording/ methods of telling guests this fact can come across wrong sometimes. Example: Instead of making a donation for a guest in their name (likely making them wonder if they will be added to a mailing list, or make them feel guilty for not donating recently), you could donate in memory of someone. That way they are thinking, “aww, cousin julie is donating money on her wedding day in honor of our deceased great grandma”. more sweet, less force down throat. This could be my upbringing as well, that by announcing your donation, whether or not you state the amount, you are kind of… bragging… that you’re doing a good deed. which negates or lessens that deed. (although i know it’s mainly to “prove” to the guest that you aren’t cheating them of a favor, because look, you gave the favor money to a charity, not a fancier dress). again that could just be me.
REGARDLESS, I would not be offended if a couple had 0 favors, or made a donation instead.

57.
babagrlshell says:

I didn’t read all the pp’s but I read somewhere recently that a bride & groom donated to a charity, but instead of a sign somewhere, they had little chocolates packaged up (you can still get the pink m&ms) with a not attached stating that “Life is sweet; in lieu of a traditional favor, a donation has been made to the xxx in honor of xxx in your name; love, x&x” AND if this annoys someone THEN BOOOOOO at them! They aren’t at the wedding for favors! They are there to celebrate you & new hubby!

58.
mrs. caramel says:

Holy cow, I cannot believe people would actually be offended by something like this! Getting a piece of cute candy vs. Donating to a great cause…. isn’t that a no brainer?? That really makes me angry, to think that people could be that selfish and complain about it.

If they really are there to celebrate your wedding, then nothing else matters. Um I just say, as a guest, you can’t be picky about what favor you get, or what color sequence the wedding is, or what flavor the cake is — its not their wedding! You do whatever you want, girl. And if people have a problem with that well then they can just throw their own wedding & give out $500 cash as party favors. It’s almost as ridiculous as saying “I didn’t like what the bride was wearing because it didn’t involve me, therefore I’m offended.” sheesh!

59.
champagnebride says:

I can’t believe people would be offended. I often give family members charity gift certificates for xmas (like kiva.org) and they love it! nobody really cares about the favors, but a donation would be meaningful (especially considering your circumstances) and memorable. If a few people are offended, do you really care about the opnion of that kind of person?

60.
Bee Icon
Miss Cupcake says:

I would never be offended by something like this, and it IS nice when the couple can relate their charity donation to something important in their lives (for instance, your grandmother and your mother).

However, I will say this, and I mean in NO WAY for this to be directed at anyone in particular…. but I am of the mindset that if you want to donate to charity, go ahead and donate, and if you want to do something good for humanity, go ahead and do that…. but why can’t it just be a kind gesture, instead of combining it with a wedding favor that brings the attention back to you? I guess I feel that donating to causes is sometimes the “trendy” thing to do, and combining it with a wedding favor is like patting ourselves on the back and telling everyone how kind we are, while in reality it is a personal, private choice that doesn’t need to be flaunted.

I guess I wonder, why can’t people just donate for the sake of doing something good? Why do we need the motivation of a wedding favor to donate? Haven’t we done the same amount of good by donating quietly instead of bringing the attention back on ourselves?

Just my two cents :-) But again, I would never be offended by a donation favor…. I am simply choosing not to do it because of my own feelings towards what giving is truly about. I will continue to donate to the causes that I feel are important without making it public knowledge, but that is my personal choice.

Thanks for bringing up such an interesting topic, Miss Flamingo!

61.
Kate says:

You can get pink M & M’s ANY time. http://www.candyfavorites.com/shop/coloredmmcandies.php?gclid=COq9zuvLiJECFQQjPAodUBotGg

They offer 21 custom colors year round. :)

62.
P3 says:

Try this website. It has gift ideas and the profits go to Breast Cancer Research. Then you will please everyone and offend noone.

http://www.theanimalrescuesite.com/clickToGive/home.faces;jsessionid=8D009612BB7049CA546C1693A8E53DE7.ctgProd04?siteId=2&link=ctg_bcs_home_from_ars_home_sitenav

63.
Mikala says:

I think the charity favor is a great idea and would not be offended at all as a guest. I’m all for edible favors but I’m not sentimental enough to keep most of the other favors I’ve received over the years and attended a wedding last summer where I didn’t notice the absence of favors until the bride mentioned it afterwards.

If you decide to go with candy alongside the donation check out the Valentine’s day section at the grocery. I’d be surprised if they didn’t have pink m&m’s and if they don’t you’ll find plenty of other pink options.

64.
dreambml says:

So many comments! We had planned on doing this. But just telling our families, they of course said, oh thats nice, what charity? when we would mention one, they would say well, so and so had this illness, every time! Unfortunately, my family has suffered many things such as breast cancer, lung cancer, (among other cancers) diabetes and severe alzheimer’s. While we had all good intentions, it really was hard not to offend people. So we chose to give candy as a favor. That all being said, if a guest actually thought to themselves we “just didn’t want to spend the $ on them” in my fiance’s words, I would say go sh*it in your hat! You are not obligated to shower your guests in silly little “favors”. The cost of treating them to dinner and drinks is more than enough. If someone was that rude to be thinking giving to a charity is rude, well, we know what kind of people they are, don’t we? I think the bride and groom should help whomever they wish - none of anyone’s business! Actually, the first wedding I went to who did this gave to an AIDS charity and I was jealous they had the guts to do so! I mean, edible favors are one thing, but the stupid junk some people give away is a waste of a couple hundred dollars that could have gone to help someone.

65.
dreambml says:

one thing too that I saw in reading these posts, someone had mentioned something about the charity being meaningful to the couple, but not necessarily to the guest….I agree with that, and of course some people will be offended. However, is a little soap or candy actually meaningful? the one thing I agree with that seems wrong is what a lot of people said - putting out cards saying “in lieu of a favor” is like, trying to excuse yourself from not buying them a little gift. You don’t need a reason! You could always leave a sign somewhere and also maybe a small container saying if you would like to donate to said charity, feel free - we have chosen to not waste our money on crap and took the money we saved from that and gave it to our charity. But if you don’t give on a normal basis, I agree with Miss Cupcake - it is kind of like saying “see how great we are”….though I still like the idea. Oh - and another thing - to write “we have donated in your name” doesn’t make sense anyway - they don’t actually make the donation in each guest’s name.

66.
Ali says:

My mom is a breast cancer survivor, so we wanted to do something purposeful with our favors, and also give our guests something to thank them for coming. So we decided to purchase some cancer wristbands that support the American Cancer Society. We also decided to put them in a little favor box and put a couple hershey kisses in them. My mom was really touched that this is something we wanted to do. You can purchase them at http://acswristbands.org/ and they’re $1 each. That way you’re donating to a charity and your guests get something. And I agree, it’s your wedding. Do what you want!

67.
beefan says:

Maybe look at sites that sell cause marketing products like avon? here’s the link- none are particularly great but perhaps the lip balm could work as a favor??
http://shop.avon.com/shop/product_list.asp?level1_id=300&level2_id=380&pdept_id=382&cat_type=C

68.
Bee Icon
Miss Flamingo says:

Wow! I never thought this many people would response to my cry for help.

Thank you for all your opinions. It is something I will discuss with mr.flamingo in due time… but I understand both sides. To mention or not to mention it (in lieu of favors) I will keep searching, who knows maybe I’ll find a great idea somewhere on the invisible univers I call the net!

No worries, I will keep you posted. And again thanks!

69.
Jessica Lynn says:

what a great way to honor the important women in your life by making a donation to something that has impacted them both! go for it.

70.
Dangie says:

I appreciate when I attend weddings and am told a donation has been made. Perhaps with thoughtful wording, it won’t seem as non-personal or insincere. Also remember that you can’t please everyone. And, if your donation helps find the cure for cancer- please make it! I’d much rather a cure for cancer than walking away with almonds! ;) Could you make a pink ribbon pin (or something similar) to attach to the donation description card? I would much rather walk out with at DIY pink ribbon and the cure for cancer than a votive…. :) Good luck.

71.
wsukarebear says:

First of all, I think you should donate and not worry about a token/favor. I have been to a bazillion weddings and can’t recall one “special” favor. And as many have said, I don’t think of it as a thank you at all. It may be a nice gesture or something good to eat, but never have I thought, “wow, they really care that I’m here and are thanking me for that!” Talk to your guests individually to say thank you. :-) Pink is my favorite color and if you gave me a rubber bracelet, I wouldn’t be wearing it in the future–I would think the idea was great, but it mostly would become (for me) another favor/token that isn’t used again.

Gosh, I’m just really surprised at the spectrum of responses. Honestly, who cares if you put a note in your program or a framed sign by the guestbook, even if it is the only donation you make all year? Again, at least the thoughtful donation has been made at all, and if someone feels that way (even a guest whom you’ve already invested hundreds of dollars in for the evening) do you care? Probably not–or you shouldn’t. Everyone around you who understands and loves the idea are the ones whose opinions you probably care about.

I really hate that you’re second guessing your tremendous gesture. If I were you, I would put a framed note next to the guestbook that says, “in lieu of favors…” and see if anyone says a darn thing. :-)

72.
Aimee says:

Honestly, I have to say I get annoyed too with the whole “in lieu of favors” line. I don’t think you donating to a cause to make yourself feel good needs to be a gift to me. If I am going to your wedding, it is because I want to celebrate with you a tremendously important event. I don’t need a gift on top of dinner, cake, spending time with people I enjoy, etc.

I do however find the way a couple of my friends handled this very issue to be wonderful. The bride’s grandmother had died of breast cancer a few years before their wedding, and they had a photo of her on a table at the entrance, with lavender bundles (her favorite flower) and a small sign that said something like “Since Grandma Smith is unable to celebrate with us today, we are celebrating her life with a donation to the American Cancer Society.” Simple and very sweet. It meant a lot to the couple, it was not a sanctimonious “we donated to charity instead buying a cheap tchotchke you’ll never keep/use”, and it really was a celebration of her grandmother’s life as people traded Grandma Smith stories at the reception.

I thought it was a very graceful way to handle a potentially tricky situation. So, that is my two cents. :)

73.
JC says:

For one thing, not only is this cause close to your heart but it’s to help fight cancer. Who would be offended with an organization that helps people like your grandma fight breast cancer? I think that’s touching thing for you to do in honor of your grandma. I mean, it’s not like controversial like stem-cell research, for example, where a lot of people will not be on the same page on that. I can’t imagine people being offended by breast cancer research. It does sound like a cute idea to have pink M&M’s and note about the donation. I mean, using tulle wrappers would be an affordable way to put a couple of M&M’s in. I’ve only been to one wedding, where my friends gave seating cards/donation note in my name. They donated to more than one cause, so not everyone had the same cause. It’s different, but it is so them (especially the groom) to do something different like that for the sake of the causes. I don’t even remember what cause it was either.

74.
Andrea says:

I hate the whole idea of favors, always have. I simply don’t see the point. But if you’re going to give favors, I don’t think a donation to a charity is the way to go about it. Now, donations to charity are a great thing to do, but the connection to your guests at your wedding is tenuous at best…and for a practice usually meant to honor the guests and thank them for coming, the donation favor usually means more to the bride and groom and does nothing for the guests.

Bottom line - If you’re going to give your guests favors, you should actually give them something. Otherwise, don’t bother with favors at all- there’s no point. If you wish, you can certainly use the favor money to donate to charity in honor of your wedding- but explicity calling attention to the fact that you’ve done so “in lieu of favors” is so unnecessary and from a guest’s point of view, could seem even slightly self-serving.

75.
Sarah says:

We went the opposite direction: we gave normal old (inedible, even!) favors, but asked for charitable contributions in lieu of gifts. It looks like both of the charities we suggested got a LOT more $$$ than we spent on favors*, and guests had the opportunity to opt for charities they liked more. Everyone wins.

*we spent $400 something, and if everyone who said they gave to American Cancer Society only gave $10, ACS still came out ahead; Ditto for Juvenile Diabetes.

76.
NatalieL says:

Miss Flamingo, I say you and Mr. Flamingo should just do what you would like… it is YOUR wedding, after all.

Personally, I have never been to a wedding that had donations rather than favors, but that is what we did at our own wedding. I hadn’t really considered the idea that much until I was looking for favors and couldn’t find anything that I thought was very meaningful for us. I also never knew how many people threw away favors until after reading posts on weddingbee! In the end, we opted to let guests choose one of three charities that they would like their portion to go to– we selected three organizations that touched the lives of family members and each guest put their slip of paper into the corresponding jar. We had several comments after the wedding on this– all were positive.

I’m not putting down anyone who chooses to go the traditional favor route, or not have favors at all. I, personally, always keep favors, but I don’t feel they are missed if they are not included in the celebration. After all, the day is about celebrating the love of two people- not about if and what kind of favor you receive.

77.
KMac says:

i work for a charitable organization and we are contacted frequently about details for donations as wedding favors. in fact, this is becoming so popular that we have begun offering items for people to give as favors so they have something tangible to give people on their wedding day. we offer scrolls that explain the donation, a ribbon posted on a card acknowledging the donation and lately we have included blank cards that a patient of ours painted the front design for. the donation helps to pay for these items, which are put together with the help of volunteers.

if you want to give something tangible along with an acknowledgement of the donation, contact your local breast cancer organization and see what they might offer for wedding favors. that way you can not only contribute to the organization, but you can give an item that comes directly from the organization.

78.
bearbride says:

i hate to admit it but i agree with manolo. but just do whatever you like!

79.
Jessica says:

I agree with Manolo.

I don’t see the connection. Why is it that the donation is done instead of wedding favors? Why not instead of centerpieces? Or instead of a string quartet? It just seems wierd that you’re calling attention to the fact that you’re not doing something for your guests.

I don’t think favors are neccessary. If you want to skip them, skip them. But that’s the same with 99% of stuff that you do for a wedding. And if you chose not to do any of it, it’s fine, but why use that opportunity to broadcast that you’re giving to a charity?

I’m not having a live band for my wedding. And I give to the local food pantry every year. So, should I leave a little card at everyone’s place setting that instead of live music, I’ve made a donation? It just doesn’t make sense to me.

I think it’s awesome to give to charity. And I think it’s fine if you don’t do favors. But why broadcast what you do with your money to your guests?

80.
Bee Icon
Miss Flamingo says:

I understand your point of view 110% thats why I was offering a little something else so my guests dont leave empty handed…. but maybe I should re-consider the structure of the whole thing…

thanks for all your opinions…

81.
L says:

I don’t agree or disagree. (Well at first, I disagreed with the Manolo post and always thought charity favors were a sweet idea…but after reading other opinions on it, I can see why it can be annoying since donations and favors have no relation.)

But, I have thought of a possible resolution for you. I understand why you’re having a hard time with this. You don’t know which of your guests may be EXPECTING a favor and even though you shouldn’t worry about that because it’s poor etiquette (I could be wrong, but I’m sure that same person will be one of those people who will judge every little detail of your wedding), you will worry anyway because I know you’re a sweet and thoughtful person and don’t want anyone to be hurt and unhappy at your wedding. And I am sure this is why most couples associate favors with donations–to note that they weren’t trying to be cheap with their guests and not provide a favor, but that they’d be more practical and use that money instead for a donation.

So what maybe you could do is indicate on the menu (or even the placecard) that you hope your guests understand that you and your husband have decided not to give out favors and instead be using that money to make a donation. And then provide a little background on the charity. Perhaps you can even allow people to sign their name on a list next to the guestbook if they would like to have their name attached to the donation. That way, it eliminates that whole “donation made in YOUR name” aspect but gives them the choice if they like the organization.

I hope that is helpful and wasn’t too confusing! Either way, good luck with it! I know I would be completely content and appreciative if you donated to a charity instead of giving me a favor. =D

82.
katya says:

I don’t see how giving to a charity that helps a medical cause like breast cancer or the American Heart Association would offend anyone. We got cookies at artgirlcookies.com (lots of designs at a good price; wish more arrived intact) of dogs (which we love) and put them with a tag that said a donation had been made to the spca in their honor.

The only way that would have offended anyone was if we made a donation to Planned Parenthood and gave out fetus cookies. That would have been sort of awesome.

Anyway, I think packaging the donation with something else like food is a good idea.

83.
violarulz says:

I was kinda lazy and breezed through the comments w/out reading most of them, so I don’t know if this is a repeat:

What about getting your pink m&ms on their website, doing something super minimal/token with them as a favor and attaching a note saying that you’ve made a donation to the Breast Cancer Foundation in honor of your guests and that you wanted to share your favorite cause with them, or something to that effect

84.
Weddingbee » Blog Archive » Watercooler says:

[…] Do Me A Favor… Be Honest by Miss Flamingo […]

85.
Married says:

In reply to this comment:
“but why can’t it just be a kind gesture, instead of combining it with a wedding favor that brings the attention back to you?”

I don’t think the attention is brought back to you at all. I know in our instance, we made a small candy wrapper to go around lifesavers that said in appreciation to our guests, we are making a donation to our favority charity and then gave the website for the local chapter we made the donation in honor of. This was to spread awareness of the chapter and the disease if people were interested to learn about it (they didn’t have to go to the website). The candies were in a basket by the door that the guests could take if desired. So, this had nothing to do with drawing attention to ourselves and if nothing else it made people aware of a disease that affects children that many people aren’t aware of.

86.
bridalmonkey says:

We are actually giving a donation to an animal shelter as well as having a candy buffet. There will be a sign designating the donation and the to-go boxes for the buffet have cute tags my mom is making that say that a donation has been giving “in your honor” to “best friends animal shelter.”

I feel kind of insulted by the quote from manolo. I would think that this would be a great party favor! Anything non-candy that I’ve ever gotten pretty much gets trashed or lost.

Once again… it’s YOUR wedding… do what YOU want.

87.
Chicago says:

I’m really bothered by this debate. My fiance and I set up a page