Register or log in —

Newer blog post
more in Blog
Older blog post
Newer blog post by Mrs. Corn
more by Mrs. Corn (oldest)
Older blog post by Mrs. Corn
Mrs. Corn's Picture
Mrs. Corn, Newport, RI Age and Occupation in '07: 31, HR for public accounting firm Fiance's Age and Occupation: 33, Consultant for public accounting firm Engagement Date: October 7, 2006 Wedding Date: September, 2007 Blogging Since: June 1, 2007 Venue: North Lawn of Fort Adams State Park About Me: I am a lazy scrapbooker who loves the instant gratification of making cards and I am very easily distracted by all things shiny. In honor of my childhood nights spent hibachi BBQing on the beach with my family, we are hosting a traditional New England Clambake for our reception.
About Mrs. Corn

So How Exactly WAS that Anniversary Cake?

September 9th, 2008 @ 2:16 pm by Mrs. Corn

I know this is the information you have been waiting on bated breath for, so I won’t make you wait any further.Last year, we indulged in the most incredible chocolate bourbon wedding cake with white butter-cream frosting from Sin Desserts in Providence, RI. It was hands down, the best wedding cake on the planet. Believe me, I know there is a lot of potential that I am biased because it was at our wedding… but we received more comments on how good the cake was than I can count.


It was so good, that when it came time to freeze the top for next year, I just couldn’t bear to freeze the whole thing, so I cut it into pieces, saved two for our anniversary and then brought the rest along on our honeymoon to snack on.

I don’t remember where I eventually got the instructions to save the cake top, but here is the process I used and the end result:

1) I was told to store the cake in a non-self-defrosting freezer. Not sure the reason for that, but the only non-self-defrosting freezer we had was the itty, bitty freezer in the upper right corner of the mini-fridge that Mr Corn brought over from his apartment when we bought the house. It now resides in our basement and is an excellent place for storing beer, vitamin waters, and the ridiculous trophy his brother won one year for winning his FANTASY hockey league:



2) First I refrigerated the cake for at least an hour (to get the icing to set) and then wrapped each slice in cellophane at least 8 times (I just kept rolling the cellophane around it). Then I wrapped them in TWO layers of aluminum foil and finally, I put each slice in a zip-lock bag and stored them in the freezer.

3) This year, I took the pieces out of the freezer the day before our anniversary and put them in our fridge to defrost. Then, about two hours before we ate them, I took them out of the fridge to let the icing get soft. Below are pics of the process of unwrapping the pieces after taking them out of the fridge:










Upon close-up inspection, I was really very surprised at how good the cake looked and I had relatively high expectation for the taste:

Mr Corn, who doesn’t like chocolate cake anyway, had some trepidation:



In the end, we both only made it a few bites into the cake. The icing was perfect, which surprised me… I would have thought that with all that butter, it would have been the first to go. The problem was that even though the first taste of the cake was surprisingly good, the aftertaste was very I’ve-been-in-a-freezer-for-a-year. But, considering we were able to eat any of it and weren’t grossed out at the get-go, I actually consider this a success. However, I 100%, without question, recommend only saving a little of it and indulging in the rest of the cake top when it is at its freshest!

Tags: , , |   Link for this post | Share this post: So How Exactly WAS that Anniversary Cake?      
Newer blog post
more in Blog
Older blog post
Newer blog post by Mrs. Corn
more by Mrs. Corn (oldest)
Older blog post by Mrs. Corn
advertisement below

18 Responses to “So How Exactly WAS that Anniversary Cake?”

1.
Guest Icon
Guest
MRS. SKI

Thanks for the tip. I always thought eating year-old-cake didn’t sound appealing.

 
2.
Member Icon
Member
cbkj (message)  78 posts, Worker bee

thanks for confirming my suspicions. so happy our baker provides an anniversary cake :)

 
3.
Bee Icon
Bee
Mrs. Gingerbread (message)  647 posts, Busy bee

I’m looking forward to eating our wedding cake next year, but I’m ordering a fresh one since our freezer is a piece of crap and the original cake would surely not hold up.

 
4.
Member Icon
Member
triciaj (message)  257 posts, Helper bee

We have to order/make a new one - our cake had whipped cream-ish buttercream. It would never survive in the freezer. :)

 
5.
Guest Icon
Guest
Jodi

Luckily our bakery gave us the option of taking home the top layer to freeze it for a year OR they’d give us a gift certificate for a free fresh anniversary cake, made to look like our top tier. Although your story was more successful than most brides I’ve heard from, most people have told me the cake is gross after being in the freezer a year.

 
6.
Member Icon
Member
lulubelle (message)  173 posts, Blushing bee

We won’t be able to take part in this, since we’re having a destination wedding. Maybe we can have a local baker do a little anniversary cake instead!

 
7.
Bee Icon
Bee
Mrs. Corn (message)  1,010 posts, Bumble bee

yeah, we had the option of the anniversary cake…but the way it was offered was that by ordering our cake, we either got a $25 gift certificate to use on our top layer OR on an anniversary cake. Since we were watching our funds, we decided to go the route that allowed for a bigger (re: 3 tier vs. 2) cake.

 
8.
Guest Icon
Guest
seagirlrun

The best advise is to vacuum seal the cake using a FoodSaver vacuum sealer. You just need to freeze the cake so that it doesn’t get smooshed, then freeze in a FoodSaver bag. Without any air, the cake will taste as good as the day you first had it. (I promise I am not an ad, just a FoodSaver fanatic since I was little!)

 
9.
Guest Icon
Guest
ceche

We ate our year-old cake last week and it was gag-worthy. I couldn’t even choke down one bite, and I am an absolute sweets fiend. Oh well, we got some amusing pictures. Congrats on your anniversary!

 
10.
Bee Icon
Bee
Miss Sweet Tea (message)  461 posts, Helper bee

I’ll have to figure a way to get some ‘anniversary cake’ shipped to us from our bakery in New Orleanssince we’re definitely not saving the top! … or, we could just buy some cake here in CA and call it anniversary cake. that would probably make more sense ;)

 
11.
Guest Icon
Guest
Tea

i highly doubt my ability to talk my bf into eat year-old cake, tradition or not. i can already see his, “omg you’re crazy” look just thinking about it now. so it’ll be an anniversary cake for us.

 
12.
Bee Icon
Bee
Miss Pomegranate (message)  956 posts, Busy bee

Good advice - and Happy Anniversary as well! :)

 
13.
Mrs. Tiramisu
Bee
Mrs. Tiramisu (message)  877 posts, Busy bee

We saved just 2 pieces too… I hope it’s edible in a year!

 
14.
Guest Icon
Guest
littlefoot

we didn’t save ours because we had a dw in hawaii and wouldn’t return for another week. so we decided to eat as much as we could (which was about half of the topper) and trashed the rest. it was a coconut cake (which is my ultimate favorite!) and like you, it was truly the best cake i’ve ever had. our guests are still raving about it. i’m trying to talk my husband into going back to hawaii for our anniversary so we can have a small cake made fresh!

 
15.
Bee Icon
Bee
Miss Espresso (message)  1,064 posts, Bumble bee

How fun! Happy Anniversary!

 
16.
Bee Icon
Bee
Mrs. Emerald (message)  901 posts, Busy bee

Haha, I am eating my last slice of wedding cake right this very minute!! Ours is actually still delicious, and we are eating every bite =) No freezer burn taste whatsover, I am so amazed!

 
17.
Bee Icon
Bee
Miss Sea Breeze (message)  912 posts, Busy bee

Happy Anniversary!

 
18.
Guest Icon
Guest
Jen

We just ate ours last night! You were smart to save just two pieces, we saved the whole thing and only ate a little.

We were happy, the top tier was chocolate with chocolate buttercream but sad that no one else go to taste it - the caterer screwed up and didn’t make us two tiers chocolate with chocolate, we ended up with a weird chocolate lemon poppyseed tier.

We could tell that it would have been good - a year ago. I managed to eat a whole piece but then had the psychological did it go bad my stomach is starting to hurt thing! I was fine though. It did taste like it had been in the freezer. Sadness.

I AM glad that now i have more freezer space!!

 


You can also just...

Newer blog post
more in Blog
Older blog post
Newer blog post by Mrs. Corn
more by Mrs. Corn (oldest)
Older blog post by Mrs. Corn
Visit our sister sites Project Wedding
Wedding Songs
eHarmony Advice
Dating Advice
JustMommies
Pregnancy Calendar
Fertile Thoughts
Infertility Support
Copyright 2004-2009, eHarmony, Inc., Advertise
 


Sponsors
Mrs. Corn
Mrs. Corn Mrs. Corn, Newport, RI Age and Occupation in '07: 31, HR for public accounting firm Fiance's Age and Occupation: 33, Consultant for public accounting firm Engagement Date: October 7, 2006 Wedding Date: September, 2007 Blogging Since: June 1, 2007 Venue: North Lawn of Fort Adams State Park About Me: I am a lazy scrapbooker who loves the instant gratification of making cards and I am very easily distracted by all things shiny. In honor of my childhood nights spent hibachi BBQing on the beach with my family, we are hosting a traditional New England Clambake for our reception.
Weddingbee PRO
 
Boards
 
Classifieds
 

Blog Calendar
November 2009
SunMonTueWedThuFriSat
1234567
891011121314
15161718192021
22232425262728
2930

Weddingbee Bios
Wiki
More