Newer blog post
more in Blog
Older blog post
Newer blog post by Mrs. Crab Cake
more by Mrs. Crab Cake (oldest)
Older blog post by Mrs. Crab Cake
Mrs. Crab Cake's Picture
Mrs. Crab Cake, Columbus, GA Age and Occupation: 25, Registered Nurse Fiance's Age and Occupation: 31, Director of Education and Living History for a museum Engagement Date: April 6, 2008 Wedding Date: June, 2009 Blogging Since: November 26, 2008 Venue: Holy Family Catholic Church, reception: National Infantry Museum About Me: I'm a perfectionist trying to balance two jobs, motherhood, my craft obsession, and wedding planning. I am obsessed with all things wedding, especially creative ideas for saving money and DIY projects. A Southern Belle at heart, I love anything southern, especially sweet tea, grits, afternoon thunder storms, crab cakes, and good old Southern hospitality. Mr. Crab Cake and I are planning a vintage inspired wedding with tons of Southern flare (can y'all say that with a thick Southern drawl?).
About Mrs. Crab Cake

I’ve never really been much of a “feminist”. Yes, I believe women can do anything they put their minds to, and we deserve every right and every penny men receive. However, I’m not going around burning any bras or anything crazy like that. I’ve always been an independent woman, capable of doing whatever I want or need to do. And I’ve definitely never felt like I belonged to anyone.

So, when it came time to decide who would walk me down the aisle, I kinda balked at the idea of having my Dad give me away. Um, hello? I’m not a cow. There is no dowry exchanging hands. I am not becoming Mr. CC’s responsibility. Do I really want to uphold this tradition?

My parents split when I was 16. My dad left abruptly. I had a very “Leave it to Beaver” childhood before then. My mom stayed home and my dad worked. They never fought, at least not in front of us. So, my dad’s unprecedented departure from our home was a shock to everyone. It hit my mom the hardest.

She had spent 12 years as a stay-at-home mom. She packed our lunches every morning, was president of the PTA, the Popcorn Lady, the Penny Power Lady, the Snow Cone Lady, and she taught Sunday School at our Church for 10 years. We had a home cooked meal every single night. Our Halloween costumes were always homemade (I still cringe at the idea of store bought Halloween costumes). She went on our field trips with us. She chaperoned our dances. She was our Girl Scout troop leader. I won’t lie and say that we appreciated it then (in fact, sometimes we were downright embarrassed by her involvement in our activities), but as I look back on it now, I wish I had the time and money to do the same thing for my daughter.

When my dad left, my mom was lost. She was propelled into a workforce she was unfamiliar with, and had no marketable job skills, to boot. Her bachelor’s degree in microbiology was all but null and void.

Yet, she persevered. She worked temp jobs for a while, until the divorce was final, and took evening classes at the same university I graduated from 6 years later. After the divorce was finalized, my mom was granted a sizable portion of my dad’s 401K and enough child support and alimony to support us. She quit working and threw all her time and energy into the Physician’s Assistant program at the University of South Alabama. 27 months later, she graduated with a master’s degree and started her second career.

I had never been more proud of my mother.

My relationship with my mom was definitely rocky in the months following the divorce. Mom was distraught and frustrated. A lot of responsibility got put on my 16-year-old shoulders, and at the time, I was very resentful. As I got older and more understanding, and especially after I became a mom, I soon realized that it was a defense mechanism, and my mom was severely depressed. She is there for me through everything and is definitely my best friend. I can’t imagine a single day without my mom.

My relationship with my father, on the other hand, has always been strained. The divorce caused a huge divide between my dad and his children. Over time, my wounds have healed, and I realized that he’s the only dad I’ve got, and I should make the best of it. We have grown closer since the birth of my daughter. We also lived together for 18 months while I was in nursing school. Sure, we don’t always see eye-to-eye, but that’s okay.

Once I had decided that I was not a cow, and I wouldn’t be “given away”, it was time to decide whom, if anyone, would walk me down the aisle. This wasn’t something that I was going to take lightly. I knew that any deviation from tradition would hurt my dad’s feelings tremendously. However, we had decided against a unity candle, and I really wanted some way to include my mother.

I decided that I wanted both my parents to walk me down the aisle. No one would be giving me away. Instead, they would be escorting me down the aisle in support of my marriage. They both contributed so much to my life; how could I leave one of them out?

My mom was thrilled. My dad, not so much. He wanted to walk me down the aisle, just me and him. He says he will do whatever I want, but I can tell he’s hurt.

So, hive, what do I do? Rescind the offer to my mom and find some other way to honor her? Tell my dad to deal and have them both walk me down? Or should I just walk alone?

Tags: ceremony, relationships |
advertisement below
Newer blog post
more in Blog
Older blog post
Newer blog post by Mrs. Crab Cake
more by Mrs. Crab Cake (oldest)
Older blog post by Mrs. Crab Cake

68 Responses to “I’m Not a Cow, or a Goat, or Any Livestock For That Matter!”

1 2 3 4 

1.
Guest Icon
Guest
sally

I think that makes you a feminist. Feminist does not mean burning bras, short haircuts and hating men.

 
2.
Guest Icon
Guest
Lina

I think having both parents walk you is a totally appropriate and fair way to honor both of them. Don’t be guilted into something you don’t want. Having both parents escort you is so commonplace nowadays — maybe you could show your dad some examples of this with pictures and explain your reasoning to him (again?).

 
3.
frenchbulldog
Bee
frenchbulldog (message)  7,730 posts, Bee Keeper

Your mother sounds like an amazing woman :)
To answer your question I think you should stick to what you want and have both your parents walk you down the aisle… your father is an adult, he will get over it.

 
4.
Janna19
Member
Janna19 (message)  2,158 posts, Buzzing bee

In the Jewish tradition, both parents walk the bride (and groom) down the aisle. I love it and I think its catching on outside Judaism as well…..I would have been so sad if it had just been my Dad, not both my parents!

 
5.
catrelle83
Member
catrelle83 (message)  292 posts, Helper bee

If I were put in your situation, I think your initial gut reaction–to have both of your parents walk you down the aisle in support of marriage–is the right decision. I’m assuming your dad will still get the honor of a dance with him, but (and this is just my own heart talking) I wouldn’t be able to not have my mom walking beside me as well as my dad.

Go with your heart.

 
6.
EAQ219
Member
EAQ219 (message)  1,448 posts, Bumble bee

I have a strained relationship with my dad as well (my parents were never married), so if it were me I’d tell him to deal with it. I always wanted only my mom to walk with me, but she really thinks I should ask my dad to walk with us. I’m still on the fence about that one. It seems that your mom means a lot to you so I think you should explain that to your dad. At some point, and this goes for my dad too, he’s got to get over it. And he will, once he realizes how much it will mean having both of them walk you down the aisle.

 
7.
Bee Icon
Bee
Miss Bruschetta (message)  5,565 posts, Bee Keeper

I agree with your line of thinking — both parents, and let you father know how important this decision you made is to you!

 
8.
Sezzy
Member
Sezzy (message)  167 posts, Blushing bee

This ceremony is about your new life, so do whatever you feel is right.

 
9.
cfitz621
Member
cfitz621 (message)  169 posts, Blushing bee

I agree with you, CC. No one is “giving me away.” And I’ve never liked that line, “And who gives this women to be with this man” (note to self: discuss that with priest). At any rate, do what you want, not what your father wants. I plan on having both my parents walk me down the aisle as, like you said, they both contributed to raising me. I think he’ll get over it.

 
10.
Member Icon
Member
lizzyh113 (message)  76 posts, Worker bee

You do whatever makes you feel best!

Oh, and I am with Sally…feminism is the belief in the right of women to have political, social, and economic equality with men…you don’t have to burn your bra to believe that :)

 
11.
Guest Icon
Guest
tenillle

I have a great relationship with my dad, but I’m still having both my parents walk me down the aisle. My mom is my best friend, and I am a Daddy’s Girl, so I couldn’t choose one. He was a bit surprised, and he did want to walk me by himself, but he understands how important it is to me. As a previous poster said, go with your heart on this one.

 
12.
2babc
Member
2babc (message)  90 posts, Worker bee

I agree with the other posts–go with your heart. We’re not having a unity candle either, and I was concerned about the way we would incorporate our moms into the ceremony. We’ve decided to have a small portion where our families will come to the front while FI and I are on the kneeling bench, and they will lay hands on us to show their blessing and support of our marriage. It’s important for both of us that our moms are honored in some way!

 
13.
Guest Icon
Guest
ktdid23

I asked both my mom and dad to walk me down the aisle and I know my dad was upset, but to tell you the truth, my mom did more than her share of the parenting at my house and I couldn’t imagine not sharing that moment with her.

 
14.
katiemax
Member
katiemax (message)  76 posts, Worker bee

I agree with AliCherri1 — you should have them both walk you down the aisle if that is what you want! I am also opposed to being “given away,” and plan to have both of my parents escort me down the aisle.

 
15.
Guest Icon
Guest
Lucy

I know he’s dissapointed, and that’s far from optimal. I’m sure as much as you dreamed about your wedding, he dreamed of walking you down the aisle and you’ve come along and burst that bubble. But he’s an adult and sometimes our bubbles are burst. He won’t like it, but he’ll go along. Sometimes that’s the most we can ask.

 
16.
Mrs. DG
Hostess
Mrs. DG (message)  8,491 posts, Bee Keeper

I think you should do whatever feels right for you!

BTW, I love this quote about feminism, “Feminism is the radical notion that women are people”.

 
17.
Bee Icon
Bee
Mrs. Corn (message)  1,127 posts, Bumble bee

Perhaps if you show him the many many other people out there who have gone this route and explain that it is to honor your relationship with both of your parents, he will understand a bit more. Part of why he’s balking is probably because he’s stuck on tradition.

 
18.
Member Icon
Member
kenziegirl (message)  339 posts, Helper bee

If you want my honest opinion, stick to your guns and have both parents. Your mom has put so much into raising you, I think it’d be a slap in your mother’s face to rescind the offer you gave her.

This sounds awful, but I think that, since your dad didn’t consider your feelings when he left, I don’t understand why you would be so considerate of him when you are trying to do what prefer and honor both parents.

 
19.
BeachBrideT
Hostess
BeachBrideT (message)  1,052 posts, Bumble bee

I think that you should do what YOU want. If you want them both there, and it sounds like you do, go for it. Your dad can share the spotlight for the 30 seconds down the aisle, and I think that your mom’s joy might outweigh your dad’s disappointment. Or, if you look at it another way, your mom’s disappointment in being un-asked might be greater than your dad’s disappointment of not being the only one to walk you down the aisle. Are you planning on having a father-daughter dance? Because that’s a special moment for just you and your dad.
I would have both of my parents walk me down the aisle if I could, but there’s no way that me, my mom, my dad and my insanely large dress would all fit! :)

 
20.
Guest Icon
Guest
Suzanno

I didn’t have my dad “give me away” either. I suppose that tradition makes a little sense even today, if you’re going straight from your parents’ house to your husband’s, but I’ve been on my own for a lot of years (and my husband and his kids moved into my house!) So I thought the whole “who gives this woman” thing was not appropriate.

I did have my dad walk me down the aisle, and then sit down by my mother. I think he was a little hurt, but mostly confused by my decision - he said “But then what is my function?” However, he understood.

My sister also had my dad walk her down the aisle, and “give her away,” although what she had him say was “Her mother and I do.”

It’s interesting to me how much families want to pretend that things are different that they are for something like a wedding - sort of putting on a public face. Your dad maybe thinks that walking with you and your mom reminds people that he didn’t necessarily live up to the ideal father image - and in fact that’s probably true. But that’s his issue to deal with. If he’s hurt by you wanting to honor your mom equally, he’s not looking very realistically at the situation.

It sounds like you and your mom have done really well on your own, despite a lot of difficulty. And I think that recognizing your mom in this way is a great thing for you to do. And most of all, I think that this is about what you want to do to honor both your parents. I would just tell your dad that you do want to honor both of them, and leave it at that. It’s not a decision that needs to be analyzed, or justified to either one of your parents - it should be enough for both of them that this is what you want.

 
1 2 3 4 

Leave a Reply


You can also just...

Newer blog post
more in Blog
Older blog post
Newer blog post by Mrs. Crab Cake
more by Mrs. Crab Cake (oldest)
Older blog post by Mrs. Crab Cake

Visit our sister sites eHarmony
Online Dating
eHarmony Advice
Dating Advice
Project Wedding
Wedding Songs
JustMommies
Pregnancy Calendar

Copyright 2004-2012, Weddingbee.com
 

Find your vendors on Weddingbee

Real reviews from brides in your area!

Favors by Weddingbee

  • Favors by season

Shop Now »

Mrs. Crab Cake
Mrs. Crab Cake

Mrs. Crab Cake, Columbus, GA Age and Occupation: 25, Registered Nurse Fiance's Age and Occupation: 31, Director of Education and Living History for a museum Engagement Date: April 6, 2008 Wedding Date: June, 2009 Blogging Since: November 26, 2008 Venue: Holy Family Catholic Church, reception: National Infantry Museum About Me: I'm a perfectionist trying to balance two jobs, motherhood, my craft obsession, and wedding planning. I am obsessed with all things wedding, especially creative ideas for saving money and DIY projects. A Southern Belle at heart, I love anything southern, especially sweet tea, grits, afternoon thunder storms, crab cakes, and good old Southern hospitality. Mr. Crab Cake and I are planning a vintage inspired wedding with tons of Southern flare (can y'all say that with a thick Southern drawl?).

Boards
Classifieds

Blog Calendar
February 2012
SunMonTueWedThuFriSat
2930311234
567891011
12131415161718
19202122232425
26272829

Weddingbee Bios
Wiki
More