Wedding Blog

Source: theknot.com

I started contacting Chicago-area bakeries for our wedding cake last September. A whole year ahead of our wedding. I know that this was definitely a faux pas, and that picking your cake need not happen earlier than 6 months before your wedding. But the anticipation of the array of cake flavors and frosting in front of me was too much for me to handle. I also like how on wedding shows, the bakers just sit and sketch the cake so easily, like creating the likeness of a bride’s dream cake was just another day at the office. What would they create for us?!

Beyond stuffing my face, there were other reasons I wanted to get in touch with these bakers.

For starters, since I’m an avid home baker, I’ve been asked nonstop since out engagement if I am going to make my own cake. Umm, no. I’ll take a pass on that one. But I know that we’re expected to have an amazing cake. Which brings me to reason number two for nailing down the cake… budget!

Cakes are so labor intensive. I’ve worked with fondant and have made very simple cakes. Pastry chefs earn every penny for the amount of work they put into a single cake. But just because it’s worth the dollars, doesn’t mean that we can afford it. We have stick to our bottom line. And we’re using the black and white damask cake as an inspiration.

I’ve rounded up our top finds for great pastry chefs that fall within our budget. While there are so many more amazing bakeries in the Chicago-area (Cake Girls, Bleeding Heart Bakery, etc), I know that unfortunately they won’t be creating our cake. Here are a few of the front runners:

Le Royale Icing
I like the thought of working with Le Royle Icing because they’re located in Oak Park, where our wedding and reception will be. While their website may not be as shiny and new as some of the trend-setters in the city, Margaret Lastick has been making cakes for over 20 years and has had an illustrious career. She quoted us a price over email but we didn’t get into specifics of what it would look like, so I’m really just going on hope that we can afford her.

The Sugar Syndicate
Cathay Rayhill’s attention to detail is amazing. Her portfolio speaks for itself, and she’s conveniently located on the north side of Chicago not far from where I live, so I could just walk to the tasting. How fabulous. From the pricing I saw in September (which may have gone up), we could probably pull this off for just $100 over budget. Not too shabby.

Sugar Bliss
A cupcake boutique located downtown, they are just too adorable, and with cupcakes at $40/dozen, that would put us far under budget. I could go either way on cupcakes. They’re really cute, but we’d definitely want to have a small cake for cutting. The great thing about cupcakes is that you can easily do a few different flavors… and, well, they’re fun!

Amy Beck Cake Design
Amazing! But sadly just a little out of our reach… unless we want a teeny, tiny little cake. It would, of course, be beautiful, but tiny! Since our budget seems to be expanding minute by minute, padding the cake budget probably won’t happen. A girl can dream, though.

Anyone else out there have any suggestions for more modern wedding cakes at a vintage budget? Right now we’re going to probably start with Le Royale Icing, as the price seemed to be the best, and they’re a local Oak Park vendor. I don’t think our cake should have to take a trek out of the city if it can instead only travel a few blocks!

Now, how am I going to continue holding myself back from that aforementioned cake tasting, you ask?! We’ve finally settled on a cake topper, thanks to Etsy’s Goose Grease. By this time next month we should have our fabulous custom cake topper in our hands and that will lead us to our tasting immediately, mark my words. Oooh, I’m so excited! I have such great plans for those mini-mes!