Register or log in —

Newer blog post
more in Blog
Older blog post
Newer blog post by Mrs. Peep Toe
more by Mrs. Peep Toe (oldest)
Older blog post by Mrs. Peep Toe
Mrs. Peep Toe's Picture
Mrs. Peep Toe, San Francisco Age and Occupation: 29, Policy Analyst Fiance's Age and Occupation: 36, Olive Oil Production Manager Engagement Date: December 16, 2007 Wedding Date: May, 2009 Blogging Since: November 26, 2008 Venue: Hotel Vitale About Me: I am a west coast lady who loves the San Francisco Bay Area. I love living with Mr. Peep and our animals: Huck the Dog and Ferris the Cat. I work to save the environment in San Francisco, while Mr. Peep makes ridiculously delicious Olive Oil. On any day you can find me reading the latest book I have gotten my hands on, eating Swedish Fish, and perusing wedding blogs! We are both champagne drinking foodies on a Bud Light budget. We are planning an eco-chic, intimate, and interfaith San Francisco City wedding.
About Mrs. Peep Toe

I have already blogged about shoes before—here, here, and here!! I even asked the hive for advice, and totally ignored all if it. (Sorry, I’m a bad bee.)

But today is a glorious day—Miss PEEP TOE finally has shoes to wear to her wedding!!! Before, I showcase my perfect pair of peeps, I thought I’d write a little bit about my experience with online ordering.*

First, Endless.com. I love the idea of Endless—free shipping both ways = fantastic-ness!! But I ordered three pairs of shoes through them, and two of them were pretty damaged. Right out of the box, they both looked second hand. Not good. The other was just not right. All three were quickly returned—FOR FREE.

These two were damaged:

Source


Source

And these were just wrong:

Source

Second, Yoox. I had never heard of Yoox, until I began shopping for the elusive pair of perfect wedding day shoes on my favorite online site: shopstyle.com. Yoox is an online store that sells designer labels (most of which I have never heard of) at discounted prices. My first big problem with this site was that there isn’t much information about their products on their site. And when asked, they don’t know.

For example, I saw these fabulous shoes.

(So sorry, after trying and trying, this was the largest image I could save and post. You can go to the link above to get a closer look.)

Upon review, I couldn’t tell if the dark part was black or brown. (This is when I believe I went into no holds barred, crazy shoe bride-mode.) The picture looked black, my coworker thought it looked black, but I wanted them to be brown so badly. I emailed the site, and they had no idea what color they were. So, I ordered them anyway. Sure enough, they were black and ivory.

The second big problem about this website is that you only have 20 days to return them, you must include the return form, and they charge $6 for you to return them via UPS. I don’t know about you, but USPS is much easier and convenient for me to handle. I had to find somewhere that takes UPS, and 2 weeks after I shipped them, I got an email saying that I didn’t fill out the return slip correctly and the shoes had passed the 20 day return policy. BUT, since I was a first time costumer, they would return them for free, just this once. Overall, I will not be ordering from them again. There was too much pressure to get them returned in 20 days.

Third, Amazon. My very first wedding shoe purchase. They came fast; shipping was free; and I thought they were perfect. Two months later, I tried them on with my dress, and they were all sorts of wrong. Since I missed the 30 day return period, I now own them outright. Anyone want to buy these gorgeous shoes? I’ll have them up on the classifieds soon.

Source

Finally, desperate times call for desperate measures: Enter FULL PRICE J.Crew.

You may have seen these:

Source

Also coveted by the lovely Miss Bruschetta. They look magnificent online, but I have to say, I was really disappointed with them in person. The Ivory didn’t look ivory, it looked more champagne/pink. And the pink part looked less pink and more blush/dark rose. And the quality—I hate to say it—but it seemed lacking.

YET, J. Crew’s best friend, J. Crew SALE did not disappoint. I present to you my fabulous peep toe shoes:

Okay, so they are more strappy sandals than peep toes, but aren’t they gorgeous? Not to mention, they are comfy, the heel is shorter than my other options, they look fabulous with my dress, and they gave me the best excuse to get a pedicure:

Surprisingly, they look pretty bridal with my nails done!!

Did anyone else go on a wild goose chase for the perfect wedding shoes?

*During my crazy, must have the perfect pair of shoes adventure, I did buy two pairs of shoes from Nordstrom (both blogged about my Miss Bruschetta), and both were fantastic, just not perfect. So yep, that takes my total shoe purchases up to nine.

Tags: |   Link for this post | Share this post: Miss Peep FINALLY Has the Perfect Pair of Peep Toes      
Newer blog post
more in Blog
Older blog post
Newer blog post by Mrs. Peep Toe
more by Mrs. Peep Toe (oldest)
Older blog post by Mrs. Peep Toe
advertisement below

34 Responses to “Miss Peep FINALLY Has the Perfect Pair of Peep Toes”

1.
Bee Icon
Bee
Miss Bruschetta (message)  5,553 posts, Bee Keeper

Hey shoe-lover twin! So glad to read your happy ending…and I must say again, you have excellent taste in fancy footwear! ;-)

 
2.
AlmostMrsG
Member
AlmostMrsG (message)  168 posts, Blushing bee

I just saw those first JCrew peep toe sling backs in blue this AM and fell in love! Too bad Mr. G is only an inch taller than me and we’re getting married on grass… no 3.5 inch stilettos for me!

 
3.
Guest Icon
Guest
lala

gorgeous! are they actually comfy? I want to wear hot shoes but i don’t want to be in pain on my wedding day!

 
4.
Miss Mary Jane
Bee
Miss Mary Jane (message)  1,516 posts, Bumble bee

OMG. I hate you for posting that Augusta shoe. It costs. So. Much. More. Than my budget. But I love it. At least you said the quality wasn’t awesome. That’ll sway me…. for now.

 
5.
Bee Icon
Bee
Miss Peep Toe (message)  1,636 posts, Bumble bee

@Miss Mary Jane: The Augusta shoe was such a disappointment.

@lala: I should clarify comfy- so much comfortable than my other options, but I also wear 3″ heels on a regular basis to work.

 
6.
Bee Icon
Bee
Miss Joey (message)  829 posts, Busy bee

Those are so cute!

 
7.
MissCamera
Member
MissCamera (message)  671 posts, Busy bee

Wow I can’t believe you had a bad experience with endless.com! I order all my shoes from them and am usually VERY happy– unless the shoes are too tight, but thats not endless’ fault! ;) )

I love your new “bridal” sandals and can’t wait to see your whole look together!

 
8.
Miss Mary Jane
Bee
Miss Mary Jane (message)  1,516 posts, Bumble bee

@Miss Peep Toe: Thank you. Your negative opinion of that gorgeous shoe will honestly keep me from spending way too much $ on it.

 
9.
LatteLove
Hostess
LatteLove (message)  4,094 posts, Honey bee

wow, who knew it would take so many shoes to find the right ones!

Glad you’re happy with your final choice! Breathe a sigh of relief. :-)

 
10.
Sweet10ve
Member
Sweet10ve (message)  111 posts, Blushing bee

I love your choice in shoes! They were all beautiful and I’m sure I would have picked the J.Crew shoes too! Thanks for letting us know they aren’t worth the cost. =)

Congrats on finally finding a pair of comfy and great looking shoes for the wedding! =)

 
11.
Bee Icon
Bee
Miss Stiletto (message)  759 posts, Busy bee

Yay, they’re lovely!! The quest is always worth it when you finally find the perfect pair ;)

I had mine on last night (and yelled at Mr. S many times “Are you looking?!” - dont’ know why I think he can’t see my shoes) …I wanted to make sure they didn’t make me too talk compared to him…and they’re perfect! I had a hard time taking them off.

I LOVE the third pair. I’d ask what you’re telling them for, but it’d be too tempting for this Bee!

 
12.
Miss Gloss
Bee
Miss Gloss (message)  1,053 posts, Bumble bee

I love the bow on the back of the first one!
Gotta love JCrew, they’ve always got your back :)
and I’ve bought 6 pairs so far.

 
13.
mary-alice-me
Member
mary-alice-me (message)  1,870 posts, Buzzing bee

I had a terrible time buying shoes. I bought vintage pair off Etsy which came damaged, a pair from Zappos that I returned because they didn’t look like the picture, and a pair from Endless that I am keeping ’cause they’re cute but probably won’t wear for the wedding.

Whew! I’m glad to see someone got more shoes than I did! I like your final choice and thanks for all the reviews!

 
14.
ColorCoated
Member
ColorCoated (message)  951 posts, Busy bee

@Miss Mary Jane: Even if it is a little disappointing, the Augusta is now on sale for $ 160 :).

 
15.
Miss Bear Cub
Bee
Miss Bear Cub (message)  1,350 posts, Bumble bee

I love them!!!

 
16.
MightySapphire
Hostess
MightySapphire (message)  2,608 posts, Sugar bee

I bought shoes from zappos, and I know you can return them within a year, but I already shredded the return slip and return label. Now I changed dresses and can’t wear them, and I don’t know WHAT I’m going to do with them!

 
18.
Bee Icon
Bee
Miss Peep Toe (message)  1,636 posts, Bumble bee

@Miss Stiletto: Actually, they’d only be $30. You know you want them!

@Miss Rye Bread: Glad I already love my shoes. Those are FANTASTIC.

 
19.
Member Icon
Member
alissa07 (message)  140 posts, Blushing bee

MightySapphire- I think you can still download a return slip off Zappos.com if you created an account! I’ve done that before!

 
20.
Member Icon
Member
ac-ny (message)  92 posts, Worker bee

Endless is owned by amazon.

I ordered about fifteen pairs of shoes from them, in two different orders. Endless was great, fast shipping and easy returns. Great selection for a narrow, flat footed girl. And much easier to search than zappos.

None of the shoes I received were damaged, so I’d go endless if your looking!

 
21.
LLauRRa
Hostess
LLauRRa (message)  843 posts, Busy bee

Woohoo! Shoe Success!

 
22.
Member Icon
Member
hmn09 (message)  34 posts, Newbee

I love your shoes! So cute in pink.

I spent sooooo many hours looking for shoes online and in stores, I even ordered a couple pairs online and sent them back. My fiance is just an inch taller than I am, but I didn’t want an ordinary ballet flat. Then I went to an upscale store and they ordered two different pairs of non bridal shoes for me. One pair of Stuart Weitzmans in “hummus” http://shop.nordstrom.com/S/3007547?cm_cat=datafeed&cm_pla=shoes:women:flats&cm_ite=stuart_weitzman_%27lowkey%27_flat:245338&cm_ven=Linkshare&siteId=J84DHJLQkR4-vyMEJ3IueIkdjgvh3M2Flg and one pair of Cole Haans in “textured ivory patent” http://www.colehaan.com/colehaan/catalog/product.jsp?productId=255408&categoryId=321002&productGroup=259849.

I loved the Stuart Weitzman’s, but the color was too dark for my ivory dress. The Cole Haan’s were perfect (I think they are a lot cuter on than in the picture). And even though they were definitely out of my budget, I splurged and got them. I couldn’t have been happier when i tried them on with my dress. And, the clerk gave me all of the essential foot petals to go with the shoe!

 
23.
Lillindy
Hostess
Lillindy (message)  4,251 posts, Honey bee

Yay, I sure do love your winning pair!

 
24.
LovestheBear
Member
LovestheBear (message)  875 posts, Busy bee

mmm…JCrew shoes. Yeah!

 
25.
Miss French Bulldog
Bee
Miss French Bulldog (message)  6,063 posts, Bee Keeper

Ooo I love the winning pair! I also love J Crew’s BFF, J. Crew SALE ;-)

 
26.
Guest Icon
Guest
liane4tino

I so need to know who makes those first silver shoes, or where else I can find those. I’m in a friends wedding and she wants us to wear a “muted” silver shoe. Those are perfect!! Also, love your shoe choice! I have white ones that are very similar to those.

 
27.
Guest Icon
Guest
SonomaBride

All I can say is Oh. My. God. We must be long lost bridal twins!! Live in San Francisco. Check. Wearing Kendra. Check. Ordered exact pair of J.Crew heels on sale last week. Check. Now just hoping that they are awaiting me when I get home from work!!! Love it!

 
28.
Bee Icon
Bee
Miss Peep Toe (message)  1,636 posts, Bumble bee

@liane4tino: Are you asking about the first shoe? See the source above. The first silver shoe is actually Matisse Elvey in Champagne. Hope that helps.

@SonomaBride: WOW, how exciting.

 
29.
Member Icon
Member
vhoef02 (message)  172 posts, Blushing bee

I love your shoe story! I actually am wearing the kitten heeled version of your shoe (in silver!).

Love your shoes!

 
30.
D.Marie
Member
D.Marie (message)  1,372 posts, Bumble bee

These are all great looking shoes! I love the color of the ones you picked…great choice. Thanks for posting about all the online stores…I was wondering myself about the experience because I wear a size 11 and wondered if I didnt like the shoe or it didnt fit how would the return policy be. Thanks Peeptoe!

 
31.
Bee Icon
Bee
Miss Latte (message)  646 posts, Busy bee

Great choice! And I met J.Crew SALE in high school and we’ve been great buddies ever since. ;) She never lets us down, huh?

 
32.
honeymyheart
Member
honeymyheart (message)  763 posts, Busy bee

wow your shoes are so pretty :) and of course the peep toe is a must!

 
33.
JennyBryde
Member
JennyBryde (message)  1,148 posts, Bumble bee

This post was FUN! All the pictures and your commentary got my heart fluttering…especially when you turned to jcrew. Fun fun!

 
34.
Guest Icon
Guest
PlanningMyPurpleWedding

Love your final pick!!!

 


You can also just...

Newer blog post
more in Blog
Older blog post
Newer blog post by Mrs. Peep Toe
more by Mrs. Peep Toe (oldest)
Older blog post by Mrs. Peep Toe
Visit our sister sites Project Wedding
Wedding Songs
eHarmony Advice
Dating Advice
JustMommies
Pregnancy Calendar
Fertile Thoughts
Infertility Support
Copyright 2004-2009, eHarmony, Inc., Advertise
 


Sponsors
Mrs. Peep Toe
Mrs. Peep Toe Mrs. Peep Toe, San Francisco Age and Occupation: 29, Policy Analyst Fiance's Age and Occupation: 36, Olive Oil Production Manager Engagement Date: December 16, 2007 Wedding Date: May, 2009 Blogging Since: November 26, 2008 Venue: Hotel Vitale About Me: I am a west coast lady who loves the San Francisco Bay Area. I love living with Mr. Peep and our animals: Huck the Dog and Ferris the Cat. I work to save the environment in San Francisco, while Mr. Peep makes ridiculously delicious Olive Oil. On any day you can find me reading the latest book I have gotten my hands on, eating Swedish Fish, and perusing wedding blogs! We are both champagne drinking foodies on a Bud Light budget. We are planning an eco-chic, intimate, and interfaith San Francisco City wedding.
Weddingbee PRO
 
Boards
 
Classifieds
 

Blog Calendar
November 2009
SunMonTueWedThuFriSat
1234567
891011121314
15161718192021
22232425262728
2930

Weddingbee Bios
Wiki
More