Register or log in —

Newer blog post
more in Blog
Older blog post
Newer blog post by Mrs. Cowboy Boot
more by Mrs. Cowboy Boot (oldest)
Older blog post by Mrs. Cowboy Boot
Mrs. Cowboy Boot's Picture
Mrs. Cowboy Boot, Santa Fe Age and Occupation: 25, Magazine Editor Fiance's Age and Occupation: 29, Artist and Whitewater Rafting Guide Engagement Date: April 28th, 2008 Wedding Date: October 2009 Venue: Devil's Thumb Ranch, Colorado About Me: I grew up in Los Angeles and have since lived in San Diego, Boston, Italy, Hawaii, New York City, and Santa Fe. I speak Italian and love pasta. My real passion is the outdoors, though. When I'm not at work, I'm snowboarding, hiking with my two dogs, mountain biking, surfing, cross-country-skiing, or boating New Mexico's rivers. Despite my boyish love for adventure, I'm a girly-girl at heart and am overly-excited to pull off the romantic, vintage-inspired, country wedding of my dreams.
About Mrs. Cowboy Boot

Why I Said No To Martha

June 29th, 2009 @ 4:12 pm by Mrs. Cowboy Boot

I have a confession to make. Our wedding was almost featured in Martha Stewart Weddings. When I say, “almost,” I actually have no clue how near or far we were from gracing their glossy pages. All I know is that I decided I didn’t want to move forward with the process. Let me explain.

First, yes, there is an application process for being featured as a Real Wedding in MSW. I wish I could tell you how to get the application, but I can’t. I simply don’t know. I happened to be connected to an editor there through work (publishing is a small world) and decided to email her after seeing one particular wedding featured in their magazine. It was Lily and John’s wedding in Santa Barbara, California—I’ve sprinkled pictures of it throughout the post so you can see what sparked my interest (as if wanting to be in MSW really requires explanation).

(source)

When I saw their wedding, I craved the richness of the photography, the clean and thoughtful details, the gorgeous styling of everyone in the wedding, the bride’s designer gown, and the way the magazine’s pages framed it all so beautifully. Seeing it in print made me think the wedding was somehow more meaningful than a wedding without inked documentation. If mine couldn’t be styled by professionals with a name like Martha Stewart behind them, I’d never be able to have the wedding I dreamed of.

(source)

So I began. I filled out the lines on the application: Bride’s Name. Groom’s Name. Wedding Date. Ceremony and reception site. That’s all I had.

Photographer? Nope. Florist? Not that either. Caterer? Dress designer? Wedding planner? No, no, no. Then it got even more specific: color palette, unique-factor, theme or design concept.

(source)

This was early on in my planning process and I hadn’t nailed down any of the above. I looked at it like this—if I could get MSW behind me, I could have the best of the best vendors in the wedding industry. I mean, how else do all of those “MSW Real Weddings” grow into such glamorous affairs? They must use the power behind The Name to nab the most avant-garde florist in town or barter with a top dress designer. I didn’t want to admit that some couples simply have an unfathomable amount of money or many uber-crafty bones in their bodies or a little bit of both to create gorgeous and unique affairs. I happen to have neither loads of money nor craftiness on my side.

So, I quickly entered my dream vendors, said a prayer to the wedding gods, and sent the application in with the required photograph of me and Mr. CB and the many inspiration pictures I’d printed out.

(source)

The application said it would take three or four months to get a response once it was received. Within one week, I had an email in my Inbox:

“Ms. CB, We looked over your packet yesterday and we’d love to get updates as details develop and get confirmed. You have a lot of good ideas and inspiration and we’d love to be kept in the loop as it all comes together. Best, anonymous MSW editor.”

(source)

This got me all fired up. I started nailing down details just to push them out the, well, outbox. I focused on things I thought MSW would like. I sent them our save-the-date and explained how Mr. CB drew the horse. I sent a selection of bridesmaid’s dresses to find out which ones they liked.

“Favors?” the editor wrote me in an email. I had never planned on including these but wrote back anyway, “Absolutely! We’re thinking of naming the tables types of herbs (since we’re foodies) and giving each table seeds so our guests can plant their respective herbs. It’s eco-friendly!”

I became obsessed, trying to send one new update each day, inching my way closer to their approval.

(source)

Finally, I asked, “How much of the wedding needs to be nailed down before you decide to cover it or not?”

I should’ve known the answer to this question since I work in magazines. Magazine ideas don’t pass the Pearly Gates of Approval until they’re completely hashed out, deeply researched, and full of quirky, interesting details. This goes for any type of story whether it be a profile of an in-the-moment person or the atmospheric story of a wedding.

Anonymous MSW editor wrote me back, “There’s no concrete answer to this one.” Shocker, I thought. She continued, “We’ll need some details nailed down on your end before we can commit to covering. That way we don’t sign up for a wedding and then find out 80% of what we loved has changed.” Duh, I was practically hitting myself over the head with my keyboard at this point.

A few months went on, we exchanged emails and they kept liking what I had to say.

(source)

That’s when I applied for Weddingbee. With a yes to my Bee application (yipppeeee!), I went back to MSW and asked if I could blog and still be considered for their magazine. I realize I didn’t need to ask their permission but I was pretty sure they might reconsider covering us if all of my details were dispelled across the World Wide Web.

I was right. They told me I had the choice: keep filling them in on our details with the hopes—not the confirmation—that they’d cover us or blog for Weddingbee. I thought about it for a few days and started to realize what was happening. I was sending them details I thought they’d like as opposed to what I really wanted. I didn’t even know what I wanted yet—I hadn’t given my vision enough time to breathe. And, I knew, even then, that writing for Weddingbee was going to be a much more meaningful experience. This turned out to be true.

Mr. CB was never a fan of being in MSW but he was willing to bend for my happiness. Making the decision to become a bee was like letting my perfectly-coiffed self drive away in a convertible, top down, hair blowin’ in the wind. I was able to let go of all expectations, pressures, and prefabricated ideas of what my wedding should look like and just Let. It. Be.

Sure, I wouldn’t end up with my wedding in print. Nor would I have the best vendors… or would I?

Now that each detail and vendor is based purely on our opinions, on what we really want our day to feel like, I wouldn’t have it any other way. It’s real and more us than it ever was before. I’d pick that over delusions of grandeur any day.

How did you make your wedding your own?

Tags: , |   Link for this post | Share this post: Why I Said No To Martha      
Newer blog post
more in Blog
Older blog post
Newer blog post by Mrs. Cowboy Boot
more by Mrs. Cowboy Boot (oldest)
Older blog post by Mrs. Cowboy Boot
advertisement below

39 Responses to “Why I Said No To Martha”

1.
Newport Nuptials
Member
Newport Nuptials (message)  1,133 posts, Bumble bee

I’m glad you chose Weddingbee, although I am a huge Martha fan!

 
2.
Bee Icon
Bee
Mrs. Peep Toe (message)  1,636 posts, Bumble bee

Wow. I think that not all of us get a chance to say no to Martha, but I think that all Brides at some point have to say no to something. It’s the point in the process where we take ownership of our own wedding- and let me tell you if you are able to do that- your wedding will be perfect. And perfectly you!

 
3.
Bee Icon
Bee
Mrs. Flamingo (message)  1,267 posts, Bumble bee

Oh thats sucky… but I can understand they want exclusivity
Im glad u chose weddingbee ;)

 
4.
Bee Icon
Bee
Miss Labrador (message)  1,324 posts, Bumble bee

I think you made the right decision. But I may be a bit biased. ;)

PS. I love the wedding you featured! I’m stealing the cake photo for inspiration. And the photo of them outside at the tables is to die for! I could see why you got so caught up!

 
5.
Bee Icon
Bee
Miss Cloud (message)  587 posts, Busy bee

I’m gladd you chose the hive! And you will forever have the bragging rights that Martha was at least interested, and YOU turned THEM down!

 
6.
Mrs. Penguin
Bee
Mrs. Penguin (message)  2,148 posts, Buzzing bee

Blogging for Weddingbee was a huge and amazing experience for me! Obviously I’m biased, but you made a great choice! Having the support of thousands of other brides out there, cheering you along the way, was an incredible way to experience my journey. You made an amazing choice — and in the end, many bees have been published as well! You could def. coordinate with your photog to submit to magazines if you feel like it, and I have a feeling, with the way your wedding is shaping up, that you’d have no problem getting published. :) Thanks for sharing your story! I know so many people wonder how to get published in Martha… many don’t realize that Martha is actually involved in your planning process as well!

 
7.
KateMW
Hostess
KateMW (message)  2,714 posts, Sugar bee

I totally wouldn’t have chosen Martha. Sorry! I love seeing your wedding though.

 
8.
Gilneas
Member
Gilneas (message)  1,029 posts, Bumble bee

How interesting. I’ve always wondered why the weddings covered my MSW always seem to be… very connected to the MS empire, but I had no idea the process was so in depth.

I think you made the right decision - in the end, how awesome would it have been to be documented in the pages of MSW? But at the same time - you don’t want to have a MSW - you want to have YOUR wedding.

 
9.
Bee Icon
Bee
Miss Stiletto (message)  759 posts, Busy bee

I didn’t know Martha took no for an answer ;)

Glad you chose us, CB!

 
10.
KateMW
Hostess
KateMW (message)  2,714 posts, Sugar bee

That should say I would have totally chosen Martha, not wouldn’t. Oops.

 
11.
amandopolis
Member
amandopolis (message)  727 posts, Busy bee

That was one of my all time favorite weddings from MSW! I spotted it last summer when I first started planning.

 
12.
KateMW
Hostess
KateMW (message)  2,714 posts, Sugar bee

Oh and I meant to add that I don’t think all Real Wedding are chosen like that, because I know of a photographer who had a wedding chosen for a huge article and it was after the wedding had been shot and put on their blog I believe.

 
13.
Member Icon
Member
diorable (message)  250 posts, Helper bee

I think you made the right choice — weddingbee IS the wedding blog; everyone reads it, including MSW!

you are one of my favorite bees here, so I’m (selfishly) happy you chose this!

 
14.
purpleHaze79
Member
purpleHaze79 (message)  875 posts, Busy bee

Although I’m a huge fan of MSW, I’m glad you chose Weddingbee! Regardless of whether or not your wedding was featured on MSW, it WILL be the great wedding that you deserve BECAUSE it’s what you really want, not what you thought they wanted to hear. Kudos to you, Miss CB!

 
15.
Bee Icon
Bee
Miss Beagle (message)  1,051 posts, Bumble bee

I’m glad you chose Weddingbee! I think it’s really hard to personalize your wedding and make it your own. It’s even harder when people are throwing their opinions at you, telling you what you “should” do- I look forward to reading all about your unique wedding and seeing the end result of your planning. :)

 
16.
LovestheBear
Member
LovestheBear (message)  875 posts, Busy bee

As much as I love MSW, I am glad you chose Weddingbee! Thanks for sharing all your great ideas and inspirations!

 
17.
Soon2BeeMrsLewis
Member
Soon2BeeMrsLewis (message)  507 posts, Busy bee

i agree with miss cloud. this was a great story miss cb and i’m so glad you are here with us at weddingbee.

 
18.
Bee Icon
Bee
Mrs. Taffy (message)  2,598 posts, Sugar bee

Wow, I’m glad that you chose weddingbee! I always thought people submitted pictures of their weddings after the fact, it’s kind of crazy that they want to be so involved beforehand!

PS- I love the dress from that issue!

 
19.
Jenniphyr
Member
Jenniphyr (message)  1,397 posts, Bumble bee

First of all, let me just applaud you first! =) It takes a lot to be able to let go of something you’ve been working at for so long.

I am glad you came to Weddingbee. And I’m beyond glad that you realized what the wedding of YOUR dreams was, rather than the wedding of THEIR dreams.

 
20.
Guest Icon
Guest
Kari

I think the blogging will be more rewarding to look back on instead of MSW.

An Idea: My husband and I are also foodies, but by career, and instead of doing a candle or sand ceremony we combined salt and pepper. It was a fun personal touch that our guests remember three years later! —Just thought I’d throw this out there as an idea if you don’t already have this portion of the ceremony planned.

 
21.
Bee Icon
Bee
Miss Star (message)  1,277 posts, Bumble bee

I think the whole process of WB will be much more rewarding in the end. I love how supportive everyone is of whatever weird wedding ideas any of us put out there, rather than feeling like Martha is judging!

 
22.
Guest Icon
Guest
summerbee

To make my wedding my own, I decided early on not to compare my wedding plans to any “ideal” wedding that I saw on a blog or in a magazine. It’s easy to get swept up in all the beautiful inspiration that’s out there on wedding blogs, but you need to give your vision time to grow and utimately follow your own dreams and plans, perfect weddings be damned!

 
23.
Member Icon
Member
clarerichardson (message)  49 posts, Newbee

I found this blurb on the MSW website about being a featured wedding:

“To submit your wedding to the magazine, please email us with information about your wedding (your name, phone number, wedding location, wedding date, a brief paragraph about what makes your wedding special, and one photograph that you think represents your wedding best). We will contact you if we are interested in getting more information from you. Also, please go to marthastewartweddings.com/community to submit photos in one of our many photo upload categories.”

http://www.marthastewartweddings.com/contact-us?rsc=footer#c2

 
24.
Melissabegins
Member
Melissabegins (message)  843 posts, Busy bee

I think I’m in the minority but I’m not a fan of Martha Stewart. I don’t even want to just say “Martha” - it gets under my skin. There seems to be this highbrow pretentious thing going on with her media empire, yet it’s common and accesible to everyone. Just don’t get it. I’m glad you joined WB and posted about what you were really looking for, versus what they wanted to hear. When you try to conform to someone else’s standard of creativity, then you completely lose it.

 
25.
greeneyedemily
Member
greeneyedemily (message)  20 posts, Newbee

i’m glad you chose weddingbee - afterall, it’s your and your fiance’s day, not Martha Stewart’s!

btw - Lily’s dress in the MS feature is the same one I’ll be wearing at my wedding in 3 weeks! i just love it! and now i know that it also photographs beautifully… :-)

 
26.
Bee Icon
Bee
Miss Powder Puff (message)  834 posts, Busy bee

I ADORE that wedding- her dress is to die for!

I’m glad that you chose to become a Bee! But I may be a bit biased about the whole thing. ;)

 
27.
Bee Icon
Bee
Mrs. Hot Cocoa (message)  1,715 posts, Bumble bee

I’m glad you chose to become a bee. But just remember that you can always get into Martha after the fact, like our very own Mrs. Jasmine!

 
28.
Ruby Slippers
Member
Ruby Slippers (message)  482 posts, Helper bee

Wow, great story! I’m glad you chose Weddingbee, though! I think your wedding is going to be so lovely, and the fact that it’s YOUR OWN, not what you think MSW would like, makes it so much better. But try to get into MSW anyway, afterwards, like Mrs Hot Cocoa says! If you’re still keen. :-)

 
29.
Amber1279
Member
Amber1279 (message)  316 posts, Helper bee

wow! what an opportunity, but I totally understand why you chose to be a Bee.

 
30.
MissBookworm
Member
MissBookworm (message)  271 posts, Helper bee

I’m glad you choose WB! Your wedding will be beautiful whether or not it’s in MSW!

 
31.
Bee Icon
Bee
Miss Mouse (message)  3,301 posts, Sugar bee

Yeah, you definitely made the right decision. What good is looking back on your wedding in print if it’s not *your* wedding?

 
32.
Miss French Bulldog
Bee
Miss French Bulldog (message)  6,063 posts, Bee Keeper

I too am SO GLAD you chose Weddingbee :) and choose to have your wedding your way! I love all the details of your wedding.

 
33.
Guest Icon
Guest
Sara

I fell in love with that wedding too! I especially loved her dress. It was way out of my budget before I even knew the price, but I searched all over the internet for that dress or a dress like it. Couldn’t find it. Oh well.

I am glad you are on weddingbee! MSW would have been so much pressure, you might have lost your mind and your focus :)

 
34.
WorstTwinEver15
Member
WorstTwinEver15 (message)  758 posts, Busy bee

Tough choice!!! We’re glad you chose to be a Bee!

 
35.
MeredithN
Member
MeredithN (message)  110 posts, Blushing bee

so glad you chose the ‘Bee! I’ve loved your posts :)

It also seems like your decisions were being shaped by what Martha (and I unabashedly love Martha!) might like instead of what Ms CB likes. So small tear for not be featured on MSW but big cheer for sticking with a great community!!

 
36.
Gerbera
Member
Gerbera (message)  823 posts, Busy bee

I know I’m HUGELY in the minority but I really do not see what the big deal is with MS Weddings. But that’s maybe because I can’t stand Martha Stewart and refuse to support anything in her empire.
So *I* am super psyched you chose to share with US instead!

 
37.
Melissabegins
Member
Melissabegins (message)  843 posts, Busy bee

Gerbera - Me too! I would perhaps support her creative team (who let’s face it, do all of the work) if they worked for themselves or in other companies, but I’m not putting a cent of my money into her greedy hands. Love the community and the openness associated with wedding blogs, and less conventional wedding publications! Let’s build the wealth and happiness of small business owners creating a community.

 
38.
Guest Icon
Guest
Imara219

That wedding looked like so much fun. I loved her dress. It was amazing! I guess weddingbee is better b/c most of the time I don’t even click on the Real Weddings option on MS website.

 
39.
Guest Icon
Guest
A Bee’s Life: Miss Cowboy Boot’s Turn » Weddingbee » The Wedding Blog

[...] I’ve already blogged about this and, to not bore you with the details, you can read about it here. In short, the magazine wouldn’t let me post my details across the blogosphere (which had grown [...]

 


You can also just...

Newer blog post
more in Blog
Older blog post
Newer blog post by Mrs. Cowboy Boot
more by Mrs. Cowboy Boot (oldest)
Older blog post by Mrs. Cowboy Boot
Visit our sister sites Project Wedding
Wedding Songs
eHarmony Advice
Dating Advice
JustMommies
Pregnancy Calendar
Fertile Thoughts
Infertility Support
Copyright 2004-2009, eHarmony, Inc., Advertise
 


Sponsors
Mrs. Cowboy Boot
Mrs. Cowboy Boot Mrs. Cowboy Boot, Santa Fe Age and Occupation: 25, Magazine Editor Fiance's Age and Occupation: 29, Artist and Whitewater Rafting Guide Engagement Date: April 28th, 2008 Wedding Date: October 2009 Venue: Devil's Thumb Ranch, Colorado About Me: I grew up in Los Angeles and have since lived in San Diego, Boston, Italy, Hawaii, New York City, and Santa Fe. I speak Italian and love pasta. My real passion is the outdoors, though. When I'm not at work, I'm snowboarding, hiking with my two dogs, mountain biking, surfing, cross-country-skiing, or boating New Mexico's rivers. Despite my boyish love for adventure, I'm a girly-girl at heart and am overly-excited to pull off the romantic, vintage-inspired, country wedding of my dreams.
Weddingbee PRO
 
Boards
 
Classifieds
 

Blog Calendar
November 2009
SunMonTueWedThuFriSat
1234567
891011121314
15161718192021
22232425262728
2930

Weddingbee Bios
Wiki
More