Newer blog post
more in Blog
Older blog post
Newer blog post by Mrs. Swan
more by Mrs. Swan (oldest)
Older blog post by Mrs. Swan
Mrs. Swan's Picture
Mrs. Swan, New York City Age and Occupation: 31, Legislative Representative Fiance's Age and Occupation: 33, Finance Guy Engagement Date: August 9, 2008 Wedding Date: August 2009 Venue: Battery Gardens About Me: I am an un-crafty but resourceful, Caribbean-born but New York-raised woman who's been known to analyze "Dancing with the Stars" and “So You Think You Can Dance”, buy stinky cheese, and use way too many parentheses. I keep lists for fun, am constantly daydreaming of my next international travel adventure (four continents down, three to go), debating sports (let’s Got Mets/Giants!) and dancing around my apartment to stay sane. I am excited to share our wedding planning journey as I hope to plan a streamlined, personal, and fun wedding with the greatest life partner I could ever imagine, Mr. Swan.
About Mrs. Swan

Through the Ring-er

July 7th, 2009 @ 12:10 pm by Mrs. Swan

I have not talked about my engagement ring, so here it is.

Through the Ring-er :  wedding rings Dsc0042

It’s not that I don’t like my engagement ring. I LOVE IT. Yet I often feel particularly uncomfortable about discussing it with people or for lack of a better phrase, “showing it off”. I guess I’ll reveal to you all my insecurity about the fact that my ring is a bit bigger than I expected (Ugh! It pained me to write that!!!). While I love it as the most lovely and generous gift that Mr. Swan has ever given me, I find that often some other people view my ring (or really engagement rings in general) in a different way.

The moment I got engaged to Mr. Swan I was this big ball of emotion and tears.

I looked at my ring and thought it looked great, but I think I was just so out of sorts and giddy that I didn’t really think about it much. Plus, it didn’t even fit my ring finger. I had a pretty expensive pinky ring for about a week before I got a chance to get it re-sized by the jeweler.

After I started to see friends and acquaintances post-engagement, people were starting to make more of a big deal about my ring than I was. I started to get upset. In my mind, I was just excited to even be getting married. My mother never got married, and again, most of my female family and friends are not. I was just happy to have found someone. Yet, all many people could talk about was the ring. As an illustrative example, I will share with you a “ring run in” that occurred with a relative of Mr. Swan last year during the holidays.

Pretty much, said relative walked into the room, asked me how I was doing, and then said, “Let’s see your ring,” all within the span of two minutes! I had just started a new, challenging and interesting job the month before. She didn’t ask me about that. I was spending my first major holiday away from my family. She didn’t ask me how I felt about that. She didn’t even asked about how I was enjoying being engaged. Um, hello, it’s nice to see you, too. I was a bit pissy that she barely even made an effort to even make some kind of conversation before she even looked at my ring. Dude, I’m a person that exists independently of my ring.

It got me thinking about engagement rings and why we as a society put so much stock in them. I understand the symbolism of the ring, of course. I know that it signifies an acceptance of a marriage proposal and life long commitment, but I definitely feel like perhaps there is a little too much emphasis on it. I wish sometimes I would get more congratulations and questions about how I’m feeling about becoming a wife than about my ring.

It upsets me when I read about women made to feel inferior or otherwise because they receive a diamond that’s too small or too big (or did not receive a diamond at all!) by others who choose to steal their joy about the ring instead of giving words of encouragement to them regarding this amazing new life event. I don’t think we should do away with engagement rings, and I think that they are important to some degree. By the way, I am not perfect. I have had my judgey moments about big rings… BUT I keep it hidden away in the back of my mind in the “Keep it to Yourself” folder!!!

Have you been in a situation where you felt uncomfortable about your engagement ring? I will get down off my soapbox now, but I’d be interested in hearing your opinions.

Tags: rings |
advertisement below
Newer blog post
more in Blog
Older blog post
Newer blog post by Mrs. Swan
more by Mrs. Swan (oldest)
Older blog post by Mrs. Swan

52 Responses to “Through the Ring-er”

1 2 3 

1.
Mrs. DG
Hostess
Mrs. DG (message)  8,491 posts, Bee Keeper

I had similar feelings, but not centered around the ring. It really bugged me that as soon as I said I was engaged, people seemed to take me more seriously. They treated me differently despite the fact that I was the very same 36 year old just a few days earlier.

Why is it that engagement/marriage seems to provide us with more legitimacy? I was shocked to notice the change, despite the fact that I always knew there was societal pressure there!

 
2.
Guest Icon
Guest
claire

I completely agree with your thoughts here. I find myself feeling uncomfortable too, because without fail, immediately upon random person grabbing my hand to see the ring, comes the obligatory “oh my goodness, it’s [insert adjective!]! He did a good job!”. I’m curious what my ring would need to look like in order to not get this response … haha. Not that I’m not appreciative of compliments [and I do think he did a good job] … I just don’t feel it’s necessary and it doesn’t make me any more excited to be marrying my guy!

 
3.
TheDivineMissE
Member
TheDivineMissE (message)  394 posts, Helper bee

I totally agree. Just this past weekend while with my future in-laws I got the “I want to see the ring again” (this was our third trip to see them since getting engaged). I got the “I can’t believe how big it is!” oh! and the best part was when cousin G started comparing my ring to cousin A’s ring. Asking how big they were and then who’s was bigger. It’s really uncomfortable.

 
4.
Miss Mary Jane
Bee
Miss Mary Jane (message)  1,970 posts, Buzzing bee

I agree too. I get TONS of compliments about my ring - people always want to see it: relatives, coworkers, waitresses, cashiers… and I catch random strangers staring at it. And then the “he did a great job!” comments, as claire mentioned. (Mr. MJ and I picked out -and paid for- my ring together.) I am pleased that people like my ring, but there are a lot more important things about me than just the jewelry on my finger! Sometimes i find myself covering my hand when I’m in the presence of certain acquaintances - I just don’t want the attention (in that way).

 
5.
Habibi
Member
Habibi (message)  567 posts, Busy bee

I’ve had people blatantly ask my carat size or try to guess (and guessed to small!). It’s uncomfortable and both times I was annoyed at myself for sharing the information instead of saying something witty like “big enough.” HA. But people are curious and I choose to believe its not with malicious intent. FH didn’t buy my ring for other people. He bought it for us. It’s something we both love and are very proud of. I don’t focus on it and if other people do, I consider it their loss.

 
6.
Champagne Wishes
Member
Champagne Wishes (message)  1,187 posts, Bumble bee

I agree 100%. It is literally the first thing people ask to see and, like you Miss Swan, they typically have a comment on size and style. I never know what to say so I just say “he did a good job”… little do they know I went with him ring shopping ;)
I love my ring but the attention it receives has tainted it a little for me. That sounds horrible but you know what I mean.

 
7.
Guest Icon
Guest
Jo

People are so crazy about rings! I got an inexpensive, artsy engagement ring, because I knew that I would be asked constantly to show it off. I did like the romance of it for a while, but then it started catching on things, I got tired of talking about wedding plans with disapproving strangers, and I didn’t want to ruin it at work… so I stopped wearing it even before the wedding. Just not my thing.

After the wedding, neither of us chose to wear wedding bands. I haven’t gotten a lot of flack for that, but I am constantly aware of the outrage inspired by a man deciding not to wear a wedding band. I didn’t make the choice because I don’t love my husband or value the marriage… it’s because I’m just not a jewelry person. I cringe every time I see a woman claim that all men who refuse to wear wedding bands are less committed to or deserving of the marriage.

 
8.
Miss French Bulldog
Bee
Miss French Bulldog (message)  7,730 posts, Bee Keeper

(I wrote a comment and it got lost somewhere in the interwebs :( )
I just wanted to say that I see how this could happen to someone and how frustrating it must be, but I was thinking while I was reading your post that this doesn’t happen to me. Most the time ppl notice my ring out of the corner of their eye while they are talking to me, but has never been the first topic of conversation. I think it was b/c everyone knew for so long that Mr Frenchie and I would get engaged, but ti was just a matter of when.

 
9.
Bee Icon
Bee
Miss Lamb (message)  970 posts, Busy bee

I’m so glad you wrote this! I too recieved a ring that is bigger than I had ever dreamed. Of course, I love my ring - the mister put a lot of thought and research into a custom design that showcases a gorgeous solitaire - but I agree, it’s very uncomfortable when people tell me how huge it is, or how lucky I am. To avoid the awkwardness, I’ve started to just agree with them - “Why yes, it is quite large and beautiful isn’t it? That’s why I said, ‘Yes!’” That way I’ve made a joke as a response to a silly comment in the first place.

 
10.
Member Icon
Member
Mrs. Sparkle (message)  37 posts, Newbee

This is SO true! I am in LOVE with my ring, but without fail when people look at my ring they grab my hand say “oh wow” and then pull it closer to their eyes are say “oh my god”. Every single person has done this, I kid you not. My brother even asked me if ALL of the diamonds were real. OF COURSE THEY’RE ALL REAL! My Fiance’s brother (whom just got married) looked at my ring and blurted out “MAN! Why’d you have to show me up like that?!” His wife was NOT very happy…

 
11.
ggsb
Member
ggsb (message)  1,245 posts, Bumble bee

I’m on the other side of this one. Apparently my ring is “too small”. I LOVE my ring and it is exactly what I wanted….however many of my husband’s friends have made off-hand comments about expecting something larger. I’m sure they are comparing my ring to the rings of my husband’s family members but it still drives me crazy. I’d had whitty responses ready for a few and ignored them for the most part but inside I’d like to punch a few of them. The part that really bothers me is when he feels the need to explain that I could have had any size I wanted but I picked an ornate vintage setting so it dictated a smaller stone. And yes, it is often the first thing people ask to see. Now post-wedding there has been an addition to my annoyance. I had the nerve to pick a partial eternity band that perfectly matched the etchings on my vintage e-ring….apparently he’s getting a hard time for not springing for the full eternity band…. le sigh!! Ok, I’ll step off my soapbox now too, thanks for the opportunity to vent a bit! :)

 
12.
jmc
Member
jmc (message)  882 posts, Busy bee

I have a lovely, but small, simple ring with tiny diamonds that I picked out myself and basically told my fiance to buy. I love it, and I feel like it reflects where we are now. We are just not people that can afford a $3,000 ring. We are people who can’t even afford the $800 ring he got me, but he put it on the old credit card anyhow.

I can tell that people are disappointed when they have to look at it, and then feel pressure to react. I don’t feel sorry for them though, because I think it’s annoying when people ask to see it, because it is usually in annoying situations like you described above, Miss Swan. I love my fiance, and I love jewelry (and even big diamonds!) but this ring is not an expression of his love for me. And getting engaged was not at all about the ring.

Of course, once we’re rich (because of course we’ll be rich!) I want big diamonds, hell yeahs.

 
13.
jmc
Member
jmc (message)  882 posts, Busy bee

@ggsb: I totally hear you.

 
14.
Guest Icon
Guest
December

My ring is a sapphire, so yeah, I’ve gotten comments. Mostly just surprised little noises indicating that the ring viewer is surprised to not find a diamond on my finger. Or “Did he pick it out himself” which translates to “Are you disappointed?” Which I’m not.. at least not that it’s a sapphire. We planned it that way, but he has much simpler tastes in settings than I do.
The worst comment, though, was from a friend who I started really being friends with after our engagement and more so after the wedding, when I moved my engagement ring to my right hand (maybe she didn’t realize she was insulting the e-ring?). But anyway, she was telling a group of us about the beautiful sapphire ring her boyfriend bought her in Mexico for like, 5 bucks or whatever cheapo price he got, and then noticing my ring said, “Oh, it actually looks a lot like that ring!” Thanks. I appreciate being compared to your random cheap Mexican ring.

 
15.
Member Icon
Member
SoyLatte (message)  18 posts, Newbee

I think I can relate! I love my engagement ring, and I could stare it all day long! My engagement ring diamond is also a lot bigger than I was expecting, and it doesn’t help that my hand is very small, making it appear even larger.
The most awkward moment I had was at the end of a meeting with the Mayor of a local City (it was a work meeting), and he says to me, “Next time we meet, would you mind taking off your rock? It’s blinding me!!” I had absolutely no idea what to say in response. I was with my boss and this was my first big meeting with City officials (I work in land development). Very awkward!!!
The strangest part of the whole ring situation for me is that while my fiance purchased the setting new, the diamond is an heirloom. So I am always of what someone will think, whether they think we paid for the diamond, or just lucked out and got it. Since then, I’ve just decided that people can think whatever they want, I know what the ring means to me and my fiance, and I love it!

 
16.
Member Icon
Member
FallBrideKate (message)  55 posts, Worker bee

My ring was my fiance’s grandmother’s. She wanted him to have it and use it. It is much bigger than anything we would have picked out on our own and it was a very generous gift from his grandmother.

I’ve had all sorts of unpleasant exchanges, including a strange guy who grabbed my hand at a bar to examine my ring (scary!) and coworkers who came over after they found out I got engaged, skipped the congratulations part and just asked to see the ring (rude) and of course, my own mother who has said more than once, “it is so big it looks fake”. Gee, thanks, Mom.

I was very grateful to receive such a beautiful ring but again, I didn’t pick it out or ask for it.

It hasn’t all been bad so I guess I can’t complain and it is a beautiful ring.

 
17.
tea
Member
tea (message)  7,263 posts, Bee Keeper

it’s that outside perception that’s delaying my ring. boo. the boy wants to make sure he gets the right one, one i’d apparently be proud to show off but i’d be proud to “show off” whatever he chose for me. alas, i cannot get him to see it that way.

 
18.
Guest Icon
Guest
Jenn R

My fiance is from a country where engagement rings are not typical, and I am a lifelong feminist who finds diamonds morally uncomfortable. STILL - I insisted on an engagement ring when we started planning our marriage. Why? I knew that some people wouldn’t take our planning seriously without a ring and that it’s the first thing people want to see when you announce that you’re engaged. We ended up buying an antique ring that suits me just fine and didn’t put anyone in debt. I feel kind of stupid that I needed that ring, but I did!

 
19.
mismikado
Member
mismikado (message)  136 posts, Blushing bee

what frustrates me is that majority of society do not take an engagement seriously without a ring. Just 2 months after we started dating, the FH asked me to marry him. Of course we both knew that meant in the distant future b/c neither of use was ready for marriage at that point… fast forward 10 months to January and we actually set the date for next May. :)
Now I don’t have my ring yet, he has bought it, but I haven’t received it yet because I took a summer sabbatical 2000 miles away. He’s giving it to me when I come home in Aug. And yet even though we are planning a wedding. We have vendors booked… we are 100% committed to each other… everyone (including my parents) refuse to accept that we are engaged simply because I don’t have a ring on my finger.
I just don’t get it!

 
20.
Muffet
Member
Muffet (message)  106 posts, Blushing bee

Some people just lack that internal filter. Either that or they’re just easily distracted by sparkly objects.
I would imagine the people that are most important to you care more about your excitment for your marriage than your ring.

 
1 2 3 

Leave a Reply


You can also just...

Newer blog post
more in Blog
Older blog post
Newer blog post by Mrs. Swan
more by Mrs. Swan (oldest)
Older blog post by Mrs. Swan

Visit our sister sites eHarmony
Online Dating
eHarmony Advice
Dating Advice
Project Wedding
Wedding Songs
JustMommies
Pregnancy Calendar

Copyright 2004-2012, Weddingbee.com
 

Find your vendors on Weddingbee

Real reviews from brides in your area!

Favors by Weddingbee

  • Favors by season

Shop Now »

Mrs. Swan
Mrs. Swan

Mrs. Swan, New York City Age and Occupation: 31, Legislative Representative Fiance's Age and Occupation: 33, Finance Guy Engagement Date: August 9, 2008 Wedding Date: August 2009 Venue: Battery Gardens About Me: I am an un-crafty but resourceful, Caribbean-born but New York-raised woman who's been known to analyze "Dancing with the Stars" and “So You Think You Can Dance”, buy stinky cheese, and use way too many parentheses. I keep lists for fun, am constantly daydreaming of my next international travel adventure (four continents down, three to go), debating sports (let’s Got Mets/Giants!) and dancing around my apartment to stay sane. I am excited to share our wedding planning journey as I hope to plan a streamlined, personal, and fun wedding with the greatest life partner I could ever imagine, Mr. Swan.

Boards
Classifieds

Blog Calendar
February 2012
SunMonTueWedThuFriSat
2930311234
567891011
12131415161718
19202122232425
26272829

Weddingbee Bios
Wiki
More