Register or log in —

Newer blog post
more in Blog
Older blog post
Newer blog post by Mrs. Bruschetta
more by Mrs. Bruschetta (oldest)
Older blog post by Mrs. Bruschetta
Mrs. Bruschetta's Picture
Mrs. Bruschetta, Philadelphia Age and Occupation: 25, Communication Professional Fiance's Age and Occupation: 25, Physical Therapy Graduate Student Engagement Date: November 30, 2007 Wedding Date: August 2009 Venue: St. Thomas of Villanova Church & the F.U.E.L. House About Me: I’m a self-proclaimed grammar geek who loves singing (like, really belting it) in the car. My mister and I are planning a vibrant summer soiree celebrating our passions – including food and Philly – and when we make it official, we’ll have been together for eight years! Being super competitive is in my nature, and talking excessively is in my genes. I’ve got a terrible sense of direction, but can always easily find my way into Mr. Bruschetta’s arms.
About Mrs. Bruschetta

Parking Pickle

July 28th, 2009 @ 5:49 pm by Mrs. Bruschetta

After we found the F.U.E.L. House, the mister and I quickly realized we were jazzed about almost everything a city reception had to offer. A counterpoint to the polished area surrounding our suburban ceremony site. A structure that’s on the Philadelphia Register of Historic Places, down the road from several significant sites connected to the birthplace of the United States and in close proximity to some our favorite restaurants — so we can celebrate in a neighborhood that’s special to us, and share this area with our family and friends.

The only thing we didn’t love? The parking situation.

We set the date, signed the contract to secure the F.U.E.L. House — and knew we wouldn’t be able to stretch the budget to include valet parking for our guests. (Given our estimated guest count, we’d have to pay two or three attendants, which would come to at least — but most likely more than — $1,000 for the night.) Instead, Mr. Bruschetta and I pounded the pavement in Old City to complete some parking research. (To help you get your bearings, our cocktail hour and reception locations are flagged on the map below in shades of blue. The hotels at which we’ve secured room blocks are in green.)

View City of Bruschetta-y Love in a larger map


Since the 218 Arch Street lot — one of the two options marked with a “P” — was already $3.00 cheaper on a Saturday evening than the lot at 38 N. Third Street, we selected the former as our “recommended” lot, and worked with the general manager to secure a $15.00 per car rate for any guest who parks here and mentions the Bruschetta (or, I guess more accurately, our real last names) wedding. The two local hotels offer places where guests seeking overnight spots can leave their cars — but we weren’t able to secure a discount for either garage.

In addition to listing this information on our wedding web site / blog, we’ll include a note — directions into the city and turn-by-turn specifics ending at the recommended parking lot, along with a reminder of the price — in our ceremony programs.

Without busting our budget, I can’t think of anything else we can do to make this easier on our guests. I’m hoping most people will understand that a reception in the city translates into a challenging parking situation — just as our ceremony in Pennsylvania means most guests (anyone coming from New Jersey) will be crossing the Delaware River, and paying the required bridge toll. We’ll definitely encourage guests who might be unfamiliar with Old City — and uncomfortable navigating public parking on their own — to carpool with others. But I’d love to hear from the hive on this one, particularly if you’ve experienced something like this as a guest, or had to deal with it while planning your wedding!

Is offering valet parking for your guests a must? Or is securing a reduced rate (and letting your guests know about this option) acceptable?

Tags: |   Link for this post | Share this post: Parking Pickle      
Newer blog post
more in Blog
Older blog post
Newer blog post by Mrs. Bruschetta
more by Mrs. Bruschetta (oldest)
Older blog post by Mrs. Bruschetta
advertisement below

30 Responses to “Parking Pickle”

1.
Bee Icon
Bee
Miss Spaniel (message)  2,597 posts, Sugar bee

Valet is definitely nice, especially for people who don’t live in or right next to large cities. I grew up in a town not all that far from LA where parking was always plentiful and free, but working in LA sometime after college was quite the shock when it came to parking. If I wasn’t already familiar, I’d probably be a little upset as a guest.

THAT said, you’re doing a lot to help guests out, with parking directions and prices listed. And if you can’t afford to do the valet (understandable; that is VERY PRICEY!), you’ve done the next best thing.

 
2.
Member Icon
Member
Kalibali (message)  242 posts, Helper bee

i think providing the information that you have is more than enough. Parking (in any city) is simply a b@!*h.

 
3.
St. Patrick
Member
St. Patrick (message)  63 posts, Worker bee

If anything, make sure your guests know that might be a nominal fee that they will have to pay for parking, especially if it’s cash only. It would be a total bummer if they are caught off guard.

 
4.
mary-alice-me
Member
mary-alice-me (message)  1,870 posts, Buzzing bee

I think it’s to be expected in a downtown city that you may have to park. You’ve done a great job outlining choice and negotiating with lots. I think you’ve done all your should!

 
5.
mdarrah
Member
mdarrah (message)  1,006 posts, Bumble bee

If the budget allowed, I’d say valet all the way. But since it doesn’t just do your best to keep everyone WELL informed of their options and prices, as well as carpooling ideas etc. Talk to several people from each “group” of friends or family and ask everyone to spread the word (as well as putting it on your wedding website if you have one). Its not a big deal, and theres nothing should have done differently, it’ll just be best if they are all informed.

 
6.
Member Icon
Member
sarsk624 (message)  346 posts, Helper bee

Since I have rooms blocked at the two hotels your guests are at as well Miss B. one thing to remember Holiday Inn offers in and out parking to guests for a flat rate. One of the major attractions of our venue was the free parking in a nearby garage (I’m sure we pay for it in our per head price but I like thinking it is free). We aren’t getting the valets though. I can’t afford it and I figure they can handle walking a block. It sounds like you’ve done all you can to try to make this smooth

 
7.
Bee Icon
Bee
Miss Moonbeam (message)  1,328 posts, Bumble bee

I think you’ve certainly done what you can, but older folks don’t look at wedding websites, and can lose information so make sure a younger relative is helping them out. And like someone said above, if it’s cash only let them know.

 
8.
Newport Nuptials
Member
Newport Nuptials (message)  1,133 posts, Bumble bee

We have this problem for my sister’s shower. We encouraged car pooling at first, and got a reduced rate, but recently realized their is free on street parking on Sundays.

Hmm..I’ve never had to pay for parking at a wedding. I think it depends on how you think your guests will react, you know them best!

 
9.
Guest Icon
Guest
Andrea

i’ve never heard of valet parking for a wedding. That seems excessive to me and I wouldn’t expect any bride or groom to provide that.

We are having a city wedding too. Our guests will have to park at the hotel ramps if they are staying there. Then they can walk the two blocks to the reception. Or they will have to park at a city ramp that is 1 block away from the reception.

I didn’t like the parking situation either. Hopefully it all works out for you and for my wedding too!

 
10.
Bee Icon
Bee
Miss Cloud (message)  587 posts, Busy bee

We have quite the parking situation as well, but the best advice I have gotten so far is from my planner “you can only do so much for people, then its up to them”, you have definitely gone above and beyond already!

 
11.
llc2011
Member
llc2011 (message)  458 posts, Helper bee

I think you’ve given them some great information! I was born and raised near Philly, and just took FI there last year and I know that parking in that area is crazy. Like others have said, just make sure to let people know that it might be cash only for the parking.

 
12.
Guest Icon
Guest
Ec

We had a city wedding and paid the valet fees for our guests, BUT it was winter in MN and we had around 100 guests. It sounds like you’re doing as much as you can to make the situation as easy as possible. Some decisions you just have to make and hope they work out and they almost always do.

 
13.
Bee Icon
Bee
Miss Sprinkle (message)  175 posts, Blushing bee

i agree with other comments, as long as you let guests know its cash only, it should be fine. i wouldn’t think it is odd to pay for parking, especially if it was in a busy downtown area.

our venue required us to hire a valet… it really is expensive but we had no other choice!

 
14.
flamingred
Member
flamingred (message)  461 posts, Helper bee

I’m getting married in Philly-both of my sisters did too, and my parents paid for valet parking for the guests-it is nice to do but can get expensive and I don’t think anyone expects it.

 
15.
Guest Icon
Guest
Sarah

I just went to a reception in Chicago and didn’t think twice about paying to park in a nearby parking garage. So yes, I’m sure your guests will be ok with it. Especially since you found the best rate! We actually paid $15 for our parking as well.

 
16.
coleyjean
Member
coleyjean (message)  55 posts, Worker bee

We are getting married in Seattle and were able to reserve a parking lot about three blocks away for our guests for $250 (that’s $3.00 a car!). It’s an easy stroll, and I figure most people would rather park for free than pay to be a block closer. We have a map on our website and plan on putting up flyers pointing the way through the city, but are heavily relying on common sense here.

 
17.
LatteLove
Hostess
LatteLove (message)  4,094 posts, Honey bee

Would it be more affordable to shuttle your guests to and from the hotel instead of having them pay for parking? It looks so close!

 
18.
Miss French Bulldog
Bee
Miss French Bulldog (message)  6,063 posts, Bee Keeper

If I went to a wedding in the city I would totally understand I would need to pay for parking :) I think you did a great job making finding the best parking for your guests!

 
19.
eileen marie
Member
eileen marie (message)  373 posts, Helper bee

I understand if you can’t afford valet, but we went to a very fancy wedding, and had to pay $20 to park in a garage at the venue downtown! Luckily, parking was included with our venue (normally $20). If you can afford to pay for parking (even lot parking, not valets), I’d do it. If not, guests will understand. I just thought it was weird to pay for parking at such an extravagant affair.

 
20.
Miss Chicken
Member
Miss Chicken (message)  222 posts, Helper bee

Just let them know the cost ahead of time for parking and the cash only business. Paying for parking doesn’t seem odd to me….

We are getting married downtown as well, and there is a parkade close by. We are going to let our guests know about that and the cost, but because our ceremony and reception are at the same location we are going to recommend cabbing or walking becuase many hotels we are suggesting will be very close by. Canada’s capital city can be a tad confusing for out of towners, and I’d hate for people to get lost on one way streets!

 
21.
Bee Icon
Bee
Miss Bruschetta (message)  5,553 posts, Bee Keeper

@LatteLove: Good idea, but we’ll be having a bit of down time between the ceremony (which is about 15 minutes away or so) and the reception, so guests will be free to drive immediately into the city or linger closer to the church…which would make a shuttle from the hotel difficult to coordinate!

 
22.
Bee Icon
Bee
Miss Stiletto (message)  759 posts, Busy bee

I was pretty bummed because in Oak Park there are garages all over that use to be free on the weekends (it was so convenient when I lived there!)…now, they charge a small fee. I don’t think it’s too terrible to suggest that guests either park there and pay for parking, or look for street parking. We’ll see..

 
23.
Jessie516
Hostess
Jessie516 (message)  4,008 posts, Honey bee

We weren’t able to budget for valet service and I worried about our guests finding parking downtown on a college campus. However, thanks to my husband’s detailed parking map and our directions, folks were able to find adequate parking without spending an arm and a leg. I think what you’re providing will work out just fine.

 
24.
Melissabegins
Member
Melissabegins (message)  843 posts, Busy bee

I’m from Philly, and I can sympathize w/ the traffic/parking/etc. That said, I think you are just fine with your plans - I don’t think guests need to be spoon-fed. We are paying for our guests’ transport, but it’s in a foreign country after a flight. The Walt Whitman isn’t that bad ;) and I’m sure that they can be prepared.

 
25.
Sister Bruschetta Dinks
Member
Sister Bruschetta Dinks (message)  18 posts, Newbee

I agree with the girls who’ve said that you should make sure to circulate this information before the wedding day. Ideally, everyone would read it on your website, but realistically, we know that won’t happen. I like the suggestion of informing one person/couple from each “group” of guests (i.e. your family, his immediate family, his extended family, your HS friends, your other friends, his HS friends, his other friends, joint friends, etc.) about the cost of parking in the city (not necessarily ALL the details like exact parking lots recommended and their locations - they can learn about those in your ceremony programs), and asking them to spread the word… if for no other reason, to make sure they have enough cash on them that day!

 
26.
Sister Bruschetta Dinks
Member
Sister Bruschetta Dinks (message)  18 posts, Newbee

Oops - one more thing. Along with informing people ahead of time, you can suggest the idea of carpooling into Philly, or even for the entire wedding day. If four people share a car, it’s less than $4 per person for parking!

 
27.
Member Icon
Member
DollyLava (message)  34 posts, Newbee

@Miss Stiletto:
I’m looking at the same venue and arguing with my mom about parking. My argument is that my city friends would rather pay $6 for parking than $80 for a hotel (which they would opt for if I choose one of the other more suburban venues).
City people are used to this sort of thing!

 
28.
Guest Icon
Guest
CBCDKM

The only advice I have it to confirm the lot is open at the hours/days when guests will be leaving. I was at a wedding in Baltimore where one of the garages mentioned to us for a Saturday night wedding was closed on Sundays! BIG problem for guests trying to drive home if they stayed over in the hotel the night before (and didn’t see the sign at the garage).

 
29.
KatieBug3017
Member
KatieBug3017 (message)  1,418 posts, Bumble bee

I am in agreement with what the others are saying for the most part; I think you are doing what you can with letting everyone know about the parking situation…if you can’t afford valet, then you can’t afford it! I like that you could suggest people can carpool, which will greatly reduce the cost!

@leenie: I think that is also a great point; is there a way to let the older guests who might not be online get a map? I’d want to make sure that they are taken care of!

 
30.
Bee Icon
Bee
Mrs. Snow Pea (message)  473 posts, Helper bee

I think you’ve been more than accommodating and guests will appreciate the notice. As a guest, I would never expect valet, so don’t feel bad about it. Our wedding was in NYC and our reception place didn’t offer valet and the parking garage was 3 city blocks away with a discount. 80% of our guests were from out of town and most of them carpooled or took the train in fact! So I wouldn’t fret. Btw, I LOVE LOVE LOVE that you’ve booked F.U.E.L!!!!!

 


You can also just...

Newer blog post
more in Blog
Older blog post
Newer blog post by Mrs. Bruschetta
more by Mrs. Bruschetta (oldest)
Older blog post by Mrs. Bruschetta
Visit our sister sites Project Wedding
Wedding Songs
eHarmony Advice
Dating Advice
JustMommies
Pregnancy Calendar
Fertile Thoughts
Infertility Support
Copyright 2004-2009, eHarmony, Inc., Advertise
 


Sponsors
Mrs. Bruschetta
Mrs. Bruschetta Mrs. Bruschetta, Philadelphia Age and Occupation: 25, Communication Professional Fiance's Age and Occupation: 25, Physical Therapy Graduate Student Engagement Date: November 30, 2007 Wedding Date: August 2009 Venue: St. Thomas of Villanova Church & the F.U.E.L. House About Me: I’m a self-proclaimed grammar geek who loves singing (like, really belting it) in the car. My mister and I are planning a vibrant summer soiree celebrating our passions – including food and Philly – and when we make it official, we’ll have been together for eight years! Being super competitive is in my nature, and talking excessively is in my genes. I’ve got a terrible sense of direction, but can always easily find my way into Mr. Bruschetta’s arms.
Weddingbee PRO
 
Boards
 
Classifieds
 

Blog Calendar
November 2009
SunMonTueWedThuFriSat
1234567
891011121314
15161718192021
22232425262728
2930

Weddingbee Bios
Wiki
More