Register or log in —

Newer blog post
more in Blog
Older blog post
Newer blog post by Ms Potato Chips
more by Ms Potato Chips (oldest)
Older blog post by Ms Potato Chips
Ms Potato Chips's Picture
Ms. Potato Chips, Boston/Narragansett RI Age and Occupation: 29, PhD Student Fiance's Age and Occupation: 30, Personal Trainer/Business Owner/Physical Therapy Assistant Engagement Date: January 1, 2009 Wedding Date: June 2010 Venue: The Narragansett Towers About Me: A semi-professional bookworm, if I could be a literary character I’d be a cross between Jo March and Jane Eyre, only better accessorized and much lazier. My hobbies include sleeping in, seasonal brews, running, Trader Joe’s, and watching Unwrapped and Good Eats with Mr. Potato Chips. I harbor an irrational fear of tulle, crafts, things that are fussy, and overuse of the phrase "Your Special Day". After a year or seven together, down the aisle we go, slouching toward adulthood and planning a Rhodie party with equal parts whimsy, cheer, and pizza.
About Ms Potato Chips

Plain Jane

October 2nd, 2009 @ 4:14 pm by Ms Potato Chips

I read Jane Eyre for the first time on the subway, during a two-week temp job at a law office. The work was tedious; as a recent college graduate my expectations were optimistic, but the job market was not. So for two weeks I commuted into the city and photocopied my days away. I picked up Jane Eyre because it was a classic I hadn’t read. I craved a literary tome to get me through my day as an errand-runner and toner-replacer. I appreciated its heft, its bulk, its heaviness in subject, bringing me back to a familiar place I hadn’t been able to access since my English department seminar days, a place that seemed distant and imaginary in this resume-sending, business-suit-wearing, serious world. I needed Jane and her sassiness, her quiet confidence, her stubbornness. When I finished my two week stint, so too did I finish the novel.

But not really. I didn’t stay in the corporate world for long, but I return to Jane at least once a year. I even have an e-text version on my iPod Touch so I can grab a virtual-page or two while waiting for an appointment or in a long line. I settle into the text and always find something new and something familiar.

What’s this got to do with weddings?

You may recall a scene when Jane and Mr. Rochester are first affianced. He wants to take her in his carriage and dress her up with the finest new gowns, baubles, jewels. She refuses, insisting on being married just as she is, in her clean, tidy, plain muslin dress.

As a 22-year-old reading the novel for the first time, I thought, “Jane! Girl! Get with it! Take the silk dupioni! Some new necklaces! What’s wrong with a little dress-up? Why not?” That was my gut reaction every time I read that part of the novel. Until recently.

Thumbing through magazines and sifting through websites, I tried to figure out what gowns might suit me, what I could picture myself wearing. I love clothes, I love fashion, and I love putting on bright colors, unexpected hues, pairing preppy with funky… but I couldn’t picture myself in a ball gown. I’m too small! My body too short and curvy! My style, too relaxed. I anticipated feeling a lot like Jane, like a little girl playing dress-up who pines for the familiarity of a plain dress, something that is “her”, something that is “me”.

Is it any wonder that I’m drawn toward dresses like this, all V-neck and pockets and simplicity?

http://www.weddingbee.com/

“Lindsey” by Vineyard, Priscilla of Boston

So despite all the blingy blinginess showcased on “Say Yes to the Dress” and “Platinum Brides”, and worn beautifully and elegantly by many friends, I figured I’d side with Jane and keep it simple. Plain? Maybe. But if it’s good enough for Jane, it’s good enough for me.

But then, THEN. There was a game-changer. A pretty big game-changer.

Did you consider a fancy bridal dress, while longing for something simpler?

Tags: |   Link for this post | Share this post: Plain Jane      
Newer blog post
more in Blog
Older blog post
Newer blog post by Ms Potato Chips
more by Ms Potato Chips (oldest)
Older blog post by Ms Potato Chips
advertisement below

38 Responses to “Plain Jane”

1.
Member Icon
Member
Kalibali (message)  242 posts, Helper bee

Yes! I just want a simple plain one, but am drawn to lace and beading, sigh!

 
2.
TravelBug
Member
TravelBug (message)  64 posts, Worker bee

I was all for that gorgeous simplicity… until I put on the ivory stunner with all-over lace and a gorgeous cutout in the back!

I am in love with Brit lit… Jane Eyre is a favorite but I am mostly guilty of being a Pride and Prejudice obsessor. I have a total girl-crush on Elizabeth Bennett. It was one of the first books I put on the Sony Reader my fiance bought me for Christmas and I’ll never take it off :)

 
3.
Guest Icon
Guest
Miss bliss

You know I think that the elegance of plain can be even more stunning than the sparkle and glitz of a glimmer gown. But on the other hand some glimmer and glitz can be stunning too! It will be fun to see your game changer!

 
4.
Mrs. French Bulldog
Bee
Mrs. French Bulldog (message)  6,078 posts, Bee Keeper

Don’t get me wrong, I LOVED my dress, but If I were to do it again I would definitely have tried on more, simpler dresses. I LOVE everything I saw Priscilla of Boston, I wish I had tried to find one pre-owned ;)

 
5.
tea
Member
tea (message)  2,681 posts, Sugar bee

i want a little something with a somewhat simple design. nothing too blingy.

 
6.
HugsKissesLadyBugsBride
Member
HugsKissesLadyBugsBride (message)  311 posts, Helper bee

You are quickly becoming one of my favorite bees!!!! :)
I think you can think you want a certain kind of dress, but when you go to try them on and try on one that might not be exactly what you *thought* you wanted, you end up finding the dress that was meant for you!

 
7.
Brianalaura
Member
Brianalaura (message)  319 posts, Helper bee

I went with a simple dress. It’s definitely more my style, and our wedding is going to be an outdoor, backyard one, so I didn’t want something too formal. Here it is on someone else:

http://www.thebridescafe.com/index.cfm?q=eriko

 
8.
Member Icon
Member
Kay7 (message)  33 posts, Newbee

You know Ms. Chips I went into my dress-hunting experience wanting something pretty simple and ultimately ended up with a dress with no lace, sparkles, pearls or pouf… But I have to admit there were moments in my search when I was all decked out in these beautiful, poufy statement-making gowns where I paused and thought “Well maybe… this is such a gorgeous dress…”

It’s hard when you try on such beautiful gowns… but the choice I ultimately made felt like me so it was right…

Man it was fun playing dress-up for awhile though…

 
9.
Laylabelle
Member
Laylabelle (message)  1,957 posts, Buzzing bee

Yes!!! I wanted plain, simple, classic - NOT BRIDAL.

Totally didn’t happen. Ended up with a very bridal gown. And am thrilled!

 
10.
Member Icon
Member
slicey19 (message)  818 posts, Busy bee

Yes! I totally know what you are talking about. I thought I wanted simple and I bought a dress with a long train and beading. Sometimes, I guess, we don’t know what we really want.

 
11.
Miss_Carmel
Member
Miss_Carmel (message)  317 posts, Helper bee

Oohhh….I’ve haven’t gone dress shopping yet (our wedding is in May 2010). I’m excited to hear about this plot twist!

 
12.
ke3
Member
ke3 (message)  248 posts, Helper bee

yes! i love simple dresses! if i could have spent more on a dress, i would have loved to buy a vineyard collection dress! :)

 
13.
Bee Icon
Bee
Miss Star (message)  1,295 posts, Bumble bee

I also love Jane :)

But I’m not that much like her, haha.

Can’t wait to see your dress!

 
14.
Bee Icon
Bee
Miss Dachshund (message)  488 posts, Helper bee

I’m drawn toward simple, too. I haven’t chosen my dress yet, or even started shopping yet (eeek, 8 months out!), but I know I’ll end up with something simple and pretty : )

 
15.
LatteLove
Hostess
LatteLove (message)  4,154 posts, Honey bee

i longed for, and went with something pretty simple and loved it!

 
16.
Bee Icon
Bee
Ms Potato Chips (message)  328 posts, Helper bee

I definitely agree with those who noted that what one ends up with is many times completely different than what she envisioned! Stay tuned for my game-changer…it’s a biggie.

 
17.
MexicanGirl
Member
MexicanGirl (message)  644 posts, Busy bee

i chose a simple dress, A-line, but not a ball gown, with minimal beading and i loved it!

 
18.
Bee Icon
Bee
Miss Parfait (message)  626 posts, Busy bee

Plain, sparkly, full, and slender…I like ‘em all. It’s a problem. I love that the dress you pictured has pockets. :)

 
19.
Bee Icon
Bee
Miss Ramen (message)  264 posts, Helper bee

i thought i was gonna be super simple. then i ended up with my lace beast. in all, it’s still pretty simple (no bling), just more poofy/fitted then i had originally anticipated.

 
20.
Bee Icon
Bee
Mrs. Quiche (message)  2,190 posts, Buzzing bee

Jane Eyre is one of my all-time favorite books! :)

I always wanted a simpler gown & that’s what I ended up with! I love my dress!

 
21.
Guest Icon
Guest
Turtle

Dude. awesome post. great to have a new bookworm in the hive.

 
22.
Guest Icon
Guest
Mareeyah

Hey, I’m reading Jane Eyre while train-traveling for more than a week now, so your post really caught my attention. Dear sensible Jane would really rather be plain and ordinary, even if she inherited a fortune to afford herself to dress as glamorously as Miss Ingram.

As I am a bride-to-be myself, I would prefer simplicity but with a very good amount of merrymaking. However, my “Mr. Rochester-like” clan prefer otherwise, so I have to submit myself to the complexity of a luxurious party and a Scarlet O’Hara ballgown. Too bad, I’m not as stubborn as Jane.

 
23.
Member Icon
Member
jhguba (message)  239 posts, Helper bee

Love Jane Eyre, and like you I have always thought that when she turns down the baubles offered by Rochester! Interesting analysis, Miss PC!

 
24.
Bee Icon
Bee
Miss Lamb (message)  488 posts, Helper bee

Ah, P. Chips - I love your literary inspiration.

 
25.
Bee Icon
Bee
Mrs. Mouse (message)  3,378 posts, Sugar bee

Ah, Jane Eyre. Maybe it’s time for a re-read. I can’t wait to see what your “game changer” was!

 
26.
bridgetjones2010
Member
bridgetjones2010 (message)  52 posts, Worker bee

Really enjoying your posts. I feared that you were going to recount the scene when Bertha rips up Jane’s wedding dress…or was it her veil? Thank goodness that’s not the case. Looking forward to seeing how your dress search turned out. I went into my search wanting nothing but lace and ended up with a “plain Jane” dress that I love.

 
27.
Jessie516
Hostess
Jessie516 (message)  4,073 posts, Honey bee

I thought I wanted something totally plain–no beading or lace and NOT strapless. I got–you guessed it, lace, beading AND strapless. It was weird because I would have never even looked twice at my dress on the hanger, but as soon as I saw it on, I kinda loved it.

 
28.
lcneiny
Member
lcneiny (message)  170 posts, Blushing bee

In real life, I’m pretty plain - no stripes, no patterns, barely any colors other than black, gray, khaki, white, brown. So I assumed my dress would also be plain…and I suppose it is, in comparison to the decked out dresses in the glossy magazines. But it’s got a gorgeous line of beading around the neckline and down the back, which is totally not me, and yet SO me the minute I put it on. Funny how things work out!

 
29.
Bee Icon
Bee
Miss Moonbeam (message)  1,336 posts, Bumble bee

Had a totally different dress in mind at first, but now I’m so in love with my dress path. Can’t wait to see what the game changer was.

 
30.
ColorCoated
Member
ColorCoated (message)  951 posts, Busy bee

I can’t wait to see what you picked.

 
31.
Bee Icon
Bee
Miss Labrador (message)  1,325 posts, Bumble bee

Oooo, that dress is purdy! Can’t wait to see your final choice!

 
32.
Bee Icon
Bee
Mrs. Bruschetta (message)  5,553 posts, Bee Keeper

I love PoB styles, and was definitely drawn to simpler styles, with fun fabric details. Can’t wait to read the next chapter of your dress saga!

 
33.
alishaneva
Member
alishaneva (message)  1,532 posts, Bumble bee

game changer, eh? This could get interesting! Can’t wait to see what you chose - though I do love that dress - how fun are the pockets?

 
34.
Guest Icon
Guest
Suz

I thought I wanted a simple dress with beautiful layering of fabric. Boy, was I wrong. I’m drawn to beading and lace and especially want it highlighting with a sweetheart neckline and lace at the bottom, like the Melissa Sweet dress Aurora that I totally love and totally can’t afford, even used!

 
35.
fiftyfootbride
Member
fiftyfootbride (message)  3,819 posts, Honey bee

That’s one of my favorite books. *sigh*

I thought I wanted a very simple, structured dress, but ended up with a big ol’ polka-dotted-organza ballgown.

 
36.
smepsi
Member
smepsi (message)  77 posts, Worker bee

you completely just made me want to read that book. I too miss the days of english lit and critical thinking - ‘closed door’ budget meetings and countless work emails can never give you the same feeling.

my dress will be relatively simple, but with a great twist. i’m going with a wai-ching, and while the dress is pretty simple, her signature stitching is just enough detail for me. i can’t wait to see it. =)

 
37.
Guest Icon
Guest
Jubille

Plain dresses or what ever dress it would be. I know we want to celebrate it simply but elegant but your towing out the picture out of it. Just be happy. But I really do prefer simpler ones for I want myself to be notice not the dress..:)

 
38.
Guest Icon
Guest
Kyle H. Porter

Rochester bandThis is really to plain for me.Maybe you should have simple but elegant wedding dress. this dress is lame..

 


You can also just...

Newer blog post
more in Blog
Older blog post
Newer blog post by Ms Potato Chips
more by Ms Potato Chips (oldest)
Older blog post by Ms Potato Chips
Visit our sister sites Project Wedding
Wedding Songs
eHarmony Advice
Dating Advice
JustMommies
Pregnancy Calendar
Fertile Thoughts
Infertility Support
Copyright 2004-2009, eHarmony, Inc., Advertise
 


Sponsors
Ms Potato Chips
Ms Potato Chips Ms. Potato Chips, Boston/Narragansett RI Age and Occupation: 29, PhD Student Fiance's Age and Occupation: 30, Personal Trainer/Business Owner/Physical Therapy Assistant Engagement Date: January 1, 2009 Wedding Date: June 2010 Venue: The Narragansett Towers About Me: A semi-professional bookworm, if I could be a literary character I’d be a cross between Jo March and Jane Eyre, only better accessorized and much lazier. My hobbies include sleeping in, seasonal brews, running, Trader Joe’s, and watching Unwrapped and Good Eats with Mr. Potato Chips. I harbor an irrational fear of tulle, crafts, things that are fussy, and overuse of the phrase "Your Special Day". After a year or seven together, down the aisle we go, slouching toward adulthood and planning a Rhodie party with equal parts whimsy, cheer, and pizza.
Weddingbee PRO
 
Boards
 
Classifieds
 

Blog Calendar
November 2009
SunMonTueWedThuFriSat
1234567
891011121314
15161718192021
22232425262728
2930

Weddingbee Bios
Wiki
More