Newer blog post
more in Blog
Older blog post
Newer blog post by Mrs. Pencils
more by Mrs. Pencils (oldest)
Older blog post by Mrs. Pencils
Mrs. Pencils's Picture
Mrs. Pencils, Washington DC/Frederick, MD Age and Occupation: 24, Program Director, Education Non Profit Fiance's Age and Occupation: 24, Administrative Assistant, Ocean Conservation Non Profit Engagement Date: July 26, 2008 Wedding Date: May 2010 Venue: Morningside Inn About Me: I'm a nerdy Northwestern girl who always knew she was meant to live in the East, harboring a deep love of ice cream, underwear, Diet Coke with a splash of Coca-Cola, pashminas, scrapbooking, stationery, wall calendars and books written for preteens. I think every day should include good thin crust pizza, chocolate, an obscure historical monument, lots of laughter, a dash of wedding planning and, of course, amazing Mr. Pencils! I'm loving the adventure of planning a Maryland wedding and Rocky Mountain reception, and most of all, I just love love!
About Mrs. Pencils

One Opinion on an Oft-Discussed Change :  wedding legal Photo103 Photo+103

In about 100 days, I will need new credit cards, a new driver’s license, and a new social security card.

There are hundreds of opinions and thousands of women who have weighed in on the discussion of a person changing their name when they get married. My voice is simply one among these, but I feel compelled to share my reasons to change my name to my fiance’s when we get married. Perhaps I should be psycho-analyzing myself for why I feel compelled… but I do. Anyway.

A few weeks ago, I asked Mr. Pencils if he thought it was strange that I was going to change my name to his. His answer? “No…I mean, well, kinda. You mean, because you’re such a feminist?”

Yep. That’s exactly what I meant.

In college, I interned with a large political action committee. The organization, and women I worked with, were the essence of my beliefs. My supervisor was my girl crush—I just thought she was the bee’s knees (haha). One day in passing, my boss commented on how she disapproved of how a co-worker that was getting married would be changing her last name once married. I tucked this opinion in my back pocket and I am reminded of it every single time the name change debate arises.

For five years, I’ve digested her opinion, considered it, felt awful over it, and finally, come to terms with it. I’ve decided:

I am a feminist, and I going to change my name.

I am not selling out to “the man”, bowing down the patriarchal expectations of our society, nor am I doing this because Mr. Pencils wants me to. I want to, and as a feminist, I am making the CHOICE. And to me, that’s what true feminism and gender equality is: humans having the freedom to choose whatever they want in terms of career, love, sex, family planning, and, yes, which age-old traditions to embrace and which to discard.

I have never been overly attached to my name. I think Mama Pencils is the same way. It’s not that I don’t like my name—it’s simply quite common, and I’m used to looking up to the sound of it in crowds for my entire life. I have always believed my last name has a “harsh” tone to it, and I truly disliked being called by my last name during the duration of my soccer years.

There is one very large reason I want to change my name and it has everything to do with connection and attachment. Mr. Pencils’ father died ten years ago, and I was not blessed enough to know him before he passed. I have learned so much about him, through Mr. P’s stories, his family, and even Mr. P’s traits and actions. When Mr. Pencils and I become part of each other’s families, in law and in name, I will also be a part of his father’s family. I will be connected to this amazing man that I never got to meet. This connection means more to me than anything anyone could say against a woman changing her name. I, with Mr. P, will carry his father’s name through our family and our children. And that’s pretty frickin’ awesome.

Do you have one particular reason for changing or keeping your name?

Tags: legal |
advertisement below
Newer blog post
more in Blog
Older blog post
Newer blog post by Mrs. Pencils
more by Mrs. Pencils (oldest)
Older blog post by Mrs. Pencils

56 Responses to “One Opinion on an Oft-Discussed Change”

1 2 3 

1.
Member Icon
Member
bean5678 (message)  52 posts, Worker bee

I’ve always liked being part of the “Bean” family, and I want my future children to have the experience of all of us under the same team name. Plus, my FI is the last boy in his family left to carry on the name, so its important to him for me to take his name. Knowing how much it means to him, I can’t imagine doing anything else…

 
2.
Bee Icon
Bee
Miss Spaniel (message)  6,792 posts, Bee Keeper

I was conflicted about changing my name, but I’ve finally accepted it (for now). I still bristle when people react to my decision as if it weren’t a choice at all, though–as if I *had* no other choice. No one’s criticized me yet for doing it, but I might deck them if they did.

 
3.
Gilneas
Member
Gilneas (message)  1,393 posts, Bumble bee

I agree. Part of being a feminist is that of gender equality - that being, if you want to change your last name, you can!

 
4.
BrianneG
Member
BrianneG (message)  940 posts, Busy bee

I can’t wait to change my name. Neither of my last names have had much positive meaning for me: (1) the biological father that left my mother before I was born and (2) the former stepfather than adopted me when I was 10 and that I stopped speaking to the day I turned 18. Becoming part of my fiance’s family is wonderful.

I seem to be in the minority of my friends getting married this year. I don’t mind changing my name professionally or getting a new engineering stamp.

 
5.
Member Icon
Member
Violachap (message)  677 posts, Busy bee

I never felt attached to my maiden name, and I never gave much thought to changing my name other than the fact that I’m going to do it. Now I’m faced with conflict over whether to drop my maiden name completely or drop my middle name. I love my middle name (Marie) and I don’t want to drop it, but then I’d definitely have to drop my maiden. Choices choices! @bean5678: my FI is also the last boy in his family, and we will be carrying his last name on into the next generation through our children.

 
6.
Miss French Fries
Bee
Miss French Fries (message)  2,218 posts, Buzzing bee

I’m changing mine, too — I just wanted to say that the picture of you in this post is too cute! :)

 
7.
Goldilocks1107
Member
Goldilocks1107 (message)  2,602 posts, Sugar bee

I completely agree with you! I’m changing my name because I can, because it symbolizes me and FH becoming our own family, and because I will move up in the alphabet and have a last name that people can pronounce.
But, I completely get those who don’t want to change their last name. What I don’t get is those who judge others for their choices - I’m okay with you being you, all I ask is that you’re okay with me being me.

 
8.
Valhalla
Member
Valhalla (message)  1,425 posts, Bumble bee

Fantastic post! While I have elected not to change my last name, I think you highlighted that one can be a feminist and still CHOOSE to do so. Because feminism is simply about having choices. The same goes for any historically oppressed group - when they are finally given choices, that equals power.

 
9.
Danish_Student
Member
Danish_Student (message)  396 posts, Helper bee

I’m in the exact same boat as you. My family isn’t taking it so well though - they don’t quite understand our wanting to share lastnames. We’ll both be First Mymiddle Hislast.

 
10.
moderndaisy
Member
moderndaisy (message)  6,703 posts, Bee Keeper

I’m totally changing my name. I am embracing the whole idea of us becoming a family unit, kids or not, and therefore needing to have the same last name. I understand why women do not change their names. This is just my preference for us.

 
11.
LittleSpitfire
Member
LittleSpitfire (message)  288 posts, Helper bee

I’m a feminist and I’m changing my name too! To me, it symbolizes me becoming a part of FI’s family, and, frankly, it is really important to him. He’d just have to live with it if I wanted to keep my name, but our relationship is so very well balanced that it means something to me to do this, in part, for him. I hope that makes sense.

 
12.
whitesonnet
Member
whitesonnet (message)  1,345 posts, Bumble bee

Here Here!! Feminism is all about having the choice, whether I want to be a childless career-woman or an overworked stay-at-home mom, it will be my choice.

And even my own step-mother has asked if I was going to change my name because I’m liberal. I love stereotypes. I plan on “upgrading” my name as soon as possible!

 
13.
Ms. Library
Member
Ms. Library (message)  1,251 posts, Bumble bee

Someone who shares my thoughts! Mr. Library came out with the same comment and was feeling a little iffy about me changing it, but I know that I want to. It’s my name and I can change it if I want to! :-P

 
14.
Entangled
Member
Entangled (message)  2,616 posts, Sugar bee

OK, someone has to be the first to admit it. I am kind of uncomfortable with name changes. Not in an upset with other people who choose to, but in that it’s so far from ever being a consideration for me that it is a little weird that other people do it. I do think I feel like, yes, it’s a choice and it’s great that we as women have that choice. But at the same time, if a couple wants a shared last name, it’s usually the woman who changes hers. I’d be a lot happier if it was seen as an accepted choice for both men and women.

What really makes me uncomfortable is the idea of being expected to change my name. Very decisive do not want here. I can understand people not having a strong attachment to their last name and I can understand people even actively wanting to adopt a new one. I am very attached to my name and my family, and sometimes it’s hard to divorce that from other people’s decisions. It really is someone’s choice and I don’t judge people for the ones they make in their situations. In fact, I think women being very judgmental of other women’s choices is one of the great enemies of feminism. I just wish the breakdown of who made which decision was a little more gender-equal.

 
15.
des_salazar
Member
des_salazar (message)  280 posts, Helper bee

I also consider myself a feminist and will be changing my name. Legally, I will be referred to as my FI’s name but for professional reason I will be keeping my name. I love my maiden name and will keep it alive by changing my middle name. The best of both worlds.

 
16.
Member Icon
Member
kmgaribaldi (message)  16 posts, Newbee

I am also a feminist, and I am also changing my name. I see it as becoming part of my fiance’s family and creating a more cohesive family unit for our eventual-children.

In addition to me changing my name, my fiance is going to be changing his as well. He is going to take my last name as his middle name - so both of us will match. I thought that this was such a great idea, because its both of us taking a step to become a part of each other’s family, not just one person taking the leap.

When I first proposed the mutual change to my fiance, he was a little thrown off balance. He said that the idea itself was great, but that so many years of social conditioning were hard to overcome. But he realized that his only objection was based in societal expectations that “real men” don’t change their names for their women. Now he’s made the decision and told his family (who loved the idea) and mine (who were also thrilled, if also a little surprised).

 
17.
Bee Icon
Bee
Miss Pencils (message)  1,027 posts, Bumble bee

@bean5678: that’s very sweet. I am glad you are happy with this decision!
@Miss Spaniel: Lol, I’ll hit ‘em too :)
@Gilneas: hear hear! :)
@BrianneG: I think both of your reasons make complete sense for your situation!
@Violachap: Can you keep both middle names?
@Miss French Fries: haha, thanks. taken during a late night thesis writing session senior year of college. oh the days. I thought Rosie the Riveter was appropriate!
@Goldilocks1107: I agree that judgement needs to disappear for such a personal choice.
@Valhalla:agreed! I work in education as well, and find that choice is a huge part of equality there too.
@Danish_Student: I like the compromise you’ve worked out- that sounds great!
@moderndaisy:agreed. I do look forward to the day however, when it’s a conversation about WHO’s name will actually change, instead of assumptive that it will be woman!!
@LittleSpitfire: I like it! My name change didn’t come from Mr. P’s thoughts- though I think he is incredibly touched by my reason for doing so.
@whitesonnet:haha, the perfect way to describe it! some days working from home with my children around me sounds quite nice!
@Ms. Library: agreed, as long as it’s your choice!
@Entangled: I 100% agree with you. I think the fact that it is usually the woman who has the CHOICE to make allows us to really talk about the fact that gender equality (among a mass of other types of equalities) still does not truly exist. I agree that it is a personal choice, and that whichever choice is made should be accepted.
@des_salazar: that’s such a great solution! awesome!

 
18.
Member Icon
Member
missvintage (message)  571 posts, Busy bee

I agree whole heartedly with you. I was on the fence for a long time, for the same reasons. I like to consider myself a feminist, I don’t want to think of it as “giving up” my identity or my former last name. The boy has “no opinion whatsoever” about it. Seriously, he just wants me to do what I want. I’m not very attached to my last name, and actually, don’t have a relationship with anyone that shares that last name anymore. But for some reason, I’m still thinking of taking my current last name as a second middle name, so that I can go by both if necessary. I have no idea why!

 
19.
Member Icon
Member
Professor (message)  422 posts, Helper bee

Great post. Pencils, I teach feminist theory and law. This (and my own experiences) have led me to the conclusion that I understand feminism to support a woman getting to make her own choice about what is right for her and not having it dictated to her by the state or because society says she has to or should. Your choice to change a name deserves as much respect as mine not to. Because I think what we need to value is the ability to have and exercise our choices and desires. [steps down off of soapbox]

 
20.
worcesterbride
Member
worcesterbride (message)  603 posts, Busy bee

Good for you, Miss pencils! I totally agree about choice. I also agree with Entangled that it’s a problem that it’s still usually the woman who changes her name, if anyone does.

Having watched a couple go through the guy changing his name to the wife’s name, I knew it wasn’t remotely an option for WorcesterGroom and me. The legal system is still not set up for it, and the time, expense, and humiliation this guy went through to take a stand for feminism was admirable, but not something WG would’ve been able to do - he would’ve had to take so many days off of work! I decided that I would change my name, and like Miss Spaniel, I get really angry when people assume it’s the only way - my in-laws in particular! I make a point of talking about it as a “choice” I made.

There’s also flack on the other side - my grad school has a lot of old-school feminist professors, and I admire them but they’re definitely of the mind that feminism means keeping your name and working full-time. I try to remind them when I can that you can’t get out of a patriarchal system by keeping your dad’s name instead of taking your husband’s!

 
1 2 3 

Leave a Reply


You can also just...

Newer blog post
more in Blog
Older blog post
Newer blog post by Mrs. Pencils
more by Mrs. Pencils (oldest)
Older blog post by Mrs. Pencils

Visit our sister sites eHarmony
Online Dating
eHarmony Advice
Dating Advice
Project Wedding
Wedding Songs
JustMommies
Pregnancy Calendar

Copyright 2004-2012, Weddingbee.com
 

Find your vendors on Weddingbee

Real reviews from brides in your area!

Favors by Weddingbee

  • Favors by season

Shop Now »

Mrs. Pencils
Mrs. Pencils

Mrs. Pencils, Washington DC/Frederick, MD Age and Occupation: 24, Program Director, Education Non Profit Fiance's Age and Occupation: 24, Administrative Assistant, Ocean Conservation Non Profit Engagement Date: July 26, 2008 Wedding Date: May 2010 Venue: Morningside Inn About Me: I'm a nerdy Northwestern girl who always knew she was meant to live in the East, harboring a deep love of ice cream, underwear, Diet Coke with a splash of Coca-Cola, pashminas, scrapbooking, stationery, wall calendars and books written for preteens. I think every day should include good thin crust pizza, chocolate, an obscure historical monument, lots of laughter, a dash of wedding planning and, of course, amazing Mr. Pencils! I'm loving the adventure of planning a Maryland wedding and Rocky Mountain reception, and most of all, I just love love!

Boards
Classifieds

Blog Calendar
February 2012
SunMonTueWedThuFriSat
2930311234
567891011
12131415161718
19202122232425
26272829

Weddingbee Bios
by machop93
by IsaiahFountain
by greencl3
by ymaldonado
Wiki
More