Newer blog post
more in Blog
Older blog post
Newer blog post by Mrs. Veggie
more by Mrs. Veggie (oldest)
Older blog post by Mrs. Veggie
Mrs. Veggie's Picture
Mrs. Veggie, Raglan, New Zealand/Scranton, PA Age and Occupation: 27, Director of Small Non-Profit Fiance's Age and Occupation: 42, PhD Student & Farmer Engagement Date: June 13, 2009 Wedding Date: August 2010 Venue: Indian Head Camp, Honesdale Pennsylvania About Me: I am a tree-huggin' farmer turned enthusiastic wedding-planner. I live in a house truck and wear flip-flops more often than shoes. In my old life I was a high school Spanish teacher in love with a crazy guy who lived off-the grid on a farm in New Hampshire. But, we decided to mix things up a bit, quit our jobs and move to New Zealand. My southern hemisphere lifestyle involves growing veggies, teaching, running our small non-profit, and surfing. I love laughing, singing, playing, and the inspirational Mr. Veggie (of course!). For our wedding, I am committed to throwing a killer party that celebrates our values without breaking the bank. Look forward to an eco-thrifty summer-campy weekend-long extravaganza.
About Mrs. Veggie

Pho-to Pho’-Sho’

April 3rd, 2010 @ 4:50 pm by Mrs. Veggie

Remember the internal struggle that was my dress-shopping experience? Well hiring (or not hiring) a photographer was even worse. Let me set the scene for you:

We have several amateur photographers coming to the wedding as guests, and SIL Veggie is a professional photographer. We’re trying to keep our budget as low as possible, and literally every cent we don’t spend on the wedding goes straight to the non-profit organization we run.

Also, a brief confessional here: I am a photography snob. After looking at many wedding photography websites, I have come to the realization that the cheaper photographers don’t do much better than I do when I go to weddings. If we are going to pay someone to take photos, we definitely want the photos to be great, not just ho-hum. So it seems like we are left with two choices:

Pho-to Pho'-Sho' :  wedding photography scranton Screen028 Screen+028

Source

Either spend quite a bit and get someone great.

OR

Spend nothing and get what we get from our guests.

Pho-to Pho'-Sho' :  wedding photography scranton Mytwink mytwink

Source

I looked at many many many photographers’ websites and made a spreadsheet that classified them by price, package details, and how much I loved them (ranging from eh… to LOVE!!). I was hoping that I would find someone that I was in love with that had reasonable prices. But the major problem was, I didn’t really have a good idea what “reasonable” was to me. I think I was hoping that some magical photographer would surface that was willing to do our wedding for nearly free, just based on the fact that we were such a charming couple. Right.

I was torn. I asked my friends, I asked my family (including SIL photographer), I polled everyone I could think of. About 99% of the people I asked (again, including SIL photographer) said, “Hire a photographer.” Their reasons were well-rationalized and well-stated. But I still wasn’t sure.

So I browsed more photography websites, asked more people, and finally sat down with Mr. Veg.

I verbalized the reasons why I thought it was important to have a photographer: I want nice pictures of our day, I don’t want any of our guests to stress over taking great pictures, I don’t want to regret not getting certain pics, and finally, I love good photography.

I verbalized the reasons why I thought we didn’t need a photographer: saving money, our talented friends will get lots of good pics, and how many pics of our day do we need, anyway?

He verbalized his concerns that photography would be the first of many splurges and that our budget would grow exponentially as our planning progressed. And then he said if it was really important to me, I should decide how much I was willing to spend on it, and what other things would get the ax.

We looked at our overall budget, and armed with my trusty spreadsheet we decided on a number that we felt was reasonable. I decided that I would contact all of the photographers in the “LOVE!!” category, tell them about us, tell them about what we were looking for, and ask if they could make something work within our budget. I set a firm number that I didn’t want to go above. If no one could give us what we wanted within our budget, we would forgo photography (gasp!).

But guess, what? Someone could! Someone would! Someone will! We have a photographer! (Well actually a team of two photographers). And they are fantastic!! Oh, you want a sample of their work, well read on, or check out Miss Snow’s engagement pictures. Yep, we have the same groovy photographers!

Pho-to Pho'-Sho' :  wedding photography scranton Screen029 Screen+029

Pho-to Pho'-Sho' :  wedding photography scranton Screen030 Screen+030

Pho-to Pho'-Sho' :  wedding photography scranton Screen031 Screen+031

Above Photos by Oh Darling! Photography

I feel really good about this decision. At first I felt like I was wasting money and self-indulging. I felt really guilty for spending that much money on something Mr. Veg was ambivalent about. But now, I feel differently. I feel like I made a really thoughtful, not-impulsive decision over something I was really excited about and normally would have jumped right into. I feel like I’ve done a good job of researching options, prioritizing, and expressing myself to Mr. Veg. Am I justifying a costly decision? Maybe.

How did you come up with a budget for your photographer?

Tags: photography, scranton |
advertisement below
Newer blog post
more in Blog
Older blog post
Newer blog post by Mrs. Veggie
more by Mrs. Veggie (oldest)
Older blog post by Mrs. Veggie

28 Responses to “Pho-to Pho’-Sho’”

1 2 

1.
jordynrose
Member
jordynrose (message)  6,351 posts, Bee Keeper

I am a bit of a photography snob myself. I found a photographer I loved that was reasonable based on what she offered/how she compared to other photographers and just went with it. I want to remember our wedding day exactly how it happened, and our photographer is great at capturing this.

 
2.
Member Icon
Member
hindsightbride (message)  8 posts, Newbee

Good choice Miss Veggie! As a bride who ended up crying for month after getting back her amateur pictures, I have been on a quest to educate other brides about the importance of this one splurge.

I can;t wait to see your beautiful photos!

 
3.
Bee Icon
Bee
Mrs. Spaniel (message)  6,792 posts, Bee Keeper

I think you made the right choice. :)

 
4.
Bee Icon
Bee
Miss Snow (message)  916 posts, Busy bee

OMG! Yay! That’s so exciting!! Aren’t they the best?

 
5.
CorgiTales
Member
CorgiTales (message)  9,861 posts, Bee Keeper

I had a basic level of photographic talent I wasn’t willing to do without and I figured out if we could afford it. Then I found the very best photog in that range that we could afford, and I booked her :)

 
6.
Member Icon
Member
tweds (message)  448 posts, Helper bee

Cosigning Corgi, above.

Your first photo was actually taken by who I ended up hiring. ;) After hearing bride after bride say that the day flies by, pictures (+/- video) are all you have when its over, etc and remembering that I LOVED my mother’s wedding photos as a child, I found out his fees, took a deep breath and then signed the contract. Then I worked everything else around him.

 
7.
Miss Cali Girl in NJ
Member
Miss Cali Girl in NJ (message)  147 posts, Blushing bee

I am going with the non-professional photographer and I am a bit nervous about it. But I couldnt rationalize spending the money. We have a number of semi-pros on the guest list and one stepped up and said she would like to try to do it. So she is dedicated to taking images of the event. But will they be fuzzy, ho hum and a burn? We will see!!! I do wish I had a bit more $$$ so she would be a back up photographer but nope!!

 
8.
Bee Icon
Bee
Miss Veggie (message)  231 posts, Helper bee

@ Miss Cali- Good for you! I wish I had enough faith to just go for it. I’m sure your photos will turn out awesome!

 
9.
Miss Shoe
Member
Miss Shoe (message)  105 posts, Blushing bee

Great decision! Quality photography was #1 on my list of vendors. It’s a way to see what you missed in the hectic rush of the day, as well as a way to relive some of the emotional moments you shared with those closest to you. I’m sure Mr. Veggie won’t be so ambivalent once the whole thing is over and you have some kick ass images that remind you of your day and all that you were feeling.

 
10.
tea
Member
tea (message)  7,288 posts, Bee Keeper

i say you made the right choice, and not so much rationalizing it, but you stated the pros & cons truthfully and made it work within your budget without losing sight of that. so kudus to you for making it work!

 
11.
cecullaton
Member
cecullaton (message)  627 posts, Busy bee

Awesome choice!!! Photography is the one physical thing to show you the details of your day! I think that was a great idea!

 
12.
Mrs. K
Member
Mrs. K (message)  8 posts, Newbee

I’m definitely a photo-snob, especially because I made a pretty serious hobby of photography for many years, and actually shot a wedding for a friend.

So when the only photographer whose shots I absolutely LOVED was way out of our price range, I decided to turn to trusty Craigslist in search of a good photographer who was looking to break into the wedding market and help us out.

And I’m so glad to say that I found a great photographer who wants to build his wedding portfolio, and whose work I LOVE. Best of all, he (and his assistant) are doing it for FREE. I couldn’t be happier!

Best of luck to you, and I definitely agree that you do want a photographer who is there to capture the day for you, and not distracted in any other way.

 
13.
Bee Icon
Bee
Miss Veggie (message)  231 posts, Helper bee

Wow Mrs K! That’s awesome. I love the good old Craigslist!

 
14.
labrat
Member
labrat (message)  472 posts, Helper bee

Our budget for photography had to be around 1K bc I couldn’t see spending half of my budget on a photography. I love photos (i’ve taken over 3K in a year on my new SLR) but to spend a fortune one photos meant we’d have to cut guests. So, I’m going with a friend who takes amazing photos and agreed to do the e-shoot, wedding, digital rights and a proof book for an amazing price. And we’ll end up having two shooters as well because it turns out future hubby’s aunt is a photographer that everyone failed to tell us until after we hired our friend.

 
15.
Guest Icon
Guest
Paris Girl

i am struggling with this right now! Just spoke with fiancee over dinner about having nothing rather than ho hum photography. Can anyone recommend a Denver area photographer or photographer who would travel and charge 2000 or less?! suggestions!?

 
16.
Cole B
Member
Cole B (message)  1,362 posts, Bumble bee

This was something we struggled with too. Luckily, we found a local photographer that we loved and she was really excited about our event. Unfortunately, she was still over our budget but when I told her we couldn’t afford her she asked to meet again so we could try to work out something.
My advice is to ask if they’re willing to do it for less, and try to barter, it’s always worth asking!

 
17.
elusivephoto
Member
elusivephoto (message)  341 posts, Helper bee

This is definitely something I’ve struggled with as well. As a pro photographer myself, I tried to convince FI that I could run back and forth to my tripod during the ceremony.

He didn’t like that too much.

I just *couldn’t* imagine not having a good photographer at our (tiny, at home, budget?) wedding. The original photographer I was looking at was around $1500, which is actually pretty reasonable, especially for the area. But, still…it’s $1500. I understand that price, if you need before and after pictures, and need someone to wrangle 150+ people, etc.

My issue is, we’re going to have 40 people max. It’s going to be small, short, intimate. A few hours of someone’s time, and if someone came to me with that, I would most certainly discount my normal wedding rates.

Then I remembered a friend of mine locally who is an international fashion photographer. He always said he didn’t do weddings, but I thought he might know someone who would do our intimate event for less. To my surprise, he said that HE would do it for us.

He’s charging us $1000, but he is the best. So, I saved $500 and feel better about the money because I am confident in his skills to get stellar magazine-quality wedding pictures for us.

My mother still doesn’t understand how we can shell out $1000 for someone to photograph the one day, but ultimately, I just had to make the decision I felt best about and not continue to debate it back and forth.

I’m so glad you also found someone great to do it within your budget! :-) I’m sorry your guy doesn’t quite get it, but this is the way we looked at it: There are two things that are going to last beyond the one day, and are worth splurging on, the rings, and the photos.

 
18.
neontl
Member
neontl (message)  1,135 posts, Bumble bee

I think that after the reception and ceremony costs, the photographer is the next biggest expense - it will be the one way that you can have those memories from this special moment in your life. You can NOT depend on fate that your guests took pictures.

What you can also do is create a wedding page on shutterfly.com - and have your wedding guests upload their pictures after the wedding too…it’s a fun way for the guests to view each other’s pictures and order pictures if they would like.

 
19.
Member Icon
Member
eimersc (message)  235 posts, Helper bee

This was a good choice. Congrats on negotiating!

 
20.
Miss Taco
Bee
Miss Taco (message)  950 posts, Busy bee

We went with the average photo cost for our overall budget and just went roughly in that range.

That doesn’t mean people won’t have some kind of commentary no matter who you choose :D

 
1 2 

Leave a Reply


You can also just...

Newer blog post
more in Blog
Older blog post
Newer blog post by Mrs. Veggie
more by Mrs. Veggie (oldest)
Older blog post by Mrs. Veggie

Visit our sister sites eHarmony
Online Dating
eHarmony Advice
Dating Advice
Project Wedding
Wedding Songs
JustMommies
Pregnancy Calendar

Copyright 2004-2012, Weddingbee.com
 

Find your vendors on Weddingbee

Real reviews from brides in your area!

Favors by Weddingbee

  • Favors by season

Shop Now »

Mrs. Veggie
Mrs. Veggie

Mrs. Veggie, Raglan, New Zealand/Scranton, PA Age and Occupation: 27, Director of Small Non-Profit Fiance's Age and Occupation: 42, PhD Student & Farmer Engagement Date: June 13, 2009 Wedding Date: August 2010 Venue: Indian Head Camp, Honesdale Pennsylvania About Me: I am a tree-huggin' farmer turned enthusiastic wedding-planner. I live in a house truck and wear flip-flops more often than shoes. In my old life I was a high school Spanish teacher in love with a crazy guy who lived off-the grid on a farm in New Hampshire. But, we decided to mix things up a bit, quit our jobs and move to New Zealand. My southern hemisphere lifestyle involves growing veggies, teaching, running our small non-profit, and surfing. I love laughing, singing, playing, and the inspirational Mr. Veggie (of course!). For our wedding, I am committed to throwing a killer party that celebrates our values without breaking the bank. Look forward to an eco-thrifty summer-campy weekend-long extravaganza.

Boards
Classifieds

Blog Calendar
February 2012
SunMonTueWedThuFriSat
2930311234
567891011
12131415161718
19202122232425
26272829

Weddingbee Bios
Wiki
More