Newer blog post
more in Blog
Older blog post
Newer blog post by Mrs. Frog
more by Mrs. Frog (oldest)
Older blog post by Mrs. Frog
Mrs. Frog's Picture
Mrs. Frog, Phoenix, AZ/Chelan, WA Age and Occupation: 29, Public Relations Fiance's Age and Occupation: 28, Online Sales Engagement Date: February 8, 2009 Wedding Date: July 2010 Venue: Amy's Manor About Me: I'm an opinionated Midwestern girl now living in the Valley of the Sun marrying a laid back Northwestern guy. I'm equal parts sass, silly and sweet. I'm fiercely loyal with a strong devotion to my family and friends. I have a not-so-secret obsession with apple juice, a new obsession with DIY projects and I love a really good cheese plate...with lots of wine. After 7 blissful years of dating, I'm having the time of my life planning the destination wedding of my dreams to my Mr. Frog-turned-Prince Charming.
About Mrs. Frog

Keeping Things Trim

May 4th, 2010 @ 12:26 pm by Mrs. Frog

When I say trim, I’m not talking haircut… I’m talking guest list. Whether you are planning your wedding or are just stalking these sites until you and your love are ready to plan your wedding (don’t lie, we’ve all done it)… you will inevitably get to the point where you must tackle the dreaded guest list. And please know, I say that with love—but good grief, is it ever difficult to narrow down a list of people who you will invite to one of the biggest days of your lives. And yes, I realize I just said good grief and that makes me sound like I’m 85 years old and I’m okay with it.

On one hand, you don’t want to invite people that you feel required to invite but on the other hand, you don’t want anyone to get hurt or feel left out. It can be a very expensive guilt-trip.

I have a confession to make. I hear many people say that with an unlimited budget, they would invite everyone they possibly could. I’m not one of those people. There. I said it. I’m of the opinion that no matter what my budget, there are only certain people that really matter to me to have there. I would prefer to have it be small and intimate. I realize that there are many that will disagree but that’s what makes this bloggerific world so entertaining, yes?

Keeping Things Trim :  wedding guest list phoenix Guestli guestlist

(source)

I’m no expert but I do have a few ideas of how to go about the process in a way that may help alleviate some of the strain it can put on you as a couple.

And let me tell you, it can create some very interesting “conversations”. For example, how he can want to invite his “friend” that lives on the other side of the country that he hasn’t mentioned in the years you’ve been together, never talks to and doesn’t even know how to spell his last name-kind of conversations. Of course, that’s just a “for instance”—I have not experienced anything of the sort…

First up, sit down together and just start listing out family and friends that you both would like included. Don’t try to limit yourself, just put down all of the names that come to mind. Once you’ve got that list created, go through and decide together who is a must, who you would like to come and who is a maybe. It sounds a bit cruel but it’s the best way to gather your thoughts and see how many people you are working with.

From there, you can incorporate the lists you will (most definitely) receive from your parents. This could result in multiple lists, depending on whether each set of parents is still married or is re-married. There are many factors that play into parent lists—if they are helping to pay for the wedding, etc. so be gentle when you explain your point-of-view when discussing the impact of their lists. (Don’t forget to decide where you stand on having children at the wedding and what the cut-off age is across the board as that will impact your overall guest count as well.)

Now comes the tough part. You have the full list of people that everyone would like included. Typically, this will be more than you can afford had planned for. Here are a few ways I’ve heard couples mention that helped them to narrow it down.

  • Does this person or couple call you/send you a card on your birthday or holidays? Do you do the same for them?
  • Would you treat this person or couple to a night out on another occasion?
  • Would this person or couple be hurt if you didn’t invite them, or would they understand?
  • Can this person or couple even come on the date/time you have selected?
  • If the couple isn’t married, how long have they been dating? (Be sure to enforce this across the board if you decide that couples must have been dating for a certain period of time to avoid hurting feelings.)
  • Have you seen this person or couple in the past year?
  • Split the list into equal parts and allow everyone the same amount, or an agreed upon amount/percentage of invites (split into bride, groom, bride’s parents, groom’s parents)

Keeping Things Trim :  wedding guest list phoenix Backyar backyard wedding

(source)

If it becomes too difficult to separate people into groups, you can always go to the opposite extreme and make the ceremony very intimate. The upside to going that route is you limit the cost—you have all of the people that are musts and you can throw a fun, casual reception later where everyone can attend. With the current state of the economy this tends to be a popular choice. It’s very easy to throw a bash in your own home/backyard… and it’s an excuse to wear your dress a second time – bonus!

For Frogger and I, we count ourselves lucky that our list was relatively small when all was said and done. We definitely had discussions about guests and made sure to decide together (with our parents) how the list would be created, but ultimately, we are thrilled that we didn’t have too many awkward moments.

Were you lucky like us or was the guest list more of a challenge to create? How did you handle making cuts?

Tags: guest-list, phoenix |
advertisement below
Newer blog post
more in Blog
Older blog post
Newer blog post by Mrs. Frog
more by Mrs. Frog (oldest)
Older blog post by Mrs. Frog

18 Responses to “Keeping Things Trim”

1.
Mrs. Pug
Bee
Mrs. Pug (message)  3,753 posts, Honey bee

good guidelines! our guest list formation was oddly pretty smooth. it was instinctive in terms of which friends we’d be inviting, and our parents, knowing our wedding was on the smaller side, didn’t invite their friends.

 
2.
Member Icon
Member
Miss Stargazer (message)  170 posts, Blushing bee

I agree, I think that a more intimate occasion is better, even when budget is not an issue. However, I got trumped. My Dad said that he was paying for the wedding, so he would invite whomever he wanted. um, ok. Enter 250 person guest list. While I lament for the small occasion I’d wanted, I think I am coming to grips with it. Also, I figure that since I can’t change it, I might as well cross that one off the worry list!

 
3.
Bee Icon
Bee
Miss Trail Mix (message)  6,328 posts, Bee Keeper

We made no cuts, only added people on!!! It’s been brutal…

 
4.
alivoo01
Member
alivoo01 (message)  2,622 posts, Sugar bee

Great post with solid guidelines!

 
5.
moderndaisy
Member
moderndaisy (message)  6,607 posts, Bee Keeper

Miss Frog, I have the same mentality as you that even if it were unlimited there are still only certain people I would be willing to invite. We actually have more space now than possible invitees so if I didnt’ feel this way, I’m sure more invitations would be going out. I want to know the people there actually care about witnessing our marriage and being there for us, not just conveniently local and sort of know who we are.

 
6.
Bee Icon
Bee
Miss Seashell (message)  1,713 posts, Bumble bee

Oh, the guest list… We’re a “the more the merrier” kind of couple, so widdling down to 200 was ridiculous.

 
7.
Cornhusker
Member
Cornhusker (message)  274 posts, Helper bee

We both have huge families, and it’s looking like we will have between 500-600 guests! Sadly this is pretty standard around our hometowns! No one moves away and family is basically your neighbors! We feel it’s important to share with whoever wants to come, and we can make sacrafices in other areas.

 
8.
Bee Icon
Bee
Miss Hamster (message)  4,046 posts, Honey bee

Good guidelines! Definitely one of the more stressful parts of wedding planning.

 
9.
Guest Icon
Guest
jenn

The only part we had difficulty with was parents’ friends- we ended up making a rule that we (bride/groom) must know them, otherwise they’re out. That mostly solved the issues.

 
10.
Marinara
Member
Marinara (message)  392 posts, Helper bee

We decided that we wanted a very small wedding for reasons totally separate from budget. We’re having 30 people. Our policy was: immediate family and those friends who would be in our wedding party if we had a big wedding. Extended famiy and parents’ friends were completely cut out. It’s worked great for us!

 
11.
peachplum09
Member
peachplum09 (message)  648 posts, Busy bee

Im with you on the, no matter the budget, number pretty much would stay the same. And I love your guidelines too, totally reasonable :)

 
12.
krissybee
Member
krissybee (message)  3,921 posts, Honey bee

hmm, its easy on my side… we have no family to invite! just my parents friends to add to our numbers. FI has a huge family so they are the ones that will have to make the cuts. i’d love to have a final guest list of 120 max.

 
13.
tea
Member
tea (message)  7,288 posts, Bee Keeper

this was a really helpful post, especially as the mister and i begin to think about who to invite to our wedding

 
14.
vistagirl
Member
vistagirl (message)  2,338 posts, Buzzing bee

we never gave our parents lists. we paid for the wedding ourselves and I was very clear that there was to be no one invited to the wedding that one of us didn’t know personally. we did invite family friends though. Our wedding was 65 people and it was our one level extended family minus the little kids (who came to the ceremony, then went off with the babysitter) and our friends. it worked out great! I think his mom was miffed at not getting a list but based on some of the things she said to me during the planning process, at one point she was lucky she got the invite!

 
15.
OctPumpkin
Member
OctPumpkin (message)  593 posts, Busy bee

Like you, we wanted an intimate wedding, around 65-75 people. Ours was pretty smooth sailing, and we only included the extended family we see regularly (i.e. I’m not paying for a family reunion). Being the spreadsheet queen, I made columns with his/her friends, our friends, family, his/her work, parents friends and the MAYBEs. It was easy too see how we were doing in each grouping and after time, it because really clear on the priority list whether or not someone would make it off of the maybe list.

 
16.
Roux
Member
Roux (message)  1,352 posts, Bumble bee

I don’t want our wedding to be too big, but seeing we both have large families we are looking at 120-150 (I hope!) But FI isn’t making it easy when he rights down 10 cousins names, and says “These are my cousins on my Dad’s side. some are married and have kids, but I don’t know their names. Also I’m not sure if cousin Jamie is a boy or girl, last time I saw Jamie was 14 years ago.” So now I’m looking for a nice way to tell him that he doesn’t know these people and I don’t want 20+ people he hasn’t seen in over 10 years at our wedding.

 
17.
winter
Member
winter (message)  1,333 posts, Bumble bee

I definetly feel the same way you do! if I had a choice I still would not invite everyone. I had about 100 people of the closest people in my life and I enjoyed that more than anything. It was the most wonderful time I ever had. I understand your requirements and those are the requirements that I had when I made my list!

 
18.
Guest Icon
Guest
megan

I only had a few rules/questions when it came to friends. Is this a person that I have seen in the past year? Is this a person that I plan on seeing or would like to see in the next year? Is this a person that I will be friends with in 5 years? Would we even be friends if there was no facebook? I feel like those questions really put things into perspective for us and we didn’t have any problems.

 

Leave a Reply


You can also just...

Newer blog post
more in Blog
Older blog post
Newer blog post by Mrs. Frog
more by Mrs. Frog (oldest)
Older blog post by Mrs. Frog

Visit our sister sites eHarmony
Online Dating
eHarmony Advice
Dating Advice
Project Wedding
Wedding Songs
JustMommies
Pregnancy Calendar

Copyright 2004-2012, Weddingbee.com
 

Find your vendors on Weddingbee

Real reviews from brides in your area!

Favors by Weddingbee

  • Favors by season

Shop Now »

Mrs. Frog
Mrs. Frog

Mrs. Frog, Phoenix, AZ/Chelan, WA Age and Occupation: 29, Public Relations Fiance's Age and Occupation: 28, Online Sales Engagement Date: February 8, 2009 Wedding Date: July 2010 Venue: Amy's Manor About Me: I'm an opinionated Midwestern girl now living in the Valley of the Sun marrying a laid back Northwestern guy. I'm equal parts sass, silly and sweet. I'm fiercely loyal with a strong devotion to my family and friends. I have a not-so-secret obsession with apple juice, a new obsession with DIY projects and I love a really good cheese plate...with lots of wine. After 7 blissful years of dating, I'm having the time of my life planning the destination wedding of my dreams to my Mr. Frog-turned-Prince Charming.

Boards
Classifieds

Blog Calendar
February 2012
SunMonTueWedThuFriSat
2930311234
567891011
12131415161718
19202122232425
26272829

Weddingbee Bios
Wiki
More