Newer blog post
more in Blog
Older blog post
Newer blog post by Ms Seahorse
more by Ms Seahorse (oldest)
Older blog post by Ms Seahorse
Ms Seahorse's Picture
Ms Seahorse, Boston Age and Occupation: 25, Veterinary Jane-of-all-trades Fiancee's Age and Occupation: 36, former non-profit fundraiser in search of something better Engagement Date: October 17, 2009 Wedding Date: September 2010 Venue: Fort Pond Lodge About Me: By day I'm a cat-wrangler, vet tech assistant, pet-sitter, receptionist, and pre-vet student, but the rest of the time, I'm a former-roller-derby girl turned dedicated-wedding planner. I love reading, writing, bicycles, animals, roller skating, and antique-y things of all sorts. I'm a vegetarian who likes spicy foods, while Fiancee Seahorse is a meat eater who does not like spices. We live outside Boston with our menagerie: a fifty pound dog, a one-eyed, seventeen-toed, toothless cat, and a perfectly put together cat who has a penchant for pooping near rather than in her litter box. In addition to planning our small lake-side wedding, we enjoy running around with the puppy, playing board games (Scrabble, anyone?), having little adventures, talking about how we should really clean the house more, and maintaining our little garden of vegetables and wedding flowers.
About Ms Seahorse

The engagement ring adventure was a big one, and a mostly fun one. At times it was stressful, as we emailed each other pictures back and forth and debated how much money to spend and whether to buy online or in person. At one point we just said, “Okay, no more talking about rings until we are holding them in our hands,” and that was the point at which we decided to only go shopping in person, which ended up being a really good decision for us.

(Side note: you all asked for ring pictures and I realized I hadn’t posted any! So here they are, for your entertainment. I, uh, couldn’t take myself seriously for pretty/fancy ring shots… so enjoy my silly ones):

A Ring to Wed Them All… Er, Them Two! :  wedding boston rings Sh3 sh3

Fancee’s pretty ring!

A Ring to Wed Them All… Er, Them Two! :  wedding boston rings Sh4 sh4

What is my ring posed on? Please see the bottom of this post for what I mean by “not taking myself seriously”.

The search for wedding rings feels similarly stressful, but somehow more difficult.

What is difficult, I think, is trying to figure out what is important in the wedding rings. I know that, because I plan to be working with a lot of different animals in my life, I want something that can withstand getting banged around and won’t get pieces of poop wedged in little corners of it. Sorry if that’s gross, but these are the hazards of the industry, people. I suspect that I will not wear my engagement ring all the time once we’re married, or at least not on the same hand as my wedding ring, so it’s not important to me that the band match my engagement ring.

But beyond these little things, which rule out a lot of rings, I don’t know what I do want. With our engagement rings, it seemed most important that I like mine and Fancee liked hers, and it didn’t matter whether they looked good together or to the other one of us. With our wedding rings, it feels important that they match, in some way. They are a symbol of our union, of our unity, and this is why it feels important that they resemble each other, or are made from the same metal, or at the very least have the same thing engraved within them. I want, when people see us together, for people to see our rings and know that we are married to each other.

Today we went to an antique store that I happened across a couple of weeks ago to look at some options. I was surprised to find myself drawn to yellow and rose gold, and I was not surprised to see Fancee drawn to the white gold and platinum. For me: simple bands with a little bit of detail or character, like little ridges you don’t notice at first or milgrain on the edges. For her: diamonds all the way around. Very different.

And THEN she found a ring for me that is just gorgeous. Again, it made my heart flutter a little. I didn’t have a camera and can’t find a picture of it anywhere, but it is a delicate vine with leaves wrapped around and around, and made out of teeny tiny diamonds and white gold. This is so not a good explanation of the ring. It is beautiful, and simple while intricate, and delicate while sturdy, and costs a little more than 5 times as much as I originally wanted to spend. And it will definitely not match Fancee’s ring, whatever she finds.

A Ring to Wed Them All… Er, Them Two! :  wedding boston rings Sh1 sh1

Aaand this is what I meant by not taking myself seriously.

A Ring to Wed Them All… Er, Them Two! :  wedding boston rings Sh2 sh2

Uh… if you like it then you should have put a ring on it? Anyone?

Okay, but in all seriousness, if you are married, what is your ring situation? Do you have an engagement ring AND a wedding band, and how did you agree on/pick your band(s)? Do they match? And whether or not you’re married, what are your thoughts/understandings of what a wedding ring “should be”? I don’t know that I care what one “should do”, but I am curious about the thoughts around these rings, as opposed to engagement rings, and where my attitudes are coming from. Give me your insight, dear readers, and tell me whether I should spend way more than I really want to on a ring that makes me flutter.

Tags: boston, rings |
advertisement below
Newer blog post
more in Blog
Older blog post
Newer blog post by Ms Seahorse
more by Ms Seahorse (oldest)
Older blog post by Ms Seahorse

21 Responses to “A Ring to Wed Them All… Er, Them Two!”

1 2 

1.
Miss Pretzel
Bee
Miss Pretzel (message)  1,893 posts, Buzzing bee

For me the choice was easy, the simple knife edge band to match my knife edge solitaire. My bridesmaid who is getting married this weekend actually opted to use her engagement ring as a wedding band. I really hadn’t heard of that before but it works well for her.

 
2.
DizzyDaffodil
Member
DizzyDaffodil (message)  386 posts, Helper bee

I am skipping a band and just having my engagement ring as my wedding ring. A band ruins my ring and makes the elegance of the lines that are so simple but so stunning just look odd, so I’m just skipping the band… That’s what works best for me!

 
3.
Member Icon
Member
slicey19 (message)  2,844 posts, Sugar bee

I think the rings hould make you happy because you are wearing it everyday. FI really wanted platinum rings for both of us which was significantly more expensive, particuarly for his. However, we shopped around which led to buying them from different sources (mine was made to match my engagement ring and his is from a jeweler we found on the internet) to sdave some $$. In the end, we plan to wear these rings every day of our lives so I think the cost was worth it. Besides, when you think about the actual weight of the medal, platinum is like 90 or 95 % platinum while white gold is something like 65% so you are getting more precious metal and it does not need to be redipped (this is how he sold me). I saw splurge on the ring you love and smile everytime you see it on your finger and think of Fancee.

 
4.
Guest Icon
Guest
Jill Baldwin

Oh, where did you find that first ring? I love it! Does it have anything engraved in it, by chance?

My fiancee proposed with my Grandmother’s ring. Look familiar?

http://croppinturtle.blogspot.com/2010/01/he-asked-me-one-very-important.html

 
5.
SabrinaR424
Member
SabrinaR424 (message)  266 posts, Helper bee

I definitely spent more than I originally anticipated on my wedding band. I ultimately decided that this is the most important ring I will ever wear, so I might as well get what I want.

As for matching rings, mine and my husband’s rings do not match in the slightest. I have a delicate yellow gold ring with diamonds; he has a chunky tungsten-carbide ring without any stones. And we didn’t get them engraved. I love yellow gold jewelry, and my wedding band matches my engagement ring. My husband wanted a metal that wouldn’t scratch, and he prefers silver colors rather than gold, which is how he ended up with tungsten-carbide. We figured it didn’t matter if our rings matched each other.

 
6.
MissCamera
Member
MissCamera (message)  770 posts, Busy bee

I told my husband that I didn’t want him to spend money on a wedding band, and that I’d be more than happy with my engagement ring alone but he’s traditional and thought I should have two rings. We went to the store together and just picked out two rings we each liked, we didnt even bother to try and “match” them. Which probably would have been difficult cause we have different tastes when it comes to clothing/jewelry styles.

 
7.
brittanyharvey
Member
brittanyharvey (message)  177 posts, Blushing bee

beautiful rings! and i knew it was a tp roll when i saw the first pic!! do i win something? anyways, really they are amazing! i ended up spending just what i wanted to on just what i wanted, you see, i’m a spoiled brat and i searched for 9 months to find my perfect wedding band in my perfect budget. it’s worth the search!!

 
8.
Member Icon
Member
jordanrae (message)  9 posts, Newbee

both of your engagement rings are awesome! very unique :)

even though we are not yet engaged, my girlfriend and i decided we are going to make our own bands…like mrs. pencils! we actually found out about this option from her post: http://www.weddingbee.com/2010/03/11/pencils-or-goldsmiths-final-product-and-cost-breakdown/
to us it is the best fit, as we both are looking for something fairly simple, yet meaningful. i firmly believe that whatever works best for the both of you will be the “right” choice!

i also wanted to say that i very much enjoy your posts :) i can relate in a lot of ways (same-sex couple, massachusetts address to name a few…) and i always look forward to new posts! best of luck with the rest of your planning! :)

 
9.
Mrs. Pug
Bee
Mrs. Pug (message)  3,753 posts, Honey bee

those are gorgeous rings. i love the one on the dog paw!

 
10.
Guest Icon
Guest
lady brett

your rings are both lovely!

and i think you put into words perfectly what i feel about wanting to have matching wedding rings, but not caring if our engagement rings match. which they don’t. in fact, our engagement rings could hardly be more different, and i think they are perfect for us.

but when we started talking about what we want in a wedding ring, we pretty much lucked out and want the exact same thing.

as for the money part, i am certain that i don’t want to include the price of the wedding bands in our budget, as they are more of a “marriage” purchase than a “wedding” purchase. but, of course, that doesn’t mean we don’t have some sort of budget for them - only that it’s one of the few (only?) things i’m prepared to splurge on.

 
11.
tetorger
Member
tetorger (message)  138 posts, Blushing bee

Now that we are looking for wedding bands, it will be difficult to find one that matches my e-ring. My fiance thinks I should just forgo the wedding band. I have thought about it, but at times I don’t wear my engagement ring with my job, and I want something I can wear all the time. I also like the symbolism of the wedding ring. A curved on would look better with my engagement ring, but I prefer the unbroken circle look. I never thought I was so traditional or concerned of what others thought of my relationship until planning a wedding!

 
12.
Bee Icon
Bee
Mrs. Spaniel (message)  6,792 posts, Bee Keeper

I think you should get what you like. My e-ring and wedding band match each other, because I wanted to wear them together as a set, but they don’t go with Mr. Spaniel’s ring AT ALL (mine is white gold/diamond; his is mostly yellow gold with some rose and white gold thrown in to make it complicated).

We’re thinking about someday getting me an additional band–just like my wedding band, but in yellow or rose gold–to wear on the other side of my e-ring, because after the wedding I suddenly wanted them to match. ;) But that’s an expense for another time, thankfully.

 
13.
Bee Icon
Bee
Mrs. Spaniel (message)  6,792 posts, Bee Keeper

I meant to add into that long comment… I love your two rings! It might be true that you have different tastes and that they don’t “match,” but I think they actually coordinate really well with each other.

 
14.
Miss Hermit Crab
Bee
Miss Hermit Crab (message)  3,562 posts, Sugar bee

gorgeous rings - I love how unique they both are

 
15.
Member Icon
Member
marieta (message)  339 posts, Helper bee

My opinion on matching or not is that the person wearing the ring be happy. We got my wedding band because it went well with my e-ring and I could stand the thought of wearing them together. When we went looking for his band, I just wanted him to like it. He wanted it to be sturdy, because he expects to bang the heck out of it. The only thing our bands have in common is that they technically have diamonds in both. Mine is white gold with channel-set diamonds that line up with my e-ring, his is a dark gray tungsten with an etched center groove and a single tiny diamond.

That leafy ring sounds gorgeous!

I understand wanting a ring that will work with your activities. I regularly bang into doorframes and other objects that jump in my way, so I knew I needed a flat or almost-flat ring. And I DEFINITELY understand about things getting in the holes. Way back when, I was sort of engaged, and I got a promise ring. It was lovely, but it had some swirly holes in it. I didn’t even think about that until I was making up some tortilla dough by hand and got it all squooshed into the ring. Took me forever to get out.

 
16.
Miss Argyle
Bee
Miss Argyle (message)  2,516 posts, Sugar bee

I have an e-ring and will have a wedding band as well. The Mr. will only have a wedding band. I only hope that he wears it!

 
17.
el0624
Member
el0624 (message)  205 posts, Helper bee

Your rings are both gorgeous. My wedding ring won’t ‘match’ my e-ring except that they will be the same metal. My fiance’s ring and mine will not be matching at all, style or metal. We talked about matching each other, but we want different things. He wants a plain band because he does a lot of work with his hands, and I want something with more adornment. I want something that will stand on its own if I wear it without my e-ring. In the end, I think it’s more important that we’re each happy with the ring that we will be wearing every day than if they match each other. Even if they don’t match, they are still a symbol of our commitment.

 
18.
winter
Member
winter (message)  1,333 posts, Bumble bee

my husband and my rings do not match at all. I dont think it makes a difference. you’re gonna have to wear it forever…i think they all look wonderful

 
19.
eileen marie
Member
eileen marie (message)  1,662 posts, Bumble bee

We used my late parents’ rings, and they happen to match, but I don’t think that it’s that important. I am not advocating going 5x’s over your budget, but it is presumably a ring you will wear for the rest of your life, so you better love it. My ring is nothing special, but I love that it symbolizes our love and the love my parents shared.

 
20.
Guest Icon
Guest
Air Compressor Regulator

Alienation Update + Picture intermission + Customer Masks…

This article was quite interesting to me, here’s a trackback to me blog. Keep up the good work….

 
1 2 

Leave a Reply


You can also just...

Newer blog post
more in Blog
Older blog post
Newer blog post by Ms Seahorse
more by Ms Seahorse (oldest)
Older blog post by Ms Seahorse

Visit our sister sites eHarmony
Online Dating
eHarmony Advice
Dating Advice
Project Wedding
Wedding Songs
JustMommies
Pregnancy Calendar

Copyright 2004-2012, Weddingbee.com
 

Find your vendors on Weddingbee

Real reviews from brides in your area!

Favors by Weddingbee

  • Favors by season

Shop Now »

Ms Seahorse
Ms Seahorse

Ms Seahorse, Boston Age and Occupation: 25, Veterinary Jane-of-all-trades Fiancee's Age and Occupation: 36, former non-profit fundraiser in search of something better Engagement Date: October 17, 2009 Wedding Date: September 2010 Venue: Fort Pond Lodge About Me: By day I'm a cat-wrangler, vet tech assistant, pet-sitter, receptionist, and pre-vet student, but the rest of the time, I'm a former-roller-derby girl turned dedicated-wedding planner. I love reading, writing, bicycles, animals, roller skating, and antique-y things of all sorts. I'm a vegetarian who likes spicy foods, while Fiancee Seahorse is a meat eater who does not like spices. We live outside Boston with our menagerie: a fifty pound dog, a one-eyed, seventeen-toed, toothless cat, and a perfectly put together cat who has a penchant for pooping near rather than in her litter box. In addition to planning our small lake-side wedding, we enjoy running around with the puppy, playing board games (Scrabble, anyone?), having little adventures, talking about how we should really clean the house more, and maintaining our little garden of vegetables and wedding flowers.

Boards
Classifieds

Blog Calendar
February 2012
SunMonTueWedThuFriSat
2930311234
567891011
12131415161718
19202122232425
26272829

Weddingbee Bios
Wiki
More