Newer blog post
more in Blog
Older blog post
Newer blog post by Mrs. Veggie
more by Mrs. Veggie (oldest)
Older blog post by Mrs. Veggie
Mrs. Veggie's Picture
Mrs. Veggie, Raglan, New Zealand/Scranton, PA Age and Occupation: 27, Director of Small Non-Profit Fiance's Age and Occupation: 42, PhD Student & Farmer Engagement Date: June 13, 2009 Wedding Date: August 2010 Venue: Indian Head Camp, Honesdale Pennsylvania About Me: I am a tree-huggin' farmer turned enthusiastic wedding-planner. I live in a house truck and wear flip-flops more often than shoes. In my old life I was a high school Spanish teacher in love with a crazy guy who lived off-the grid on a farm in New Hampshire. But, we decided to mix things up a bit, quit our jobs and move to New Zealand. My southern hemisphere lifestyle involves growing veggies, teaching, running our small non-profit, and surfing. I love laughing, singing, playing, and the inspirational Mr. Veggie (of course!). For our wedding, I am committed to throwing a killer party that celebrates our values without breaking the bank. Look forward to an eco-thrifty summer-campy weekend-long extravaganza.
About Mrs. Veggie

Registration Hesitation

June 20th, 2010 @ 4:35 pm by Mrs. Veggie

Mr. Veggie and I have been a bit slow boarding the registration train. Well, let me re-phrase that. I have been aboard the train for ages now, not only aboard, but driving the train full-speed ahead. Presents? For me? Oh Yeah! Mr. Veggie has been standing in front of the train, chained to the tracks like any good protester, both hands extended, trying with all his might to stop the train from moving.

There are a few (very legitimate) reasons for Mr. Veggie’s protest.

Numero Uno: We live in NZ. Our guests live in the US. We don’t want to have to pay to ship things that are heavy, bulky, or easily obtainable here in NZ. Numero Dos: We need money, not stuff. Numero Tres: We are stating a non-profit and need funds… so I guess that’s the same as number two: we need money. Numero Cuatro: We don’t want to support consumerism simply for the sake of buying some doohickey on our behalf, especially if that doohickey has a huge ecological or social footprint. Mr. Veggie’s thought was that if we really wanted money only, than we were sending a mixed message by creating a registry.

I shared all of his concerns whole-heartedly. We definitely would prefer cash, and of course we would prefer our gifts to be ecologically and socially responsible and easy to ship. But instead of looking at the registry as way of promoting reckless behavior, I saw it as a way of promoting appropriate behavior (kind of like sex education in schools, “no glove no love”). If we only registered for items that we really needed, that were easily transportable, that we both thought were reasonable, wouldn’t that encourage our guests to avoid any legendary wedding presents bound for re-gifting?

Mr. Veggie wasn’t sold, but eventually my charming nature and wit won him over and he agreed that a registry would be OK, as long as we both agreed on the items. But then the question remained, where would we register? Oh yeah, and what would we register for?

Several friends gave us suggestions for “green” registries. We checked out 3R, Gaiam, and a few others that I can’t remember off the top of my head. They all looked great, and had a few things each that we might register for. Then I had an idea. “Wouldn’t it be great if there was a registry where we could choose things from all different stores, and add our non profit to it, and ask for things like airline gift certificates?”

Apparently someone else thought it was a good idea, too.

Enter Wishpot. The answer to our prayers (well prayers might be a bit dramatic - let’s go with desires). We have added it to our wedding website with a note.

Registration Hesitation :  wedding registry scranton Screen09  And guess what? People have already started buying us stuff! Presents! Green, small, light, presents! All for us! Woo hoo!

Did you have a non-traditional approach to your registry? What route did you go?

Tags: registry, scranton |
advertisement below
Newer blog post
more in Blog
Older blog post
Newer blog post by Mrs. Veggie
more by Mrs. Veggie (oldest)
Older blog post by Mrs. Veggie

24 Responses to “Registration Hesitation”

1 2 

1.
Bee Icon
Bee
Miss Knitting (message)  1,072 posts, Bumble bee

I’m in the middle of trying to figure this out. It’s not going well…

 
2.
christalynn11
Member
christalynn11 (message)  1,216 posts, Bumble bee

I think your letter states well what so many of us would like to say - which is that money is better, presents are great, but money is better. With you starting your own non-profit, I think this sounds a bit less “gimme gimme” than the typical “please donate cash” type of registry.

After being recently laid off, we have decided to register at only one location (I know, how faux-pas of us!) and also open a honeymoon fund. Our honeymoon was already a gifted timeshare, but we paid the airfare and chose a resort that is optional all inclusive. Our honeymoon fund will allow us to eat out, enjoy local festivities and go on day trips we otherwise could not afford. We hope people appreciate gifting us an experience instead of a ‘thing’

Registries are a tough choice for many brides given that we (usually) have a house full of things by the time the wedding day rolls around!

 
3.
bluestuff
Member
bluestuff (message)  254 posts, Helper bee

Love your thoughts on your registry. Wish I had known about Wishpot before we got married! Congratulations on your soon-to-be nonprofit. I’ve already loved reading your posts, but you went up a notch now that I know about your Spanish studies — I majored in Spanish in college :) (Saw the link to your nonprofit in the screen shot….) Looking forward to reading more posts!

 
4.
supergeek
Member
supergeek (message)  111 posts, Blushing bee

We made a registry of stuff that would be useful, but it’s pretty much untouched. Our only concern is getting gifts at our wedding and not being able to transport them home (since our wedding is pretty far away). But when we went to the traditional registry places I was shocked by the minutiae that they try to get you to register for!

 
5.
Miss Cardigan
Bee
Miss Cardigan (message)  8,645 posts, Bee Keeper

I think that’s a great way to handle it! Love the way your letter is written - you worded it very nicely!

 
6.
Mrs. Bear Cub
Bee
Mrs. Bear Cub (message)  1,566 posts, Bumble bee

I totally lol’d at the image of mr. veggie chained to the front of the front of the registry-train in protest!

Great idea, btw! We did something very similar. (And fyi, over 95% of our guests got of $$, not doohickeys!)

 
7.
Guest Icon
Guest
Tamara

That seems like a really good compromise… Checked out your non-profit’s site.. it’s so awesome! Congratulations!

 
8.
Guest Icon
Guest
Jenn

Great post, glad you got what you needed. Another good option that has recently popped up is http://www.weddingrepublic.com - it’s great. A friend that’s getting married in the fall is using and it looks pretty guest-friendly too.

 
9.
Member Icon
Member
edb (message)  415 posts, Helper bee

I think that comes across really nicely - I agree that starting out with your nonprofit is very non-selfish; and I love the specific ask for contributions to the travel fund. If people are giving money, they like to have a specific purpose.
We started our registry through Alternative Gift Registry, but it has it’s disadvantages - like no fun pictures of the items! I’m afraid people won’t use it…

 
10.
texaslawgirl
Member
texaslawgirl (message)  1,062 posts, Bumble bee

I have to be honest… I would be completely turned off by that letter. I’m just of the school that giving such specific instructions on what gifts you want (light/easy to ship/etc.) comes off as in bad taste.

 
11.
texaslawgirl
Member
texaslawgirl (message)  1,062 posts, Bumble bee

I have to be honest… I would be completely turned off by that letter. I’m just of the school that giving such specific instructions on what gifts you want (light/easy to ship/etc.) comes off as in bad taste.
I’m not sure it’s your place to give your guests guidelines of what gifts you feel are acceptable (although I’m sure some people would argue that is exactly what a traditional registry does).

I think I would have just written a letter that said “Please no gifts, your presence is enough.. blah blah” and hoped for cash, rather than spelling it out. Just my opinion.

 
12.
texaslawgirl
Member
texaslawgirl (message)  1,062 posts, Bumble bee

Sorry for the double post! Wasn’t done writing.

 
13.
Mrs. Bear Cub
Bee
Mrs. Bear Cub (message)  1,566 posts, Bumble bee

@texaslawgirl: If it’s not the bride & grooms’ place to give the guests guidelines for what physical gifts to buy, then what’s the purpose to a gift registry in the first place?
I know this is your opinion in the matter - everyone’s view of “what’s acceptable” at a wedding is different. Remember that you’re reading this letter as a complete stranger to Ms. Veggie. The people who matter who will be reading this letter are her close family and friends - people who have known the Veggies for many years, and who know and understand what would really bring them joy on their wedding day. Isn’t that the point of a “gift” - to help out in exactly the way that needs help?

 
14.
texaslawgirl
Member
texaslawgirl (message)  1,062 posts, Bumble bee

I think it’s a point that we are just going to have a difference of opinion on.

 
15.
Bee Icon
Bee
Miss Pashmina (message)  190 posts, Blushing bee

What a great idea! I love how you handled it. Way to go!

 
16.
Bee Icon
Bee
Miss Socks (message)  1,323 posts, Bumble bee

I also think this is a fabulous idea for you guys…give your guests lots of choices, but each choice will bring you happiness! Win-win in my book!

Also–love the train imagery!! haha glad you two found a compromise!

 
17.
Guest Icon
Guest
Arachna

That’s really cute. I would be charmed by the ‘appreciate your persistence’.

 
18.
Bee Icon
Bee
Miss Sewing (message)  2,701 posts, Sugar bee

sounds like a good compromise :) we don’t have a registry since we’re lazy and because attending a dw is way too expensive already.

 
19.
Member Icon
Member
Joeswaffle (message)  180 posts, Blushing bee

I think it is a good assortment of ways they can give you “gifts”. It puts the major focus where you want it, the non-profit but also gives people options if they want to give an actual gift.

 
20.
Member Icon
Member
scournoyer418 (message)  138 posts, Blushing bee

I think it is great to encourage donations to a non-profit so close to your heart (because you set it up!). I am considering doing a gift registry that allows people to donate to a few charities that have meaning to us.

 
1 2 

Leave a Reply


You can also just...

Newer blog post
more in Blog
Older blog post
Newer blog post by Mrs. Veggie
more by Mrs. Veggie (oldest)
Older blog post by Mrs. Veggie

Visit our sister sites eHarmony
Online Dating
eHarmony Advice
Dating Advice
Project Wedding
Wedding Songs
JustMommies
Pregnancy Calendar

Copyright 2004-2012, Weddingbee.com
 

Find your vendors on Weddingbee

Real reviews from brides in your area!

Favors by Weddingbee

  • Favors by season

Shop Now »

Mrs. Veggie
Mrs. Veggie

Mrs. Veggie, Raglan, New Zealand/Scranton, PA Age and Occupation: 27, Director of Small Non-Profit Fiance's Age and Occupation: 42, PhD Student & Farmer Engagement Date: June 13, 2009 Wedding Date: August 2010 Venue: Indian Head Camp, Honesdale Pennsylvania About Me: I am a tree-huggin' farmer turned enthusiastic wedding-planner. I live in a house truck and wear flip-flops more often than shoes. In my old life I was a high school Spanish teacher in love with a crazy guy who lived off-the grid on a farm in New Hampshire. But, we decided to mix things up a bit, quit our jobs and move to New Zealand. My southern hemisphere lifestyle involves growing veggies, teaching, running our small non-profit, and surfing. I love laughing, singing, playing, and the inspirational Mr. Veggie (of course!). For our wedding, I am committed to throwing a killer party that celebrates our values without breaking the bank. Look forward to an eco-thrifty summer-campy weekend-long extravaganza.

Boards
Classifieds

Blog Calendar
February 2012
SunMonTueWedThuFriSat
2930311234
567891011
12131415161718
19202122232425
26272829

Weddingbee Bios
Wiki
More