Newer blog post
more in Blog
Older blog post
Newer blog post by Mrs. Seashell
more by Mrs. Seashell (oldest)
Older blog post by Mrs. Seashell
Mrs. Seashell's Picture
Mrs. Seashell, Chicago, IL / Providence, RI Age and Occupation: 28, Marriage and Family Therapist Fiance's Age and Occupation: 31, Electrical Engineer Engagement Date: September 3, 2009 Wedding Date: September 2010 Venue: The Glen Manor House About Me: Fonts and fashion, stationery and Sundays, photography and french toast... the beauty is in the details for this fun-loving Chicagoan who loves to plan plan plan! The soon-to-be hubs plays "Mr. Fix-It" in our new condo while I swoon over beautiful, personalized stationery and choose shades of aubergine for my bridesmaids' dresses... and thus begins my new fairy tale! Skirting to the East Coast for our September nuptials where my home state of Rhode Island awaits with fall foliage, I'm just a few dress fittings and bachelorette party away from saying "I Do" to a very happy ending!
About Mrs. Seashell

The Truth About Cohabitation

July 13th, 2010 @ 6:11 pm by Mrs. Seashell

The Truth About Cohabitation :  wedding providence relationships Truth A1 truth-a

{source}

Not that long ago, living together before marriage was largely regarded as highly rebellious. In many circles it still is. But what’s changed is that cohabitation 20 or 30 years ago was a revolt against marriage, and today it is typically a step in the process toward marriage. How often are we doing it? Statistics suggest that the number of couples that live together before marriage today is around 50%.

When Mr. Seashell and I began apartment hunting back in June 2008 (after just a mere 6 months of dating - which now sounds insane) Mama Seashell wasn’t thrilled. Interestingly, the first thing she said wasn’t that it was completely ridiculous since we’d just met, but her sentiment was: “I really thought you were someone who cared more about getting married.” She was speaking to the heavily publicized statistics that couples that cohabitate are doomed to two realities: they will never marry (or suffer a heavily delayed engagement), and they risk a substantially more likely divorce. I do agree that couples who live together for a long period of time without clear, mutually agreed upon vision of when marriage will occur do risk a delayed engagement. I hate the “Why buy the cow when you can get the milk for free?” analogy, but it does have some merit here. The statistic that I do want to speak to is that couples who live together before marriage are doomed to a higher divorce rate. I have good news for those of us living in sin:

If you have only lived with your husband/wife before marriage your likelihood of divorce is actually LOWER! In fact, the number is 28% versus 50% as compared to the general population.

What’s that you say, Miss Seashell? This means that serial cohabitators do run a higher divorce risk. They are the ones that have been driving the statistics up. Think about it, it makes sense. People who have lived with multiple partners are used to moving in, breaking up, moving out, and starting over. Those are the ones who are statistically at risk.

Now, I’m not saying that living together before marriage is right for everyone. I can respect that sharing a home and a bedroom is something that many couples value until after they have exchanged vows. But it was the right decision for me and Mr. Seashell. And yet, if we had broken up at any point since moving in together I can recognize that it would have felt much more like a divorce than a breakup. It’s a risky endeavor, but we were both intensely confident that living together was a single step in a larger process.

Did you live with your fiance before marriage? What factors went into the decision?

Tags: providence, relationships |
advertisement below
Newer blog post
more in Blog
Older blog post
Newer blog post by Mrs. Seashell
more by Mrs. Seashell (oldest)
Older blog post by Mrs. Seashell

73 Responses to “The Truth About Cohabitation”

1 2 3 4 

1.
mcnetn3
Member
mcnetn3 (message)  1,675 posts, Bumble bee

My SO and I live together for 2 main reasons 1)we were a LDR and I moved to the same city he is in and it didn’t make financial sense to live separately and 2) he felt that living together before marriage would ensure we wouldn’t try to kill one another after we got married and started cohabitation.

 
2.
Bee Icon
Bee
Mrs. Hamster (message)  4,046 posts, Honey bee

Interesting post - I agree that living together certainly doesn’t have the rebellious vibe it once did. I remember a recent article about how in cities with high costs of living (NYC being one of them, boo!), living together was also a function of practicality and sharing the rent bill. Not that that should be the *only* reason, of course, but it certainly accelerated things for some couples.

 
3.
Bee Icon
Bee
Mrs. Ribbons (message)  2,018 posts, Buzzing bee

We lived together, but we got engaged first and really, that was the deal for me. I wasn’t moving in until we were engaged. I needed it to be clear that this was serious!

 
4.
sulaii211
Member
sulaii211 (message)  770 posts, Busy bee

I was reading a similar study- and essentially the other reason for a high divorce statistic was that bad relationships were turning into bad marriages- like moving in together made it harder to break up?!

Funny.

 
5.
BrianneG
Member
BrianneG (message)  938 posts, Busy bee

We lived together for a year before we got engaged, but neither of us ever lived with anyone else. Also, I always said that I didn’t want to live with someone unless I was engaged so agreeing to move in basically was a true commitment without a ring.

We moved in together because we knew it was going to happen eventually. It just got pushed up because my roommate followed her heart to Chicago.

 
6.
M.Ruder
Member
M.Ruder (message)  1,440 posts, Bumble bee

We’re not living together. We had planned on it, but when he bought the house I decided not to.

What’s another year? And besides, statistics show that cohabitation DOES increase chances for divorces, and the amount of spiritual happiness in the relationship is lowered.

 
7.
fourpeass
Member
fourpeass (message)  122 posts, Blushing bee

Thank you! You hit the nail on the head. I hate when people give the higher divorce rate as a reason not to move in before marriage. When FI and I decided to move in together because we knew were serious about each other and that we were making a serious commitment to one another. I wouldn’t have if I didn’t think marriage was somewhere down the line. I didn’t just move in with any boyfriend.

 
8.
Miss Chapstick
Member
Miss Chapstick (message)  2,098 posts, Buzzing bee

I love this new statistic :)

Looking back, Mr Chapstick and I moved in together really fast … like only after three months. It was just something that happened to work out for us, but yeah, I would never recommend that to other new couples, haha!

 
9.
DianaLynn
Member
DianaLynn (message)  197 posts, Blushing bee

Same as Mrs. Ribbons, had to to be engaged before we cohabitated.

 
10.
Entangled
Member
Entangled (message)  2,616 posts, Sugar bee

We moved in after five months - and my parents were fine with it because they moved in 35 years or so earlier after six. Yeah, both us and our folks met while living in New York. Rent are expensive and getting a regular roommate usually requires putting in a temporary wall and giving up your living room!

I really hate the “why buy the cow” analogy, though. For one, it assumes that men are interested in living together and sex and women are interested in commitment. In a lot of my relationships, it’s been the opposite, actually. I’m a big believer in “why buy the car if you can’t take a test drive” but then again, that’s just as ridiculous and reductionist. Among the people I know, cohabitation is pretty much considered a pre-requisite for marriage, though. It’s actually pretty interesting to see people from totally different viewpoints, though, since my social group is fairly homogenous this way.

 
11.
beccaod
Member
beccaod (message)  46 posts, Newbee

We still aren’t living together and are getting married together in 2 months. We could have, I own a house and he is living on his own, but we decided against it. Of all the benefits of it, the negatives outweighed it. I must say that our parents (super conservatives) have been influential in our decision. We decided that we could wait and moving in together after marriage was the right choice for us. Sometimes its hard to not come home to each other, but it will make marriage that much more exciting!

 
12.
Guest Icon
Guest
Carla @ I Run, You Run

My fiance was SO afraid of moving in together because of the higher divorce rates (he comes from a divorced family). But I also found the statistics you mentioned — that if you marry the only person you ever lived with, the divorce rate is actually lower than if you do not. And hence, we have been living in sin for almost a year now (moved in together after 8 months).

 
13.
JenBabe
Member
JenBabe (message)  316 posts, Helper bee

@fourpeass: Ditto

 
14.
Miss Cardigan
Bee
Miss Cardigan (message)  8,645 posts, Bee Keeper

Definitely an interesting post! Mr. Cardigan and I have (unofficially) lived together for about a year now, and are officially moving in together in a few weeks - I think it has really strengthened our relationship, and it was the perfect choice for us!

 
15.
Guest Icon
Guest
Rachael

I think this new statistic makes sense. Getting engaged & planning the move happened around the same time, and I also wouldn’t have done it if it wasn’t part of a larger process. Now I can’t imagine doing it any other way. The idea of either not living together right after the wedding or having to deal with that stress right around the same time as the wedding just seems insane. It’s also made it easier to decide on what to register for and plan the wedding together, etc.

 
16.
Guest Icon
Guest
Christine

We not only moved in together after knowing each other a mere six months, but we bought a house together. I actually wonder if we would have made it as a couple if it weren’t easier to walk away. In fact, if it weren’t for me and the house, he may have very well moved off to Minnesota when he got a job offer 9 months in, and well that would certainly have changed the entire dynamic of our relationship.

We lived together for three and a half years before getting married, and spent two of those years engaged. Eight months into the marriage, and it will be five years together tomorrow, and we’re still going strong.

 
17.
Guest Icon
Guest
SoontobeMrsD

FI and I moved in together about 6 weeks prior to engagement. He had wanted to proposed before we moved in, but his work stopped paying him. Thankfully, he got a new job and we are getting married in 3 1/2 months.

It was hard at first. He had a lot of quirks, but I got used to his, and he got used to mine. We also have 2 roommates, which we wanted because we wanted to make getting married feel “different”. That’s actually been the most challenging part- we can’t wait to get married and move in together as husband and wife!

 
18.
Member Icon
Member
Miss Jenniefart (message)  63 posts, Worker bee

We moved in after three monthes because our leases ran out and it kinda made sense. We still had flatmates and I had my own room, that soon got turned into a computer room ha!I think we have worked through lots of issues living together, and I don’t know if I would have dealt with them as well with the pressure of “omg i’m married to this douche forever” in my head. I may have reacted diffrently. By the time we are married, we would have being a couple for six years living together on and off for four years….

 
19.
Miss Taco
Bee
Miss Taco (message)  950 posts, Busy bee

Eenteresting. I didn’t know the part about serial cohabitors. Mr. Taco actually lived with three other girlfriends before me and I sort-of lived with an ex (we broke up shortly thereafter) but I’m not too worried about it ;)

 
20.
sf_carrie
Member
sf_carrie (message)  463 posts, Helper bee

Great post! I really like that you are weaving in some of your professional expertise into your posts, they are really interesting and useful. As to our decision… a lot of things influenced our moving into together before getting engaged. FI was not so much for it at first because of the higher divorce rate stat but after dating for 2 years I pushed for it because I had been married before and I wanted to “test drive the car” as a previous comment mentioned and make sure we could live together without driving each other crazy. FI had never lived with anyone before and hadn’t had a rooomate in many years so I wanted to see how he’d deal with me in his space all the time. The other big factor for me is that I knew we’d start TTC immediately after marriage (I’m 35) and I wanted some time to live together and iron out the little household differences before we had bigger changes in our lives. We started living together about 3 mo before getting engaged (but we both knew the proposal was coming within 6 mo when I moved in) and by time we will have gotten married, we will have lived together about 7 mo. I miss my former shorter commute and the gym in my old building, and occasionally the opportunity to leave dishes in the sink and watch copious amount of crap TV but overall, living together has been super awesome, especially getting to start each day with each other. Plus saving on rent in SF is great too.

 
1 2 3 4 

Leave a Reply


You can also just...

Newer blog post
more in Blog
Older blog post
Newer blog post by Mrs. Seashell
more by Mrs. Seashell (oldest)
Older blog post by Mrs. Seashell

Visit our sister sites eHarmony
Online Dating
eHarmony Advice
Dating Advice
Project Wedding
Wedding Songs
JustMommies
Pregnancy Calendar

Copyright 2004-2012, Weddingbee.com
 

Find your vendors on Weddingbee

Real reviews from brides in your area!

Favors by Weddingbee

  • Favors by season

Shop Now »

Mrs. Seashell
Mrs. Seashell

Mrs. Seashell, Chicago, IL / Providence, RI Age and Occupation: 28, Marriage and Family Therapist Fiance's Age and Occupation: 31, Electrical Engineer Engagement Date: September 3, 2009 Wedding Date: September 2010 Venue: The Glen Manor House About Me: Fonts and fashion, stationery and Sundays, photography and french toast... the beauty is in the details for this fun-loving Chicagoan who loves to plan plan plan! The soon-to-be hubs plays "Mr. Fix-It" in our new condo while I swoon over beautiful, personalized stationery and choose shades of aubergine for my bridesmaids' dresses... and thus begins my new fairy tale! Skirting to the East Coast for our September nuptials where my home state of Rhode Island awaits with fall foliage, I'm just a few dress fittings and bachelorette party away from saying "I Do" to a very happy ending!

Boards
Classifieds

Blog Calendar
February 2012
SunMonTueWedThuFriSat
2930311234
567891011
12131415161718
19202122232425
26272829

Weddingbee Bios
Wiki
More