Newer blog post
more in Blog
Older blog post
Newer blog post by Ms. Sloth
more by Ms. Sloth (oldest)
Older blog post by Ms. Sloth
Ms. Sloth's Picture
Ms. Sloth, Philadelphia Age and Occupation: 35, Account Manager and Fashion Blogger Fiance's Age and Occupation: 30, Design Admin Engagement Date: December 25, 2009 Wedding Date: May 2011 Venue: Bartram's Garden About Me: I'm an internet junkie and music snob with a good eye for a bargain. I couldn't live without thrift store shopping, cheeseburgers, sushi, Coke Zero, websites devoted to silly photos of baby animals, Photoshop, and Mr. Sloth. Speaking of which, he and I are a pair of goofball homebody nerds who love our beagle (the most ridiculously adorable dog EVER) to an embarrassing degree. We're planning a low-key and intimate yet festive and quirky outdoor wedding with DIY details and deeply personal touches, and it's all taking place in the city where we fell in love and call home: Philadelphia.
About Ms. Sloth

Proposal: The Story

September 15th, 2010 @ 4:11 pm by Ms. Sloth

So here’s how it happened, guys.

Allow me to set up the story: most of Mr. S’s family lives in the midwestern U.S. His parents live in northeastern Indiana, and his brother, sister-in-law, and both of his grandmothers live in northwestern Ohio. We make the 10-hour drive every year to spend Christmas with them. We planned to leave on Wednesday, December 23rd.

About a week before that, Mr. S’s dad called to tell us that his 87-year-old grandmother, who is very independent despite many health problems, fell in her garage, broke her hip, and spent almost 24 hours on the floor until Mr. S’s dad decided to take a drive to check on her, found her, and called 911. Poor, poor Grandma G.

She had her hip surgery a few days later, but the shock of the surgery combined with the breathing and heart problems she’d been suffering from for several years left her almost completely unable to breathe. She was hooked up to a lot of machines to help her breathe, but it was looking like she could stop breathing at any time. Grandma G’s living will stated that she didn’t want to be hooked up to a ventilator.

So on Monday the 21st, Mr. S’s father called us to tell us that Grandma G probably wouldn’t make it to Christmas. We quickly packed, Mr. S called his boss to tell her he was taking an extra day off of work (I’d already taken the day off), and we got prepared to leave a day early, Tuesday the 22nd, for what would be a sad, somber Christmas.

As we left Tuesday morning, Mr. S’s dad called again with some good news. They’d transferred Grandma G from her small-town, local hospital to a larger hospital in Toledo with a first-rate cardiopulmonary ward, and she was already doing much better. We drove all day Tuesday and got to the hospital around dinnertime. Grandma G seemed disoriented but was breathing decently. We went back the next day, and her mind was much clearer. Mr. S’s parents and the doctors all thought that her improvement was a Christmas miracle!

Meanwhile, I’d kind of suspected that Mr. S was planning to propose either before we went to his parents’ or while we were there, just so that he could share it with them in person (since we only see them a few times a year). When Grandma G got sick, I figured that the proposal wouldn’t happen. It just didn’t seem appropriate to do it with her being so sick. But when she started to recover so quickly, I started to get my hopes up again…but not too much.

On Christmas Day, everyone gathered at his parents’ place. It was me, Mr. S, one of his older brothers (the other lives in Florida and couldn’t make it this year), his brother’s wife, his other grandmother, and his great aunt. We did the usual opening of presents, one at a time. When we were finished (after several hours), Mr. S’s dad stood up to make a round of his famous Bloody Marys. But Mr. S said “Dad, don’t go anywhere yet.”

And then I knew.

He said “There’s one more present.” He stood up and walked over to me with a small gift bag. Inside was a box, and inside the box was my ring. He said “Will you marry me?” and I said yes, and stood up to give him a giant hug and kiss. I almost cried, but I managed not to.

After all of the congratulating and hugging and kissing, I called my mom, and then we called Mr. S’s other brother and sister-in-law in Florida.

That was it. Not too many bells and whistles. He didn’t get down on his knee. And that’s fine. Actually, that’s perfect. We are not a bells-and-whistles couple. The fact that he asked me earnestly, in front of the people who matter most to him, was perfect enough for me. I wouldn’t change a thing about it!

Were you pleased with how your proposal went down?

Tags: philadelphia, proposal |
advertisement below
Newer blog post
more in Blog
Older blog post
Newer blog post by Ms. Sloth
more by Ms. Sloth (oldest)
Older blog post by Ms. Sloth

13 Responses to “Proposal: The Story”

1.
DoxieDoll
Member
DoxieDoll (message)  164 posts, Blushing bee

How incredibly sweet! That seemed like a perfect moment! Proposal stories always make me tear up a bit :)

 
2.
Miss Meerkat
Bee
Miss Meerkat (message)  3,216 posts, Sugar bee

Awww! I love it when a proposal reflects the couple and the is so you guys. Mr. M. prosed while we were on a trip which is so us. LOL

 
3.
Moose1209
Member
Moose1209 (message)  1,992 posts, Buzzing bee

I love a good Christmas proposal story!! I hope Grandma is doing much better!

 
4.
Miss Sloth
Bee
Miss Sloth (message)  3,184 posts, Sugar bee

@Moose1209: Thanks - yeah, Grandma is a trooper. She had to move into assisted living, but she’s doing extremely well!

 
5.
Bee Icon
Bee
Mrs. Trail Mix (message)  6,328 posts, Bee Keeper

SO sweet that he did it in front of his family, I’m so impressed you didn’t cry!

 
6.
photographernico
Member
photographernico (message)  527 posts, Busy bee

Our proposal story was similarly influenced by a grandparent’s health issues. Glad it had a happy ending!

 
7.
MissSnowBunny
Member
MissSnowBunny (message)  46 posts, Newbee

I just got tears in my eyes!

My fiance proposed to me in the kitchen- sweet because it was the first room we painted together.

 
8.
Swiss Miss to Bee
Member
Swiss Miss to Bee (message)  1,004 posts, Bumble bee

Great story, I’m glad his grandma was ok! Mr. Swiss did it in front of his fam as well :)

 
9.
Bee Icon
Bee
Miss Glasses (message)  2,741 posts, Sugar bee

Christmas Day proposals are so sweet <3

 
10.
missmerlee
Member
missmerlee (message)  45 posts, Newbee

my fiance’s family does the same thing opening presents! does it annoy you as much as it annoys me??? He also didn’t propose on one knee, but after we had made our bed and I was laying down with one of our fur babies.

 
11.
baldor1
Member
baldor1 (message)  1,312 posts, Bumble bee

Awww…what a sweet proposal! My fiance’ didn’t propose in front of his family but they were all in town a couple of weeks before he proposed and he told them that he had the ring and was going to get on one knee. It explains why I had gotten so many random hugs, winks and high-fives that weekend! =)

 
12.
Guest Icon
Guest
Ashley

Hey there Miss Sloth,
I’m sorry, I’ve turned into a bit of a stalker! But I loved your story, and I love that if you’re not bells and whistles, there doesn’t have to be bells and whistles. My fiance got down on one knee at a vineyard, the very first vineyard we ever went to, we’d had such a great day and we were just tipsy enough to be even happier and the weather was perfect, the wine was perfect… we’re one of those ‘how does it feel’ couples… we know things by how the day goes/how the mood is/what the weather’s like… intuition told him it was just right and his intuition told him just how to do it. I am more of a traditional, ‘yes, please get down on one knee first’ kind of girl. But he still didn’t need to put it on an airplane banner or anything, just me and him among the grapevines, exactly how he knew I’d love it!!

 
13.
Guest Icon
Guest
Proposal Power Struggle? | Weddingbee

[...] then, at Christmas - He proposed. And it was simple, but [...]

 

Leave a Reply


You can also just...

Newer blog post
more in Blog
Older blog post
Newer blog post by Ms. Sloth
more by Ms. Sloth (oldest)
Older blog post by Ms. Sloth

Visit our sister sites eHarmony
Online Dating
eHarmony Advice
Dating Advice
Project Wedding
Wedding Songs
JustMommies
Pregnancy Calendar

Copyright 2004-2012, Weddingbee.com
 

Find your vendors on Weddingbee

Real reviews from brides in your area!

Favors by Weddingbee

  • Favors by season

Shop Now »

Ms. Sloth
Ms. Sloth

Ms. Sloth, Philadelphia Age and Occupation: 35, Account Manager and Fashion Blogger Fiance's Age and Occupation: 30, Design Admin Engagement Date: December 25, 2009 Wedding Date: May 2011 Venue: Bartram's Garden About Me: I'm an internet junkie and music snob with a good eye for a bargain. I couldn't live without thrift store shopping, cheeseburgers, sushi, Coke Zero, websites devoted to silly photos of baby animals, Photoshop, and Mr. Sloth. Speaking of which, he and I are a pair of goofball homebody nerds who love our beagle (the most ridiculously adorable dog EVER) to an embarrassing degree. We're planning a low-key and intimate yet festive and quirky outdoor wedding with DIY details and deeply personal touches, and it's all taking place in the city where we fell in love and call home: Philadelphia.

Boards
Classifieds

Blog Calendar
February 2012
SunMonTueWedThuFriSat
2930311234
567891011
12131415161718
19202122232425
26272829

Weddingbee Bios
Wiki
More