Newer blog post
more in Blog
Older blog post
Newer blog post by Mrs. Zebra
more by Mrs. Zebra (oldest)
Older blog post by Mrs. Zebra
Mrs. Zebra's Picture
Mrs. Zebra, Providence, RI Age and Occupation: 24 Marketing/Costume Designer Fiance's Age and Occupation: 26 Management/Firefighter Engagement Date: December 12, 2008 Wedding Date: March 2011 Venue: The Providence Biltmore About Me: I'm a small town New England girl with an affinity for procrastination, crossing the proverbial line, and putting her foot in her mouth. I'm a lover of history, all seasons, sewing and Incubus. I design costumes on the side for my old high school's theatre department, which is where I met my sexy man. Our motto for our Big Fat Lebanese/Portuguese/Irish near-300 person wedding is "the more the merrier"! We are marrying in a Catholic ceremony and are hammering out the details of our Victorian-inspired reception.
About Mrs. Zebra

Registry Guilt

September 15th, 2010 @ 12:30 pm by Mrs. Zebra

So, we’ve registered. I want to break registering up into two parts, and I’m going to go Sour Patch Kids style and give it to you sour then sweet.

I feel guilty.

Registry Guilt :  wedding providence registry Zebra zebra

Source

My mother raised me to be thrifty, which is partially why my favorite store is Marshalls. Believe you me, being thrifty is a learned behavior. I love shopping the clearance racks and sifting through Marshalls finds now, but when everyone else was wearing Nike in fourth grade, I wasn’t so proud. I’ve always been spend-conscious, even to the point where I commuted to school for two years to save money. Zeb was raised on the opposite side of the spending spectrum, and there is nothing wrong with it. We often joke about his expensive taste and how he already has everything. Spending is a learned behavior, and I surely hope to pass my thriftiness (but not my shopping addiction) on to my children. Now that you have our history, back to the registry.

We own a home—no surprise there. We get along with what we have just fine. So we’re standing in the middle of the store, with a scanning gun, looking at all the things we already have. The first thing we scanned was a white shower curtain. We’ve already got a white shower curtain. Why do we need a new one? We don’t—that’s why I’ve already eliminated it from the registry. As we kept scanning with reckless abandon, I was brought back to the day my mother and I went shopping for a family member and Mom was saying how ridiculously expensive some of the things she had registered for were. She registered for, not they. I’m going to get all the glory and all the blame. That’s why I feel the pressure-like guilt. On the other hand, Zeb’s mom and I have had a chuckle over some inexpensive things people have registered for. Most likely, my guilt stems from the fact that I have indeed judged people based on their registries. If only my naive self had known the staff follow you around telling you “you should register for three times as many things as people” and “you should register for goodies in all price ranges in case a group wants to go in and buy you something big” and (my personal favorite) “those Calphalon pans will last you a long time, and they have shrinkage technology in order to not shrink your steak when you grill it on the stove.” OK, that last one may not be a direct quote, but it’s pretty close. I feel bad that I am telling people how to spend their money. It is true, they have several choices on how to spend, but will they judge me by what everything costs regardless of whether they buy it?

Part of my guilt also stems from the fact that a family member recently hinted that there are a lot of weddings in the family and “what’s wrong with a backyard wedding?” My family and Zeb’s family have very different views, as previously noted, which also puts me in an awkward spot. However, the main point of a wedding is to celebrate the union of two people and to join families, and hell, if we and our parents want to shell out for a damn fancy shindig, well, dust off your blue suede shoes and enjoy it. I’m sensitive to those family members who cannot afford to buy me a gift, and from them I ask for only their love and support. It is not about the gifts, or registries, or centerpieces (although they are sexy as hell): it is about love.

In writing this, I feel better. Perhaps I have been letting my guilt build and get the better of me in more areas than just the registry. I do want to say one thing, though, and this is true for all the brides out there registering: Do not register for something that you don’t like because it is cheaper. Let Judgy McJudgerson do what she does best because in the end $50 saved is $40 somebody wasted on something you don’t like.

Tags: providence, registry |
advertisement below
Newer blog post
more in Blog
Older blog post
Newer blog post by Mrs. Zebra
more by Mrs. Zebra (oldest)
Older blog post by Mrs. Zebra

22 Responses to “Registry Guilt”

1 2 

1.
Miss Sloth
Bee
Miss Sloth (message)  3,184 posts, Sugar bee

I totally feel guilty about registering too. I just don’t like the idea of making a list to say “Hey, everyone! Buy us this stuff!”

The thing is, people are going to give gifts (well, most of them will, anyway) and if you don’t provide suggestions via registry, you’ll end up with, at best, three of the same crock pot, and at worst, a room full of ugly and/or useless stuff that you don’t need or want.

As a guest, I totally appreciate a registry (well, for a shower, anyway. I usually give moolah for the wedding itself) but as a bride-to-be, the registry makes me feel dirty.

 
2.
blondeeebuckeye
Member
blondeeebuckeye (message)  1,083 posts, Bumble bee

i felt bad registering for $60 flatware sets. but in the end, it will last us forever and if people dont like that, they dont have to buy it. they can buy a gift card instead, or something else. im not going to register for things i dont like because someone will judge me for having expensive taste (im budget conscious, but i definitely like nice things).

 
3.
Mrs. Gloss
Bee
Mrs. Gloss (message)  1,222 posts, Bumble bee

I think you nailed it - Registering is hard! I didn’t want to register for cheaper things knowing that they would break easily or that I didn’t really like them; but at the same time didn’t want people to think I was being selfish, esp. in a hard time. I wish I could’ve written a note that said “We realize some of these things are big bucks, we have them on here to get the completion discount :) Please use coupons and wait until things go on sale - I appreciate a good deal just as much as a good gift.”

 
4.
Member Icon
Member
whao1225 (message)  234 posts, Helper bee

My fiance and I had the EXACT SAME experience!!!!!! We registered at Macy’s and after an hour, walked out of the store with only 5 things on our list, haha!!! We already have everything we need in my apartment and like you, I am a beyond thrifty spender. Anything over $10 is expensive to me, haha, just kidding, kinda. Enjoyed your post, thank you!

 
5.
Member Icon
Member
piglet_625 (message)  2,541 posts, Sugar bee

I felt bad too, but at the same time, I keep thinking that it’s just a list of possibilities. If people buy off my registry, I’ll appreciate it, but if they don’t, whatev! :)

And if people judge me by my registry, then I think they don’t know me or FI well enough to have their opinion actually matter anyway!

 
6.
seattlemeg
Member
seattlemeg (message)  538 posts, Busy bee

Definitely hear you on this. My FH also has the expensive taste, and a will to spend. I try to buy everything on sale.
It was hard to look around and figure out what we need, we are so lucky to have the life that we live, I feel ungrateful asking for more. We didn’t register for all that much, we have a bunch of useful and inexpensive kitchen tools from Crate and Barrel on our registry and some nice decorative things from Macy’s, plus new sheets and things that will be helpful and useful.
To somewhat avoid the why did “she” register for that problem we also registered at REI. We need camping stuff, people are pretty psyched to get it for us (especially our friends who we go hiking and camping with) win-win.

 
7.
fieldielover
Member
fieldielover (message)  104 posts, Blushing bee

I’m a pathological bargain hunter. My FI jokes that I won’t buy something until I find it for 90% off retail, which is not far off. It gives me ridiculous satisfaction to pay less than I should.

That said, I am passionate about cooking and about really nice cookware. Since I’m in my early 30s, I have already bought myself (at huge discounts) a KitchenAid mixer, LeCreuset pots, and All Clad off of eBay. There are a few pricey goodies that I’d love to have, and may register for, but my friends and family will know that its because I’ll use and love them forever (though of course, no one is obligated to buy them and I won’t suffer if I don’t receive them!)

I don’t begrudge people registering for beautiful things, but what kills me is things that are just so overpriced - I’m thinking of the $50 kleenex box cover and the $129 salad tongs. I want the people who can only spend 50-75 to have plenty of options that feel like a nice, reasonably substantial gift. I know some of this just comes from having been on my own longer than others, but my advice is to go ahead and have some splurge items on there, but choose them wisely and don’t go platinum on everything.

 
8.
Member Icon
Member
Merry02 (message)  428 posts, Helper bee

I went through serious guilt when we registered, and we had to leave the store without completing the registry because I was so overwhelmed. I ended up completing it online. I felt guilty because my husband and I had lived together for three years, and I figured people would assume we already had everything. In reality, most of our items were cheap and falling apart, or really old hand-me-downs. I learned people will comment no matter what. When people found out one of our stores was Crate and Barrel, I got a lot of comments about it being expensive. In actuality, all but a few items were in the $20-$50 range. Sometimes you just can’t win.

 
9.
camrie
Member
camrie (message)  3,044 posts, Sugar bee

I didn’t feel guilty - I got really excited when someone gave us that $30 Calphalon pan or a set of our china - because it was something we’d use and would never buy for ourselves.

I would MUCH rather, if someone wants to get me something, have them spend money on something we will use rather than on something we can’t.

We didn’t care about getting gifts, but we didn’t want people to waste their time or money figuring out what we might want.

 
10.
SuperShopper
Member
SuperShopper (message)  866 posts, Busy bee

Ah, this is the feeling I’m dreading… haven’t registered yet but there’s always those judging eyes. I have vowed to try my best to take it in stride, do my thing and enjoy all my decisions - regardless if they’re different from anyone elses! :)

 
11.
Member Icon
Member
marieta (message)  339 posts, Helper bee

Thank you. This hits home. I’m dreading the registry… and honestly we haven’t decided if we’re doing one at all. We don’t need much, and I don’t like the idea putting pricey things on a registry that we wouldn’t buy ourselves. Why would we expect someone else to?

I probably will try to put some sheets on there, though, because I know what I like and those do wear out (if my washing machine doesn’t eat them). But there won’t be much fancy stuff on it, and hopefully nothing we only put on it to put on it.

 
12.
BunnyBunz
Member
BunnyBunz (message)  173 posts, Blushing bee

I feel a bit of guilt too. I feel like it is asking for gifts and that makes me so uncomfortable. We do have a lot of things we want/need which helps though. One thing I keep reminding myself of is that I really appreciate it when I’m buying a gift if the registry has a ton of options on it at various prices. Then I get to decide how much to spend and buy things I’ll enjoy giving.

 
13.
LRin2011
Member
LRin2011 (message)  386 posts, Helper bee

I feel so much guilt from my registry. We have a tons of stuff on there but most of it is pricey!

I wish I could tell all my guests don’t but it unless its on sale and/or you have a coupon!!

The everyday place setting we registered for is almost the same price as our china, but there is a local store that always has it on sale for like $40 off, but I’m not going to set up a registry just for people to get our everyday dishes there. Somehow I will try and have my mom get the word out.

 
14.
LittlestBirds
Member
LittlestBirds (message)  2,605 posts, Sugar bee

A few years ago, an old acquaintance posted this on her Livejournal, while looking at a couple’s wedding registry. She’s speaking to her boyfriend.

“They registered for sixteen $50 bowls. Your friends are asking for $800 worth of *bowls*.”

That quote was in my mind the entire time we created and updated our registry. The fear of being judged can definitely temper what you end up asking for - it forces you to think, Is this absurd, what I’m asking for? What I suggest, though, is to take a step back and put down the gun. Registering online was a very pleasant experience, as there were no pushy salespeople telling us what to register for, and no panicked confusion to push us to register for something we already owned. We went around our home and noted things that we lacked and have needed when we were cooking or baking, and things that really needed to be replaced/replenished (mainly towels and bedding). We were left with a registry that I was thoroughly happy with and not the least bit guilty about.

 
15.
Member Icon
Member
Gingers (message)  55 posts, Worker bee

wow so many comments, this is actually simpler than it looks..if you already have everything you need, why even register…and No, its not true that you’ll end up with 5 picture frames or lamps or pots, that is ridiculous…we recently got married and we didnt have a registry… simply because we’ve lived together for 3 years and we have everything we need and if we dont we go and buy it. (or wait until there is a sale) we received mostly money, gift cards and a couple of champagne bottles. only 1 guest bought us towels and another gave us a couples massage certificate. (which we really enjoyed)
i think people are getting more creative when it comes to gifts, also when someone asked me about what i would like i said that appreciate they asking but i prefer a gift that they picked themselves. (thats just how i feel)
good luck with your registry, there is nothing wrong with it but i think people should know that a registry its just a suggestion.

 
16.
Bee Icon
Bee
Mrs. Trail Mix (message)  6,328 posts, Bee Keeper

Hahahaha, I felt guilty until the day the first present arrived…And after that, I had so much fun receiving presents that I started stalking it!

 
17.
photographernico
Member
photographernico (message)  527 posts, Busy bee

Registering was not the riotous time I thought it would be. Pretty much the opposite. Stressful choices because this is Forever Stuff and also because there will be judging. I’ve already received the “Don’t forget where you came from” comments.

 
18.
Guest Icon
Guest
Kate

I haven’t registered yet, but I already know I am not going to feel guilty. As a 30-something bride, I have bought a lot of wedding gifts for other people. Now it’s my turn! In fact, there are still some things that I actually need (like a set of every-day dishes to replace the awful hand-me-down ones I have been using.) I have been holding out on buying some of this stuff, knowing that some day I would get to register.

I’m not going to go overboard on the registery — I consider myself a pretty practical person — but I am going for quality items that I will use and that will last.

 
19.
Bee Icon
Bee
Miss Glasses (message)  2,741 posts, Sugar bee

People have been really generous and I feel totally guilty too. I am a simple gal and I know exactly how you feel!

 
20.
Guest Icon
Guest
Debbie

Being a UK bride to be its slightly different with our wedding. We have lived together for almost two years and have everything we need. Therefore we will be asking for contributions towards our honeymoon or vouchers towards a new kitchen! It may sound rude to some but i really dont need expensive items i wont use or i already have.

 
1 2 

Leave a Reply


You can also just...

Newer blog post
more in Blog
Older blog post
Newer blog post by Mrs. Zebra
more by Mrs. Zebra (oldest)
Older blog post by Mrs. Zebra

Visit our sister sites eHarmony
Online Dating
eHarmony Advice
Dating Advice
Project Wedding
Wedding Songs
JustMommies
Pregnancy Calendar

Copyright 2004-2012, Weddingbee.com
 

Find your vendors on Weddingbee

Real reviews from brides in your area!

Favors by Weddingbee

  • Favors by season

Shop Now »

Mrs. Zebra
Mrs. Zebra

Mrs. Zebra, Providence, RI Age and Occupation: 24 Marketing/Costume Designer Fiance's Age and Occupation: 26 Management/Firefighter Engagement Date: December 12, 2008 Wedding Date: March 2011 Venue: The Providence Biltmore About Me: I'm a small town New England girl with an affinity for procrastination, crossing the proverbial line, and putting her foot in her mouth. I'm a lover of history, all seasons, sewing and Incubus. I design costumes on the side for my old high school's theatre department, which is where I met my sexy man. Our motto for our Big Fat Lebanese/Portuguese/Irish near-300 person wedding is "the more the merrier"! We are marrying in a Catholic ceremony and are hammering out the details of our Victorian-inspired reception.

Boards
Classifieds

Blog Calendar
February 2012
SunMonTueWedThuFriSat
2930311234
567891011
12131415161718
19202122232425
26272829

Weddingbee Bios
Wiki
More