Newer blog post
more in Blog
Older blog post
Newer blog post by Mrs. Earrings
more by Mrs. Earrings (oldest)
Older blog post by Mrs. Earrings
Mrs. Earrings's Picture
Mrs. Earrings, Fresno, CA/ Nelson, New Zealand Age and Occupation: 20, Student, Wannabe Writer Fiance's Age and Occupation: 19, Photography Student Engagement Date: February 14, 2010 Wedding Date: January 2011 Venue: Gardens of the World About Me: I'm a girl from down under who grew up in Indonesia and I'm marrying a California boy. I'm addicted to all things sweet, have never met a chocolate silk pie than can get the better of me, and have dreams of one day being a fulltime novelist. I go weak in the knees for lace, tea cups, and a beautifully crafted sentence. When I get excited about something (whether it is historical linguistics or the Beatles) I tend to go overboard in research, and planning this wedding is no different. Mr. Earrings is my high school sweetheart, my best friend, and somehow we combine all our quirks into one big happy mess.
About Mrs. Earrings

I know, practically every blogger bride has to bring up the subject of last names and whether she will be changing hers or not. For good reason—it can be a subject that comes with very mixed-up feelings. To some it can seem a simple decision between “yes” or “no,” but for others, it is not that simple at all.

I always thought I would be absolutely fine and dandy with taking Mr E’s last name as my own (incidentally, both our last names start with the letter “E” so at least my initials stay the same).

And then…well, I started not feeling so black-and-white about it. This happened first when Mr E and I were reading sample ceremony scripts together to get ideas for ours, and we came across the pronouncement line: “I give you Mr. and Mrs. [insert man’s last name here], husband and wife!”

I totally froze.

A Little Compromise: Notes on Taking His Name :  wedding legal new zealand Deerinh DeerInH

source


Just thinking about our officiant saying that, only with Mr. E’s last name instead, made me panic. Now, it isn’t that I don’t like Mr. E’s last name. It’s not that I’m not proud to share a name with him, representing our new family unit and the commitment we have made to each other. I like the idea of all that very much.

It’s that I’m kind of attached to my name already…I’m used to it and to give it up feels like I’m losing a vital piece of my identity. This is for a few reasons: First, I strongly identify with my family and their name. We take a great deal of pride in it—it isn’t exactly common either. Secondly, I’m an English and linguistics student so names and the naming of people or things is something I am obsessed with. Changing my name completely feels just a bit too much like a personality shift (yes, I know, it isn’t literally. But it sure feels like it). Who is this Mrs E_? What will she be like? Not that learning to identify with a new name will be a bad thing, but it is going to be something to get used to…and I usually take quite awhile to get used to major changes. I need to “marinate” on things like that for awhile.

A Little Compromise: Notes on Taking His Name :  wedding legal new zealand Thinkin thinkin

source

Finally, I have established myself with my writing and my research/studies under my maiden name already. I don’t want to lose all the ground I have covered with my old name by having to get recognised for my work again under a new one.

Ahh dilemmas. But don’t worry—there are solutions, too!

Mr E is very understanding of my need to warm up to the idea of a new name. He even said he would be quite happy to take my name if that is what I want (it isn’t whose name we have that is important to him—it is the sharing of a name). But we have decided that we won’t take that route—instead we have come up with a different sort of compromise: I keep my original name for my writing and career (that is, it is going to be my pen name). But for everything else in life I will proudly take Mr. E’s name. This is a compromise that we can both be comfortable with (though I still need to get used to the sound of “Mrs E” !) and feel unified under.

And we have also decided that when we are pronounced as husband and wife (ooh, now those are two words I can really feel happy about) only our first names will be used. So that we will feel like “us”: two individuals joined together forever in love.

Have you had mixed feelings about changing your name after marriage (if you will be changing it)?

Tags: legal, new-zealand |
advertisement below
Newer blog post
more in Blog
Older blog post
Newer blog post by Mrs. Earrings
more by Mrs. Earrings (oldest)
Older blog post by Mrs. Earrings

28 Responses to “A Little Compromise: Notes on Taking His Name”

1 2 

1.
MissHelen
Member
MissHelen (message)  2,440 posts, Buzzing bee

I had mixed feelings, so he’s taking my name. He’s not attached to his and I am attached to mine, so it works out well.

 
2.
Encore
Member
Encore (message)  680 posts, Busy bee

I have so many issues with changing my name that I could write a book on it. I’m glad I have a little over 7 months to figure it out.

 
3.
Member Icon
Member
ariellebride (message)  431 posts, Helper bee

I just got married 2 weeks ago and will be starting the process to change my name soon. It’s a VERY strange feeling. I’m happy with my choice but also feel like I’m “ditching” my family and joining his. I know it’s not the case at all. We’re starting our own family, but it’s such a weird feeling!

 
4.
M.Ruder
Member
M.Ruder (message)  1,440 posts, Bumble bee

I’m keeping my name until I graduate college, because that’s the name I want on the degree. But then I’m taking his name!

 
5.
Masala
Member
Masala (message)  476 posts, Helper bee

I was a linguistics major in college! So I too am kind of obsessed with the names of things and the meanings behind them, but in this case, I’m glad to shed my maiden name. It’s not my mom’s name anymore, I’m not close with my dad, and I’m starting a new family with my to-be-hub, so I’m looking forward to the change.

 
6.
Member Icon
Member
mskaila (message)  40 posts, Newbee

That sounds like a great compromise!

 
7.
Baileyh
Member
Baileyh (message)  3,491 posts, Sugar bee

I felt the same way as you! I stil do and i have change my name!! *laugh*

When we came into the reception i didnt want the DJ to announce us like “Mr and Mrs A Grose” because i felt like i had just become this invisible thing that his now…so were were announce and Mrs Bailey and Mr A Grose…not a huge difference but enough to make me feel better :)

 
8.
Member Icon
Member
crayfish (message)  4,993 posts, Honey bee

I think the hardest part for me has been the people around me not accepting my decision. I hyphenated. My family/friends that live in Texas where I grew up are very conservative, and don’t understand why I didn’t just take his name completely. My very liberal friends/coworkers in Boston are disappointed in me for hyphenating or taking his name at all. Why can’t we all just make our choice and be left alone about it?! An interesting comment on sexual politics in different social realms, to be sure!

 
9.
Miss Taco Night
Member
Miss Taco Night (message)  241 posts, Helper bee

@crayfish: I completely agree- I’m going to take FI’s last name because I just prefer the way it sounds and I like how it makes us a “family unit”, but I think it’s fine and lovely if people decide to keep their own name or hyphenate. It’s a very personal choice.

It baffles me that some people get so emotionally invested in other people’s decisions (of course, this applies to all things wedding and not just name changes!)

Miss Earrings, I think this was a very smart compromise :)

 
10.
Guest Icon
Guest
Brian

My fiancee feels the same way. She’s been agonizing over this decision for the last 9 months (at least), and now that we’re getting married in 1 month(!), it’s coming down to the wire.

I totally understand her point of view, and I think it is dumb that our society expects the woman to change her name but not the man, but we’re also not strong enough to buck the trend and do something totally out there like choose a totally new name.

I had this discussion with my (very conservative) parents, and to try to get my thoughts across, I asked them why my fiancee should be expected to change her name, and not me? My mom nearly flipped out, saying that she would be personally offended if I changed my name, as if it would be a slap in the face to her and our family, that I was not proud to be part of the family, etc.

We are both very close to our families too, which makes it more difficult. I don’t personally have any strong feelings either way for her to change her name or not, although we both think that it would be nicer to have the same name when it comes to having kids. We have friends where the parents have different last names, and the mother always gets called by the child’s (father’s) last name anyway. It’s just less confusing if the parents have the same name.

 
11.
Goldilocks1107
Member
Goldilocks1107 (message)  2,602 posts, Sugar bee

I’ve started the name change process and it is a HASSLE. But, it was really important to FH that we share a name, and since I didn’t have any real attachment to my current last name, I don’t have a problem switching. I just wish it was easier to do!

 
12.
Miss Jellyfish
Bee
Miss Jellyfish (message)  1,450 posts, Bumble bee

This sounds just like my dilemma! I ended up legally changing my name (fist maiden newlast) and then I am keeping my name for my job. After all, I’m the one who went to law school, not him! Earrings, are you legally changing yours or just socially?

 
13.
Member Icon
Member
Lili316 (message)  132 posts, Blushing bee

I completely respect each person’s decision about whether to change their name. However, I think brides sometimes overthink it - for me, it was a hassle to change it and it took a little getting used to, but I hardly even think about my old name anymore (it’s been 2 months). I’m not trying to make light of people’s struggles over whether to do it, but I just want to point out that the adjustment may not be nearly as difficult as you think.

 
14.
Guest Icon
Guest
Suz

As I face down my wedding in five months, I am happy to have this issue resolved. I am not taking his name legally, but socially, anything goes. Being 32, I have seen my girlfriends try out every option out there (change name, add maiden as middle, hyphenate, create new last name together, etc), and everyone has turned out OK with their respective choices. I am lazy, and the idea of going through the hassle of changing my name right after the hassle of planning a wedding makes my stomach hurt. And I do like my name, and am proud of my father’s influence in my life, and don’t see the need to give it up on official documents. I realize many people will call me “Mrs. D” anyway, and that’s fine. My fiance jokingly asked that I change my magazine subscriptions to “Mrs. D”, which I’m more than happy to do if it makes him happy. :)

 
15.
Kemi82JP
Member
Kemi82JP (message)  749 posts, Busy bee

I ALWAYS had no question in my mind that I would change my name. I felt it signified us as a family and I thought it was romantic too… and now that I have I am having all these new feelings of regret for my old name! I miss it. It never occurred to me just how much I identify myself with my maiden name and how much I would feel like I lost a part of myself. I of course will not change it back, I still agree with the reasons I chose to change it, and I’m sure I’ll get used to the new name… but I kinda wish I had just kept my old one. It’s been 3 months and I’m still not used to it.

 
16.
Totes Magotes
Member
Totes Magotes (message)  87 posts, Worker bee

This is a tough one for me, although my man doesn’t mind one way or the other. I’ll keep my last name legally and professionally, but socially, I won’t mind being “Mrs. Magotes.” I loved the idea of combining our last names into one, and changing both our names legally, but he didn’t dig that. So we’ll do it on Facebook instead ;)

 
17.
Guest Icon
Guest
golden8214

I kept my last name. It didnt present a problem at all during the ceremony or reception. The officiant said “ladies and gentleman John and Jane” and the DJ did the same. No one even knew that they werent calling us by our last names. Probably because we didnt call attention to it. No big deal for us.

 
18.
Bee Icon
Bee
Miss Earrings (message)  2,481 posts, Buzzing bee

Good to hear that it is possible to get used to the change eventually :) We did think about hyphenation but the hyphenated name would be ULTRA long so no go :P
@Miss Jellyfish: I will legally change mine. Quite a few of my female professors have their maiden name for work and their married name for everything else so I just copied them :P (I dont know if that is as easy to do in the states as it is in NZ…we dont have to go through such a big process to change our names here).
And I definitely understand the whole wanting YOUR name on your degree! That was one of my major points for keeping my name in that area.

 
19.
Guest Icon
Guest
mightywombat

There was never much doubt for us - it was always clear to both of us that I would be keeping my name. Luckily for me, my fiance always assumed that would be the case and has no problems whatsoever with it.

In fact, one of the sweetest things he’s said to me (one of many, awww) was when we were talking about it a long time ago, and he said, “But I *like* saying your name.” (Meaning my full name.) From his perspective, it was the name of the person he fell in love with, so why would he want that to change?

I agree with everyone else, though - it’s a completely individual decision and I would never dream of thinking that our choice was the best one for another couple.

 
20.
tetorger
Member
tetorger (message)  138 posts, Blushing bee

I am changing my last name, mainly because mine now is ten letters and his is four. Totally with you on the pronouncement of marriage deal. I am NOT Mrs. His First Name, I am Mrs. My First Name.

 
1 2 

Leave a Reply


You can also just...

Newer blog post
more in Blog
Older blog post
Newer blog post by Mrs. Earrings
more by Mrs. Earrings (oldest)
Older blog post by Mrs. Earrings

Visit our sister sites eHarmony
Online Dating
eHarmony Advice
Dating Advice
Project Wedding
Wedding Songs
JustMommies
Pregnancy Calendar

Copyright 2004-2012, Weddingbee.com
 

Find your vendors on Weddingbee

Real reviews from brides in your area!

Favors by Weddingbee

  • Favors by season

Shop Now »

Mrs. Earrings
Mrs. Earrings

Mrs. Earrings, Fresno, CA/ Nelson, New Zealand Age and Occupation: 20, Student, Wannabe Writer Fiance's Age and Occupation: 19, Photography Student Engagement Date: February 14, 2010 Wedding Date: January 2011 Venue: Gardens of the World About Me: I'm a girl from down under who grew up in Indonesia and I'm marrying a California boy. I'm addicted to all things sweet, have never met a chocolate silk pie than can get the better of me, and have dreams of one day being a fulltime novelist. I go weak in the knees for lace, tea cups, and a beautifully crafted sentence. When I get excited about something (whether it is historical linguistics or the Beatles) I tend to go overboard in research, and planning this wedding is no different. Mr. Earrings is my high school sweetheart, my best friend, and somehow we combine all our quirks into one big happy mess.

Boards
Classifieds

Blog Calendar
February 2012
SunMonTueWedThuFriSat
2930311234
567891011
12131415161718
19202122232425
26272829

Weddingbee Bios
by machop93
by IsaiahFountain
by greencl3
by ymaldonado
Wiki
More