Newer blog post
more in Blog
Older blog post
Newer blog post by Mrs. Prairie Dog
more by Mrs. Prairie Dog (oldest)
Older blog post by Mrs. Prairie Dog
Mrs. Prairie Dog's Picture
Mrs. Prairie Dog, Cincinnati Age and Occupation: 24, Program Coordinator Fiance's Age and Occupation: 25, PhD/Biomedical Engineer Engagement Date: December 18, 2009 Wedding Date: May 2011 Venue: Glendale Lyceum About Me: I'm a pilgrim soul of a girl with a house full of books and a coffee addiction that could slay Juan Valdez. My life is a whirl of grammar correction, good music, glue-gunning, and two pets named Hazel and Winston Churchill. I'm marrying my high school boyfriend in a formal-ish spring affair, roughly themed: "Elizabeth Bennet crashes a party co-hosted by Jay Gatsby and Cath Kidston, and loves it."
About Mrs. Prairie Dog

We had agreed to exchange one “small” present before traveling to our hometown for holiday break. I gave him a few pairs of boxers. He gave me a diamond ring. Underwear vs. Jewels…it’s hard to say who came out victorious.

“The ring isn’t the present!” he told me after we calmed down a little. “The ring is independent of Christmas. THIS is the small present.”

A weighty, rectangular package revealed the most recent issues of The Knot and The Knot: Ohio. What can I say? The guy knows his audience.

Then we drank the bottle of champagne he had hidden in the refrigerator. We danced and giggled and took pictures and started to talk about wedding stuff. I laughed about how I had given him underwear, which he had feigned enthusiasm for—not letting on that he was going to propose minutes later.

“I wasn’t faking!” he insisted. “I like them a lot. They’re my fiance boxers!”

In Which We Get Engaged and Tell No One for 24 Hours :  wedding cincinnati engagement Decembe decembe

(Double chin/fiance boxers + crazed happiness/gratuitous ring flash…at least we have fun.)


High on champagne bubbles and engagement, we proceeded to open all of our Christmas presents for each other while watching Love Actually and flipping through my new magazines.

We didn’t tell anyone until almost 24 hours later because my parents were stopping by on their way to a dinner. I figured, why tell them now if we can SEE their reactions tomorrow? But we didn’t want to tell anyone else before we told my parents.

So we kept it to ourselves—our little secret—for a whole day. (Well, I told the girl at the nail salon. She said she liked my ring, and I said “THANKS I GOT IT LAST NIGHT.”)

Of course, I understand the reaction of wanting to shout it from the rooftops, but to all you waiting ladies: consider having at least a few hours for the two of you.

After that, it’s all questions and reactions and people looking at your relationship in a new light. People will be a part of it for the rest of the process, and I wouldn’t have it any other way. But I love that we had those hours for just us—reveling in our engagement within the four walls of my little house, within our little life together.

And waiting to see my parents’ reactions in person? Worth it!

In Which We Get Engaged and Tell No One for 24 Hours :  wedding cincinnati engagement Decembe01 decembe01 In Which We Get Engaged and Tell No One for 24 Hours :  wedding cincinnati engagement Decembe02 decembe02

Did you start calling people right away after you got engaged? Or did you wait it out a little?

Tags: cincinnati, engagement |
advertisement below
Newer blog post
more in Blog
Older blog post
Newer blog post by Mrs. Prairie Dog
more by Mrs. Prairie Dog (oldest)
Older blog post by Mrs. Prairie Dog

50 Responses to “In Which We Get Engaged and Tell No One for 24 Hours”

1 2 3 

1.
Member
KLloyd1 (message)  814 posts, Busy bee

I got engaged in the middle of my student’s art show with my family and friends around me. I did call my sister a while later but there wasn’t much calling to be done.

 
2.
Bee Icon
Bee
Mrs. Trail Mix (message)  6,328 posts, Bee Keeper

Such a cute story! My parents knew bc Mr TM had called them previously to arrange for them to drive down to NYC to surprise me right afterwards!

 
3.
Bee Icon
Bee
Miss Earrings (message)  2,477 posts, Buzzing bee

You guys are adorable :) And I love the pic of your mother’s reaction!

 
4.
HoneyBear
Member
HoneyBear (message)  3,486 posts, Sugar bee

Awwww ‘fiance boxers’! love it!

 
5.
culby cheese
Member
culby cheese (message)  193 posts, Blushing bee

We waited for three days… We were on vacation and basically waiting for a call to come back because my grandpa either passed or was going to… I kept it just between us (and every one I ran into on vacay) because I wanted to live in a happy bubble where nothing was wrong for a couple days… He passed two weeks after we got engaged, but he was the first to see the ring when we got home. :)

 
6.
hilsy85
Member
hilsy85 (message)  3,680 posts, Sugar bee

So sweet!! I wish I could have told my parents in person, but I couldn’t hold it in and called them like a half hour after it happened.

 
7.
redbullfanatic
Member
redbullfanatic (message)  489 posts, Helper bee

We got engaged on our last night on vacation and we didn’t tell anybody till we got back home. Actually his dad didn’t know for almost a year, we figured his mom or brother would tell him or something. Oops.

 
8.
Miss Zebra
Bee
Miss Zebra (message)  1,044 posts, Bumble bee

Aw! Your parents faces are priceless.

 
9.
DoxieDoll
Member
DoxieDoll (message)  164 posts, Blushing bee

We just got engaged 10/22 and he did it at home. It was amazing and so, so private. We waited a couple of hours *due to bursts of happy tears and piggy back jumps of glee!* but we did get around to it.

He had asked my Dad earlier that day, so he already knew :)

 
10.
Member Icon
Member
MUI831 (message)  728 posts, Busy bee

We got engaged in Maine. I wasn’t planning on telling anyone but our families. However, FMIL saw fit to immediatly update her FB status and ince my MOH to be is a friend of hers. I couldn’t let her find out that way so I had to track her down. While I certainly appreciate FMIL’s enthusiasm, seriously??? FI was ok with it b/c this cut out the need to tell his friends and family. Ah, men.

 
11.
XxMyXxDecemberXx
Member
XxMyXxDecemberXx (message)  347 posts, Helper bee

I called my mom and told her, I was an hour away in Pittsburgh on new years eve.. I saw my mom when I got home like 2 hours later

 
12.
MissCatherine
Member
MissCatherine (message)  278 posts, Helper bee

I love the expression on your parents’ faces!

 
13.
Member Icon
Member
Missbliss (message)  784 posts, Busy bee

I love your thoughts! Sweet photos too!

 
14.
xtatic1
Member
xtatic1 (message)  778 posts, Busy bee

I called my mom, but she already knew seeing as my fiance asked their permission a week earlier. She kept her mouth shut for a whole week! I had to wait 3 days to tell any friends (besides my MOH)/coworkers because we were in Tahoe…I wanted to see their reaction.

 
15.
feministbride
Member
feministbride (message)  283 posts, Helper bee

So sweet!! I waited about 30 minutes before I had to call people… all our family and friends new it was coming very, very soon so they were also on pins and needles waiting! I see your point though… I’d really love to have had a bit more time, but it wasn’t truly us anyways, it was us and the photog he hired to catch the moment :)

 
16.
almostmrsc
Member
almostmrsc (message)  232 posts, Helper bee

We got engaged on Cape Cod 3 days before my birthday this past June. We waited until we got back in town the following afternoon before we told anyone. We told my mom first and then we progressively told our immediate family (parents & siblings) over the course of a week before we told all of our friends and my family over 4th of July weekend. I purposely avoided Facebook for a week for fear I would spill the beans before I could tell my family. I’m so glad that we had that time to enjoy it even though I was sunburned & bug bitten and slightly miserable from both.

 
17.
D.Marie
Member
D.Marie (message)  2,484 posts, Buzzing bee

Congrats!! Love all these pictures…so fun! I love that he gave you The Knot Magazing…so cute…what a great fiance! Welcome to the Knot!

 
18.
Miss Elephant
Bee
Miss Elephant (message)  6,182 posts, Bee Keeper

Such a sweet story! Mr. E asked my parents so they knew ahead of time, but I did start making calls as soon as we left the restaurant.

 
19.
Mrs. French Bulldog
Bee
Mrs. French Bulldog (message)  7,730 posts, Bee Keeper

What a cute story :)
We hung out just us for awhile where he proposed and then went home to tell my parents.

 
20.
froggy518
Member
froggy518 (message)  268 posts, Helper bee

I’ve loved so many little things about these two posts! Mr. Prairie Dog (I mean, Almanzo Manly Wilder) sounds like such a cutie! (”They’re my fiance boxers!” I die.)

I totally agree about waiting a bit before telling others (assuming it’s a non-public proposal, anyway). We were out of town on a day trip when my fiance proposed (in the car, mind you), so we had several hours of sight-seeing plus the additional hours in the car on the way back to giggle and just be immersed in happiness.

 
1 2 3 

Leave a Reply


You can also just...

Newer blog post
more in Blog
Older blog post
Newer blog post by Mrs. Prairie Dog
more by Mrs. Prairie Dog (oldest)
Older blog post by Mrs. Prairie Dog

Visit our sister sites eHarmony
Online Dating
eHarmony Advice
Dating Advice
Project Wedding
Wedding Songs
JustMommies
Pregnancy Calendar

Copyright 2004-2012, Weddingbee.com
 

Find your vendors on Weddingbee

Real reviews from brides in your area!

Favors by Weddingbee

  • Favors by season

Shop Now »

Mrs. Prairie Dog
Mrs. Prairie Dog

Mrs. Prairie Dog, Cincinnati Age and Occupation: 24, Program Coordinator Fiance's Age and Occupation: 25, PhD/Biomedical Engineer Engagement Date: December 18, 2009 Wedding Date: May 2011 Venue: Glendale Lyceum About Me: I'm a pilgrim soul of a girl with a house full of books and a coffee addiction that could slay Juan Valdez. My life is a whirl of grammar correction, good music, glue-gunning, and two pets named Hazel and Winston Churchill. I'm marrying my high school boyfriend in a formal-ish spring affair, roughly themed: "Elizabeth Bennet crashes a party co-hosted by Jay Gatsby and Cath Kidston, and loves it."

Boards
Classifieds

Blog Calendar
February 2012
SunMonTueWedThuFriSat
2930311234
567891011
12131415161718
19202122232425
26272829

Weddingbee Bios
Wiki
More