Newer blog post
more in Blog
Older blog post
Newer blog post by Mrs. Brooch
more by Mrs. Brooch (oldest)
Older blog post by Mrs. Brooch
Mrs. Brooch's Picture
Mrs. Brooch, Arlington, VA Age and Occupation: 25, Writer/Editor Fiance's Age and Occupation: 29, Front Desk Manager Engagement Date: October 3, 2009 Wedding Date: April 2011 Venue: Oxon Hill Manor About Me: I’m an indecisive girlie-girl with a motor mouth, can-do attitude, and knack for making others laugh. I dream of becoming a best selling novelist like Elizabeth Gilbert or Julie Powell (a girl can dream, right?), and love long road trips, a beautiful countryside, music, blogs, books, and all things vintage/thrift/antique/or homemade. I’m a Virgo, i.e. overly sensitive, emotional, and critical, and there’s no such thing as short and sweet in my world. I want to say and do it all. Mr. Brooch grounds me. I point where to go and he figures out the way. He’s a pragmatic fancy-pants who enjoys video games and movies. We both adore our mutt, Rocky, and spending time with our amazingly supportive family and friends. We’re planning a garden wedding with a formal reception with lots of whimsy and unique, Southern-inspired details.
About Mrs. Brooch

The bad news is that I don’t have a picture of my dress. Boo! I know! Totally lame. Especially after all you’ve been through to this point, bearing with my whining about not being able to make a choice and then voting (thank you all so, so much for your votes!).

I’m dying to show you my final pick, believe me. I’m so relieved to have finally made a decision. But with all of the chaos at Kleinfeld for Say Yes to the Dress, a picture was the furthest thing from my mind!

I may try to find a sample locally, try it on again, and take a few pictures for the hive, but if not, my hope is that you’ll see it on TV! What better reveal is there than that?

The good news is that before picking my dress, my favorites were the same as yours! I was still considering three (numbers 5, 9, & 11) standing in Kleinfeld, but the more I thought about each one, the happier I was I didn’t settle with any of them.

Why I Didn't Pick Dresses 5, 9, or 11 :  wedding arlington wedding dress Untitle1 Untitle

Here goes nothing!

My true feelings about the top contenders…

Dress 5

I could have worn this dress to my wedding without qualms. It was truly much of what I imagined my wedding gown would encompass: the taffeta, the modified A-line silhouette, and little bit of bling along the sweetheart neckline. Definitely a winner. Like many of you, I think this dress would have been a nice fit for a Sunday afternoon, outdoor wedding. It was light and airy, and flattering. I’m so glad that so many of you liked it.

What I wasn’t crazy about was the train, which you can’t see pictured here, but it wasn’t what I had in mind.

While this dress remains my favorite of ALL those I tried, it lacked a little something and definitely doesn’t beat out the one I did ultimately pick.

Why I Didn't Pick Dresses 5, 9, or 11 :  wedding arlington wedding dress P1011391 P101139

Dress 9

Each and everyone of you read right through my snippet about this dress. MY DRESS, I said and rightfully so as I have lusted after it for more than a year. Imagining my wedding day, I always imagined this dress, because it was feminine and flowy; it was sexy and sleek; it represented a beautiful mature me!

When I tried it on for the first time (in the picture below), it definitely didn’t disappoint. Whereas I thought my back might be too thick or my arms might be too big or the front might be to low cut, none of it was the case. It looked fabulous and I felt fabulous in it.

The only piece missing, which was for me a really big piece, was it feeling like a wedding gown. It was almost too flowy. It was too much like an evening gown, something casual, than it was (for me) the perfect dress for our wedding. I would have felt under-dressed.

I don’t think it was at all what Mr. B had in mind for me, either. We watched the show Four Weddings the other night and one of the brides had a T-back dress. He said, “Oh no she didn’t!” Mind you, hers was much more low cut in the front, but still. It wasn’t traditional enough for either of our tastes.

There’s no doubt, though, that I still love it…

Why I Didn't Pick Dresses 5, 9, or 11 :  wedding arlington wedding dress 2010 101 2010-10

Dress 11

To be 100 percent honest, I was getting ready to purchase dress 11 when I posted the vote. It was my pick. It was the last dress I had found (at Rosalin’s Bridal) and seriously hugged the sales lady, yelling out, “this is it!”

I told you I was the girl who cried dress…

It was between the two dresses above and the Maggie Sottero Rachelle (dress 10), when I tried on this dress. My mom and I were shocked, because we weren’t expecting to find something ELSE to add to our list of favorites, but we couldn’t get over the way the dress hugged my waist. I loved my figure!

In hindsight, I’m so glad I didn’t buy this dress! It’s too much! There’s beading and bling everywhere! The other thing I thought of when I decided against this dress was how hot I would be! I only had the dress on for about 10 or 15 minutes in the dressing room, and I was sweating! Mama Brooch swears the dressing room was just small, but the last thing I want is to be uncomfortable and hot in a dress I’m wearing all day and night.

Nevertheless, it’s a beautiful gown. I think it’s still my mom’s favorite, but I just think it was too much for me. It’s still pretty, though! They all are!

Why I Didn't Pick Dresses 5, 9, or 11 :  wedding arlington wedding dress P1011431 P101143

So there you have it: how I talked myself out of my favorite three wedding dresses! What else is new, right? Now there’s NO TURNING BACK with the gown I DID purchase! The reveal is coming soon. :) I hope you all like it as much as you loved these guys! Thank you again for your votes!

Did you talk yourself out of any dress favorites?

Up next: My latest obsessions: accessories and cathedral veils! :)

Tags: arlington, wedding-dress |
advertisement below
Newer blog post
more in Blog
Older blog post
Newer blog post by Mrs. Brooch
more by Mrs. Brooch (oldest)
Older blog post by Mrs. Brooch

12 Responses to “Why I Didn’t Pick Dresses 5, 9, or 11”

1.
finlandfairy
Member
finlandfairy (message)  131 posts, Blushing bee

Wow at 9. SPARKLY! I do love sparkles :)

 
2.
moderndaisy
Member
moderndaisy (message)  6,607 posts, Bee Keeper

I totally talked myself out of my #1 pick. I actually had an appointment to go in and be measured and put down a deposit and the night before I freaked out and showed DH a picture b/c I knew there was something wrong. Sure enough, he agreed it was way too plain for our fancy ballroom wedding so I left a VM with the salon cancelling my appointment. I kept trying and eventually came across my perfect dream dress :)

 
3.
pansyshell
Member
pansyshell (message)  1,955 posts, Buzzing bee

I had liked dress 9 in a magazine. When I showed it to DH he said the same things as you guys…it wasn’t a wedding dress in our minds and spoke more of an evening gowned. I’m sure your dress is perfect!

 
4.
Guest Icon
Guest
Katie

Thanks for explaining! I’m DYING to see the dress you did pick! So excited for you. :-)

 
5.
Guest Icon
Guest
menobride

I LOVE that first dress. And, I AM having a Sunday garden wedding!

I already bought my dress, but….
What is that first one?

 
6.
Entangled
Member
Entangled (message)  2,616 posts, Sugar bee

I tried on your dress 5 the other day (and thought about your post about it even). I loved loved loved the low back but it wasn’t right for me, either.

I am having so much decision and drama… going back and looking at my pictures of my trip last Saturday is changing my mind about everything and a new dress is emerging as my favorite. Argh, pressure!

 
7.
Member Icon
Member
hopeandpray (message)  250 posts, Helper bee

Excited to see what you picked! Those are 3 great dresses but it’s good to see why they weren’t the one for you

 
8.
jordynrose
Member
jordynrose (message)  6,351 posts, Bee Keeper

Now I want to see what you picked!

 
9.
jgoulart
Member
jgoulart (message)  1,069 posts, Bumble bee

I had three contenders while shopping too, it’s tough!

 
10.
Guest Icon
Guest
Sexy Shirt Dresses « Her Shoe Addiction, Inc

[...] Why I Didn’t Pick Dresses 5, 9, or 11 (weddingbee.com) [...]

 
11.
Guest Icon
Guest
Cawuk

it was greatly riveting to look over http://www.weddingbee.com
I call for to reproduce your register in my blog. It can?
And you et an account on Twitter?

 
12.
Guest Icon
Guest
Cynthia

Each style was so distinctly different from each other! No wonder it was a hard choice

 

Leave a Reply


You can also just...

Newer blog post
more in Blog
Older blog post
Newer blog post by Mrs. Brooch
more by Mrs. Brooch (oldest)
Older blog post by Mrs. Brooch

Visit our sister sites eHarmony
Online Dating
eHarmony Advice
Dating Advice
Project Wedding
Wedding Songs
JustMommies
Pregnancy Calendar

Copyright 2004-2012, Weddingbee.com
 

Find your vendors on Weddingbee

Real reviews from brides in your area!

Favors by Weddingbee

  • Favors by season

Shop Now »

Mrs. Brooch
Mrs. Brooch

Mrs. Brooch, Arlington, VA Age and Occupation: 25, Writer/Editor Fiance's Age and Occupation: 29, Front Desk Manager Engagement Date: October 3, 2009 Wedding Date: April 2011 Venue: Oxon Hill Manor About Me: I’m an indecisive girlie-girl with a motor mouth, can-do attitude, and knack for making others laugh. I dream of becoming a best selling novelist like Elizabeth Gilbert or Julie Powell (a girl can dream, right?), and love long road trips, a beautiful countryside, music, blogs, books, and all things vintage/thrift/antique/or homemade. I’m a Virgo, i.e. overly sensitive, emotional, and critical, and there’s no such thing as short and sweet in my world. I want to say and do it all. Mr. Brooch grounds me. I point where to go and he figures out the way. He’s a pragmatic fancy-pants who enjoys video games and movies. We both adore our mutt, Rocky, and spending time with our amazingly supportive family and friends. We’re planning a garden wedding with a formal reception with lots of whimsy and unique, Southern-inspired details.

Boards
Classifieds

Blog Calendar
February 2012
SunMonTueWedThuFriSat
2930311234
567891011
12131415161718
19202122232425
26272829

Weddingbee Bios
Wiki
More