Newer blog post
more in Blog
Older blog post
Newer blog post by Mrs. Cardigan
more by Mrs. Cardigan (oldest)
Older blog post by Mrs. Cardigan
Mrs. Cardigan's Picture
Mrs. Cardigan, Austin Age and Occupation: 21, Student/Soon-to-be Special Education Teacher Fiance's Age and Occupation: 20, Student/Soon-to-be Accounting Systems Analyst Engagement Date: August 16, 2009 Wedding Date: January 2011 Venue: Vintage Villas About Me: I'm a native Austinite who was raised as a die-hard Aggie. Luckily, I'm a pretty persuasive girl because I managed to convince my high school boyfriend (now fiance!), Mr. Cardigan, to ditch his hardcore Longhorn ways and join me up at A&M, where we currently reside with our adorable dogs, Cullen & Ranger. We're currently planning a bright, cheery wedding with a ridiculous amount of DIY projects that I can't wait to tackle! I love crafting in any form, reading, and margaritas (I think I love them the most!). Organization is what keeps me sane and I love helping others, which is probably why I ended up as an education major. It gets a little chaotic sometimes when you're planning a wedding among all of the papers, projects, finals, and certification exams, but we're having the time of our lives and we can't wait to get started on our journey as husband and wife - and we're so excited to share our wedding with the hive!
About Mrs. Cardigan

On Becoming a Family

November 16th, 2010 @ 12:35 pm by Mrs. Cardigan

One thing that has been really weird for me to accept is the idea that now that Mr. Cardigan and I are getting married, his family is my family, and vice versa.

That’s not to say that I don’t feel that he’s become a part of my family (I absolutely do!) or that I don’t feel welcome in his, but it’s just an odd idea to me that I will call his brother my brother and he will call my sister his sister. And the weirdest part of it all for me?

The holidays.

Mr. Cardigan and I have had many, many long discussions on how we plan to split up the holidays and it definitely isn’t an easy decision to make.

Mr. Cardigan originally wanted to alternate years with our families, but I am adamantly against that idea. I’m a sucker for tradition and I like things to stay the same from year to year. So, we decided that we’d do Thanksgiving with one side of the family and Christmas with the other.

Annnnd that’s where the hard part comes in. How do you choose which side of the family gets which holiday? We went back and forth a lot over this, and what it boiled down to was this: I have never not woken up in my home on Christmas morning (except last year when we spent Christmas with Mr. C’s family, but I’m not counting that). And I don’t want that to ever change. And I want my children to have that same experience. I want our little immediate family to be able to have traditions of our own that no one else is a part of. I want to wake up at home and make breakfast for my family and watch my kids open their presents in the comfort of our own home. After that, we can spent the rest of the holiday with other people, but it is absolutely vital to me that we at least wake up in our own home on Christmas.

Once Mr. Cardigan heard my reasoning and realized exactly how important it is to me to have Christmas at home, the decision was kind of made for us. We’ll do Thanksgiving with his family (who celebrates in a different city from where we live) and Christmas with mine, who celebrates in Austin. Mr. Cardy wasn’t too excited about the idea at first, but once he realized that we can still celebrate Christmas with his family in the weeks before or after Christmas, he felt much better about the arrangement.

So, this year is the first year we will be doing things this way. And to be honest, I’m kind of weirded out by it. I mean, I’ve never in my life spent Thanksgiving anywhere else but at my grandmother’s house. It’s the same every year, with entirely too many people crammed into her tiny little lake house, and it’s loud and rambunctious and there are dogs running all over the place. But, it’s just what Thanksgiving is to me. Mr. Cardigan, on the other hand, attends Thanksgiving at his grandfather’s house which is much, much larger and fancier. They have different food than we do, different traditions (as in, they don’t watch the A&M vs. TU game. What’s up with that?!) and just has a different feel altogether. But it’s officially my new tradition, so I guess I’d better get used to it.

Mr. Cardigan and I have felt like a family for quite some time now, but we’re actually putting that into action now. It’s been quite a journey for me thinking about the fact that in a few months, Mr. Cardigan will officially be my closest family member, and he’ll become a permanent fixture in my family’s Christmas celebrations, just as I will in his family’s Thanksgiving.

I’m so exited for all of the big changes on the horizon, and I’m trying to accept them without freaking out too much. I’m glad Mr. Cardigan and I have come to a holiday arrangement that we’re both happy with, and I can’t wait to see what our new holidays will look like!

How do/will you and your SO split holidays? Was it hard to come to a decision?

Tags: austin, family, relationships |
advertisement below
Newer blog post
more in Blog
Older blog post
Newer blog post by Mrs. Cardigan
more by Mrs. Cardigan (oldest)
Older blog post by Mrs. Cardigan

58 Responses to “On Becoming a Family”

1 2 3 

1.
Member Icon
Member
crayfish (message)  4,993 posts, Honey bee

So, when you guys have kids, you’re still going to sleep over at your parent’s house every Christmas Eve? Sounds lovely in theory, but logistically, maybe not as realistic? What about starting your own Christmas tradition in your own home?

We’ve got a much harder time with things - my parents are split between TX and CA, and with my husband’s family in DC, it just isn’t possible to recreate the childhood memories. So, we are making our own! We will have our very own “Chrismahannukah” this year. Yay for new families!

 
2.
Ms.Shamrock
Member
Ms.Shamrock (message)  481 posts, Helper bee

We’re still working it out. I absolutely LOVE LOVE LOVE spending Christmas at Mr. Shamrock’s younger sister’s house. I wouldn’t miss it for the world. But then to spend Thanksgiving and New Year’s at his older sister’s house? No deal. Even though as my parents get older, they want less to do with holidays, it’s unreasonable to expect that I would spend EVERY holiday with his family. Ever since my Gram passed, Thanksgiving is just a holiday about meat and men in knickers.
But like I said, we’re still working it out. :)

 
3.
Ms.Shamrock
Member
Ms.Shamrock (message)  481 posts, Helper bee

@crayfish: I think she means the home that she and Mr. PD have. Not her childhood home.

 
4.
Bee Icon
Bee
Miss Ostrich (message)  1,948 posts, Buzzing bee

this has also been a little tricky for me & Mr. Ostrich, too, as i am also fiercely loyal to my christmas family traditions. for us, the happy compromise is spend christmas eve as a couple, christmas day with my fam and drive/fly down to los angeles to spend the week after christmas with Mr. ostrich’s family. we tried this for the first time last year and it was just as magical as the actual day - we went ice skating, opened presents and had hot cocoa galore…wishing you the same magic, cardi!

 
5.
missjyc
Member
missjyc (message)  2,769 posts, Sugar bee

we’ve been lucky enough to have each year worked itself out for both thanksgiving and christmas holidays with both sides of our families.

we hosted thanksgiving to my side of the family and his parents who all live in the same area last year. (ILs have always done thanksgiving small with just the three (DH & the two of them))….

for Christmas, we spend christmas eve/morning together (just us, and our future children)…. then we go to mass with IL’s and eat brunch with them and do gifts. then we spend Christmas evening with my family. the wknd before or after (whichever is closer to the holiday) we drive up north with IL’s to see DH’s aunts/uncles/cousins who are about 1.5 hours away from us.

 
6.
mjchexum
Member
mjchexum (message)  485 posts, Helper bee

Fiance and I have been together 3 years and we still haven’t figured out a perfect solution. One of the problems being that my parents are divorced, and my dad is remarried, so I have a stepfamily that’s been part of my life for 15+ years that I’d like to spend holiday time with too. We’re still struggling to figure it all out.

 
7.
SerenaSF
Member
SerenaSF (message)  662 posts, Busy bee

I think when you are older and have already been living on your own for awhile this becomes a lot easier. Since the first year of dating my fiance (then boyfriend) and I started spending holidays together and dividing up where we spent them. We became the most important people to each other so it seemed crazy that we would spend major holidays and events apart. Christmas is a much bigger deal to me than it is to him, so we spend Christmas with my family and Thanksgiving with his. I couldn’t imagine it any other way, but I would have had a much harder time not spending all the holidays with my family when I was in my early 20s.

 
8.
Violet Violet
Member
Violet Violet (message)  985 posts, Busy bee

This is tricky. But so far it’s worked. We spend Christmas Eve with my family, which is our tradition–we open gifts at midnight. Then on Christmas morning we drive up to his mom’s house and spend Christmas day with her. This year, I’m staying home bc he’s deployed.

 
9.
Miss Palmetto
Member
Miss Palmetto (message)  52 posts, Worker bee

We haven’t actually talked about how all this will work…mostly because we are from the same hometown which makes things MUCH easier. But I feel like we will probably always spend T’giving with my fiance’s family at their beach house. Its a huge deal for them and always such a great time…in fact I am going for a few days without him this year as he has to work over Thanksgiving at the hospital. Christmas we will just split…and we can literally drive down the street about a mile to the other’s house…we know, we’ve got it good!

 
10.
Member Icon
Member
Joanna910 (message)  65 posts, Worker bee

I totally understand and feel like I am in the same situation as you. Every thanksgiving and Christmas I have been with my immediate family and I love it. I love our traditions but I can’t ask my fiance to give up his family and his traditions. So we are going to be switching back and forth between families each year for the holidays. Once we have kids I am sure this will change and we will do Christmas at our own home so that the kids can wake up and do the special traditions that we make ourselves. It is hard to give up the old, but I guess with marriage that means starting a new family and new traditions.

 
11.
Member Icon
Member
eeper (message)  486 posts, Helper bee

I nearly cried the first time I spent Christmas away from my family. It was so different, but I think it’s a part of growing up. We both love Christmas so we could never stick with seeing just one family. We don’t have any hard & fast rules, but we knew this year we would spend Christmas with my family so we will do Thanksgiving with his. Last year was the opposite.

One thing I am really looking forward to when we buy a house and have kids is to start our own traditions, and let the relatives come to us sometimes!

 
12.
SandraMarie_1986
Member
SandraMarie_1986 (message)  1,363 posts, Bumble bee

I know exactly what you mean about waking up at home and making breakfast and opening gifts. It’s just home. That’s how I grew up too. We’re still having issue with how to spend the holidays but we’re making it work. I’m so glad to hear you two found a way to spend time with both sides of the family.

 
13.
Guest Icon
Guest
Jenny

I love the part about the A&M vs. TU game!! I am a big Aggies fan and that is a big part of our families thanksgiving tradtition!

 
14.
Bee Icon
Bee
Miss Panther (message)  1,046 posts, Bumble bee

I’m not going to lie, I think this is going to be my least favorite part of being married. So far, I’ve refused to leave my mother for Christmas (after my dad died, I had a pretty good excuse) and have convinced Mr. Panther to come with me for a couple of those years, but I think this is the last year I’m going to get away with it. The idea of waking up in someone else’s houses on Christmas morning is just horrible to me. Horrible, horrible, horrible. I know, I’m a huge baby — but I can’t help it!

 
15.
Whimsical.Sprite
Member
Whimsical.Sprite (message)  828 posts, Busy bee

Last year we did both holidays at both houses (a lot of driving). Thankfully both of our families are very accomodating, and we work it out where we have a holiday on two different days.

Thus, this year we spend actual Thanksgiving with his family and “Saturday Thanksgiving” at my parents. Next year actual Thanksgiving will be with my family and “Saturday Thanksgiving” will be with his side.

I feel like everybody wins that way. After all, it isn’t about having the actual holiday on the actual day. It is about seeing family and spending time with them regardless of the “day”.

 
16.
MissMeg
Member
MissMeg (message)  353 posts, Helper bee

This has been a long discussion for us as well. We are planning on alternating years with Thanksgiving - his family gets us this year. And until we have kids, we’re going to do Christmas Eve with his family and Christmas Day with mine. That was a fairly easy decisions since his family opens all the presents and everything on Christmas Eve and mine does on Christmas Day. It’s a 2.5 hour drive…. but it’s do-able. Once we have kids we’ll probably do our own Christmas Eve/Day stuff and see family in the weeks before and after Christmas.

 
17.
Guest Icon
Guest
csn279

You didn’t mention how Mr. Cardigan’s parents feel about the arrangement? As the mother of a recent groom, it would make me sad if my son and daughter-in-law never wanted to spend Christmas with us…I’m willing to share holidays with my DIL’s family (they live in another part of the state). And being a daughter-in-law myself, I made it a point through the years to always give fair time to both sides of our family. I have to say, compromise is the key! Good luck to you, I hope everyone is happy with your arrangements :)

 
18.
Member Icon
Member
Rose_Dust (message)  13 posts, Newbee

I’m so glad you brought this up. I am currently struggling with this issue. I love tradition and the traditions that my family had made over the years and the idea of giving any of it up really hurts. I know that it isn’t about just me anymore but I wish I could have it both ways. So I think the solution we’ve come up with so far is that we’re going to spend christmas eve with his family in Ohio and then drive 2 hours back home that night hopefully in time to make the 11pm church service which has become a staple to me. Then we’ll do presents and traditions at my parents house in the morning. I’m sure things will change when kids are in the picture but for now that’s how we’re going to try it.

 
19.
Ms. Anemone
Member
Ms. Anemone (message)  624 posts, Busy bee

Thanks for sharing this, Cardy.
I am big on the waking-up-at-home-on-Christmas bit, too. There’s just nothing like it.
@MissMeg: we’re thinking something similar until we have kids. (only our travel is a 2.5hr plane ride!)

 
20.
totheislnds
Member
totheislnds (message)  5,411 posts, Bee Keeper

This is something i have struggled with because if i had it my way i would spend every holiday with my family. Luckily for the time being his family is only an hour from my parents so its very possible to see both families on the holidays. This is my last year of being “single” and i plan to spend every freaking moment with my family and take it all in because next year we will have to figure out which house to go to.

 
1 2 3 

Leave a Reply


You can also just...

Newer blog post
more in Blog
Older blog post
Newer blog post by Mrs. Cardigan
more by Mrs. Cardigan (oldest)
Older blog post by Mrs. Cardigan

Visit our sister sites eHarmony
Online Dating
eHarmony Advice
Dating Advice
Project Wedding
Wedding Songs
JustMommies
Pregnancy Calendar

Copyright 2004-2012, Weddingbee.com
 

Find your vendors on Weddingbee

Real reviews from brides in your area!

Favors by Weddingbee

  • Favors by season

Shop Now »

Mrs. Cardigan
Mrs. Cardigan

Mrs. Cardigan, Austin Age and Occupation: 21, Student/Soon-to-be Special Education Teacher Fiance's Age and Occupation: 20, Student/Soon-to-be Accounting Systems Analyst Engagement Date: August 16, 2009 Wedding Date: January 2011 Venue: Vintage Villas About Me: I'm a native Austinite who was raised as a die-hard Aggie. Luckily, I'm a pretty persuasive girl because I managed to convince my high school boyfriend (now fiance!), Mr. Cardigan, to ditch his hardcore Longhorn ways and join me up at A&M, where we currently reside with our adorable dogs, Cullen & Ranger. We're currently planning a bright, cheery wedding with a ridiculous amount of DIY projects that I can't wait to tackle! I love crafting in any form, reading, and margaritas (I think I love them the most!). Organization is what keeps me sane and I love helping others, which is probably why I ended up as an education major. It gets a little chaotic sometimes when you're planning a wedding among all of the papers, projects, finals, and certification exams, but we're having the time of our lives and we can't wait to get started on our journey as husband and wife - and we're so excited to share our wedding with the hive!

Boards
Classifieds

Blog Calendar
February 2012
SunMonTueWedThuFriSat
2930311234
567891011
12131415161718
19202122232425
26272829

Weddingbee Bios
by machop93
by IsaiahFountain
by greencl3
by ymaldonado
Wiki
More