Newer blog post
more in Blog
Older blog post
Newer blog post by Mrs. Pony
more by Mrs. Pony (oldest)
Older blog post by Mrs. Pony
Mrs. Pony's Picture
Mrs. Pony, Bloomington, IL Age and Occupation: 25, Attorney Fiance's Age and Occupation: 34, Attorney Engagement Date: March 22, 2010 Wedding Date: September 2011 Venue: Mackinaw Valley Vineyard; Bloomington Center for the Performing Arts About Me: I found my Southern counterpart in law school and since he popped the question last March, we have been busy graduating, job searching, bar taking, and wedding planning. My loves include must see TV, magnets, quotes, anything green, my car, fun socks, the Cubs, and my Mr. Together we love wine, playing outside, and exploring the world together. Stay tuned to see our Midwest wedding full of Southern charm, vintage flair, lots of DIY details, and a whole lot o’ wine.
About Mrs. Pony

Carnation Quandary

May 13th, 2011 @ 3:03 pm by Mrs. Pony

I have never been particularly fond of carnations. I always thought they were a cheap flower used to fill out an inexpensive arrangement. I considered carnations to be the “ugly” flower. Probably because of that scene from The Wedding Planner where JLo’s boss, Kathy Najimy, tells her assistant she cannot have carnations near her and to take the “ugly flower” out of her sight. Anyone recall that? Or anyone else base their world view on movies besides me? No? Whatever, I know you do too.

Carnation Quandary :  wedding bloomington flowers Kathjlo kathjlo

Image credit: Columbia Pictures via Yahoo Movies

Not the exact scene, but you know what I’m talking about.

I also associate carnations with those junior-high flower exchanges where the color of the carnation signified how the sender felt about you. My lack of a relationship was always very apparent after those damn flower days. Teenage angst over flowers is hard to forget.

But back to the point. Carnations. They’re flowers. Flowers I’ve never particularly cared for, but now that I’m considering which flowers to incorporate into our wedding, the more I appreciate carnations’ virtues. Carnations are available in a wide variety of colors year round, they are inexpensive, and they have pretty amazing lasting power.

A couple of weeks ago I was schooled on just how hearty carnations are. I got this carnation two weeks ago from a vendor at a (waste-of-time) wedding show:

Carnation Quandary :  wedding bloomington flowers Carnati carnati

My flower. Heehee. *personal picture*

When we got home from the show I cut the stem off, filled my bud vase with some tepid water, stuck my carnation in said vase, and forgot about the damn thing. I tend to do that with a lot of things. Which I’m thinking does not bode well for my future offspring.

Anyway, despite my complete lack of effort to care for it, this carnation has generally managed to stay pert after two weeks. It started to lose its shape and wilt more in the past few days, but I am still very impressed with its longevity. This is especially promising given that our wedding will be outside in the September heat.

This little flower opened my eyes and has me reconsidering my stance on carnations. And, after a bit of research, I am seeing how beautiful these flowers can be when bunched together.

Carnation Quandary :  wedding bloomington flowers Carn5 carn5

Photo by Lucas Allen for Real Simple / Via Intimate Weddings / DIY tutorial at Real Simple

Carnation Quandary :  wedding bloomington flowers Carn1 carn1

Image credit: Carolyn Roehm

Carnation Quandary :  wedding bloomington flowers Carn2 carn2

Image credit: Martha Stewart Weddings

Carnation Quandary :  wedding bloomington flowers Carn4 carn4

Flowers by pd Bloom / Via Intimate Weddings

Carnations paired with roses can give a lush, monochromatic look:

Carnation Quandary :  wedding bloomington flowers Carn3 carn3

Image Credit: Carolyn Roehm

My only concern when looking at these inspiration pictures is that these arrangements are very sculptured and modern looking, which is not the vibe we are going for. I’m not sure what our vibe is exactly, but modern it is not.

So, carnations: a lovely and cheap flower choice, or were my preconceived notions correct?

Tags: bloomington, flowers |
advertisement below
Newer blog post
more in Blog
Older blog post
Newer blog post by Mrs. Pony
more by Mrs. Pony (oldest)
Older blog post by Mrs. Pony

31 Responses to “Carnation Quandary”

1 2 

1.
Bee Icon
Bee
Mrs. Quiche (message)  3,160 posts, Sugar bee

Carrie Bradshaw loved carnations & I do, too! :) I love when they are grouped together - so pretty!

 
2.
vintagemodernbride
Member
vintagemodernbride (message)  316 posts, Helper bee

carnations are definitely making a comeback in wedding world. i say go for it! they’re cute and fluffy and come in so many colors :) they look great bunched up instead of just by themselves (imho)

 
3.
peacockchris
Member
peacockchris (message)  369 posts, Helper bee

I think carnations are gorgeous. I like them better when used by themselves, not mixed in with other flowers.

 
4.
bebefly
Member
bebefly (message)  1,348 posts, Bumble bee

I LOVE carnations. They’re so freaking pretty! Especially a bunch of them….which is why they’re half my centerpieces :) You seriously can’t go wrong!

 
5.
Member Icon
Member
pumpkinclouds (message)  164 posts, Blushing bee

I love carnations too. My mum had them in her wedding bouquet and my dad buys them for her every year on their anniversary, so I’m probably biased by happy memories, but personally I just think they’re beautiful

 
6.
Bee Icon
Bee
Mrs. Seashell (message)  1,713 posts, Bumble bee

You can put me in the “cheap/prom” category. I’ve never been a fan. BUT the arrangements you posted are actually quite pretty! I think it’s all about creating volume.

 
7.
Bee Icon
Bee
Miss High Wire (message)  754 posts, Busy bee

Love me some carnations!!

 
8.
Member Icon
Member
angeljessie54 (message)  79 posts, Worker bee

I think the carnations pictured above are very pretty! I too had the same missconception of the flower from middle school days! I personaly was sad that my hydrangeas started to wilt sooner than I would have liked - later in the evening of the reception. In April, though it wasn’t outdoors, the building was only cooled by fans and open doors. Not uncomfortable, but no AC blaring.

I say go for it!

 
9.
Bee Icon
Bee
Miss Candy Apple (message)  1,465 posts, Bumble bee

Those first two are totally gorgeous. And I love how they smell :) I think that you could definitely group them with other flowers - I think they would actually look particularly nice with some non-florals, like leafy ferns or something. So pretty :)

 
10.
Member Icon
Member
MaesieLaBird (message)  47 posts, Newbee

Carnations were my Grammy’s FAVORITE flower so they also hold a special place in my heart. I’m going to have a lot of carnations at my wedding :)

 
11.
Bee Icon
Bee
Miss Hyena (message)  1,881 posts, Buzzing bee

OMG. I NEED those carnation balls in the flower pots! Why did you wait until a week before my wedding to post this?!?!?! Aaaaah!

 
12.
Miss Feather
Member
Miss Feather (message)  364 posts, Helper bee

I love them bunched together! I am the same boat as you I want them for my centerpieces but then I dont want guests to thinks I got them because I am cheap so I am leaning towards Hydrangea now lol same volume and pretty good cost

 
13.
Guest Icon
Guest
FluffyVallieres

Wow those pictures have converted me to the carnation side… GORGEOUS!

 
14.
aunt pol
Member
aunt pol (message)  1,473 posts, Bumble bee

That pic from Real Simple convinced me. I used pale pink and cream carnations for my bm bouquets, lots of them bunched together, and they’re so pretty. I used them for the tables then, in bud vases, with lots of candles as well, but I wanted v simple centrepieces. I used pale peonies and lisianthus then for my bouquet, but the carnations were wonderful. And they still look great a week later, and they were dead easy to work. Go for it! Be generous with them, is the main thing, I think.

 
15.
Guest Icon
Guest
Melissa

I have them in my house all the time–4 or 5 tightly gathered in a little vase on my coffee table makes me super happy. I think they got a bum rap somewhere along the way.

 
16.
Guest Icon
Guest
SusieQ

I think carnations are… okay. Done wrong (ie with baby’s breath) I think they look tacky. At first I thought about doing huge carnation bunches for my wedding, too. But then I priced it out and they are not that cheap. I mean the individual carnations are cheap, but it takes SO MANY carnations to create a full centerpiece like the ones you have pictured that it was one of the more expensive centerpiece options. If you’re looking for volume, I would go with hydrangeas.

 
17.
Kcoleybear
Member
Kcoleybear (message)  683 posts, Busy bee

I, like you, had a dislike of carnations also stemming form the very dramatic scene in The Wedding Planner, where J. Lo’s boss threatens to deport her assistant if he puts another carnation in her bouquet. But now I am planning a wedding and am on a budget I began to consider them. We did not end up using them, but I do love the look of them all bunched together. I would look at different containers. This could make them look less modern and structural.

 
18.
mymelody
Member
mymelody (message)  12 posts, Newbee

Charlotte from Sex and the City called them “filler flowers” but I personally like them and think they’re gorgeous. I say, go with what makes you happy!

 
19.
Guest Icon
Guest
Christina

May I suggest, since carnations are pretty cheap, just buy some “bouquets” from the grocery store and experiment. I think you will find that Carnations works in lots of ways. Your photos were very sculpture like but I have seen carnations look great in looser settings. They also help fill in and support other flowers in a bouquet so you can stretch your dollar.

 
20.
mrspaetz
Member
mrspaetz (message)  3,805 posts, Honey bee

I used to think they were ‘meh’ until I saw how visually striking they look when bunched together!

 
1 2 

Leave a Reply


You can also just...

Newer blog post
more in Blog
Older blog post
Newer blog post by Mrs. Pony
more by Mrs. Pony (oldest)
Older blog post by Mrs. Pony

Visit our sister sites eHarmony
Online Dating
eHarmony Advice
Dating Advice
Project Wedding
Wedding Songs
JustMommies
Pregnancy Calendar

Copyright 2004-2012, Weddingbee.com
 

Find your vendors on Weddingbee

Real reviews from brides in your area!

Favors by Weddingbee

  • Favors by season

Shop Now »

Mrs. Pony
Mrs. Pony

Mrs. Pony, Bloomington, IL Age and Occupation: 25, Attorney Fiance's Age and Occupation: 34, Attorney Engagement Date: March 22, 2010 Wedding Date: September 2011 Venue: Mackinaw Valley Vineyard; Bloomington Center for the Performing Arts About Me: I found my Southern counterpart in law school and since he popped the question last March, we have been busy graduating, job searching, bar taking, and wedding planning. My loves include must see TV, magnets, quotes, anything green, my car, fun socks, the Cubs, and my Mr. Together we love wine, playing outside, and exploring the world together. Stay tuned to see our Midwest wedding full of Southern charm, vintage flair, lots of DIY details, and a whole lot o’ wine.

Boards
Classifieds

Blog Calendar
February 2012
SunMonTueWedThuFriSat
2930311234
567891011
12131415161718
19202122232425
26272829

Weddingbee Bios
Wiki
More