Newer blog post
more in Blog
Older blog post
Newer blog post by Mrs. Seal
more by Mrs. Seal (oldest)
Older blog post by Mrs. Seal
Mrs. Seal's Picture
Mrs. Seal, San Francisco Age and Occupation: 25, Personal Assistant Fiance's Age and Occupation: 29, Sales and Support Specialist Engagement Date: December 12, 2009 Wedding Date: November 2011 Venue: Sts Peter and Paul Church/The Bently Reserve About Me: I am a goofy, wannabe crafty, well-intentioned Renaissance Woman (OK, perhaps "aimless wanderer" is a more aptly suited term for me, but hopefully you get the point)—basically I dabble in just about everything and pride myself in such. Without warning, I occasionally breakout into soulful improvised songs and interpretive dances and there's just no stopping me! As so many others before me, planning our wedding has unearthed a deep, intense passion for all things bridal and I secretly fear the day it will come to an end. Mr. Seal and I are quite the pair and life with him by my side is extremely rewarding—I am so thankful to have found him. Together we are planning a black-tie San Francisco affair for 250—light on the stuffiness and with lots of extra Seal-y flair.
About Mrs. Seal

Prior to planning my own nuptials, I had never attended a wedding expecting an open bar. I kind of always hope there will be beer, wine and perhaps spirits for purchase, but in the rare occasion that a full on open bar is provided-I am legitimately surprised and grateful.

Open Bar Vs. Cash Bar: Zach the Beverage Guy Reigns Supreme :  wedding alcohol san francisco Img 9046

The Seals at my cousin’s wedding reception (Not only was it open bar-it was at a bar!)

When it came time to decide upon the type of bar that we would be providing at our own wedding, I’ll admit I was a little naive. I figured, because I never expected free alcohol, that our guests would come to our reception with a pocket full of cash ready to purchase their own drinks-and was thus set on a cash bar.

Now, let me clarify for a moment here-I am by no means implying that having a cash bar (or no bar, for that matter) is naive, simply that my initial decision (without weighing all of the options) was such.

It was soon brought to my attention that asking guests to fly/drive out to San Francisco, pay for hotel accommodations, buy us a wedding gift and then purchase their own alcohol at a party for us was a decision at least worth thinking twice about.

So I did.

And I had a complete change of heart. I soon realized that, for me, having an open bar was something I really cared about. I’ve never hosted a party and expected guests to pay for refreshments before, so why start with our wedding? Plus, our families really do like to drink-paying for a bar service on their behalf would likely be a much better bargain than having them dish out “per drink” rates.

So I decided I would at least look into it and honestly, hive, I was really surprised by what I discovered. Our venue has only one preferred vendor when it comes to beverage catering (yeah, I didn’t know “beverage caterers” existed either), which definitely initially scared me. What if their rates were outrageous? How much would it cost to buy them out and provide my own alcohol? How much is alcohol insurance?! I was a nervous wreck while I waited for the quote.

But then the clouds parted, a light shined down upon me and Zach the beverage guy (whom I’ve never met but imagine to look A LOT like Zeus) said, “HEY CRAZY FACE, YOU CAN TOTALLY AFFORD US! AND WE’RE AMAZING! BOOZE FOR ALL.” (Ok, I paraphrased a bit, but you get the point.) I was even more surprised to learn that their “service only” (cash bar) option was only marginally cheaper than the full on open bar.

Open Bar Vs. Cash Bar: Zach the Beverage Guy Reigns Supreme :  wedding alcohol san francisco 1528151 1528151

Background photo via EyeFetch/Photo of Zeus via Peperonity/Tastefully edited by me

(For full disclosure-our reception is scheduled to run from 5pm-12AM, but we are closing the bar at 10. It’s a bit of a compromise, but I figure five hours of gratis imbibing should do the trick, no?)

I know that the “Open Bar vs Cash Bar” debate can be a bit of a hot button topic and I want to make something clear-though Emily Post would have likely disagreed, I truly believe that each couple knows what works best for them. For example, not every family likes tequila as much as mine does and not every budget allows for five hours of free-flowing booze-definitely consider each option thoughtfully, but do only what you can.

OK. I’ll get off my soap box now. Time for a drink.

What, if any, type of bar are you providing at your wedding? How did you come to make that decision?

Tags: alcohol, san-francisco |
advertisement below
Newer blog post
more in Blog
Older blog post
Newer blog post by Mrs. Seal
more by Mrs. Seal (oldest)
Older blog post by Mrs. Seal

39 Responses to “Open Bar Vs. Cash Bar: Zach the Beverage Guy Reigns Supreme”

1 2 

1.
Bee Icon
Bee
Mrs. Prairie Dog (message)  400 posts, Helper bee

i felt the same way. an open bar, for us, was a given. but for some couples/families, what if half the guests don’t drink? an open bar might be so underutilized that it would be wasteful.

 
2.
Bee Icon
Bee
Mrs. Prairie Dog (message)  400 posts, Helper bee

PS “the same way” = that different things work for different people.

 
3.
Bee Icon
Bee
Miss Doily (message)  650 posts, Busy bee

I understand, Mr. D and I have really gone back and forth on this very question! I agree with Mrs. PD, different things work for different people! I’m glad you found what worked for you!

 
4.
Bee Icon
Bee
Mrs. Hyena (message)  1,882 posts, Buzzing bee

Totally makes sense. Our families are total beer and wine people, so it didn’t make sense for us to serve an open bar. Just beer and wine would do. :)

 
5.
Guest Icon
Guest
t

I know what you mean about it being different for everyone! My so’s family and my dad’s family, for instance, aren’t big on drinking at all, while my mom’s family and myself are huge wine drinkers, so we could honestly have just wine & champagne and everyone would be happy! Anything else would be overkill.

 
6.
Guest Icon
Guest
Future MRS Scott

We are having an open bar with a monetary cap on it. I figure its the best of both worlds

 
7.
Earlybride
Member
Earlybride (message)  1,875 posts, Buzzing bee

The only true reason why most couples say no to a open bar is because they cant afford it.Its as simple as that.My FI and I are having free beer but if they want something stronger they will need to buy it themselves.And even with the beer we have our limitations.We have given explicit instructions to not tap any new barrel without talking to my FI or I.Y?Because every barrel or keg that is tapped we are responsible for the cost of it.And we don’t want them to tap a new one if its 1-2-3 hours from the time the reception is ending and only one or a couple people want more beer.Can you imagine them tapping a huge keg and only a glass or two were given out from it?That’s money down the drain and does not make sense.Wasted money for us.Oh and I have NEVER been to an open bar wedding before either.Do what U WANT,NOT WHAT OTHERS TELL U U SHOULD.I don’t think people will leave your reception if its not an open bar and if they do that’s pathetic people and downright rude.

 
8.
Member
Margaritachka (message)  197 posts, Blushing bee

i’m russian. you go to a russian party you expect to see a bottle (and thensome) of top-shelf! vodka, tequila, and Cognac on the TABLE. Considering half our wedding is american, our compromise is having a open bar of top shelf alcohol….and believe me, this is definitely something my family is nervous about. But it’s all about compromises, and ab what works for you…

 
9.
Bee Icon
Bee
Miss Funnel Cake (message)  690 posts, Busy bee

Hahaha I love your clouds parting illustration. Highlarious.

Still not sure what our alcohol situation is. I mean, we’re having a brunch that starts at 10am and we have some fair amount of alcoholics in the family, so maybe open bar is not in the cards for us. But I’m all for them if money provides. Cheers! :D

 
10.
zippitydoodah
Member
zippitydoodah (message)  156 posts, Blushing bee

Oh I would never thought of having a cash bar. I’ve been to 17 weddings and only ONE had a cash bar, and even then it was for the last 2 hours only and until 11pm it was open bar. In fact, I worked as a banquet server for 2 years at a hotel and only 2 weddings in those 2 years were not open bar! Lordy you should have seen the riot that nearly broke out when my one cousin’s wedding had that 2 hours of pay bar! No one brought cash and were not expecting it and most people left shortly after. Maybe it’s a Catholic thing? (all 17 weddings have been Catholic).

I seriously didn’t realize that this wasn’t normal and that people had cash bars, but I guess it’s whatever your family/friends/you are used to! I think since all my cousins had open bars, to not pay for their drinks at my own wedding would be like not buying a wedding present for someone when they bought you one at their wedding…

 
11.
Member Icon
Member
jodiejulybride (message)  17 posts, Newbee

We don’t really drink ourselves and are having a lunch time reception (11:30am-2:30pm). More then half of our guest don’t drink. I thought that we should have an open bar because that’s just “what you do” but the man said “no” to the bar all together! He said we don’t drink, so why should we pay for those few who do! But we will have a champaign toast, as a compromise I think.

 
12.
zippitydoodah
Member
zippitydoodah (message)  156 posts, Blushing bee

also when reading about wedding etiquette (I was trying to figure out wedding invitations yeesh) every single thing I’ve read has said it is completely unacceptable to not at least provide wine and beer for free- they are your guests at a party and you are the host, they shouldn’t have to pay for drinks. Of course, I can’t keep track of all the wedding etiquette out there lol, so I guess so long as you’re sure no ones going to be offended at your wedding (or if you don’t care if people are offended- easier said than done in my opinion) than do what you want!

 
13.
kate02121
Member
kate02121 (message)  448 posts, Helper bee

I definitely agree that it’s what works best for each couple. I do think it’s interesting how much differentiation there is between expectations for different families, social groups, regions, ethnicities, and faiths in this respect.

Without this site, I’m not sure I ever would have been aware that this is even an issue, much less a hotly debated topic. We come from one of those areas/social groups where you typically do find an open bar, so we are going with that, but I won’t say I didn’t do any additional thinking on it after reading posts on the issue.

 
14.
Bee Icon
Bee
Miss Parasol (message)  2,142 posts, Buzzing bee

Wow, Seal, you did so much research and put so much thought into this! I’m impressed! Since Mr. Parasol and I are having an at-home reception, an open bar is pretty much out for us (way too much money), but it’s OK because our family and friends are mostly wine and beer people. So we’ll have a lot of that–oh, and a lot of sangria because it’s so yummy and will go with our Mexican dinner!

 
15.
bLISSFLbRDE
Member
bLISSFLbRDE (message)  119 posts, Blushing bee

@zippitydoodah: I totally agree!!!
I mean by all means if you want to come to MY wedding and pay for YOUR drink, Go right ahead!!!!I hope everyone sensed the sarcasm because I was laying it on pretty thick. I mean free drinks are free drinks. I am not a big drinker but if I was I d be an alcohol snob for sure. But, you know what? even as an alcohol snob, I would take free alcohol any day on the spot(if I was a drinker)!

 
16.
Gerbera
Member
Gerbera (message)  4,481 posts, Honey bee

I’ve never been to a wedding (Chinese or otherwise) where there was NOT an open bar so it was never a thought to me to do anything else? Didn’t even know other ways were done till weddingbee?
Full Open Bar was always a must for us…I mean come on my husband’s family is German AND Irish, was there really a question? ;)

 
17.
Bee Icon
Bee
Miss Macarons (message)  235 posts, Helper bee

Our venue requires us to use their beverage caterer. We were worried at first that it’d be outrageously expensive and that we wouldn’t be able to do some sort of open bar. I’m really happy his pricing is quite reasonable and the cost is about the same as if we were to do it ourselves.

 
18.
Guest Icon
Guest
captain plan-it

Are any of you from Canada? More specifically, Ontario? We aren’t able to “buy out the bar” and bring in our own alcohol. Open bar for us would mean paying $5 per mixed drink/wine and $4 per beer (or more). Open bar would be thousands of dollars that we don’t have, even just with 100 people or so. Is that how it works for all of you too?

 
19.
Member Icon
Member
BriarRose (message)  202 posts, Helper bee

My husband’s side of the family also love to drink at parties/weddings so having a cash bar was not an option as we just couldn’t charge our friends and family for drinks. We also found that cost difference between open and cash bar were minimal.

We had a cocktail hour with our signature drink, Margaritas, which were well priced by the gallon cocktails that complimented the fajita action station.
We then had an open bar from 6pm-10pm… at 10pm we had all the cousins and family our age get together for one last shot that was a delicious concoction made by the bartender.
There was really no need for anymore drinks past 10pm as many guests had already gone home and only family was left dancing the night away until 12am.

 
20.
Mrs. Elephant
Bee
Mrs. Elephant (message)  6,182 posts, Bee Keeper

I agree on being what works for each couple. We’ve been to weddings with no bar, open bar, cash bar, just wine… pretty much anything you can think of. We went with wine and beer and I think out of all of our guests, only a handful opted to pay to drink something other than beer or wine.

 
1 2 

Leave a Reply


You can also just...

Newer blog post
more in Blog
Older blog post
Newer blog post by Mrs. Seal
more by Mrs. Seal (oldest)
Older blog post by Mrs. Seal

Visit our sister sites eHarmony
Online Dating
eHarmony Advice
Dating Advice
Project Wedding
Wedding Songs
JustMommies
Pregnancy Calendar

Copyright 2004-2012, Weddingbee.com
 

Find your vendors on Weddingbee

Real reviews from brides in your area!

Favors by Weddingbee

  • Favors by season

Shop Now »

Mrs. Seal
Mrs. Seal

Mrs. Seal, San Francisco Age and Occupation: 25, Personal Assistant Fiance's Age and Occupation: 29, Sales and Support Specialist Engagement Date: December 12, 2009 Wedding Date: November 2011 Venue: Sts Peter and Paul Church/The Bently Reserve About Me: I am a goofy, wannabe crafty, well-intentioned Renaissance Woman (OK, perhaps "aimless wanderer" is a more aptly suited term for me, but hopefully you get the point)—basically I dabble in just about everything and pride myself in such. Without warning, I occasionally breakout into soulful improvised songs and interpretive dances and there's just no stopping me! As so many others before me, planning our wedding has unearthed a deep, intense passion for all things bridal and I secretly fear the day it will come to an end. Mr. Seal and I are quite the pair and life with him by my side is extremely rewarding—I am so thankful to have found him. Together we are planning a black-tie San Francisco affair for 250—light on the stuffiness and with lots of extra Seal-y flair.

Boards
Classifieds

Blog Calendar
February 2012
SunMonTueWedThuFriSat
2930311234
567891011
12131415161718
19202122232425
26272829

Weddingbee Bios
by FutureMrsGeels
by machop93
Wiki
More