Newer blog post
more in Blog
Older blog post
Newer blog post by Miss Porcupine
more by Miss Porcupine (oldest)
Older blog post by Miss Porcupine
Miss Porcupine's Picture
Miss Porcupine, NYC/Lancaster, PA Age and Occupation: 26, Sales Coordinator/Publishing Fiance's Age and Occupation: 26, Assistant Manager/Sales Engagement Date: August 8, 2010 Wedding Date: March 2012 Venue: Riverdale Manor About Me: I'm a born and bred New Yorker with a love/hate relationship for the city I have always called home. Although I may seem quiet from afar, I have a loud personality once you get to know me. I am a book nerd at heart, but love a night out in the city with good friends. I have a serious addiction to all things cheese, chocolate, cardigans, Mexican food, and reality TV. The future hubs and I met in college, settled in New York, and decided to go with a rustic/peacock infused wedding in Lancaster, PA, right near his hometown. Come the big day, we will be together 5 years, and we're looking forward to making it official!
About Miss Porcupine

City Slicka Meets Country

September 11th, 2011 @ 4:15 pm by Miss Porcupine

I can truly say that as a kid I never thought about my wedding. Like most little girls, I played house with my dolls and knew I wanted the real version of this marriage/kids situation someday. But, for whatever reason, I never imagined the wedding part.

I was never really interested in the whole “princess for a day” notion of a wedding. I still, to this day, don’t get it—why does marrying someone turn you into a princess? (Unless your husband is a prince, Kate Middleton.) I never oohed and ahhed when we drove by a wedding party or bride. I wasn’t even a tomboy; I just was unfazed by such things. I think I was too busy eating Yodels or something.

City Slicka Meets Country  :  wedding lancaster venues Porcupine

Mmmm, Yodels / Image via Drakes Cakes Online

So, when we got engaged I was sort of starting from the beginning.

After I realized Mr. Porcupine would truly never be cool with an elopement (yeah, like I said I’m an oddity—*I* want to elope and he does not), I started doing some research. It was then that I discovered sites like Style Me Pretty and learned about the whole rustic-chic, barnyard, farm, DIY wedding style that existed. Call me clueless, but growing up in NYC I never knew this was something people did.

City Slicka Meets Country  :  wedding lancaster venues Green B01 green_b01

Image via Green Wedding Shoes / Photo by Cameron Ingalls

City Slicka Meets Country  :  wedding lancaster venues 417 417

Image via Style Me Pretty / Photo by Jessica Smith Photography

City Slicka Meets Country  :  wedding lancaster venues England England

Image via Style Me Pretty / Photo by Candi Coffman Photography / Event planning & design by Zinke Design

I quickly realized this style does not exist, really at all, in NYC. Although I love a huge bash at a catering hall, the whole catering hall/classic ballroom style, which is most popular and readily available here, just doesn’t seem to fit us. (I see all my friends rolling their eyes right now—so guys, I SEE you. Quit it.) I also didn’t want a restaurant or loft wedding. Too artsy and modern for us. There are some rustic-type options outside of the city on Long Island and in New Jersey, but they were not exactly right or on the affordable end. (Long Island vineyards—YES! Price tag—NO. *Snookie wahhh*) I was never set on the idea of getting married in NYC, and this sealed the deal.

After three and a half years of dating Mr. Porcupine, I was pretty sure I liked the idea of getting married in Pennsylvania, where he grew up. His brother’s wedding was a tented reception on a giant farm and, yes, this city girl loved the country feel even though I’m pretty sure I am made out of concrete. Plus, there is something so refreshing and relaxing about whenever we get the chance to get out of the city and spend some time in Pennsylvania.

Luckily, Mr. Porcupine was fine with this. He liked the rustic idea I was throwing at him. He also agreed that the classic ballroom thing wasn’t really us. I did some Knot searches for venues in the area by his town (pre my discovery of Weddingbee). I found a few places I loved and showed them to Mr. Porcupine. He’s pretty laid back, so there was a lot of nodding, OK-ing, and “sounds good”-ing before he went back to reading Sports Illustrated headlines online.

So off we went a few weeks after our engagement to check out our top four or five. We didn’t plan to book one. We had already made plans pre-engagement to go down to visit Mr. Porcupine’s family. We figured, while we were there, why not look at a few places? We each already had a favorite we were leaning toward.

Was your venue search a mutual agreement?

Tags: lancaster, Venues |
advertisement below
Newer blog post
more in Blog
Older blog post
Newer blog post by Miss Porcupine
more by Miss Porcupine (oldest)
Older blog post by Miss Porcupine

17 Responses to “City Slicka Meets Country”

1.
Guest Icon
Guest
Anne

Sooooo…..what happened? I feel like this story is cut off in the middle!

 
2.
Bee Icon
Bee
Miss Parasol (message)  2,132 posts, Buzzing bee

You’re not an oddity! I wanted to elope, my Mr. P did not, and so we’re having a wedding! It’s actually a nice compromise of what we both envisioned, though I still would have preferred a wedding with just the two of us!

 
3.
alicia1745
Member
alicia1745 (message)  501 posts, Busy bee

You sound exactly like my FI and I! I wanted to elope - he did not!
I was also the girl that did not dream of her wedding day growing up- something my MIL cannot get through her head.

 
4.
Member Icon
Member
Future Army Wife (message)  1,102 posts, Bumble bee

Ours was. I picked out several to go visit. He decided after the first that we were getting married there and needn’t bother visiting the others.

 
5.
Bee Icon
Bee
Mrs. Hyena (message)  1,882 posts, Buzzing bee

I also wanted to elope and Mr. H didn’t! I even told him on our wedding morning that it wasn’t too late to elope. :)

 
6.
ChaiAnkh99
Member
ChaiAnkh99 (message)  598 posts, Busy bee

I grew up in PA, and a friend of mine got married at Riverdale Manor last year. I only saw pictures, but it looked absolutely lovely and is definitely not something you could find in the city!

 
7.
Coffee cup
Member
Coffee cup (message)  1,839 posts, Buzzing bee

I didn’t WANT to elope, but I did propose it to FI. Of course I’ll like a wedding and in my mind I was kind of planning it already, but it sounds like a lot of money. Thankfully he brought me to my senses :) and here I am.

 
8.
Ocean
Member
Ocean (message)  223 posts, Helper bee

You had me at Yodels. ;-)

 
9.
dagret
Member
dagret (message)  110 posts, Blushing bee

I hope Riverdale Manor wasn’t damaged in the flooding! It is beautiful venue.

We just went to a wedding there and while the place was absolutely beautiful and the food was great, their wedding coordinator was an absolute beyotch. I mean, flat-out rude to guests on more than one occasion throughout the evening.

All the other staff were excellent. The wedding coordinator is flat-out mean though. And in talking with some other folks who have been to weddings there, they’ve felt the same way.

 
10.
Bee Icon
Bee
Miss Porcupine (message)  428 posts, Helper bee

@Anne: more to come. Too much for one posting!

@Dagret: I’ve heard the same about Riverdale’s owner. There are a few coordinators that work there though. I’ve actually been dealing with a coordinator that is as sweet as can be, but she is currently on maternity leave. Hoping she comes back in time for the wedding because I have a short fuse and won’t deal with that nonsense.

 
11.
theoddbride
Member
theoddbride (message)  316 posts, Helper bee

Your story rings so true to me. Never dreamed about a wedding or “princess stuff,” I strongly encouraged by FI to do a city hall badda-bing baddaboom done and finished but he is really leaning towards a wedding. We haven’t decided yet.

 
12.
Knubbsy-Wubbsy
Member
Knubbsy-Wubbsy (message)  2,395 posts, Buzzing bee

I loved Riverdale! My cousin had her wedding there last summer. Wonderfully photogenic and the food wasn’t bad either. We went early to help set up (my aunt was kind of going crazy) and the coordinator we worked with was really nice. It gets pretty hot in the gazebo in summer but that’s not a concern for you.
It’s a classy country too which is nice (I would recommend a sign to direct people when to turn, we totally drove past the driveway at first)

 
13.
Bee Icon
Bee
Miss Skunk (message)  120 posts, Blushing bee

I’m with you about the whole not dreaming of a wedding. My mom recorded the royal wedding of Diana and Charles in ‘81 and I remember still in the early ’90s her rewatching that tape and sniffling. I soooo didn’t get it.

I still kinda don’t, but I’m with you and trying to come up with my own definition of a wedding.

 
14.
HappyWanderer
Member
HappyWanderer (message)  77 posts, Worker bee

Nope you’re not odd at all. I didnt spend any time at all as a girl dreaming about my wedding day. I had other things to do :)

I wanted to elope my sweetie didn’t but we did manage to find a venue/ feel that works for both of us. I also told him since I wanted simple and he didn’t, he had to help with the planning

 
15.
Guest Icon
Guest
Erica

We wanted the same kind of wedding. We always planned on (and ended up with) the Queens County Farm Museum. Surprised it didn’t make your list!

 
16.
Miss Kid
Member
Miss Kid (message)  122 posts, Blushing bee

I also didn’t think about the wedding part as a kid. I started from scratch on all of it, I was amazed at the amount of blogs out there, and the existence of google reader! I probably looked at all the same places as you, including L.I. vineyards because that’s where he proposed, but ended up booking Riverdale on my own because he was traveling on business at the time but I knew it was the best there was. How awesome is it that the DOC is included?! Glad you got a sweetheart coordinator, we most likely have the coordinator that everyone’s talking bad about, but hopefully everyone else is wrong.

 
17.
Bee Icon
Bee
Miss Kettle (message)  909 posts, Busy bee

“yes, this city girl loved the country feel even though I’m pretty sure I am made out of concrete.” Another priceless quote. As a city girl getting married outside her big city (Chicago), I can totally understand your drive to get out. I’m not going country, but I am going away from the hustle and bustle. Looking forward to seeing your venue options.

 

Leave a Reply


You can also just...

Newer blog post
more in Blog
Older blog post
Newer blog post by Miss Porcupine
more by Miss Porcupine (oldest)
Older blog post by Miss Porcupine

Visit our sister sites eHarmony
Online Dating
eHarmony Advice
Dating Advice
Project Wedding
Wedding Songs
JustMommies
Pregnancy Calendar

Copyright 2004-2012, Weddingbee.com
 

Find your vendors on Weddingbee

Real reviews from brides in your area!

Favors by Weddingbee

  • Favors by season

Shop Now »

Miss Porcupine
Miss Porcupine

Miss Porcupine, NYC/Lancaster, PA Age and Occupation: 26, Sales Coordinator/Publishing Fiance's Age and Occupation: 26, Assistant Manager/Sales Engagement Date: August 8, 2010 Wedding Date: March 2012 Venue: Riverdale Manor About Me: I'm a born and bred New Yorker with a love/hate relationship for the city I have always called home. Although I may seem quiet from afar, I have a loud personality once you get to know me. I am a book nerd at heart, but love a night out in the city with good friends. I have a serious addiction to all things cheese, chocolate, cardigans, Mexican food, and reality TV. The future hubs and I met in college, settled in New York, and decided to go with a rustic/peacock infused wedding in Lancaster, PA, right near his hometown. Come the big day, we will be together 5 years, and we're looking forward to making it official!

Boards
Classifieds

Blog Calendar
February 2012
SunMonTueWedThuFriSat
2930311234
567891011
12131415161718
19202122232425
26272829

Weddingbee Bios
Wiki
More