Newer blog post
more in Blog
Older blog post
Newer blog post by Miss Warbler
more by Miss Warbler (oldest)
Older blog post by Miss Warbler
Miss Warbler's Picture
Miss Warbler, Long Beach/Malibu Age and Occupation: 24, Quality Assurance Editor Fiance's Age and Occupation: 32, Handheld Administrator Engagement Date: December 7, 2010 Wedding Date: April 2012 Venue: Calamigos Ranch Malibu About Me: I’m a Korean BBQ loving, cheesecake enthusiast bride living in the LBC! By day I write and edit for an online search engine marketing company. By night I am a volunteer food taster of all that is delicious. I am fortunate to be marrying an amazing man who loves me and my quirky ways. I love food, books, indie music, and Harry Potter. We are planning a small, intimate wedding up in the Malibu Hills with our closest family and friends. With the help of my wonderful fiance, our loved ones, and red velvet cheesecake, our wedding will be glorious!
About Miss Warbler

The Name Game

September 14th, 2011 @ 7:13 pm by Miss Warbler

I have a confession to make. I am completely undecided on whether I am going to take Mr. Warbs’s last name.

The Name Game :  wedding legal malibu Hello M hello-m

Image via Wedding by Color

In the old days when things were simpler, a woman would take her husband’s last name without question. It was a clean and clear-cut decision. It wasn’t even really a decision—it was just something that you did. Now there are so many different elements to consider. A career woman might not want to change her name because it’s the name she built her career with. A student might be in the process of getting a new loan or financial aid; changing her name in the middle of that would just be confusing. While these are both valid examples, I’ll admit that they don’t apply to my situation. The real reason I’m hesitant about changing my name is two-fold.

I love my last name. I don’t care for Mr. Warbs’s last name.

I know, I know—I sound like a whiny child, but I can’t help it. Let me explain.

My last name is very unique. I’ve only met one other person with the same name who was no relation to me. There’s a football player who has it, too, but I’m pretty sure this person IS related to me somehow. He comes from Mississippi, and there’s a whole town in Mississippi that is basically made up of my family. True story! But the real reason that I love it is because it’s basically the last thing I have that ties me to my father. When he passed away six years ago, it was incredibly hard on me. I remember in the months after he passed I desperately looked around the house for things that reminded me of him. Now when I go visit his grave site and see our last name in big bold letters, I feel a little more connected to him, a little more loved. I apologize if that sounds morbid. A part of me feels that if I change my last name I’ll lose that much more of him. He was so proud of our last name that he made me feel proud, even when I was teased about it as a kid. Since my sisters and I have different fathers, I feel like it’s my duty to carry on my dad’s name.

While I may have gotten teased a couple of times as a kid, Mr. Warbs got teased ALL of the time. His last name is like easy pickings for the school bully. Without giving it away, Mr. Warbs’s last name is Dull. As in a synonym for the word. When I told my friends and family his last name after we started dating, the general reaction was, “Wow, you might be Mrs. Dull someday!” Well, they were right! Sure, I’m past grade-school age, but I can just imagine everyone snickering at the doctor’s office when a nurse calls out, “Mrs. Dull?” Not cool. Like me, Mr. Warbs is really proud of his last name. He can trace his ancestors back as far as the Great Depression. That’s something to be proud of. I can’t even trace my ancestors past my great-grandfather. He wins hands down.

When I told Mr. Warbs how I felt about the name game, he was shocked at first that I didn’t wholeheartedly want to take his last name. But, he said that he understood and would be happy with whatever I decided as long as we were married. He said that if I wasn’t comfortable with it, I didn’t have to change my name at all. Ugh, he’s so freakin’ sweet sometimes!

So I have a couple of options. Under no circumstances do I want to lose my last name completely. But I also want to take Mr. Warbs’s last name. Mostly because I know it would mean a lot to him and because I really want to be called Mr. and Mrs. So, I’ve decided that I will either add my last name as my new middle name, or hyphenate my last name with Mr. Warbs’s. So I will either be Mrs. Dull or Mrs. Warbs-Dull. The first option is a good compromise, but I also like my current middle name! However, I don’t use it that often so I’m willing to part ways with it. The second option is my favorite, because I like seeing our two names together. Also, if we ever do decide to have children (we both are in agreement not to, but who knows?) I would want them to have both of our last names. But, I would then have four names: Mrs. First Name Middle Name Warbs-Dull. That would be quite a mouthful!

Which option do you think I should go with? Is anyone else going the hyphenated route?
Tags: legal, malibu |
advertisement below
Newer blog post
more in Blog
Older blog post
Newer blog post by Miss Warbler
more by Miss Warbler (oldest)
Older blog post by Miss Warbler

27 Responses to “The Name Game”

1 2 

1.
Member Icon
Member
ruffledbride (message)  55 posts, Worker bee

Remember that your parents also gave you your middle name, so I think you should keep it :) Especially since you like it. I say go the hyphened route! Who cares if it is going to be long…how often do you actually go by your entire name? Plus you seem to like the hyphenated option :)

 
2.
Coffee cup
Member
Coffee cup (message)  1,839 posts, Buzzing bee

I like the option of becoming Mrs. Warbs-Dull but i’m mexican so I’m udes to freakishly long names.
I think it will be easier for you to use Mr. Warbs name as middle name, but it really comes to be your decision. If it was me I’ll go with Mrs. Warbs Dull.

 
3.
dooneybell
Member
dooneybell (message)  63 posts, Worker bee

I have fought myself here alot.
My fiance is German….very German. Very proud to come from a German family, is blonde and blue eyed giant every sterotype you can think of German.
So we have a similar issue I like Doone Y. Bell and I’ve always been Doone Y. Bell. He couldn’t fathom me not being Doone Y. German. My name actually sounds fine with his or with mine but I just feel like if we’re creating a new family together then hyphenating is the only and best way to show that. I will be Doone Y. Bell-German. Otherwise I feel like what’s been represented is just me joining his family that he isn’t even all that close to.

 
4.
Bee Icon
Bee
Mrs. Prairie Dog (message)  400 posts, Helper bee

i didn’t change my last name, and i LOVE my decision to keep it. we are a family, a team, a unit, and have been for many years- changing my last name (or not) wouldn’t change us. i’m proud to have my own career (which my name/reputation is tied to), plus- no paper work, no fuss, no confusion.

remember, there’s not a hard and fast rule about name changes. you can do it when it feels right! that’s my plan- if it ever feels like the right thing to do, i’ll do it! but that day was not the day or week after our wedding, and it’s not today. plus, pdog told me he’s proud to be married to a girl who stayed true to her gut feeling despite societal pressure (and there was some). besides, we have cute, wall-mounted coat hangers that spell out EL + JD - why mess with a good thing? haha ;)

 
5.
Bee Icon
Bee
Miss Parasol (message)  2,132 posts, Buzzing bee

I’m pulling for you to hyphenate, but mainly because that’s what Mr. P and I are doing! I love seeing our last names together–it’s a beautiful testament to our union, and I can’t wait to start using it in two days (ahh!). Ultimately, you should do whatever you’re most comfortable with, and I hope you find out what that is! :)

 
6.
psegnini
Member
psegnini (message)  21 posts, Newbee

Well, coming from Central America we all have four names and that’s not a big deal hehe Still in the US I go by first name+first last name to make it easier. I think you should hyphenate the names because that way you can keep your dad’s family name and also take in your future husband’s. If you think about it, how often do you say your full name now? It’s not like people would call you Mrs. First Name Middle Name Warbs-Dull on a daily basis.

 
7.
Member Icon
Member
GonnaBEE_MrsAcree (message)  7 posts, Newbee

I have been thinking about this a lot recently too! I will probably take my FH’s last name in the end, I do like the tradition of it and I know he’ll be honored to have me do so, but have been mulling over the same options.

For me… I just really have strong family values and feel like it’s throwing my last name to the wayside. It feels a bit disrespectful to me to just toss it aside, especially when my family is my rock! One compromise we’ve considered is using my current last name as a middle name for a child (works well with a boy, if we have one). That would bring the name back in and keep it in OUR family. If we don’t have a boy? Who knows… haha We’ll have to come up with a Plan B for using it in our lives.

I like the idea behind hyphenating the two names, but then it just seems like it becomes difficult for your children… will your daughter be faced with the same decision when it’s her turn to marry? Would she add a THIRD name to hyphenate them ALL?

I am going to a wedding on Saturday where the bride and groom have BOTH decided to hyphenate — they call it “ultra-modern” :)

In the end — just do what’s right for you!

 
8.
Amigos
Member
Amigos (message)  8 posts, Newbee

I wish I could give you some advice, but I’m in the same boat! I have an extremely unique last name. I always said I would only take my husband’s last name if it was as cool as mine. Well…his is pretty unique too. I love his last name and, while unique, is easier for people to pronounce than mine. On the other hand, my last name connects me to my Basque heritage and feels so engraved in my soul. We could hyphenate, but I guarantee it would be the wackiest name you have ever seen. Like someone threw a bunch of letters into a hat and pulled out 17 random letters to make a name. Everyone says how that would be extremely unfair to our kids to hyphenate our last names, but it’s important to me that my children know the importance of their heritage.

My fiancé has expressed how little he cares if I take his last name or not, which I think makes it harder! If he approached me and said “It would mean so much for you to take my last name”, then problem solved. I would do it. But if he doesn’t care and I really love my last name?!?! Ugh. Thanks for the post :) Glad to know I’m not alone!

 
9.
Member Icon
Member
cortneyc (message)  205 posts, Helper bee

We have a similar problem in my extended family! I have two cousins (sisters) who married two brothers. The brothers are descended from the folks who founded the town of Boring, Oregon (read: last name is literally “Boring”). One of the sisters and her husband kept “Boring” as is, but the other sister is a high school chemistry teacher! No one want a class from Mrs. Boring! She and her husband edited it to “Borin”.

I think you can’t go wrong either way. Whatever you feel is right for you is best!

 
10.
zippitydoodah
Member
zippitydoodah (message)  154 posts, Blushing bee

I like my fiance’s last name so I have no problem changing mine. In my family we’re really proud of our name and we can trace the family way back… even though I’m losing my name, I kind of feel like one thing about the traditional female-taking-the-name thing is that it makes it easy to trace families and create a family tree.

I also am curious about a few generations from now when everyone with hyphenated names has kids… and if they don’t want to lose their name they just add a hyphen and soon we have people with huuuuge last names! I’m just teasing :P but I really am curious! Would you be hurt if your children chose to continue with the Dull name and not yours? My roommate’s last name is also a synonym for Dull and she thought it would funny to hyphenate with her name first so that it makes her fiance’s name sound boring haha.

 
11.
Bee Icon
Bee
Miss Porcupine (message)  428 posts, Helper bee

Hyphenating is so common right now I say go for it. Mouthtful or not, it is what it is. You have the right to keep your name. It sucks that our identities get shifted like that (if we choose to take our husband’s name) while the guys get to go on their la ti da way. (I think it’s a conspiracy because I, for one, can’t imagine Mr. P having the patience/drive to fill out all the name change paperwork. I’m pretty sure guys would NEVER get around to changing their name if it was the social norm). I’ve just always hated my last name (no one can pronounce it or spell it and it’s so rare that you can Google me in a second) and like Mr. Porcupine’s more common last name.

 
12.
WinterWhite2012
Member
WinterWhite2012 (message)  90 posts, Worker bee

I vote for hyphenating. I am making the same decision now. My FH has been very understanding about it (my reputation in my career field has taken a long time to build up). He offered to let me just keep my name. However, we plan to have kids one day, so I’m going to hyphenate. I actually like the idea of replacing my middle name with my current last name; however, that isn’t an option as I go by my middle name. No one knows my first name, but I won’t drop it because it is my mother’s name. You will figure out what works best for you. I think at the end of the day, you just have to do what is best for you.

 
13.
Jamiezilla
Member
Jamiezilla (message)  210 posts, Helper bee

Honestly, the Great Depression was not that long ago. I wouldn’t let his family history influence your decision though.

My fiance’s family name is old too and we’ve talked about my reasons for wanting to keep my name. One of the biggest reasons is that two years ago my FBIL married someone with the same first name as me. It’s somewhat funny, mostly annoying because she took his last name and how strange would it be trying to make reservations for a trip with two people with the same name? If anything, I’ll hyphenate it to compromise while still being me.

 
14.
RegulaToBe
Member
RegulaToBe (message)  13 posts, Newbee

I’ve had a hyphenated name almost my entire life. I think hyphenated would be the best situation even if you feel it is a mouthful. Especially since you have such an emotional connection with your last name I think it would be a shame to lose that piece of you since it means so much.

 
15.
miss popsicle
Member
miss popsicle (message)  24 posts, Newbee

I’m not changing my name, primarily for professional reasons. Like Mrs. Prairie Dog, I started my career many years ago with my “maiden” name and my name is tied to it.

Also, I have the opposite problem than the OP in that my name is incredibly common while his is extremely unique. I sometimes like the anonymity that my name provides and don’t know if I would be comfortable changing to a name that literally maybe 100 people have (would definitely take some getting used to).

Anyway, the career is the main reason but I would probably have to think about it long and hard even if I didn’t have that “excuse”.

 
16.
soverysarah
Member
soverysarah (message)  24 posts, Newbee

This is something I’ve considered lately too. My name as it stands is the (I’m pretty much giving it up here) same as a country singer’s. In my hometown’s I’m known as that. I’m with you though on it making you feel closer to your dad. I lost my dad 15 years ago and to not be a “BLANK” feels strange. Ultimately though I want to take my fiance’s last name. I like it, it’s French! (lol) If I want to change my middle name to add in my maiden name I can always do that in the future.

On the kid front, My fiance and I plan on having kids and are planning to work my maiden name into one of their names. My friend (code name) Jill’s mom hyphenated her name but Jill only has her dad’s last name. I wouldn’t worry about how it will be for the kids because 4 names isn’t too long and if they want to shorten it when they are married they could always do that too.

All in all, I would say for your situation you should hyphenate. If you can’t picture yourself without it, don’t drop it.

 
17.
Guest Icon
Guest
Anon

I’m so confused. Your great grandfather’s generation was actually post-Great Depression? Are we talking about the Great Depression of the 1930’s or some other time?

 
18.
Guest Icon
Guest
kate

whatever you do, do not hyphenate your children’s name. I just married a person with hyphens and now we don tknow what to do b/c we have three names and you can’t hyphenate three-ways…

 
19.
Guest Icon
Guest
sparkles

My darling hubby has an awfully difficult
German last name (ie totally unpronounceable).
I grew up with a very elegant but pronounceable English name, and my family instilled a lot of pride into me about the name and our history, yes, we can trace our roots back to before the Norman conquest of England, (rather a blue-blooded lot and fairly snobby ;) !) However, I chose to take my husband’s name as a gift of love to him. Honestly, the normal name change was super easy, I just made sure I had all my ducks in a row and it took me probably all of 2 hours at the max. HOWEVER…I am also a physician, and had built my career on the original name! Oh my! What an incredible hassle! It took me nearly a year to change my name in the medical profession, and I still get such despair from my nurses “why oh why did you change your name??” LOL.
I’m still glad I did it though :) Just a thought, though your case is different. Sounds like you have a loving and supportive man!

 
20.
futureMrsCPT
Member
futureMrsCPT (message)  589 posts, Busy bee

I will be taking the Mr’s last name. I have several male cousins who’ve already had children (including boys) so I know my name will be carried on. Hyphenating my last name with his last name is not an option because my maiden name is 8 letters long, 3 syllables, and his is 8 letters long and 2 syllables and it would just be too much of a mouthfull! And my middle name is after my Godmother who is also my Aunt, so I don’t want to drop it.

 
1 2 

Leave a Reply


You can also just...

Newer blog post
more in Blog
Older blog post
Newer blog post by Miss Warbler
more by Miss Warbler (oldest)
Older blog post by Miss Warbler

Visit our sister sites eHarmony
Online Dating
eHarmony Advice
Dating Advice
Project Wedding
Wedding Songs
JustMommies
Pregnancy Calendar

Copyright 2004-2012, Weddingbee.com
 

Find your vendors on Weddingbee

Real reviews from brides in your area!

Favors by Weddingbee

  • Favors by season

Shop Now »

Miss Warbler
Miss Warbler

Miss Warbler, Long Beach/Malibu Age and Occupation: 24, Quality Assurance Editor Fiance's Age and Occupation: 32, Handheld Administrator Engagement Date: December 7, 2010 Wedding Date: April 2012 Venue: Calamigos Ranch Malibu About Me: I’m a Korean BBQ loving, cheesecake enthusiast bride living in the LBC! By day I write and edit for an online search engine marketing company. By night I am a volunteer food taster of all that is delicious. I am fortunate to be marrying an amazing man who loves me and my quirky ways. I love food, books, indie music, and Harry Potter. We are planning a small, intimate wedding up in the Malibu Hills with our closest family and friends. With the help of my wonderful fiance, our loved ones, and red velvet cheesecake, our wedding will be glorious!

Boards
Classifieds

Blog Calendar
February 2012
SunMonTueWedThuFriSat
2930311234
567891011
12131415161718
19202122232425
26272829

Weddingbee Bios
Wiki
More