Newer blog post
more in Blog
Older blog post
Newer blog post by Miss Porcupine
more by Miss Porcupine (oldest)
Older blog post by Miss Porcupine
Miss Porcupine's Picture
Miss Porcupine, NYC/Lancaster, PA Age and Occupation: 26, Sales Coordinator/Publishing Fiance's Age and Occupation: 26, Assistant Manager/Sales Engagement Date: August 8, 2010 Wedding Date: March 2012 Venue: Riverdale Manor About Me: I'm a born and bred New Yorker with a love/hate relationship for the city I have always called home. Although I may seem quiet from afar, I have a loud personality once you get to know me. I am a book nerd at heart, but love a night out in the city with good friends. I have a serious addiction to all things cheese, chocolate, cardigans, Mexican food, and reality TV. The future hubs and I met in college, settled in New York, and decided to go with a rustic/peacock infused wedding in Lancaster, PA, right near his hometown. Come the big day, we will be together 5 years, and we're looking forward to making it official!
About Miss Porcupine

If there is one piece of advice I can give on registries, it would be: do NOT register anywhere until the last possible moment. A month before your bridal shower invites go out will do just fine. If you’re having an engagement party I would recommend making a “mini-registry” for it. Then go back and do a full-out wedding registry later.

Seriously, I am not being a crazy rebellious bride. I speak from annoying experience. In the past five months more items have gone discontinued off our registries then I think we even registered for.

Mr. Porcupine and I decided to register at Crate and Barrel and Bed, Bath, & Beyond. Then, after subtle pressure from friends and family, we decided to register at Macy’s too, since some people live, die, and swear by Macy’s (and their wondrous sales). I don’t blame anyone—Macy’s has kick-ass sales.

Mistake #1: Having more than two registries.

We started our “Registry Day” with a stop at Crate & Barrel. It was the first stop so we were bright and fresh.

The Love/Hate Registry Conundrum :  wedding lancaster 2598531 259853_

Personal Photo

The store we went to is a pretty small location in Soho, so there wasn’t too much of a chance to get overwhelmed by the selection. I love everything in that store. It’s a sickness. Funny part is, we will probably end up deleting this registry and transferring everything over to Bed, Bath, and Beyond, because their crap is all the same! Why you ask? Because the HOLY GRAIL is starting a registry program. More on that later.

Then we were off to Bed, Bath, and Beyond.

Mistake #2: Entering a flagship location to register.

Do NOT do this. DO NOT, I repeat, enter a flagship location and think you’ll be able to leave without having a mental breakdown. Seriously, this was the worst idea. Also, the registry consultant was the bane of my existence. We had to handwrite out the registry information form. Then she had to enter everything into the computer to set us up. (Unlike Crate & Barrel where you do the computer entry yourself.) Can you talk about typos GALORE? This woman typed my password to the registry SO wrong, my last name wrong, and our wedding date wrong (as in it was off by about five months!) Thanks lady! She also kept us waiting for a literal half hour for the damn scanner (they were not crowded at the registry table) as she blundered around like a scatterbrain. Sorry, I really have no patience for incompetent people. This is my evil New Yorker head poking in. We’re in a recession people! There are plenty of intelligent people waiting to snatch up your job!

FINALLY, we got the scanner and walked around in blind confusion. Do we need this? Which brand is better? Did we register for this at Crate? Where am I? What the hell is this buttony cofangled gadget? Why are there 900 people in here at this very moment buying George Forman grills?

I started blindly zapping things anxious to be done. The place is HUGE. They also have every single invention in the universe stacked side-by-side like buddies. You see, I’m the type of nerd who sits for hours on the internet comparing reviews of gadgetry before I purchase anything. I hated blindly guessing, and knew when we got home I would have to go back and check reviews on everything. It didn’t take long for me to realize we needed to leave STAT.

Over the next week I fixed up the registries via the interwebs, and registered online at Macy’s for most of our linens/sheets and such. Three registries began to make me ill though. I started duplicating things like a dimwit. I had to go back and delete and update. Then things started going discontinued like mad. Don’t even get me started on what I’m sure will happen once the new year rolls through in a couple of months. We will probably have negative 80 items on the registries by then.

Tell me Bed, Bath, and Beyond, how is it that a BLENDER and an ELECTRONIC CORKSCREW OPENER, of all random items, goes out of stock/gets discontinued. AND, why can’t your system magically replace it with the new version 15.0? Oh, also, my vacuum that I laboriously researched went off into discontinued land. GAH! (I get it…. It’s actually the manufacturer’s fault, but whatever I need a scapegoat!)

I also recently found out that the Container Store is starting their registry program in October. Yes, THE HOLY GRAIL. (UPDATE: I just Googled it and it has officially begun!) I need EVERYTHING in the Container Store more than I need any more pots, pans, cups, or spoons. I go into the Container Store and get lost for hours. I once emerged and the seasons had changed.

So, moral of the story is: Wait to Register! Do not listen to your families’ pressure to register early. Just say no!

DISCLAIMER: No, I am not trying to be a give-me-gifts brat. I will gladly say thank you to anything people give me as a gift. Give me a damn toilet brush and I will be excited. But, registering is a HUGE freakin’-A deal around these parts. You must register or you are shunned from your family and friends for being difficult. I hate being shunned.

Anyone else hating on the registry process?

Tags: lancaster |
advertisement below
Newer blog post
more in Blog
Older blog post
Newer blog post by Miss Porcupine
more by Miss Porcupine (oldest)
Older blog post by Miss Porcupine

22 Responses to “The Love/Hate Registry Conundrum”

1 2 

1.
StarIzInkd
Member
StarIzInkd (message)  335 posts, Helper bee

I actually had a mystery shop where I had to make a registry for a certain company. It was my first registry and a sneak peak for when my FH and I actually do it for real. I was miserable. It was over-whelming, I didn’t know how many glasses or settings I would need… is it okay to have 8 glasses but 10 place settings of flatware? Ugh… frustrating and very time consuming!

 
2.
Member Icon
Member
SnowflakeDS (message)  343 posts, Helper bee

I love how you put your Container Store addiction “the seasons had changed”. I compared mine to eating chocolate recently. ;)

 
3.
Guest Icon
Guest
Anon

This is great advice! And I would add that doing registries online has been pretty stress-free in my experience. You don’t have to deal with a possibly incompetent sales assistant and there is usually more variety to choose from online, depending on where you register.

 
4.
Bee Icon
Bee
Miss Ticket (message)  475 posts, Helper bee

Excellent points. We first registered for 3 stores because one of the original ones we picked didn’t have any locations in PA (where a large % of our guest list is from) only for them to build a store there after we registered at 3 locations. Honestly 90% of what we’ve gotten has been from one store anyways. I’m sorry your experience at Bed Bath and Beyond was less than pleasant. The girl that helped us register was fantastic, she walked us around the store suggestion items we might need and she wasn’t frivolous about it like insisting we need a sham wow or anything lol.

 
5.
Member
kwebb (message)  26 posts, Newbee

I registered 3 months in advance and now everything on my Macy’s registry is on sale! My wedding is less than a month away so hopefully it will not all be discontinued by then!! We had to pick out new dishes like 4 times!

 
6.
Bee Icon
Bee
Miss Ladyfingers (message)  1,119 posts, Bumble bee

Yep. I had to replace a bunch of stuff on my Crate and Barrel registry after the summer had passed. And I hear you on the Bed Bath and Beyond stuff being the same! We (OK, *I*) kept our serving stuff — platters, flatware, glasses — at Crate and Barrel, but all our appliances, gadgets and whatnot at BB&B. Honestly, we just want money — which is to say, if somebody’s going to get us a gift WHICH WE’RE TOTALLY FINE WITH THEM NOT DOING, we’d rather it be money. And then I can just put the rest of the registry stuff on my Christmas list :) Also, I did all our registries online, because I hate people and shopping in real stores.

 
7.
Bee Icon
Bee
Mrs. Pony (message)  4,175 posts, Honey bee

Such good advice! Our friend’s registry said items on it were discontinued the same day they registered, yet no one at the store explained this to them. Needless to say, they had to register again and were not happy about it.

 
8.
Guest Icon
Guest
AT

Spare yourself the agony and do it all online!!! Most people want items that can be purchased online anyway and this way you won’t register for in-store-only stuff. Plus you can read reviews and compare items. Coordinate all of your stuff for your household. Compare stuff from different stores and delete any duplicates. Walking through the stores is sooooo friggin overwhelming. I found that items I scanned with the gun were later deleted as I became more strategic with my online registering….

 
9.
Miss Seal
Bee
Miss Seal (message)  1,179 posts, Bumble bee

Oh, I so feel ya. I have to research, research, research before I purchase anything…so registering for electronics that I hadn’t triple-checked reviews for was a nightmare. Anyway, I SO wish the Container Store had a registry option earlier–I’ve still got a month…maybe it’s not too late!

 
10.
NYCcaliBRIDE
Member
NYCcaliBRIDE (message)  344 posts, Helper bee

This post made me lol! I feel ya, we went to Macys in NYC a couple weekends ago and it was a nightmare. The woman helping us was so scattered and it took forever to give us a scanner. I think we’ll stick to doing most of it online. I am SO happy to hear about the container store! I’m going to try and convince my FI to get on board with that one!

 
11.
Bee Icon
Bee
Miss Porcupine (message)  429 posts, Helper bee

@StarIzInkd: Ha, we’ve defniitely registered for far TOO many settings/glasses that we will never use.
@SnowflakeDS: That store seriously sucks you in!
@Anon: Yes, doing it online =life saver.
@Miss Ticket: You would think the consultant at a flagship store in NYC would be good at what she does! Yuck, no bueno. Glad your experience was better.
@kwebb: Our dishes were the only thing that haven’t gone discontinued yet. And, I hope I didn’t just jinx it ….
@Miss Ladyfingers: I should have remembered my mutual hatred for people when I went into this thinking it would be fun. Haha. I have no patience…
@Mrs. Pony: Ugh, that’s annoying. When we had gone home and checked our registry (the same day) we saw our flatware was “limited quantities available.” No way that will make it to 2012!
@AT: Yes, definitely do it online. I hate when items are “store-only” and there is no picture online to represent it!

 
12.
Bee Icon
Bee
Miss Fox (message)  859 posts, Busy bee

We haven’t even attempted registering yet, so thank you for posting this! SO EXCITING about The Container Store.. Foxy is obsessed with that place. I didn’t even think about things going out of stock or discontinued.. here I thought we’d register, like, now. CLearly not a good idea. At least you can sorta fix everything online though, right?

 
13.
Bee Icon
Bee
Miss Porcupine (message)  429 posts, Helper bee

@Miss Seal: There is still time!! Haha.
@NYCcaliBRIDE: What is up with NYC consultants at stores being clueless? Another checkmark for my growing NYC disdain!

 
14.
Bee Icon
Bee
Miss Porcupine (message)  429 posts, Helper bee

@Miss Fox: Yes, super easy to fix online. But, definitely wait until your shower is closer.

 
15.
Bee Icon
Bee
Mrs. Pain au Chocolat (message)  1,698 posts, Bumble bee

Once the “where are you registered?” type questions began, we dutifully registered… a whole year in advance.

 
16.
Ms. Anemone
Member
Ms. Anemone (message)  624 posts, Busy bee

I feel your pain! So many hours scanning things…. then deleting them. Ugh.

 
17.
Ms. Anemone
Member
Ms. Anemone (message)  624 posts, Busy bee

I feel your pain! So many hours scanning things…. then deleting them.
Which is, of course, not half as bad as having something seemingly drop off the face of the earth.

 
18.
Bee Icon
Bee
Miss Sunhat (message)  865 posts, Busy bee

We registered at BB&B and Macy’s too. Thankfully we haven’t had an issue yet with discontinued items but I’m going to have to keep an eye on it!

 
19.
Bee Icon
Bee
Mrs. Parasol (message)  2,132 posts, Buzzing bee

Great tips and advice! Registering is kind of a nightmare, but once I got the feel of it, I felt a lot better. And I heartily agree with going mainly with one store. It’s so much easier and saves so much headache. But the fact that BB&B lets items go out of stock/be discontinued and doesn’t alert brides and grooms is supremely annoying. Mr. P and I REALLY wanted our bedding, and we were a little disappointed that we never got it. No wonder–it was completely sold out!

 
20.
Guest Icon
Guest
Sarah

Amazon has an amazing registry…and so far, NOTHING on mine has been discontinued. Can’t beat free shipping for orders over $25 either. We also have an obligatory Macy’s registry, that one has been a pain in the butt with discontinued items!

 
1 2 

Leave a Reply


You can also just...

Newer blog post
more in Blog
Older blog post
Newer blog post by Miss Porcupine
more by Miss Porcupine (oldest)
Older blog post by Miss Porcupine

Visit our sister sites eHarmony
Online Dating
eHarmony Advice
Dating Advice
Project Wedding
Wedding Songs
JustMommies
Pregnancy Calendar

Copyright 2004-2012, Weddingbee.com
 

Find your vendors on Weddingbee

Real reviews from brides in your area!

Favors by Weddingbee

  • Favors by season

Shop Now »

Miss Porcupine
Miss Porcupine

Miss Porcupine, NYC/Lancaster, PA Age and Occupation: 26, Sales Coordinator/Publishing Fiance's Age and Occupation: 26, Assistant Manager/Sales Engagement Date: August 8, 2010 Wedding Date: March 2012 Venue: Riverdale Manor About Me: I'm a born and bred New Yorker with a love/hate relationship for the city I have always called home. Although I may seem quiet from afar, I have a loud personality once you get to know me. I am a book nerd at heart, but love a night out in the city with good friends. I have a serious addiction to all things cheese, chocolate, cardigans, Mexican food, and reality TV. The future hubs and I met in college, settled in New York, and decided to go with a rustic/peacock infused wedding in Lancaster, PA, right near his hometown. Come the big day, we will be together 5 years, and we're looking forward to making it official!

Boards
Classifieds

Blog Calendar
February 2012
SunMonTueWedThuFriSat
2930311234
567891011
12131415161718
19202122232425
26272829

Weddingbee Bios
Wiki
More