Newer blog post
more in Blog
Older blog post
Newer blog post by Miss Elk
more by Miss Elk (oldest)
Older blog post by Miss Elk
Miss Elk's Picture
Miss Elk, City: Syracuse/Long Island Age and Occupation: 25, Medical Student Fiance's Age and Occupation: 25, Computer Engineer Engagement Date: November 22, 2010 Wedding Date: May 2012 Venue: The Old Field Club About Me: I’m a Long Island girl finishing my last year of medical school in western NY, on the road to becoming a pediatrician. When I’m not studying or sleeping at the hospital, I spend my free time watching bad TV (Vampire Diaries anyone?), playing with my pooch, singing incredibly off-key (to the annoyance of Mr. Elk ), and reading Harry Potter for the zillionth time. Mr. Elk and I are planning a secular wedding infused with both Irish and cultural Jewish traditions. Only a week after I become an M.D., I will get my Mrs. degree, too!
About Miss Elk

One of the first things Mama Elk requested when we announced we would be having a secular ceremony was that Mr. Elk break a glass at the end, and I agreed. If you are not Jewish or have never been to/seen on television a Jewish wedding, the man traditionally breaks a glass (or in the past a light bulb—easier to break, apparently) at the conclusion of the ceremony. I have always been taught that this is to symbolize the destruction of the temple in Jerusalem back in the day, but there are a lot of possible meanings. Still don’t know what I am talking about? You can refer to the only good scene from SATC2 for a movie version of the tradition.

Now, I know what you are thinking! Miss Elk—that is not secular at all! That is actually very religious. But, you have to understand—every wedding I have been to (for the most part) ends with the breaking of a glass. It is the grand finale (well, before the kiss!). It is how my relatives will know to say mazel tov and clap and get ready to party.

How did I convince Mr. Elk, though? When I first brought up this topic with Mr. Elk, he was surprisingly easy to convince. As a Curb Your Enthusiasm enthusiast, Mr. Elk probably knows more about Judaism than I do (well…almost). Moreover, we have attended numerous weddings of my cousins, and he is pretty used to the routine by now, so it isn’t all that foreign to him. There was almost a problem when he learned the actual meaning behind the tradition, and he started to get upset that we were breaking the “no religion” rule. Luckily, quick-witted me had a response: “Babes, we will just think of it as the last time you get to put your foot down in this relationship.” Mr. Elk laughed, told me never to repeat that to anyone, and agreed to partake in the tradition.

Now I just wonder what his Irish Catholic family will think…

Did you incorporate traditions that your significant other or their family may find strange? How did they seem to take it?

Tags: long-island, music |
advertisement below
Newer blog post
more in Blog
Older blog post
Newer blog post by Miss Elk
more by Miss Elk (oldest)
Older blog post by Miss Elk

10 Responses to “Our Jecular Wedding: Because How Will They Know the Ceremony Is Over?”

1.
Bee Icon
Bee
Mrs. Spaniel (message)  6,792 posts, Bee Keeper

We didn’t bother with the Temple explanation. It scares away bad luck (ha), and it symbolizes something that is forever changed, and that was good enough for me (a secular “Jew”) and Mr. Spaniel (a… cultural Catholic).

I bet his Irish family won’t mind too much. :) If any of Mr. S’s Catholic family was bothered by it, it never got back to us (and they’re not known for their silent grudges… it’d be out in the open ;).

 
2.
amyrose
Member
amyrose (message)  40 posts, Newbee

My husband is Irish Catholic, and we had a jewish ceremony in a temple, led by a rabbi, with all of the the jewish traditions. Since I knew my husbands family would have no clue what a lot of the traditions meant we put a little gloassary in our programs explaining the breaking of the glass, the chuppah, the ketubah, etc.

 
3.
Bee Icon
Bee
Mrs. Pony (message)  4,175 posts, Honey bee

I love this tradition, I secretly wished we could have done it, even though neither of us are Jewish.

 
4.
Guest Icon
Guest
anon

I stepped on a piece of glass in our hotel room the day I got engaged and had to get it surgically LOL I think I will be skipping any glass breaking!!

 
5.
Bee Icon
Bee
Miss Porcupine (message)  429 posts, Helper bee

Hahaha I love your reasoning for your personal meaning of breaking the glass.

 
6.
Bee Icon
Bee
Miss Doe (message)  540 posts, Busy bee

I think it’s great you are including something that is so important to you! Good for you for standing strong on this one ;) I’m white sure his family will understand, and who cares what they think…it’s YOUR wedding!

 
7.
MissTBee
Member
MissTBee (message)  111 posts, Blushing bee

Maybe she really did call you and the message was lost in translation and she does not believe you for some reason or another, so she is hurting as well. I think you should consider that might be an option as to why she is distant all of a sudden. Maybe she wanted you to be a part of her day and when you didn’t call she was really hurt. Or maybe shedding really want to be in your wedding. Sometimes that happens, people just say yes as to not hurt someone’s feelings when they know if the shoe were on the other foot they wouldnt have you in their bridal party. I would just let it go if you want to maintain your friendship. Try to have a nice conversation with her WITHOUT mentioning a single thing about the wedding. If she brings something up be happy for her and not sound like you are hurt. Ultimately it is the brides decision who she wants and doesn’t have in her wedding. I hope you guys can figure it out. Good luck hun

 
8.
Guest Icon
Guest
walter

Good tradition, I secretly wished we could have done it, even though neither of us are Jewish

 
9.
Guest Icon
Guest
Ms Kit

It may have religious meaning, but it’s another tradition cultural Jews just can’t resist, and that’s because it’s totally fun. Plus, there are a lot of proposed meanings, so you don’t have to do it for all of them if you want to do it for one (see Mrs. Spaniel above, for example).

 
10.
Guest Icon
Guest
Woolnotwheat

The explanation I’ve always heard at many weddings was something along the lines of “may your love last as long as it would take to put this glass back together”. I think they sell sugar glasses/easy to break glasses just for this purpose, and if you are outside or even on carpet, be sure to have a hard board to stomp on. Nothing like saying that and then the glass won’t break.

 

Leave a Reply


You can also just...

Newer blog post
more in Blog
Older blog post
Newer blog post by Miss Elk
more by Miss Elk (oldest)
Older blog post by Miss Elk

Visit our sister sites eHarmony
Online Dating
eHarmony Advice
Dating Advice
Project Wedding
Wedding Songs
JustMommies
Pregnancy Calendar

Copyright 2004-2012, Weddingbee.com
 

Find your vendors on Weddingbee

Real reviews from brides in your area!

Favors by Weddingbee

  • Favors by season

Shop Now »

Miss Elk
Miss Elk

Miss Elk, City: Syracuse/Long Island Age and Occupation: 25, Medical Student Fiance's Age and Occupation: 25, Computer Engineer Engagement Date: November 22, 2010 Wedding Date: May 2012 Venue: The Old Field Club About Me: I’m a Long Island girl finishing my last year of medical school in western NY, on the road to becoming a pediatrician. When I’m not studying or sleeping at the hospital, I spend my free time watching bad TV (Vampire Diaries anyone?), playing with my pooch, singing incredibly off-key (to the annoyance of Mr. Elk ), and reading Harry Potter for the zillionth time. Mr. Elk and I are planning a secular wedding infused with both Irish and cultural Jewish traditions. Only a week after I become an M.D., I will get my Mrs. degree, too!

Boards
Classifieds

Blog Calendar
February 2012
SunMonTueWedThuFriSat
2930311234
567891011
12131415161718
19202122232425
26272829

Weddingbee Bios
by machop93
by IsaiahFountain
by greencl3
by ymaldonado
Wiki
More