Sign up   Login  
Newer blog post
more in Blog
Older blog post
Newer blog post by Miss Panda
more by Miss Panda (oldest)
Older blog post by Miss Panda
Miss Panda's Picture
Miss Panda, Boston, MA Age and Occupation: 26, Graduate Student Fiance's Age and Occupation: 23, Graduate Student Engagement Date: June 27, 2011 Wedding Date: June 2013 About Me: I love window shopping, cute animals, crafting, baking, and most forms of procrastination. I tend to be overly meticulous with choices to a point of complete and total indecision. Mr. PBear and I met and live in the amazing city of Boston. We are big nerds who love trying new foods, playing video games, and cuddling with our adorable hamster. After 5 years together, we are planning an intimate, DIY-heavy, vintage garden themed, nonreligious wedding in the city where we fell in love.
About Miss Panda

The Guest-List Creep

October 22nd, 2012 @ 1:59 pm by Miss Panda

Something about getting married makes people just ooze out of the woodwork. Friends you haven’t seen since you had braces, former coworkers that you have never talked to outside of work, that estranged third cousin once removed, and though you not interesting enough to talk to on an even semi regular  yearly more-than-half-a-dozen-times-in-your-entire-life basis, they suddenly decide your wedding is the. place. to. be.

This is a phenomenon I like to call the guest-list creep. The guest list creep is the strange monster that wiggles into your guest list to make it seem to grow bigger and bigger every time you turn around. It’s the trickle of people that seem to appear over time, even though you’ve theoretically had a fairly set list for about a year. Even when you seem to manage it well, over time and before you realize it, your Aunt Polly’s nephew’s cousin’s best friend has somehow managed to make his way onto your list.

The Guest-List Creep  :  wedding boston guest list Brainsl Brainsl

I don’t know why, but I always picture the guest-list creep as the Futurama brain slug. (source: Futurama Wiki)

Because PBear and I have had a fairly long engagement of two years minus a few days, this creep has happened fairly slowly so that I didn’t even realize it had happened until we realized that the people on our list would no way be able to fit into our venue. Our venue has a very strict fire code limit of 60 people.

Our original list of 60 people has ballooned to almost 80, and I can think of at least 10 people who might need to be added to the list and haven’t been yet. Oftentimes, I worry that the people we want to invite won’t fit because of the people we “have” to invite. I think that number will just keep growing.

Frankly, I’m amazed that these people want to come to our wedding. As a big introvert, I’m not a big fan of being the center of attention. I want to have a wedding to declare our commitment to each other in front of the people we love and who love us. And I know I am fortunate that more people in the world love us than we have space to accommodate, but I have never really imagined a wedding with lots and lots of people there.

If it comes down to it, we might have to resort to desperate measures.

The Guest-List Creep  :  wedding boston guest list Decide  decide-

Image via Someecards

But it’s not the people we want there that bother me, it’s the people who seem to be adding themselves. Why do people who barely know us want to be there? Weddings are not cheap for either side, whether you’re hosting it or you have to fly there and pay for hotels, gifts, attire, etc, etc. This all adds up so fast.

Things I wish I had done:

  1. Don’t sing it on the mountain. As much as we love to talk about our wedding and the stresses and ups and downs with planning the most expensive party of our lives, there is something to be said about not telling everyone on the planet that you’re getting married. If they don’t know, they can’t ask. Facebook I think is a big problem, just because of how easy it is for people to connect.
  2. Give your parents set number of invites. Yes your parents might be paying for the shabang, but it’s not a party for them, it’s a party for you. It would hopefully prevent your parents from inviting the cashier at their grocery store if they realized that it would eat up one of their only 10 invites. This should give them time to determine who they want there and who they can just show pictures to at a later point. Furthermore, you’re an adult now, it’s time you learned to say no.
  3. Pick a venue that can hold more people than your maximum, maximum list. This will give you some buffer room, so when that inevitable creep appears, you can find space for them. Yes, the rule of thumb is generally 20% of your guest list declines, but what if they don’t? By giving a bit of a buffer for those extra guests, you don’t have to worry about being on top of the list as strictly. Furthermore, a slightly bigger venue will seem less cramped—win win.
  4. Be more thorough with the original list. Maybe if our original list had all of these people on it, we wouldn’t have booked a venue that wouldn’t hold everyone.
  5. Cut off the list at some point. Seriously, if you don’t come up with these people on your first 10 passes, are they really that essential to be there?
  6. Realize you can’t make everyone happy. I need to remind myself of this every once in a while. Your ideal is not everyone else’s ideal. Someone’s going to be offended. Make sure you’re happy with the people who you have show up.
  7. Plus-ones. Take them into account when you’re making the list! I’m a little divided about plus ones. On one hand, I think it’s rude not to invite couples as couples; on the other hand, I hate the idea of strangers watching us get married as well. We’re trying to limit plus-ones to couples in a serious relationship. What that entails, who knows?

I know I’m being very snarky in this post, but it’s one of those things that is causing me a lot of grief right now. I wish I could wave my hand and invite everyone, but if I am realistic about it, there is no way we can afford to, no way everyone can fit in our amazing venue, and that’s not the type of wedding I ultimately want.

I just hope that people understand. Anyone else deal with the guest-list creep and have good techniques for combating it?

Tags: boston, guest-list |
advertisement below
Newer blog post
more in Blog
Older blog post
Newer blog post by Miss Panda
more by Miss Panda (oldest)
Older blog post by Miss Panda

20 Responses to “The Guest-List Creep”

1.
Bee Icon
Bee
Miss Wallaby (message)  1,729 posts, Bumble bee

OMG we have guest list creep and our wedding is weeks away… But those are some great tips I wish we had read when we first started working on the guest list! I definitely agree that it’s good to pick a venue where you have some extra space in case the guest list grows. We’re getting married at an outdoor venue so space isn’t really an issue.

 
2.
BookishBelle
Member
BookishBelle (message)  1,258 posts, Bumble bee

Our rule is if they aren’t living together, engaged, married, or have been dating long enough that we have met the significant other and have let them into our friend group so that we’d want to invite them anyway, they don’t get invited. We’re being very strict with plus ones, because we refuse to have strangers at our wedding, everybody invited will be sat with people they know so they won’t be alone, if they can’t spend a night without their boyfriend of less than a year that we’ve never met, then that’s one less plate to pay for…I’d say the wedding has made me more cutthroat but it’s probably always been my personality LOL. As for the creep…we’re just very good at going “Haha, very funny” when people we haven’t spoken to in years talk as if they’re coming. Hey, we haven’t spoken to them in years, if we lose their “friendship” over an invite do we really care? Nooooot so much…

 
3.
RapunzelRapunzel
Member
RapunzelRapunzel (message)  812 posts, Busy bee

I totally feel you on the creep! We knew we were going to have a LARGE wedding to begin with just in people we love and care about (large families, large church), but then people we do love and care about (like our grandmothers!) started insisting we invite others we barely know!!

 
4.
Guest Icon
Guest
thatredheadedsister

I am having the same problem. We have a max budget set for 100 people and I made it very clear to myself that I would NOT tell people at work. Of course one person noticed the ring and in front of a large group of people I was not planning on inviting told me they better be getting an invite from me. Ive never talked to them outside of work and most of them didnt know I was even in a relationship! Like you said, people are going to be offended, but I want friends around us

 
5.
janine0711
Member
janine0711 (message)  36 posts, Newbee

Cost kept our guest list down. While I wish we could have invited a lot more of our friends the price tag of the 186 people we did have really put that in check for us. We invited 221 so we did have our share of declines. And I was of the same mind when it came came to plus ones, if I haven’t met you, you didnt make the cut. I feel weird about having random plus ones there to share in my day and be forever in photos!

 
6.
Bee Icon
Bee
Miss Toadstool (message)  2,408 posts, Buzzing bee

This past weekend my mom was asked by my cousin’s MIL to be invited to the wedding, the lady who I haven’t seen in over a year claims that she can’t miss my wedding. I’m so mortified.

 
7.
Bee Icon
Bee
Miss Gray Wolf (message)  628 posts, Busy bee

oh man. THIS. we cut off plus ones too – unless you had a serious sig other – we defined that as one year or more. for the most part, that length of time meant that we also knew the sig other pretty well, so we ended up inviting people we wanted too.

 
8.
Bee Icon
Bee
Mrs. Pain au Chocolat (message)  2,297 posts, Buzzing bee

I think explaining you are having a small wedding, for all the reasons you mentioned, would work with most people. That and limiting the parent-generated invites! We created a list and shared it with all sets of parents to make sure we were all on the same page; to my surprise, more were cut than added.

 
9.
Bee Icon
Bee
Miss Panda (message)  945 posts, Busy bee

@Miss Wallaby: It is times like this when I wish we had picked an outside venue. I completely understand its appeal now!

@BookishBelle: our original rule was living together, engaged, married, or started dating before we got engaged (which admittedly is like two years…). I’m not sure that’s holding though =/ yikes. I do like the cutthroatness though. I completely agree. Before I started planning a wedding, I didn’t understand when people were being so tight with the guest list. Now I understand, and I’d like to apologize to my dear friends!

@RapunzelRapunzel: I agree, it’s never who you expect either!

@thatredheadedsister: yeah, I’m not completely sure what to do about the work people. There are a few people at work I’d love to invite, but now that our group has exponentially increased in the last two months, there is no way I can invite everyone.

@janine0711: yup! I’d love to get a group picture, but I hate to look back at it years from now and wonder, wait who’s random +1 was that again?

@Miss Toadstool: lol. yes! That is exactly what I’m talking about. I don’t get it!

@Miss Gray Wolf: yeah I think that’s a reasonable cut off. We’ll see when we get closer to the date what ends up happening.

@Mrs. Pain au Chocolat: I’m very jealous! (random side note: you have the tastiest looking icon ever. Every. single. time. I see your icon, I get hungry)

 
10.
Highness
Member
Highness (message)  82 posts, Worker bee

my worst guest list issue was sending out save the dates and then changing the guest list. couldn’t remember if I had cut someone or not. DON’T DO THIS. other than that we’ve been sure to mention that it’s a small wedding with close friends and family to keep the looky looes at bay.

 
11.
KelannaDC
Member
KelannaDC (message)  298 posts, Helper bee

I’ve been trying very hard NOT to suffer from a case of the guest list creep. However, after much battering on WB, I’ve decided to open up some +1s. I totally agree with you about not wanting strangers there to celebrate our wedding, so this has been the toughest part of the whole wedding planning.

For people who don’t understand why you aren’t having the most open guest list policy, perhaps they’d like to make a small donation towards wedding costs. :)

 
12.
LFdimples
Member
LFdimples (message)  24 posts, Newbee

Ugh! Don’t even get me started on plus ones… We have a friend that was not invited with a guest because he’s totally single. I noticed a post on his Facebook yesterday asking ladies to audition to be his date for the wedding!

 
13.
StephK527
Member
StephK527 (message)  987 posts, Busy bee

This is an issue my BFF has had to deal with. . .what started out as a very intimate, unique affair (like yours, 50-60 people tops) has grown into a slightly larger, somewhat traditional one. She totally could have written this post!

Plus ones are the devil no matter WHAT size your guest list is. We have a large one and it was up to 297 when we did the ‘everyone 18 or over gets a plus one’ game. We’ve since narrowed it to what you suggested – everyone in a serious relationship/couples we know.

 
14.
MzJynxie
Member
MzJynxie (message)  772 posts, Busy bee

I’m for the everyone gets a plus one if they wanna, even if they aren’t in a relationship the could bring a friend…but most of the same people will be invited so the plus ones are just a courtesy really.

 
15.
Member Icon
Member
Jacofblues (message)  1,057 posts, Bumble bee

I didn’t actually talk to my parents! I asked them once if they wanted to invite anyone and they said no! It was hard work, the guest list

 
16.
Guest Icon
Guest
L.G.

In my opinion, plus ones should be about the guest and not about whether the bride and groom know and/or like them. Most people do not enjoy going to parties by themselves, and by allowing a plus one, you are giving your guest the gift of bringing someone they will have a good time with!

 
17.
Bee Icon
Bee
Miss Panda (message)  945 posts, Busy bee

@Highness: Yup, that is a fear of mine. I tried very hard not to send it to people I wasn’t sure I would be able to invite, but because of that, it means that I sent the stds to way fewer people than I would have liked. Even then, I’m wondering if the list is going to change… sigh

@KelannaDC: lol, gosh I wish I could do this. It’s not just the plate cost, it’s everything else too

@LFdimples: yikes. Seriously who thinks a wedding is a good first date, also auditioning. Maybe he should rethink his technique.

 
18.
Bee Icon
Bee
Miss Panda (message)  945 posts, Busy bee

@StephK527: I’m not sure there is a good solution for inviting plus ones. I agree, big or small, the plus ones always make the guest list math hard to do.

@MzJynxie: @L.G.: I would like to give everyone a plus one, I really would, but it’s hard to justify kicking people off of your guest list for them, especially when a good chunk of your list is single. None of these people should know absolutely no one though. Everyone will be sat with people they should know. Frankly, I’m not completely sure why you would want to go to a wedding as a plus one. Being the plus one has always been super awkward for me.

@Jacofblues: jealous!

 
19.
KelannaDC
Member
KelannaDC (message)  298 posts, Helper bee

@Miss Panda: I totally agree with you about not kicking out people that you want as guests, just so that you can have a stranger plus one at your wedding. My wife has gone to weddings without me before, and we were both perfectly happy with it. She did her thing, and I had friend dates with my own friends. It was a win-win situation. According to some of the etiquette police in the hive, if you budget for 60 people, then you really only invite 30, and allow everyone a plus one. That. Is. Crazy. :)

 
20.
Guest Icon
Guest
Padiddle

I assume a plus one for everyone I’m inviting. Going to a wedding is expensive. Especially if the bride has an engagement party, wedding, bridal shower, etc. If I spend money on presents to all of those, I want to bring a guest! I am giving others the courtsey of that.

 

Leave a Reply


You can also just...

Newer blog post
more in Blog
Older blog post
Newer blog post by Miss Panda
more by Miss Panda (oldest)
Older blog post by Miss Panda

Copyright 2004-2013, Weddingbee.com
 

Find your vendors on Weddingbee

Favors by Weddingbee

Shop Now »

Miss Panda
Miss Panda

Miss Panda, Boston, MA Age and Occupation: 26, Graduate Student Fiance's Age and Occupation: 23, Graduate Student Engagement Date: June 27, 2011 Wedding Date: June 2013 About Me: I love window shopping, cute animals, crafting, baking, and most forms of procrastination. I tend to be overly meticulous with choices to a point of complete and total indecision. Mr. PBear and I met and live in the amazing city of Boston. We are big nerds who love trying new foods, playing video games, and cuddling with our adorable hamster. After 5 years together, we are planning an intimate, DIY-heavy, vintage garden themed, nonreligious wedding in the city where we fell in love.

Boards
Classifieds