The Pros and Cons of Buying an Engagement Ring on Etsy

A diamond engagement ring sitting on a a small bunch of pink flowers.

An engagement ring is a big purchase that takes quite a bit of thought and planning. Usually, this ring has a large price tag and it undoubtedly will become a treasured memento. As you’re debating where to buy this special item, you may want to consider purchasing it on Etsy. There are some pros and cons associated with buying such a valuable piece of jewelry from this site, but with that being said, it’s definitely an option worth exploring.

Before we delve into the pros and cons of finding and buying an engagement ring on this site, it’s important to understand what the site even is. Etsy is a popular online platform that allows small business owners to sell their goods to people around the world. The company’s mission is to connect shoppers who are seeking unique products from independent sellers. The site features handmade items, as well as vintage pieces.

The Pros of Buying an Engagement Ring on Etsy

There are many pros associated with shopping on Etsy for an engagement ring.

There’s a Wide Range of Options

A selection of diamond engagement rings.

The first pro to buying an engagement ring from Etsy is the sheer amount of product on the site. Since each Etsy “shop” is owned by someone different, there’s an abundance of unique options. No matter what you’re looking for, you’ll likely be able to find it on this versatile site.

It’s Budget-Friendly

While you can surely find engagement rings on Etsy that are quite pricey, the site also features many budget-friendly options. Not only will you be able to find something unique, but you’ll likely find a good deal to go along with it.

There Are Vintage Options

Vintage rings have a definite sense of flair to them, and Etsy is a great place to source a vintage or even antique piece of jewelry. If your future spouse loves all things with a history, you will definitely want to look on this platform for a ring.

You Can Support a Small Business

Another important pro to note when it comes to buying an engagement ring on Etsy is that in doing so, you’ll be supporting a small business. In a world that’s filled with box stores offering appealing pricing and sales, the ability to support someone’s small business that they pour their heart and soul into is something that feels good and empowering.

You Have Easy Access to Reviews

One of the nice things about shopping on Etsy is that there are a wide range of reviews available right on the homepage of each shop. This can allow you to easily gauge how many successful purchases have been made from the shop (the total number of purchases from each shop is readily available here, too). People can post photos and text about their purchase. Sellers don’t have the ability to delete reviews, so any negative reviews a shop receives are there to stay. This can be very helpful in finding a great piece of jewelry from an awesome seller.

The Cons of Buying an Engagement Ring on Etsy

To counter the upside of buying this piece of important jewelry on Etsy, there are also some downsides to think through before you place your order.

You Can’t See the Ring in Person Before Purchasing

A diamond engagement ring on a female hand.

The inability to see the ring you’re purchasing on Etsy in person can be a tough pill to swallow. While an abundance of photos from different angles makes it easier to get an idea of what you’re purchasing, that doesn’t quite replace the ability to hold the ring in your hand, see the materials it’s made of, and get a glimpse of that sparkle in person.

There’s no Stone Affiliation or Tracking

Most accredited jewelry stores have diamonds and rings that have certain affiliations with them. These denote many different things including the quality of the stone and where it originated from (for instance, was it naturally occurring or created in a lab or factory?). These affiliations give important information that you may want to know, and most Etsy sellers likely won’t have these affiliations or information about their products.

The Options Can Be Overwhelming

If you have absolutely no idea what you’re looking for in an engagement ring, shopping for one on Etsy could be a bit overwhelming due to the sheer number of options. The site features run of the mill rings, more eccentric pieces, and everything in between. While you may be able to navigate the wealth of options just fine, if you are someone who has a hard time with decision-making or feel like you may need the assistance of a sales person, buying an engagement ring on Etsy probably isn’t the route for you.

Find Amazing Vendors