Find Local Wedding Vendors

Discover and connect with wedding vendors that share your taste and your budget. With trusted reviews, you can rest easy that your wedding day will be as beautiful as you envisioned.

Cakes in Hanover,

The Broken Cookie Bakery & Coffee House

1000 Carlisle St
Hanover, PA
Services: Cakes | Login to save vendor
(717) 698-1659

About Us

Congratulations on your engagement! We’re so pleased you have considered The Broken Cookie to make your wedding cake. Here at The Broken Cookie we know how special your wedding day is, and we want your cake to be just as special. We can create anything that you wish: cupcake tower, individual cakes, 3 tiered cake, or anything in between. We can even make your wedding favors!

The base price for a premier wedding cake at The Broken Cookie is only $4 per person. This includes moist yellow or chocolate cake with white or chocolate buttercream. For those wanting a little more flavor on their wedding day, you may choose a specialty cake flavor or filling for an additional $.75 per person.

Mix it up! Each tier can be its own flavor and filling... A sure way to please every guest!

We can design your wedding cake to look phenomenal! However, intricate detail work, flowers, etc. will be an additional fee. Please contact Megan to set up your cake tasting today for a customized quote.

This is how we ensure your 100% satisfied with your wedding cake, wedding favors, etc:

* Decide on 3 cake flavors to taste.
* Call and make an appointment with Megan to taste cake and discuss the specifics of your wedding day (day, time, location, reception venue, colors, theme, etc).
* Make sketch of cake and/or favors.
* Receive approval of cake/favor design, flavors, filling, servings and colors.
* Couple signs cake order form and places 25% non-refundable deposit to hold wedding weekend.
* 7 days before wedding cake must be paid in full (a payment plan can be arranged, just speak with Megan about your needs).
* Enjoy your wedding day! Your cake will be set up at your reception venue waiting for the first cut by the new Mr. & Mrs.!

To receive a customized quote, call Megan to set up your appointment today!


Every year I hear Bride's say "I want something different for my favors" Well you've come to the right place! We can custom design any cookie to make it jive with your wedding. Want margarita glass cookies for the ladies and beer mug cookies for the guys - no problem! An individually wrapped cookie with each guest's name on it as their place card? Easy! How about a "Cookie Bar"? Ask me about this one! You'll have people talking for weeks!


It's your last night of freedom before the "Big Day" - so make it count and go all out! Get a XXX cake from our talented cake designer or even get some cookies cut out know. Make the night memorable with a little treat for the girls before you head out on the town. Tell the guys we do cakes for Bachelor parties too!


So you like our cakes and our cookies but you've already placed your order with another cake company. No problem - book us for your bridal shower. Tell who ever is in charge that you want your bridal shower cake and favors from The Broken Cookie. You're the bride, they have to listen to you! :o) Look at our gallery for some sample pictures of bridal shower cookies. They're sure to be a hit!


5 out of 5
Quality of Service:
  • Responsiveness:
  • Professionalism:
  • Value for Cost:
  • Flexibility:
  • We have used the Broken Cookie for previous birthday cakes/cupcakes and we loved them. We had a two tier cake and cupcakes for our wedding cake. The design of the cake was exactly what we wanted. The red velvet cake was absolutely delicious (so were the other flavors). My husband and I have been getting so many compliments from our guest on how great/delicious the different flavor cupcakes were. We would highly recommend the Broken Cookie for cakes, cookies, and cupcakes. We were extremely happy with the service we received.

    Frequently Asked Questions about Cake

    What types of desserts do you provide?

    Cookies, Croquembouche, Cupcakes, Dessert Buffet, Groom's Cake, Pastries

    What services do you provide?

    Consultations, Delivery, Setup

    What dietary needs can you accommodate?

    Gluten Free

    Are you licensed by the state health department?


    Find Amazing Vendors